Capital_Room
rather dementor-like
Disabled Alaskan Monarchist doomer
User ID: 2666
I've read/watched a couple of debates on this topic, and my thoughts are rather inchoate and unformed as of yet (I often thought both sides made good points), but I'll try to lay a couple of them out here:
First, I tend to agree with a couple of people out there (I don't remember which) who argued that, while they agree with the substance, "Christian nationalism" makes for a poor label.
Second, as I've said on Tumblr, I think we need more people saying what Heidi Przybyla has said, as to the defining characteristic of "Christian nationalism":
The thing that unites them as Christian nationalists — not Christians, because Christian nationalists are very different — is that they believe that our rights as Americans and as all human beings do not come from any Earthly authority. They don't come from Congress, from the Supreme Court, they come from God.
Yes, we need more people saying that Americans' rights come from Congress and the Supreme Court (except when they overturn Roe or keep Trump on the ballot), and anyone who says otherwise (such as Thomas Jefferson, or the rest of the Founding Fathers, or pretty much any American statesman up until maybe half a century ago) is a dangerous, fanatical “Christian Nationalist” theocrat.
Third, this is in many ways an extension of some debates that have been going on longer than I've been alive, particularly the "you can't legislate morality" vs "all law is 'legislating morality'" debate; and also the question of what extent the voters in our democracy are allowed, by way of their elected representatives, to enact laws that reflect their collective moral values, specifically when those values are informed by their religion and you have the 1st Amendment. I'm reminded of times in the gay marriage debate, when proponents would argue that secular arguments against gay marriage are really just religious arguments if the person making them is Christian, to a level that almost approached 'separation of church and state means only atheists get to make laws.'
I'm reminded of Sullivan's The Impossibility of Religious Freedom. That true moral neutrality of the public square is impossible, and that there will always be some sort of dominant moral framework to the law which "overrides" any religious views to the contrary; that in the early days of America, this was a generally Protestant Christian framework, with freedom of religion primarily being a truce between denominations not to use the state to settle matters of doctrinal differences; and that since that's no longer the case, we should instead "solve" the current tensions by moving toward the French, by rethinking "freedom of religion" to mean something more like "freedom of conscience," but that once you step outside your church/synagogue/mosque/temple, your moral views must become totally subordinate to a "secular" moral system.
In other words, that with the Constitution forbidding the establishment of theistic religion, the void may — and must — be filled by the unofficial establishment of a nontheistic religion-substitute.
Fourth, I don't remember where it was, but I recall one commenter on the issue of "Christian nationalism" arguing that the reason it's rising as a new boogeyman for the left is because many of them had thought, post-Obergefell, that they had indeed pretty much achieved Sullivan's solution and banished the last traces of "Christian morality" from the public square. But then Trump and Dobbs happened, and older people on the Christian right — who'd previously taken the existence of a sort of "Moral Majority" Judeo-Christian consensus in America for granted — realized just how much they'd lost in the public square and began shedding some of their passivity. That Christian-informed moral views might begin inching back into our politics, particularly with the influx of Hispanic immigrants, is thus a trend to be squashed.
In short, that this is simply a fight as to which set of values is going to have cultural dominance.
I can say from 30 years of living here with a fair amount of certainty that, regardless of tribal sympathies, the entire Northeast US would need to be pacified
Yes, and? Eradicating the "Blue Tribe" as a culture is the goal, and if that requires eliminating a lot of them physically, then so be it.
Let's gameplan it.
I'm not sure I can go into much detail; not without going beyond the limits of what this place allows.
But the ideal scenario, as for methods, is Caesarism — we get an Augustus seizing power. Worst-case scenario, then, is probably Boojahideen — the Left gets to see what an actual "Christian Taliban" looks like.
Is there killing?
Definitely. The question is how much will be necessary.
Brainwashing?
Russell conjugation: I educate, you indoctrinate, they brainwash.
New laws? Revoking of old laws?
Both, and massively so.
What institutions are torn down and which remain?
As with Augustus, the surface forms of some old institutions would probably survive, but the substance would be radically replaced.
For example, with academia, our Caesar's actions should fall somewhere between Henry VIII's Dissolution of the Monasteries and 1960s Suharto.
Is there a victory possible that is not an orgy of violence because I just cant see it.
I can't see it, either. Indeed, our mental pictures of "a progressive culture war rout" are very similar. It's just that, barring some better path to victory, I find that to be a preferable outcome to the alternative.
Per my comment on how the Blue Tribe's hatred for the Red Tribe is a core part of their culture, the only way to keep my people safe from Blue Tribe's unceasing attempts to eradicate our culture is to eradicate the Blue Tribe as a culture first.
