4bpp
Now I am become a Helpful, Honest and Harmless Assistant, the destroyer of jobs
<3
User ID: 355
Right, based on your original post I assumed that your main objective was to have "normal male sexuality" be high-status or at least accepted.
So you think Jensen's behaviour is less archetypally heterosexual male than yours? What are you doing, engaging in ghetto gangbangs? How is "ban premarital sex" a particularly heterosexual male position?
Is this like "no enemies to the left" but for male heterosexuality instead of left-wing politics?
I want to know why high IQ people study this.
(1) Being puzzled at high-IQ people believing and dedicating effort to Creationism is somewhat like being puzzled at very muscular people living in isolated mountain valleys without infrastructure. Why, you might naively think, we know that humanity has the raw strength to dig tunnels through mountains with ease, and these people are near the peak of human strength! Surely if some wimpy noodle-armed Swiss engineer can do it, then the ripped Balochi shepherd should not even break a sweat!
But actually, it turns out that building infrastructure in adverse terrain is so hard that the variation in an individual's arm strength is almost irrelevant to whether it can be achieved, and would be insufficient if you are looking at something like the Himalayas or Alps anyway. Instead, all the great feats of infrastructure-building are due to tools and massive, society-wide coordination, which pooled the individual strength of lots and lots of humans, systematically directed it towards common ends, and recursively augmented it with tools whose strength is not in the same ballpark as that of humans at all.
Intellectual infrastructure is actually the same: contra the Rationalist fantasy of the quadruple-digit IQ superman sitting in his parents' basement and rederiving quantum mechanics from playing with legos, even the smartest kid growing up in intellectual Balochistan will at most be able to make a difference analogous to moving some slightly bigger boulders off of his village's farmland. The big achievements of our scientific worldview were created not because of the greater intellectual strength of its supporters, but because an organisation pooled that individual "strength", directed it towards common ends and recursively augmented it with tools (starting with dialectical logic and progressing through mathematics and statistics and sophisticated computer-based models etc.) whose intelligence is not of the same type or in the same ballpark as that of humans.
In this metaphor, we even have obvious counterparts to considerations that apply to the strength scenario: much like the Balochi herdsman could emigrate to Switzerland and start working at a construction site, a bright kid from an Evangelical family could go to university and wind up being brainwashed into contributing to a lab researching evolutionary genetics. (...but many will never leave Balochistan/Evangelicalism.) A Swiss engineering student could go through a hippie phase and wind up getting stuck and going native on the Indian subcontinent. (born-again Christians) Some Balochis might get together and actually learn how to organise themselves to the point where they start building viaducts and tunnels. (Modern evolutionary science ultimately came out of the Catholic church doing just that! Some smart creationists started organising themselves, built dialectic and the scientific method, and suddenly their intellectual descendants were entertaining theories their antecessors would have dismissed as heretical.)
(2) Humans are always very tempted, if they feel that someone is playing a rigged game against them, to "cheat back". Because of this, evolution-believers often, upon seeing creationists "strutting around the chessboard like a pigeon, knocking over pieces and declaring victory", start compromising on their own intellectual rigour when the public is watching, such as with the dinosaur soft-tissue dismissal mentioned in a parallel response, many an argument pertaining to global warming, or for more recent CW material the COVID lab leak hypothesis. The problem with this is that people on the other side will always see this cheating, and take it as a license to cheat for their own side in turn; as is being demonstrated everywhere over and over again, no culture war battle is ever resolved by cleanly establishing which side started it first and getting that side to concede. So in turn, any smart Evangelical starting from a position of open-mindedness (but strong intellectual attachment to his own team being in the right) will have no trouble finding ample examples of evolution-believers bullshitting, fudging data and celebrating weak arguments, and feel that justice demands that he be allowed to counter likewise.
I think you and several others here are overindexing on the Manhattan Project, which really was a black-swan moment of government and scientist competence in a black-swan era of the same. What competent centralised action has there been anywhere in the last 35 years? Just look at the COVID response.
What are some things you are 100% positive that an AI won't be able to do in 2027?
