Modern-day journalism. The woman is self-aware and knows the article makes her look histrionic. It’s probably exaggerated, it may not be real. She’s doing it for attention and ad revenue, like “stupid” TikTokers and reality TV stars. She’s two steps ahead.
My main issue with LLM writing is that it's overly verbose. The biggest sign I'm reading AI is when I subconsciously start skimming, and even after skipping entire paragraphs, feel like I haven't skipped anything important.
If AI could write concisely, I'd see no issue with it in technical documents and news articles. If AI could write in someone's voice given a sample of their previous text, I'd see no issue with it at all. Maybe even in the former scenario, like how practically nobody cares that most writing is no longer hand-written; the "writer's voice" would shift to the subject and focused details.
\6. National service should be a universal duty. We should, as a society, seriously consider moving away from an all-volunteer force and only fight the next war if everyone shares in the risk and the cost.
I like the corollary that, if not everyone shares the risk and cost, society should not fight the next war. Meaning we’d probably fight only when it becomes existential.
A position I heard elsewhere that I agree with: ideally, every nation should have a mandatory (for everyone) “Service Corps”, which isn’t just war preparation but also community service. Unfortunately, in most nations today, it would probably be corrupted.
The interesting part here is that the limit could be much further than practical relevance and context not actually that degraded
The limit is far enough that today’s models are useful: for example, they can code and (allegedly) find vulnerabilities in production software.
But I don’t believe today’s architecture can accurately emulate human intelligence, unless the model is retrained very frequently (daily?) on omni-local data (including everyone’s personal details and private codebases), effectively brute forcing continuous learning. Because today’s (consumer) models have been trained on practically the entire internet with the world’s compute, plus synthetic data and tool use, yet still they consistently hallucinate in long complicated tasks that humans after adjustment consistently solve.
In the last thread, my opinion was that LLMs are missing something essential. And I still think that, but I wouldn't be surprised at all if LLMs required very little theoretical augmentation to reach AGI.
I believe they’re missing good continuous learning.
By definition: with human-level continuous learning, any class of human-solvable problems could be solved by guiding the LLM through examples until it generalizes. After enough generalization, it would be hard to find problems it can’t solve. Granted, “human-level” is doing a lot of heavy lifting, it’s not far from “LLMs are just missing intelligence”.
By observation: the vast majority of LLM failures seem to stem from needing to store everything in context and losing track when it gets too large. The vast majority are stupid mistakes that it seems like, if they were prepended to a small-context prompt, the LLM would not repeat.
What about Cr1TiKaL?
I found one freakout (and he’s back now). For a guy who’s become inconceivably rich and famous by monologuing in front of a camera about internet drama, over a decade, I consider that heroically sane.
In fairness, the goalposts were moved because we realized LLMs couldn't do certain AGI things despite passing the "AGI" tests.
For example, they can pass a Turing test consisting of a independent questions with short answers, but could never pass a "Turing test" over years, because they have limited context windows (and even with tools and a filesystem, too many things change for them to store and organize). They've effectively passed ARC-AGI 1 and ARC-AGI 2, but not yet ARC-AGI 3, while a median (from their tests) human passes all (play it yourself).
They'll be "true AGI" when we can no longer create (non-physical) tests they don't immediately pass.
Although I agree with SnapDragon that they're "partial AGI". I believe the missing component is continuous learning: they start output like a human, as they've been trained to, so if they continued to be "trained" on their observations, presumably they'd continue to output like a human.
I think you're right about social media companies not making their sites less toxic on their own. So...I do think we should regulate kids social media more, and maybe adult social media past a certain size. I'm specifically wary of regulating small sites, because for example that hinders hobbyists and startups.
I think parental controls work. Current parental controls aren't good, but better ones are possible; and it's true that particularly smart and determined kids will subvert practically any controls, but not all kids are smart and determined. An example of a better parental control is a phone OS that, without an admin password, blocks sites not in a "kid-friendly" whitelist provided by a third party. I don't see why that's particularly hard to implement or configure.
I think mandatory ID for specific services is fine, my objection is mandatory ID to use the internet.
Service providers have plausible deniability since you can't prove or verify a users age beyond just asking the user like they do now.
The problem isn't kids clicking "yes" on "am I over 18?" and seeing porn, the problem is kids clicking "no" and seeing porn anyways, because it's in YouTube Kids. If governments don't hold YouTube accountable for this today, I don't see why they would after mandatory ID.
