Bartender_Venator
No bio...
User ID: 2349
Charlemagne also genocided German pagans
I have actually sperged out about this one before
For Joan of Arc it's pretty accurate (even the "it wasn't a show trial" revisionist school is trying to rehabilitate the English and their clerics), you'd want to look at something like the Albigensians or Jan Hus, burned by a Church Council after being given safe conduct by the Emperor. Joan was charged with religious offences because she was a religious symbol, which seems fairly straightforward to me.
More generally, burnings and other such things were fairly rare in the Medieval era unless they were directly connected to political upheaval, like the Albigensians - and my understanding is that such things were also relatively rare in Medieval Islam, much of their fanaticism is a reaction to modernity. The Reformation changes that a lot in Europe, but even then it's a drop in the bucket compared to the general brutality of the time. There was no real separation between politics and religion and, as such, it's basically up to you if you want to charge religion or politics with things like the Thirty Years War. But up until the Reformation, if you read any sources from the time it's clear that Christianity was a moderating force on violence rather than an accelerant.
Joan of Arc was given a highly political show trial at the behest of the English, and their allies in Paris, not the Church, and was initially sentenced to imprisonment after abjuring her 'heresy' (a heretic who abjured could not legally be burned - at least, not at the time). Compare that to secular treason trials of the time, since, after all, from an English perspective she was in rebellion against the true King of France. There is an inherent conflict between the brutality of secular power and the commandments of faith in Christianity that is less pronounced in Islamic history. Having said that, from a secular-right perspective, one could also say that Islam wouldn't be a serious problem if we didn't have that Christian merciful-universalist strain in our modern morality.
It's a pretty classic pattern in other areas of art, too. Child of an elite family has material wealth, and probably good genes, so uses their time for creative pursuits. After all, money can't buy cool (unless you launder it through getting yourself in the right galleries, throwing great parties, etc.).
I remember in the museum at Santa Fe there are some quite chilling examples of this depicting the torture of captives - for instance, the techniques used to tie a man up and hold him over a fire so he dies as slowly as possible.
- Prev
- Next

Strongly recommend the Orson Welles film, particularly if you want to see where David Lynch got a lot of his groove from.
More options
Context Copy link