Get Gary Marcus to admit that he was fundamentally wrong. (Not purely meant as a zinger: I don't think we will be getting the Yudkowskian Superpersuader yet.)
"Hacker multitools" that could quickly test a large variety of known exploits against a target machine or network were a script kiddie staple since the '90s in internet/LAN settings as well.
Does this imply you also support letting current university members vote on whether to allow conservatives in universities? If not, what is the material difference?
The Rosenberg discourse seems to really be exploding these days (has it even been more than a week since that NYU podcast personality made the same call on Elon Musk?). All I can say with some certainty is that if anyone dares doing it in any case with the slightest partisan valence, this will turn the culture war ratchet quite a bit of the way towards African conditions very quickly; expect every new administration to start with a series of televised executions of whichever champions of the previous one were insufficiently slippery.
The Palestine Liberation Organization was founded back in the 1960s. Of course there were boycotts of Israel from the very beginning (and in fact before the founding of Israel), with the Arab boycott of Jewish activity in Palestine starting in December of 1945.
By "the current form", I mean mass activism by affluent educated Westerners who should not have any personal stake in the conflict. I am vaguely aware that there were some instances of tourists before (wasn't there some Japanese lady who actually fought as a guerrilla on the Palestinian side in the '70s?), but I'd be surprised if it turned out many people before 2000 or so.
Surely the Arab boycott (which would have been people fighting against the expulsion of their coreligionists and often coethnics) is in a different class.
In any event, it's worth noting that ending slavery in the United States required a successful military invasion. Of course military invasions of Israel have been tried, without success. Given that (1) Israel has nuclear weapons; and (2) it's Jewish citizens know that they face a truly existential threat, it seems unlikely that such an invasion will succeed any time soon.
I'm not sure off the top of my head if in the lead-up to the civil war enough European countries even stopped trading with the Confederacy to count as a blockade; and either way, compelled autarky in the 19th century represents rather less of a drop in QoL than it does in the 21st.
I don't know about the existentiality of the threat, if the threat is merely being forced into a two-state solution with clear borders, division of Jerusalem and full surrender of the West Bank and Gaza. Of course people there might believe that such a setup is untenable for them; but I would be skeptical, because convincing your people that their back is to the wall and any step back is a step onto the slippery slope towards absolute defeat is the oldest and most baseline tactic for rallying the troops (the Blues and Reds do it, and the Russians and the Ukrainians, and the Palestinians and the Israelis, etc.), and still peoples get talked out of the belief in the face of sufficient hardship all the time.
Oh, I don't doubt that it would take a very long time to root out every single eight-5090 rig. Would it be necessary, though? I think a properly motivated jihad (as might happen if there is >>WWII levels of destruction) might just about get at all the medium-sized bunker-based clusters and up, and it's less clear to me that everything much smaller than that would be sufficiently powerful to not just be useful but to be such an advantage that it would motivate defection from the jihad and a new AI arms race.
The amount of compute the big names have to throw at AI at the moment to not just vibecode a handful of Angry Birds clones but actually automate enough jobs simultaneously to show up as a measurable signal in market metrics, prove theorems or achieve self-improvement seems to be well in excess of what you could just fit in a handful of random bunkers. Of course, if between now and putative WWIII there is a lot more "vertical" rather than just "horizontal" progress (like, singleton 200GB models that can spit out Five Point Palm Exploding Heart Techniques for taking down countries with a handful of drones and internet posts, rather than ever-better cooperation between ever-larger swarms), this will no longer be the case.
Hey, don't shoot the messenger. In r*ddit terms, I personally really just want to say ESH.
Or maybe a 63 year old guy who dresses like he's still 30 has bad judgement all round.
Huh, I didn't even realise he was that old. Based on pictures I'd have pegged him around early 50s at most. Guess the rich can even play this kind of midlife crisis on another level.
But, like – aren't you more invested in actually accomplishing your goals?