Also note that OS "age verification" currently implemented in some states is just asking the users' age:
Provide an accessible interface at account setup that requires an account holder to indicate the birth date, age, or both, of the user of that device... (CA-AB-1043)
Provide an accessible interface at account setup that requires an account holder to indicate the birth date or age of the user of that device... (CO-SB26-051)
I do think this OS age verification will reduce kids being exposed to harmful content, and mandatory ID would reduce it further. I agree that's a good thing. The problem is these laws may introduce other problems that make them overall negative.
Specifically, I don't really object to the age verification in California and Colorado because it's lackluster: one can enter a fake birth date, and probably use an OS that refuses to implement it without enforcement. But I would object to mandatory ID, because governments and companies have repeatedly failed to secure sensitive data, and people should have an outlet to express views unsavory to those around them (since many people would retaliate against or be deeply hurt by certain views, even mundane views (from a general perspective)).
Estacada High School in Oregon seems to have succeeded.
I think mods should intervene
Another call for a recurring Butlerian Jihad Roundup, so AI/tech drama doesn’t detract (or get detracted by) Trump/woke drama.
Keep in mind, governments and companies are more or less incompetent.
Be that to do business with the bank or government offices that would have required you to go there in person, but can now be solved with a few swipes or clicks.
Banks and government offices already have your ID. They still require you to go in person, because 1) people steal each others' IDs, and 2) they haven't upgraded their systems since before the mainstream internet.
I would in fact be quite partial to the idea that certain demographics would never see a gambling ad ever again.
Gambling ads and suggestive content are visible even on kids' sites designed to block it. The blocks don't work, because 1) selective blocking is a hard problem, and 2) companies don't invest enough because they want to maximize profit (and governments don't fine them enough).
If what kids see on the internet matters so much that parents should revoke access to it, why isn't what's on there a bigger deal? We've already seen fine posts on here regarding the subject of foreign interference in media with the recent forced sale of TikTok. That, on top of the promulgation of hard and soft pornography, should be dealt with head on rather than being excused away under the guise that this is all somehow a meaningful avenue of anonymous expression whilst your ability to express your political views is a total sink or swim predicament based entirely on the whims of billionaires and the political extremists they bankroll, who can revoke your ability to meaningfully express yourself at will.
It is a big deal, but: foreigners steal locals' IDs, and convince them (sometimes by visiting in person) to spread foreign propaganda. Pornography is popular, some pornstars are already public and some viewers have no shame.
Theoretically your identity could be veiled to the public on certain platforms in a formalized manner, and unneeded breaches of information could be prosecuted similar to a libel suit. The big companies could now properly curate content based on a very firm 'don't show porn to under 18's' criteria. Meaning the government has a foot in the door of their algorithms. Maybe we could finally stop pretending that technology is all too complicated to legislate. And maybe, just maybe, this will lead to my YouTube frontpage sucking less. Maybe.
Companies already aren't allowed to leak PII: it leaks anyways, they get sued and lose, but the final payout is negligible. YouTube already controls your frontpage and tries not to show porn to under 18s. Technology is already legislated, but governments abuse and/or ignore the legislation and companies find workarounds.
I do suspect mandatory ID would reduce kids exposed to harmful content, foreign interference, and porn (distribution and consumption). But significantly increase political (and non-political petty) speech consequences, which would be worse, because governments and companies will leak the IDs of users with views they dislike, and leaking everyone's views won't work as explained here.
Voicing support for party X whilst your boss hates party X, in practice, will get you fired. Even if there are laws against it, your boss will assign you annoying tasks, over-scrutinize your mistakes, etc. to evict you for a different official reason. And there's no way to detect this without false positives.
The loss of online anonymity would also damage relationships, and not just ones with irreconcilable political beliefs. People "code-switch" all the time; imagine no code-switching because everything you write online is visible under your ID. Men talking about women around other men, women talking about men around other women, kids talking about their teachers to other kids, teachers talking about kids and parents to other teachers, etc. Austists would love to know everyone's views about them and may easily adjust, but I suspect most people would be turned off by others' behavior in other groups. Importantly, 1) even when they logically know such back-talk was always happening, they would struggle to emotionally handle concrete examples; and 2) some back-talk is criticism aimed at helping the target or those around them.
—-
Thinking more about it:
Direct P2P would also avoid these problems. While maybe mitigating the social harms of today’s internet, which were less common when in-person and telephone communication were dominant, like social isolation and a certain type of (embarrassing) meannness and brainrot.
If online anonymity were eliminated for everyone, while providing a way for everyone to communicate (with ID) only to who they choose - that may be better than today. People could even make public political statements without repercussion, by privately communicating them to a trusted speaker for their party…so this doesn’t actually eliminate anonymity, just makes it harder…but doesn’t anything?
