Yeah, there’s also still the issue where sometimes comments double load.
https://redditenhancementsuite.com/ is stil around. It says "maintenance mode" but volunteers have been updating it. I don't know if it bypasses browsing without an account, but it keeps Old Reddit with some QOL improvements...
Oh, it's why more comments don't load: https://old.reddit.com/r/help/comments/1xcymlp/load_more_comments_link_not_working/
I hope AI can make improvements here. It has the potential. Although, my favorite games are all indie, ironically because they have more spirit.
I feel like, in an AAA game I can walk through the most beautiful (and expensive) landscape and barely notice. But there's something about the simplicity and imperfection of indie that primes me, so that a simple detail may stand out and evoke some feeling latent and forgotten.
That's true. And AI could fork LibreOffice, but I suspect it would be faster and better to do a fresh port (and someone could test both, with barely any effort...but I'm not paying for the credits).
Reddit is so broken, "load more comments" stopped working for me logged in. Probably because they are trying to block logged-out browsing again (and failing, anyways), but it's another reason we're better off separate.
Because Google Docs already exists.
Or there are other alternatives: LibreOffice, OnlyOffice…this site list contains 7 more. And don’t forget LaTeX, Typst, and 100+ free markdown editors.
I think it’s good for politicians to be diverse (in the general sense). A politician CSA survivor has unique experience they may provide to draft better CSA preventions, without the majority needed to propose overzealous ones.
Plus, I doubt every CSA survivor is less mentally stable (or able to deal with shitbags) than average, or let’s say, top 10%. And constantly mentally stable people are unlikely to understand mental health issues, so in their legislation, unlikely to account for their effects. Again, I think the ideal is enough politicians with mental health issues to have them accounted while the majority ensure the general environment remains stable.
A better analogy may be blind passenger in a motor vehicle. Maybe their enhanced hearing can detect something.
Yes. Catching Democrat politicians in lies and supporters parroting them even when obviously exposed has made me deeply cynical of the entire party. Also institutions propped by lies. Although it has not made me any less cynical of the Republican Party, who aren’t exactly honest either.
It hasn’t changed my core beliefs, but has changed how I see the world and believe they would best be accomplished. It hasn’t changed how I voted yet, but has changed how I speak and act.
I’ve yet to meet an IQ 80 person who could really and truly understand socialization or art or nature, and outside of maybe football defense where all they need to know is “tackle guy in front of me” most sports require at least average intelligence to understand the strategy.
What about Mike Tyson? An incredible boxer (and boxing requires quick thinking) but doesn’t seem smart. Apparently his estimated IQ is 78.
I’m sure g does correlate: most dumb people don’t excel at anything that requires any form of intelligence, and most smart people (even autistic) do have social and emotional intelligence. But at the same time, an autistic genius who’s desperately lonely is not choosing to spend their g towards math. They may have the core smarts and just some small brain issue with them, but the small brain issue makes them socially unintelligent.
Quick note
Most people vastly overestimate their ability to predict second- and third-order effects of anything, including strategic speech.
I’ve concluded that “second-and-third order effects” are effectively unpredictable. There are the obvious-when-you-see them, then there are the plausible, which look convincing until you change some variables plausibly and reach the opposite conclusion. It’s like trying to predict the weather, except we’ve become good at that…like trying to predict the weather 1 week in the future? Unless you have inside (or obvious) information, you can only “mostly guess”.
So people’s politics include, if they’re smart common sense, and if they’re in a group currying favor…but otherwise, they come down to identity, because there’s no other coercion than within. Thus, I think politics is like art. People countersignal for the same reason they make unique art: because they want to stand out and be unique, so they see and express the unique parts of themselves. And I think, like unique art, countersignaling is very good, it satisfies curiosity and creates insight…except when people seriously adopt delusions or meanness, then they are hurting themselves and others, and also obviously wrong according to a reasonable, nice person.
You might, by temperament, aim it at different problems.
But the point is, that is what we measure and ultimately what matters.
There are savants who are STEM experts but cannot socialize or understand art, even when it clearly limits their QOL. Maybe their brains are technically wired better, so if we just teach or condition them right they could be therapy or art experts too, whereas we could not turn a mediocre therapist or artist into a STEM expert. But until we do that, their intelligence is for all intents different than someone who’s good at STEM but also socialization, or someone who’s charismatic but otherwise stupid.
Oh, the Amish survive, and classical liberalism and other niche ideologies with at least a few members. It's just that they will never leave nicheness unless they change. Even the Amish, with hundreds of thousands of members and growing faster than the general population, would take 30 years to reach 1,000,000 members at approximately their current rate (3%/yr) - and in 30 years the world will be much different, so it's practically certain they'll adapt in some ways.
"Use what worked in the past, but adapt to the present / future" was the entire ethos behind small-l liberalism. And it led to psychotic progressivism.