I'm not them! I don't know how many times I need to stress it, but I really don't have that much of a stake in the Israel-Palestine fight. (I have noted that I don't like the idea that Israel gets supported in my name and with my money, which gives me moral culpability for things I want nothing to do with. I should add to this that I don't like the way the Western censorship machine often gets deployed in the cause of Israel; it peels yet another set of people off the already meagre free-speech coalition if they strongly feel that BDS proves that some censorship is good actually.) Ultimately, I argue about this here mostly because I like arguing; I would not take concrete steps beyond perhaps avoiding rabid pro-Israel activists in a professional and personal context (but I would equally avoid rabid pro-Palestine activists) and letting it influence my voting decisions a bit.
(...) This is what I find so strange about the pro-Palestine movement. (...)
All of that seems like an unfortunate consequence of how politics is played nowadays, but given the game is what it is I do not think it is necessarily ineffectual. In Germany and in the US, actions targeted against Israel-the-state have been repeatedly equated with antisemitism/hatred of and paranoia towards Jews by proponents of the Israeli cause, in order to draw from the very large repository of bad publicity that the latter enjoys post-WWII. One way to counter this strategy is to ram antisemitism itself back into the Overton window; if "all my homies want to genocide the Jews" is a mainstream statement, then "you just want to boycott Israel because you want to genocide the Jews" loses its effect. But try to tell pro-Israel Jews that they should maybe not have sacrificed the seedcorn of anti-antisemitism to Moloch.
Slavery was almost universally accepted in Western civilisation up until a few centuries before the American Civil War. What do you think happened between that and the Union going into a bloody war to abolish it? Did enough people just solipsistically decide it was bad through application of pure reason with no external input?
I want to respond to both of your replies together, if you don't mind.
instrumental vs. terminal Goals
The pro-Palestine movement in its current form has surely not been around for as long as opposition to slavery was before the relevant constitutional amendments were passed in the US. Can you say with certainty that there was no period of 20+ years before that point, where locally it would also have looked like the anti-slavery people are only concerned with pointless symbolic actions like condemning slavery, attacking slaveowners, propagandising for the humanity of slaves and helping the odd fugitive? After all, if your plan has two steps and the first is a precondition to the second, and you have reached an impasse with the first, it can make sense to focus all your energy on the first.
To that point, a lot of people, even beyond those you would normally consider to be pro-Palestine activists (including me), find it pretty likely that all other things equal Israel would prefer not a "durable two-state solution" but the total eviction or eradication of Palestinians anywhere near its territory, and probably significant chunks of land from other adjacent countries (Egypt, Lebanon, Syria, Jordan) minus their populations as well, and barring a total victory they would still prefer a constant low-key war where they are totally in control of the situation (so no Oct 7th, but maybe occasional incidents with stray bullets hitting border posts followed by a punitive action which may even let them annex some more land) to any realistic version of permanent peace in their current internationally recognised borders (which would probably require the surrender of settled territory or full franchise for Gazans and West Bankers who would then outbreed and outvote them).
If you are pro-Palestinian, you don't want either of those two outcomes, but it's not like you have more direct actions available than those that shift Israel's own cost-benefit calculus. The most obvious way to reorder their preferences is to make their preferred options worse by imposing external costs; since they are hardly Juche Korea and therefore significantly depend on foreign trade and military aid, turning international institutions and public sentiment against them is actually an effective measure. Maybe Israel would prefer being stuck on a small, misshapen piece of land with fixed borders and forced to grapple with its internal contradictions without the unifying threat of war + foreign trade, or multicultural Salad Bowl Israel whose only lever to remain majority Jewish is figuring out the birthrate problem + foreign trade, over being Greater Israel with the foreign relations of North Korea.
Funny how easily all of the agency is assigned to one side or the other. Some other members of this forum would be thinking "women like powerful and rich men no matter their own SES" and complaining about hypergamy around now. Maybe they could even come up with their own saying about the conscience of a "wet snatch" or thereabouts!
One man's modus ponens is another man's modus tollens. I say deBoer is wrong about white/black relations: manipulating white people's attitudes towards black people clearly does work, or slavery would never have been ended. (There's an implicit motte-bailey here, between reducing the total amount of "white hatred" and the unattainable task of eliminating all of it, as the benchmark measure being compared to feeding kids.)