The Kids Aren't Alright, at least it seems. I constantly hear studies and anecdotes on how Gen Z and α are significantly more awkward, asocial, mentally ill; and evidence suggests social media is why.
Hence I think governments are desperate to get kids and teens off social media, or at least make it less toxic, and/or reduce usage, to fix them. I agree with that goal.
But I'm wary of these bills: they threaten anonymity, can be bypassed, add regulatory burden... Although this YouGov survey rates Australia's ban "cautiously optimistic". Still, I much prefer:
-
Banning phones in schools (which I think is so obvious, it's surprising and embarrassing many schools haven't already done it)
-
Encouraging more in-person socialization with after-school activities, kids third-spaces, etc.
-
Less toxic social media algorithms, better parental controls, cultural encouragement for parents to limit social media - not via laws
To me he seems like a pathological liar but no worse. At least he says good things.
I don't think he should be murdered. If you were in his position, what would you do?
Although I don't trust him with ASI, nor anyone else.
A scenario you didn't mention: AI takes over and rules alongside Moloch over everyone.
I think this is much more likely than technofeudalism: because people are too incompetent, and what would someone who desires to dominate everyone desire after?
It doesn't have to be ASI. Climate change alone may do it, by coercing everyone to cooperate more to maintain normal.
I don’t want ID to be part of the internet either.
Anon review sites are already untrustworthy. Ideally, people revert to paid trustworthy critics or form paid webs of trust, so rando nitpicking and shill glazing are both ignored.
I think providing good service is reasonable, as long as the customer is polite and not asking for something particularly demanding.
The refund wasn’t your problem, the manager is the one who’s losing from giving customers extra.
My focus is when customers are disrespectful, or the boss is disrespectful, or otherwise causing the employee unnecessarily difficulty.
I think that pettiness is particularly evil, because it’s clearly unjust, loss without gain. Whereas even a robber baron, while unjust, at least gains the money others lose, and can donate it back to society. I wonder why society doesn’t focus on tackling pettiness more than other issues.
I have a modest proposal that service workers shouldn't have to deal with that.
For example, maybe if a customer is rude, the business can forcibly fine them. A customer can challenge the fine + court fees, and is presumed innocent, but since it's a private establishment the business can present video evidence.
Thus, business owners are incentivized to let employees refuse to serve rude customers, rather than the other way around (importantly, the customer can't be fined after a sale).
It's a small thing, along with letting factory workers wear headphones.
Bypass Paywalls Clean
https://gitflic.ru/user/magnolia1234
It’s on a Russian site because it kept getting DMCAd on GitHub.
I can relate.
I think it's nostalgia: creators have trouble finding new ideas, so reuse old ones, but since consumers are desensitized, less exciting parts are cut. Hence Genshin's rewards without the quest, slice of life's wholesome moments without pain, etc.
I don't think putting back the less exciting parts would work, even though they're important (particularly the delayed gratification that yields longer-lasting satisfaction). If that's all it takes, there are already more than a lifetime's worth of old RPGs and niche animes/movies. I think we need "breakthroughs" that create new genres (or popularize previously niche genres), and that requires (most visible) creators to regain their creativity.
Why aren't (most visible) creators creative anymore? I suspect it's partly because of centralization of distribution: there are creative artists that you don't see, or potential creative artists that give up (or don't start) because they don't expect to be seen. Also because of LLMs, modern tools/techniques and asset packs: they help creation but not original creation, and creators that start relying on them become too lazy to stop. Also because of homogenized culture, and people too embarrassed to express themselves. Ultimately, these are all speculation.
Related: "character always wears something different" (https://old.reddit.com/r/TopCharacterTropes/comments/1s4hq5p/love_design_trope_the_character_has_a_different/)
My favorite trope is surrealism (technically a genre but it has a tvtropes page). Specifically surrealism that I can relate to the real world, I think because the real world is surreal. Advertisements, institutions, politicians, celebrities, social media…are caricatures of what we imagine is reasonable society, formed from our idolization of the past. (Though fortunately, less so lived experience; closer to me becomes more normal, because it’s how I came to define normal).
And I hate to be cynical, but predict everything will get weirder. Imagine what people from the 1800s would think of today, or cavemen of the 1800s.
It’s not a bad thing, though not good, it just is. A related trope is Cosmic Bliss, though I like when it’s not bliss but just not irreconcilable horror.
Examples: TADC, ENA (I didn’t like until it “clicked” that ENA depicts an autistic worldview and masking). I wish I had examples that aren’t silly cartoons.

Your style transfer example has the obvious AI tells (frequent em-dashes, ends with “it’s not X it’s Y”) and scores 100% on GPTZero. I cant read the attachment, does it really reflect the style?
More options
Context Copy link