Static advertisements aren’t the worst (unlike animated) and may be better than nothing. But better than advertisements are murals commissioned to real artists whose goal isn’t to sell something to the lowest common denominator. I prefer those on walls and structures and imagine Fenway Park would look better with them too.
The latest stupid culture war news: The notorious Good Good golf advertisement. Featuring a country club golf gentleman (fine member of high society) having a manic episode, so excited to try overpriced "luxury" slop, he shoves a lady to the ground. Instead of calling the police, the other players just look on; maybe he's the owner, you know the type, with so much money and so little financial or social awareness that he'd even waste it on, random example, a "Quantum Triple Diamond Driver".
I don't fault lefties for boycotting Good Good, coercing them to retract the ad and apologize. Because they should do it to every commercial: I want every non-monopoly with aggressive advertising to be given this (or the Bud Light post trans ad) treatment, until public and online spaces look even better than São Paulo, Lancy Geneva, and Maine (where billboards are outlawed). At least this ad tries to not be boring and obnoxious; I actually think it's somewhere in the top 1% I see and hear (although not a compliment), thankfully rarely anymore thanks to uBlock Origin, SponsorBlock, and generally avoiding software whose primary function is ad delivery.
And this includes invasive tracking. Recently Twitter sent C&Ds to Nitter and XCancel. This follows Reddit tightening old.reddit and Facebook/Instagram have always been locked down. Thankfully there are always alternatives, right now https://twitterwebviewer.com https://nitter.kareem.one for Twitter, https://redlib.catsarch.com for Reddit, and https://inviziogram.com/ for Instagram - but it's annoying and contributes to link rot. This is your regularly-scheduled reminder to quit Twitter and the other brainrot social media, and replace them with more productive activities, like maybe, partaking in these "sophisticated" forum discussions on theMotte.
It’s a fuzzy line.
What if the person isn’t baking a cake but officiating weddings, should they be forced to accommodate gay ones as long as they follow the same script as straight ones?
On the other hand, the person baking cakes won’t know whether their clients are gay without obnoxious vetting which would hurt their business. A man and woman can walk into the store and order a cake, then give it to their gay friends.
I believe freedom of association should work like that: a seller can refuse “service”, but once they provide it, can’t restrict the buyer or force them to retract.
-
Towns decide public spaces because they own public spaces. Individuals decide their own spaces (house or apartment interior, car interior, and exteriors to limited extent), groups of towns or states decide buildings that serve multiple towns (e.g. waste treatment plant, nuclear power plant; car exteriors should also be state or nation mandated, because the vast majority will drive between towns, and many will drive between states).
-
You would have those towns, but many towns (including some cities) have roughly an even split, so I expect they’d be more reasonable. Also, I think the town shouldn’t dictate what people do within their own home or apartment room, although it would be hard to prevent them, it would be hard for them to enforce anything.
So why is it legitimate to ask for action at the local/district level, but not at the state level?
Because states have too many people. It’s easier to move towns than states because you can visit your old spaces faster, and there would be small groups that wouldn’t find refuge in any state, but may be large enough to take over a town.
Like @vorpa-glavo’s comment I support individualism when feasible, but individual homeowners aren’t rich enough for their own private park, library, etc. or soundproofing, road maintenance, etc. Towns are, so they shou
Free expression and the freedom from exposure can coexist: places advertising sex in abstract (like "NSFW") opaque to bystanders unless they consent.
In public spaces I think it should be the town that decides what's allowed. A problem with today's society is that large states and larger governments intervene in things that should be local: unless it's like child abuse or slavery, people can move (and I don't think drag shows fall into child abuse, although admittedly I've never seen one, I'm thinking more severe cases like physical assault, neglect, and deprivation).
What about locals who worry about themselves suffering if the datacenter generates noise, increases electricity, etc.? Even when the company makes promises, what would their small town do if they’re ignored?
Sure, many people are upset because of the vague threat of AI dystopia or ingroup alignment, and use the above concerns as a more practical excuse, but still they seem like serious concerns.