On the other hand, I feel like the jury is still out on whether any direct material interventions (be they cash transfers, meals for kids or DEI initiatives) had a measurable long-term effect on the welfare of African-Americans; and either way, for the more ambitious ones of those interventions they would never have been implemented had emotional buy-in from the white ruling class not been achieved first.
In more concrete terms: if you accept that Israelis and Palestinians are primarily competing for the same limited resource (sovereignty over a strip of land) and so their utility is zero-sum, and believe that "purely symbolic" acts and attitude shifts for the Palestinian side do nothing, then why do they bother you so much? If meals > UN condemnations, then shouldn't a pro-Israeli be happy that pro-Palestinians waste their time on UN condemnations instead of providing them with meals (or all-expenses-paid drone pilot internships in Ukraine)? Being simultaneously pro-A and against anti-A acting ineffectually seems like an inconsistent position, unless you are not actually engaging in object-level discussion of policy but just trying to load anti-A with negative affect or demoralise proponents (which is waging the culture war, not discussing it).
There's still the option a large negative-sum drone world war that destroys supply chains and puts the genie back in the bottle for long enough while also making humanity desperate enough to enable a Butlerian jihad.
If a nation can defect, why can't a nation just defect to "kill all humans except for a narrow self-selected elite"~"kill all humans"? Surely that option dominates the UBI one. Fewer mouths to feed and house. On the other hand, if you expect its competitors are sufficiently aligned that they will crush such a nation in retaliation, they could do this to one that defects from the make-work scheme too.
Rust's way is not to make things they don't like impossible, but instead to make them deliberately cumbersome. I was following the language pretty closely in its early days, and the approximate moment they lost me was when they decided to do away with the ~ syntax and instead introduce the Box<T>/box for inline heap allocation and destructuring of heap-allocated data, thus irredeemably encumbering standard functional programming idiom involving ADTs. The stated explanation was that it was a deliberate decision, because they considered this idiom to have bad performance and did not want programmers to use them. I think the variety of escape hatches using unsafe blocks also counts as this.
It's not clear to me if you can disentangle this from the entire Western "universal culture" package that the dominant world cultures downloaded. As in, maybe rationalising modernism is necessary to make cultures dominant, and the first inventors of rationalising modernism happened to like kissing, and so those who adopted one and became dominant also adopted the other and started being into kissing.
I know this reeks of pop sociology, but I really can't shake the feeling that it's a natural temperamental fit. Rust is a high-barrier-to-entry language beloved of academic experts, designed to force or at least strongly incentivise you to follow what they consider best practice, and its constraints are sold as being there to keep you (the programmer) and people around you safe from yourself. Aligned against it are C/C++ programmers who aren't entirely joking when they say real men program in assembly, admire Duff's Device and on some level tend to believe that segfaults are a force of natural selection acting on weak programmers. (I say this as a proud member of the latter class.)
Rust has the vibes of COVID measures, mandatory child seats and ski and bike helmets and emissions limits on your car. It's only natural that the status-conscious care foundation neurotic demographic would flock to it.
Would you be willing to share some screenshots?
Is there public interest in arresting people for them? There's already way too little supply to meet demand for this sort of media-legible oppression; if word gets out that sending those can get you in real trouble, what little there is might also collapse and then how are we going to raise sympathy for figures who upset the outgroup?
- Prev
- Next

Capitalism, more than anything, was the one social tech that let us tame the Big Men of history, so that rather than gathering continent-spanning empires by conquest, gathering slave harems and casting leprous corpses across city ramparts, they mostly work to produce widgets that entertain us in return for a small predictable payment. The only concession is that we had to grant them in return was a modicum of tolerance for their eccentricities. Forgetting for a moment that AI doom is imminent anyway, do you really want to cancel the deal?
More prosaically, as old man Moldbug observed, power is always a two-way street. As long as your moral principles have no way of affecting Jensen Huang or Elon Musk, they in turn have no motivation to affect your moral principles. If you start saying Jensen Huang can't have affairs because you find affairs immoral and coordinate with enough people that your view matters, you will find that he will develop an interest in changing your view and smashing your ability to spread it and coordinate with other people who have it. Alarmed at drag queen story hour? How much CEO harem story hour do you think several billions of $ can buy?
More options
Context Copy link