The replacement of classical liberalism with “woke” is exactly why classical liberalism did and does need to adapt. Likewise, the Amish may genuinely live more happy and sustainably than the trad posers, but the posers’ culture is more popular, and their simple life (a necessary ingredient of their happiness and sustainability) means they don’t have the force to stop it. Ultimately, you cannot recreate the past, only a crude imitation with misery nostalgia; the only way forward is to combine multiple elements of the past to create something novel, analogous to entropy and evolution.
That doesn’t mean classical conservatism nor liberalism will completely lose to their replacements. Those are after all inferior in many ways. The future will take some of what the present does right and some of what the past did right and leave out some of what each did wrong. I wish we would take classical liberalism’s idea tolerance and coherence and adopt it to modern trends…but what ideas the future takes and leaves, ultimately no-one can know.
Multiple intelligence is absolutely real. Look at the rationalists, “geniuses” who make obvious logic errors and can’t communicate.
Maybe social and emotional intelligence are just instinct and upbringing, while logic is faster thinking or larger context i.e. “liquid intelligence”. But intelligence is only valuable and measurable by what it observably does: in a way anything is “intelligent” because it follows the laws of physics, the secrets of the universe, but we generally don’t label it as so because it won’t tell us.
It is sex discrimination, it was before the change (Boy Scouts and Girl Scouts are inevitably different). But I think it’s good discrimination: men-only and women-only social spaces are important, and objectors could create a third Coed Scouts.
The problems here are 1) it’s unfortunate irrespective of whether it’s justified, and 2) a new Boy Scouts would probably encounter discrimination lawsuits moreso than the existing Girl Scouts, which means the law isn’t fair (yes, “both rich and poor (or here, popular and unpopular) can sue each other” is unfair when there’s inadequate reparation for illegitimate lawsuits.)
Hegseth is trying to change Scouting America (Motte discussion). I think instead he should, and he really should, re-create the Boy Scouts (letting Scouting America become the coed scouts, then maybe or maybe not fade away).
It also has the very sizeable drawback of people regarding the opposite gender as other
But frat members do socialize with women, in parties, other clubs, and classes.
The solution is to increase mandatory co-ed socialization, but that doesn’t require preventing same-sex socialization. And too much co-ed causes some men (and women) to resent the opposite gender, which may be pressure-released in same-sex settings.
For some it’s also “useless” like art: they want to understand and explain to others because they find the logic beautiful (in the exact same way artists find art beautiful).
And if AI obsoletes most human labor, why not keep paying them for that? A global mental health crisis is creating inefficiency and infighting, just look at modern politics.
When the results come with a proof it is always right (well, occasionally it exploits the prover, but I’m sure that’s far rarer than human error).
He’s widely considered the best living mathematician, really he’s the most famous and certainly one of the best.
The Green-Tao theorem proves there are arbitrarily long arithmetic progressions of primes, and an arithmetic progression is a sequence of numbers with constant difference, like (3, 7, 11) and (14, 19, 24, 29). He made progress in many other unsolved conjectures, including Collatz and Navier-Stokes.
He did manage one practical contribution: reducing lung MRI scan times. His work may eventually also improve cryptography (I remember this SMBC comic featuring Tao and already improved cryptography, but it’s about how someone else’s theoretical contribution found practical applications).
I’m not defending false accusers. I’m defending real victims who can’t prove themselves, protecting false accusers in the process, only because we can’t separate them. It’s the classic hypothetical “will you spare one innocent person if it means sparing 100 guilty ones?”
Obviously, sparing 100 murderers who will probably reoffend is not worth the life of one innocent. But false accusers are not murderers (and don’t actually ruin one’s life), nor do they avoid social consequences that make it hard to reoffend - in any somewhat-democratic system that could legalize execution in the first place.
Moreover, the above hypothetical is what defends false accusation victims, since allegedly the ratio of false accusations is very low. In general, I believe the legal system shouldn’t interfere in ambiguous situations, because it makes some people distrust it and reduces incentive to avoid them. Protecting both (ambiguously) false accusers and victims makes everyone somewhat unhappy, but kills no-one, while the alternative makes one group much unhappier.
I may write a long post of my thoughts about this, because coding LLMs have also become very impressive (and reliable) very recently. In summary:
Research has stagnated, with low-hanging fruit claimed decades ago and researchers only making novel contributions in their late 20s (even many PhDs today aren't really novel). Academia has also become burdened with bureaucracy: bloated administration, "publish or perish", and "researchers" who game the system without producing anything worthwhile (because even those who do produce must game today's system a little). It has been dying long before LLMs.
LLMs open the door to a new realm of opportunity. I expect many more groundbreaking discoveries going forward, of people who apply them in creative ways and others who follow. Like the proliferation of computers or the Internet; most would agree LLMs are at least as big a milestone. And if academics play their cards right, a resurgence of impressive discoveries is exactly what will revive their public appearance and funding.
But LLMs also close the door to most of the current realm. Most work that would be PhD-worthy before is now saturated by LLMs, who can do years of grunt work in weeks (where lower quality is unnoticed or tolerated). We also don't know how much better they'll become; I suppose in math, they already surpass Tao himself. People who've devoted years of learning and effort, now finding that easy to replicate, are feeling left behind, and some will be left behind, because they have to start over...