Honestly, I believe every major issue is astroturfed to some extent, by opponents to get supporters to claim weakman arguments, and by “conspiracy theorist” influencers and news for attention.
Hence a prison sentence is justified regardless of sanity. The if she wants more “punishment” she can administer it to herself, ideally by community service.
I believe in punishment for deterrence and prevention.
Prevention: will she have future kids? Will she get some future hormone imbalance that makes her go on a killing spree? Maybe she should be monitored and given therapy, and to prevent this situation happening in other parents, we should monitor and give therapy to those suspected with PDD. But prison is overkill.
Deterrence: this justifies some kind of prison, someone who regrets having kids may fake PDD and kill them for similar release. But I still think a long sentence is excessive, prison is miserable and giving up your kids for adoption should be less.
More generally, the US has such long prison sentences, does it have any effect on crime? For frequent (3x) offenders I support the death penalty (with strong evidence), but for others I think it’s wasteful and unnecessarily cruel.
Everything is relative. How much of a state of emergency are we in? Is the doomsday clock ten seconds to midnight? Five milliseconds? And what does that mean in real time?
Real emergency powers, like involuntary confinement for suicide, make the situation better in the short term but worse in the medium to long term, point being there will be no long term if not enacted. If the “emergency” is long, the solution better work as long, or you just wasted time, in an emergency no less.
Alternatively, even if HBD is true, individuals should be treated colorblind. You don’t have to accept a premise to reason hypothetically.
Look, some of these things might be right, but we’re in an authoritarian state of emergency
Ironic, exactly what an authoritarian would say.
The problem, of course, is there is no post-emergency period.
True emergencies exist and probably warrant more authoritarian leadership (it’s in many constitutions, e.g. the US president is also military leader). But to succeed in a true emergency the leader must be trusted by most subjects, and defer or resolve less urgent conflicts, e.g. offering large concessions on non-emergency issues (which should be most of them), and convincing that the emergency is real.
Neither party has done either. I’ll accept we’re in some sort of emergency (crazy politicians, Gen Z apathy, climate change and TFR collapse). I’m not remotely convinced a leader of any major party can lead us out.
And of course, this guy (attacking Arday criticism)’s fear is acting against himself. How will supporting Arday do anything against Trump authoritarianism? It seems like he has too much fear, blocking rationality. Although I think it really seems like he’s doing it for ingroup brownie points (maybe a raise or promotion).
I don't think so. News has incentive to be sensational and over-dramatic, and it is. More people are afraid of shark attacks than car crashes, because a run-of-the-mill shark attack will reach the news but a car crash won't, but the latter are more likely and dangerous.
But if that social media then starts banning people for legally protected speech, they ought to lose this protection
I don't care about big social medias, but repealing Section 230 altogether would be a bad idea because it may affect smaller forums like this. Every half-decent forum has to ban some users: spammers and generally obnoxious.
I wish people were more tolerant to other opinions and more willing to join smaller or federated platforms. In the meantime, we can encourage the latter, even BlueSky. I honestly don't think being heard by everyone is necessary or even reasonable, there are too many people online and some want their echo chambers, but small forums you at least get heard by some, and the best can be amplified; whereas large social medias' ability to promote decent posts (by my standards) are questionable at best.
Also groupthink. All ideologies are flawed, and if you can't point out flaws without greater risk to yourself, you get Stalin, woke, LinkedIn (iykyk), etc.
Attention ≠ importance is a general problem. e.g. Far more articles on celebrities than the ongoing Sudan genocide, or the outsized attention on trans rights.
Fortunately, you can ignore the repetitive articles, and they do provide more general insights. e.g. In many arguments, trans can be substituted for other minorities.
In this case, I feel sympathetic towards Arday and that the system failed him, he was in a distorted world and suddenly forced to confront reality. But it was more important he got help than affect others' actions that he could've largely ignored (by not checking the news, or only checking a sympathetic outlet).