There's a regular commenter over at the Dreaded Jim's blog known as "The Cominator," whose standard position is that only one right-wing regime has ever gone far enough when it comes to purging the Left enough to make a lasting difference. I recently looked up the historical figures to put some numbers to The Cominator's proposals… and it pretty much lines up with the National Center for Education Statistics's figure for the total number of people employed by US postsecondary institutions. Throw in Democrat party politicians — a figure about a couple of orders of magnitude smaller — and it'll about match, proportional to population, the level's achieved by Cominator's exemplar.
Pass laws that affirmatively teach whatever it is they think kids should know,
Except, as we've seen in Florida, this doesn't work. It gets characterized as "right-wing cancel culture," "don't say 'gay,'" "'whitewashing' history," and so on. And, as a number of teachers and union representatives have asserted, they're not going to obey. I've seen invocations of the Scopes trial — 'it didn't matter how many laws the backwards creationists passed to forbid it, we never let those stop us from teaching the truth of Darwinian evolution; and similarly, it doesn't matter how many laws the stupid right-wing bigots pass trying to mandate we teach lies about America's racist history, LGBT+ identities, or whatever, we will keep on providing children with the Truth!' Personnel is policy, and there's a general dearth of enforcement mechanisms when the entire profession is ideologically captured and in opposition. Which gets to the next part.
then pay what and train who is necessary to alter the majority ideology among teachers.
The only way to do that is to fire pretty much all the existing teachers and replace them with new ones that aren't beholden to the current ideology. So, first, how long would it take to train enough new teachers to replace the over 400,000 teachers and administrators Texas currently has. Second, this would require replacing the current ideologically-captured system of teacher-training, which would pretty much require the wholesale purging and replacement of American academia, at which point one gets into the domain of coup-complete problems.
and is flabbergasted how a country of 300 million cannot pick someone younger to lead it.
This, of course, assumes that it is that "300 million" who do the picking…
School vouchers address a problem at a much lower level than necessary.
Secondly, they fail to address the fact that most teachers are still fundamentally progressive.
And how do you propose places like Texas address this instead? What does addressing the problem at a "higher level" look like?
Again, alienating the core fans lost them the support they would have needed in these tougher economic times.
That's what high ESG scores are for — who needs "core fans" to buy your product, when you can get that sweet, sweet Blackrock money to see you through instead? Go woke, go broke have Larry Fink pay to keep you afloat.
This has been going through a number of the podcast & youtube circles I listen to, and there's a few points made by some of them that I've pretty much come around to.
First, that as one put it, Sweet Baby Inc. is just successful Feminist Frequency. This bit of "Gamergate 2.0" just serves to illustrate that the gamers lost in the original.
Not that it was ever really a battle worth winning. That's the second point. "The only thing faker than Trump was Gamergate," as a podcaster put it. Because video games — like movies, comic books, football, etc. — are just an escapist "release valve" keeping people idle and passive. That the attitude of the Gamergaters — including the current anti-SBI crowd — is really just "burn my society down around me, I'm fine with that, just so long as you let me have this little corner of escapism."
It's treating a symptom (a potentially useful one at that) instead of going at the disease. I remember one of the videos had clips from one of SBI's top people, which included what was basically encouragement of a "nice video game studio you've got here; shame if someone were to call it sexist/racist/homophobic/transphobic" strategy. But why does that strategy work to begin with? Another reason firms like SBI work is ESG scores and the corresponding low-interest money. Why is that a thing? Because our society lets fat-cat finance capitalists like Larry Fink go unstopped.
Without video games, or Marvel movies, or football to keep them passive, maybe young men would start getting up off their butts and get active. Don't "fight" to take back gaming or comic books, fight to take back your country, to take back Western Civilization. Because there won't be anyone trying to "wokify" your little hobby once the Woke have been crushed utterly.
Why do you do it? How long will you keep doing it? Will you ever stop? Will you someday say "oh, the revolution has gotten to my stop and I want off," or is the only real goal to keep pushing and hurting and winning endlessly?
Contrary to what Trump claimed, nobody ever really gets tired of winning.
There are many useful actions to take, many useful things to be done, many choices to be made, many strategies to pursue. It is, in fact, possible to Do Something
I see absolutely no evidence to support any of this. Indeed, all I ever see people hold forth as possibilities are "plans" based on pure wishful thinking and optimism bias (and sometimes religious faith), none of which, at least to my perception, can possibly work.
I have experienced this myself, a number of times.
And you were right to, and you shouldn't have let people dissuade you from it.
Personally, I think it helped me gain an understanding of what is happening and why.
To what end? Understanding what is happening and for what reason is only useful if you can actually do something about it. It does no good to understand the "whats and whys" of something unstoppable and unavoidable.
Unfortunately the greatest trick the progressives pulled is to convince white people they don't matter.