...well, I really hope they won't have to completely start over: I believe they should get legacy funding and support, kind of like the grant given to Tao, even if their work is completely eclipsed by LLMs - the door to financial stability and recognition artificially held open for the last cohort. Because otherwise no-one will start future long-term projects for fear of getting burned. But obviously new PhD students should not do what LLMs have trivialized, or are likely to barring true ASI...which leaves open the question what will they do, but this is a question that has always existed, and which most spend their first years figuring out anyways.
As I've said before, LLMs may lead to utopia or dystopia, but I don't think of them as good or bad, and I don't think it's worth most people's thought, because they are practically inevitable. What matters is that they are transformative, so we should figure out what they may transform, how, and prepare. I wish academia would adjust: gift-wrapping up obsolete work, leaving those researchers with their currently-allocated finance and prestige (including tenure) but expecting them to try to transition into something new...but unfortunately I slightly expect it to continue as-is, with funding for an unreasonably long time (because it's so entrenched), but that may not be long at all, and/or what it becomes to maintain the funding may make today (or 6 months ago) look like the ideal of pure scientific advancement.
Anyways, how may human-directed research, and math in particular, evolve? I'm almost certain it will stay and actually think it will grow. This is what I think is actually interesting (whereas, is any of the above unexpected?), but also more speculative and philosophical, so I have to think and plan it a bit longer.
we execute those who falsely claim rape
Sure in theory, but only if the claim is proven false, which I suspect is practically never. Even if the accused has a perfect alibi, the "victim" may have misremembered or misspoke the location; you'd have to find multiple obvious fabrications, but if you report finding one, they may suddenly not remember much else, which is not unusual genuinely after a traumatic event. The problem is that many women who are actually raped don't report, fearing getting mislabeled as a false accuser, and judicial consequences will worsen this.
What should happen, obviously, is that people accused of rape should be minimally affected unless and until solid evidence. Which is obviously not completely possible, but can be mitigated a lot by providing extra (financial and emotional) support to them. Look at it this way: the people who hating the falsely accused cannot be coerced into not hating them, locking up the "victim" would only and surely increase their hatred. Also, we can teach women to not only avoid dangerous situations, but (if they want) entrap potential rapists with real evidence, because who's defending someone who would actually rape?
(Ok, that last part they have to ensure the person is unambiguously planning rape, otherwise we get more "teenagers beat up random guy they assumed was a pedophile" and we just had Primetime, not to mention the woman must be careful for her own safety...so it's not actually a good idea in general. But I can't let go that it may be worth it for someone accused of serial rape, to also vindicate them if they turn out OK, because an ambiguous rape hurts both parties' reputations.)
My broad understanding is that when male only places begin to allow female membership they tend to disappear a decade later. I read an interesting paper in the last year that when a college major gets about something like 30-50% female it then quickly becomes 100% female.
Not in STEM, despite decades of trying. Even 20% is far more than the classes and conferences I’ve attended.
Solution: instead of extreme drinking, frat parties host LAN tournaments, hackathons, and pen testing contests. Women seem to conspicuously avoid these, which I think is a shame honestly, but at least they’re way more fun and don’t lead to alcoholism.
Apparently philosophy also suffers from lack of women, so alternatively, the frats can become debate clubs. Instead of hazing, require inductees to demonstrate some actual understanding of Hegel.
(And yes, there are a significant amount of trans women compared to cis woman, but they’re all still a tiny minority compared to the men.)
We've trained diffusion and RWKV language models that are coherent: nowhere near frontier transformers, but I believe they basically surpass GPT 3.5. You can test RWKV locally on your machine by downloading a desktop app from https://rwkv.halowang.cloud/, and Google released DiffusionGemma 4 months ago.

I believe sharing stories is good because it helps others understand the world. Sharing a story, true or false, distorts people's perception, but they can ignore it, they can refuse to believe it, and they can contextualize it, so I think it's almost always a net positive. As long as the story doesn't obviously dox anyone.
Judgement: I agree it seems unlikely the men are legally guilty, because there is not solid evidence they didn't ignore the woman's consent, and AFAIK US law doesn't factor drunkenness into consent (unless "incapacitated"). In general, I still hold that laws shouldn't apply in ambiguous situations like this. But they may be morally guilty.
My take, maybe unconventional, is that if it was consensual (otherwise the problem is obvious), the problem happened when Jane Doe was "slut shamed" and uninvited to the Halloween party. That made her feel socially unwelcome, and thus taken advantage of, which I think she was: it would be unreasonable for her to expect the sex to develop into a deeper relationship; but it's unfair for it not to lower her social standing without affecting the men's, and if that's the natural consequence. them what she did to lower the men's is too (Prisoner's dilemma, except if the fraternity and sorority members thought more, they could've realized it beforehand).
More options
Context Copy link