How I see it, nature's idea of optimal human life is what it is now. Nature wants humans to interfere, it wants "fit" species to survive (defined by their survival). But preserving elderly who waste resources and seem to be unaware and unhappy, it doesn't help us or seem to be helping them, and nature is leaving the decision to collective us.
To me it feels like yet another huge eu overreach
Generally? Yes. If they try to ban DeepSeek or regulate open models (including private hosting), that would be very bad (because I can't imagine how they'd non-invasively).
But for ChatGPT and Claude it's almost nonexistent, because when you use them
-
You already give up privacy.
-
The output is often obviously LLM, even if you prompt them to avoid the tropes. Survivorship bias I know, but if you can remove the LLM vibe, I'm sure you can remove the watermark.
More importantly, why does it matter to know something is AI generated? If that's the only information, it doesn't affect privacy. If the output is good, I promise most people won't care. And the holdouts, why do you care about their attention? like a black person trying to move into a sunset town, instead, let it be their loss.
You’re not wrong about uppercase-A Academia, but it will be sought and kept alive unless there’s another institution to replace the type of projects it handles. It’s the worst system except for industry, independent research, and everything else.
We don’t need college as it exists today, but it fills certain niches that need replacement:
-
Undergrad: specialized education beyond what school teaches. Although we could probably have online learning with online/LLM lessons, small in-person groups, and tutors for milestones and edge cases; a more decentralized college-like system without the bureaucratic overhead and tuition costs of today’s colleges. Honestly, I think this is the future: it has only been possible recently (last 20 years without the assistance of reliable LLMs, last 4 months with them), so although traditional college has existed for so long, maybe now it’s obsolete and only persists by inertia.
-
Postgrad, lowercase-a academia: projects too experimental and unprofitable for industry, too expensive long and collaborative for hobbyists. We have a system to fund those projects (grants), understand (papers) and verify (peer review) their results, have experienced people (PIs / advisors) plan them and manage inexperienced ones (labs) and pass tacit knowledge to their successors (PhD students); feel free to propose a better alternative, or figure out how to create a parallel academic system.
Russia is still communist in spirit: the state is a full-on dictatorship that controls everything and spreads dogmatic propaganda full of doublespeak, currently fighting a pointless cruel war and struggling despite having a massive advantage, effectively massacring its own citizens. Even communist times had people with extra income and private property ("more equal than others"). Russia is also widely considered miserable and it's economy is declining.
Meanwhile, my understanding is that in non-Russian-aligned Slavic nations communism is widely stigmatized, and many have banned communist symbols and ideology.
Call it woke, call it the woke right, call it whatever. The real war is freedom vs censorship, and due to the Paradox of Tolerance, it never ends.
I’m fine with pausing the frontier (I just don’t expect it), but until then, I think pausing open models creates more risk than it solves. If people don’t have a personal genie, they resort to Claude; the genie is more personalized and individually-aligned than the near-certain alternative.
A magic one-many apocalypse can’t be disproven from any technology. I suspect we created a ticking time bomb with the mass Internet and social media (see: declining TFR, Gen Z stare, declining metrics like average US lifespan) and moreover climate change, which may not cause apocalypse only if new advancements and their associated risks. Not enough for major risks and sacrifices like eroding individual liberty, but that’s the saftyists’ position.
(And to be clear, pausing open models while credibly pausing the frontier would be OK, because it shows a global cooperation that would make me optimistic, that apocalypse is less likely than the alternative, and that broad individual rights to preserve the more important ones are less needed.)

What I don't understand (well, kind of) is why the "left" does so much damage here, but not to, say, GrubHub, whose pandemic ad I feel is 20x more offensive, insensitive to the most discriminated demographic.
I'm just alluding to how country club members pride themselves on being civilized and "cultured", in contrast to the barbaric violent poor, yet here we purportedly have one assaulting a woman because she reaches for his golf club. I don't have anything against the country club culture, but I think they regard themselves too highly, believing their exclusivity and luxury improves their character, while they ultimately pursue shiny things and creature comforts like the rest of us.
More options
Context Copy link