Not all that hard a "trick" though, given how we're unusually-outbred WEIRDos, and given their ability to keep WWII as one of the core defining narratives of modern society. So long as 'white people thinking they do matter' can be pattern-matched to the Austrian Painter and his snappy-dressed minions (still providing the basic visual short-hand for "evil" in all our entertainment for over seven decades)…
Why do we need to throw away billions salving the egos of people who can never meaningfully give anything of worth back?
Because if you won't, they'll provide a political power base for those who will.
we remove any reason to think that outcomes across groups should be the same
This gets back to that effort-post I need to write, but, for some "outcomes across groups should be the same" doesn't need a reason, because the "should" in that statement is expressing deontic modality, not epistemic modality. That "equity" — equal outcomes across groups — is a terminal value, a moral obligation of our society to provide, and which needs no further justification given its self-evident moral correctness. Like the Jamaican HBD blogger who argued that blacks are indeed genetically predisposed to higher criminality, but that their incarceration rate should be population-proportional no matter how much more crime they commit, as part of his general position that society is obligated to redistribute from 'genetic haves' to 'genetic have-nots' however much is necessary to equalize group outcomes despite the differences in ability, intelligence, behavior, etc.
we're not putting the genie of 'sexual liberation' back in the bottle of 'no sex outside of marriage'.
Why not? Sure, it wouldn't be easy, but I don't see it being impossible. If nothing else, a total collapse of industrial civilization and global reversion to pre-1700 technology levels would indeed put the proverbial genie right back; which establishes that it's at least possible. Sure, "turning back the clock" would probably require some pretty strong measures to pull off, but I figure a determined, non-democratic far-Right government could probably accomplish quite a lot toward this end.
You don’t say what other things can be done in the present
Because I'm pretty sure I'd eat a ban for doing so. What exactly did you think I meant by "flipping the table"?
Do reactionaries commonly believe it’s actually good to vote for the bad side?
In my circles, no, because it's "bad" to vote at all, being against democracy as we are.
It seems clear a future where the GOP gives up on winning election will not be good for gun rights.
Except you're assuming that right-wingers giving up on winning elections means doing nothing at all.
Plus, you ask us to focus on one small, narrow area where the Right is winning — for now, though the long-term demographic trends point toward an almost-certain reversal down the line — and ignore the many, many more issues where we're losing. Again, it's another version of the assertion that we should be happy merely with losing slowly, on the grounds we could be losing faster.
And, if you’re a conservative, avoiding a bad change is a victory itself.
Well, good thing I, for one, am a reactionary, not a conservative. "Not losing" is not winning, winning is winning.
If the culture war situation was, on average, where it is specifically on gun rights
But it's not, and there's no way within the "rules of the game" to get it there.
for abundant sexual access outside of marriage,
And if we nip the whole chain you lay out in the bud at this stage?
The question is not whether things would be even worse if our enemies had even more power than they currently do. The question is whether the formal system can in fact provide impartial redress for our grievances. I think the evidence is pretty clear that it cannot.
Yeah, when the choice presented is between losing quickly and losing slowly, the answer is to flip the table.
I've argued this same point with fellow right-wingers IRL (and it's interesting which ones tended to agree), to the point of arguing that overturning no-fault divorce should be a higher priority than trying to get Obergefell overturned. First, because AIUA the former is primarily statutory, and passing legislation is generally easier than overturning Supreme Court precedent; and second, because without no-fault divorce, I'd expect gay marriage rates drop significantly even if still legal.
If elections are so rigged against the GOP
My argument isn't that Republicans can't win elections, its that their winning elections doesn't matter. As Yarvin once said, there's a difference between taking office and taking power. It doesn't matter if some Republicans get voted in, real power resides far more in the permanent bureaucracy, the "NGOcracy" non-profit networks, academia, and other such Left-captured institutions, which together have so many ways of blocking temporary, merely-elected GOP politicians, that it doesn't much matter who wins the election, because the Left wins either way.
And I had much more radical things in mind for "where the Right is strong" than the Senate and Electoral College.
I, like the rest of the country, feel like nothing good will come of the election.
…
I don't respect sore losers, and moreover, I don't like the fact that there is no path forward for the right.
If you thought it was bad before, Russell Berman has a piece at The Atlantic with an even worse scenario: "How Democrats Could Disqualify Trump If the Supreme Court Doesn’t":
Near the end of the Supreme Court’s oral arguments about whether Colorado could exclude former President Donald Trump from its ballot as an insurrectionist, the attorney representing voters from the state offered a warning to the justices—one evoking the January 6 riot that had set the case in motion.
By this point in the hearing, the justices had made clear that they didn’t like the idea of allowing a single state to kick Trump out of the presidential race, and they didn’t appear comfortable with the Court doing so either. Sensing that Trump would likely stay on the ballot, the attorney, Jason Murray, said that if the Supreme Court didn’t resolve the question of Trump’s eligibility, “it could come back with a vengeance”—after the election, when Congress meets once again to count and certify the votes of the Electoral College.
Murray and other legal scholars say that, absent clear guidance from the Supreme Court, a Trump win could lead to a constitutional crisis in Congress. Democrats would have to choose between confirming a winner many of them believe is ineligible and defying the will of voters who elected him. Their choice could be decisive: As their victory in a House special election in New York last week demonstrated, Democrats have a serious chance of winning a majority in Congress in November, even if Trump recaptures the presidency on the same day. If that happens, they could have the votes to prevent him from taking office.
[Emphasis added]
Just picture what happens if Trump wins in November, but a Democrat Congress refuses to certify in January and gives it to Biden instead — totally not an "insurrection," just "defending Our Democracy". Sure, maybe the lefties around you won't "whine and complain for 4 years"… or maybe they'll be complaining about how "racism and sexism is everywhere again" as demonstrated by Trump winning the vote despite being an illegitimate candidate, and what a perilous state Our Democracy is in that Congress had to resort to such extreme measures after the courts failed to do their job, and so on. While, meanwhile, there's certainly going to be even more unhappiness on the Right.
(Though, really, I'm coming around to preferring an outcome like this. Because if this doesn't get Republican voters to accept that "Our Democracy" is fundamentally rigged against them and that voting is pointless, I don't know what will.)
Is there a way for the currents to move right without the undercurrents moving left?
I actually want to discuss whether the currents/counter-currents situation leaves any actual options for non-leftists, and I think that merits discussion.
My first reaction is to say no, there aren't any actual options for non-leftists, we're doomed, all hope is lost, etc., etc. Though, when I express such views online, at best I get people going on at me about how "that's the depression talking" and so on. (And when I push those people for what they consider options, it's mostly of the "vote harder, debate harder, 'own the libs with facts and logic' harder, and somehow overcome all of the left's institutional, cultural, and rhetorical advantages through sheer excellence" sort.) More often, it's lectures about how "despair is a sin" (here, the "solutions" tend to be waiting for Divine Providence to eventually deliver), or even just denunciations as a shill ("are you getting paid for this demoralization op in shekels or yuan?") or a traitor ("getting killed by leftists is the real right-wing victory").
So, in the spirit of trying to be more optimistic — like my therapists keep telling me — I'll limit it to saying there are no options for non-leftists within "the rules of the game" as currently constituted (and so thoroughly rigged against us). As for options "outside the game," well, I don't think I can discuss those here without eating a ban. Thus, I'll vaguely gesture toward Sun-Tzu's comments about not fighting where your enemy is strong and you are weak, but where you are strong and the enemy is weak.
Where exactly would you classify Confucianism in terms of "religion" vs. "not a religion"? I'm thinking both of Confucius's refusal to address supernatural matters, as well as atheist Confucians like Xunzi. Do you see Confucianism as having "worked" only to the extent is was a philosophical adjunct to traditional Chinese "folk religion"?

In theory, sure. The argument is that in practice, the results tended toward a Protestant framework, and that other religions — particularly Catholicism and Judaism, but also to a lesser extent Buddhism, achieved the tolerance they did by "Protestantizing" their forms of practice to varying degrees. Indeed, it's not just Sullivan who has argued that the way Americans — particularly the courts — think of religion almost entirely in terms of beliefs about the supernatural (orthodoxy over orthopraxy) is very sola scriptura and sola fides in character.
I've seen something along these lines also raised as a criticism of modern reconstructionist neopaganism as contrasted to both (what we know of) the original, as well as surviving polytheistic practices (such as Shinto and Hinduism). Specifically, that neopagans tend to focus a lot more on belief — personal belief — in a list of deities, as opposed to centering upon the performance of rites, making of sacrificial offerings, reading of omens; that "traditional" polytheism is much more orthopractic and — for lack of a better word — transactional.
Back during the Iraq War, and still occasionally since, I encounter people online arguing that Islam "isn't a religion," but is instead a "political ideology" or similar. And when those folks bother to try to make case for this position, it usually boils down to an inability to fully squeeze the likes of fiqh into that Protestant-tinged frame of what is or isn't a religion.
For that matter, even that proposed reduction of freedom of religion to "freedom of conscience" is based on the implication that the most important part of "religion" is what you, in the privacy of your own head, do or don't think about god(s) and the supernatural. (I'd note that this is a rather unusual view historically speaking. The Romans would have found it pretty alien. Their contemporaries in China too. Probably the Aztecs and the Incas, too.)
More options
Context Copy link