@Capital_Room's banner p

Capital_Room

rather dementor-like

0 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2023 September 18 03:13:26 UTC

Disabled Alaskan Monarchist doomer


				

User ID: 2666

Capital_Room

rather dementor-like

0 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2023 September 18 03:13:26 UTC

					

Disabled Alaskan Monarchist doomer


					

User ID: 2666

a swing towards right wing curmudgeons

There was a lengthy comment by a guest in one of Neema Parvini's recent videos relevant to this point (at about 1:23:00); let me see if I can transcribe it:

The time scale isn’t to do with presidencies, and people think in time horizons that are far too narrow. Policy is not decided every four years. Policy is not made up every four years. There is permanent continuation policy of the American government and the American Empire that has taken place since 1945; and that much is very, very evident.

The people saying leaders matter — Trump was never the leader of America. Trump was never in power. That is the lesson you should take away from this. He didn’t know how many troops were in Syria; they simply lied to him and waited until he left office. Donald Trump was not in power because the levers of power lead nowhere; and emotionally attaching to who is in the presidency is part of the problem that we have, in that most Western policy in most places is on rails. I do not believe that the last ten years of the Tory government in Britain, to answer AA’s question, would have been particularly different under a Labour government. The Equality Act is something that was dreamt up by Labour and brought by the Tories.

People talk about the Uniparty. It’s really a basic bitch Libertarian talking point, but they’re right. There really is no difference in terms of macro-policy, in terms of a decades-long time scale, whether you have a blue government or red government, because nations are not ruled by elected officials. Democracy does not function. Nations are ruled by the permanent bureaucracy, which does not change.

And to bring my final point into this, a political victory, and a real transfer of power is what took place in Ukraine in 2014, with a process known as “lustration,” where they banned every government official — including judges — from being part of the government for five to ten years. That is what it looks like when an American-directed vassal actually wants to change who is in office.

Who is in office does not change in Western democracies, and that is a fundamental misunderstanding of this point. We shouldn’t celebrate this, and we shouldn’t have an emotional stake in it, because who is in power is not changing. It is not changing in the Netherlands, it is not changing in Argentina, and it has not changed in Italy. Who is in power has not changed, and I think that is really why talking about the posters put over the permanent regimes and bureaucracies — which largely are vassals of global American power, let’s be fair — is relatively meaningless. It’s impossible to say whether you were better off or worse off under certain regimes, because the regime does. Not. Change.

You are assuming that people wait in their homes for the SWAT teams to come for them, which it is not clear they will do.

Because that's what all the fellow Red Tribers I talk to proudly declare they're going to do, and sometimes going on about how they'll shoot anybody who calls on them to do more. "We're the people who, when someone tells us to breathe, suffocate to death. It's our superpower." "'Fourth generation warfare' means the 'lone wolf' with no coordination, supplies, logistics, plan will automatically win over any superior number of well-supplied, well-coordinated troops!"

Further, you are assuming that the capability is limited to our ubiquitous autoloading cartridge-firing weapons

Plus some limited explosives, crudely-assembled technicals, etc. The problem is that amateurs talk tactics, professionals talk logistics. And logistics require coordination. As in the German Peasants' War, it's these that win the war. One side is highly coordinated (read David Hines), while the other is practically allergic to coordination (at least partially due to the other side's ability and willingness to come down hard on any attempts to build it, but also due to fundamental temperament).

the political fights over gun control are useful to coordinate within Red Tribe over the question "is it time to fight?".

Except that from what I see — particularly given the Left's deft hand at proverbial "frog-boiling" — the answer is consistently never. "This is not the hill to die on." Nor is the next, when we retreat to that one. Nor the next, nor the next. I've seen fellows on the right lay out some "redline" where the Left will have truly "gone too far" if they cross it… and then a decade later, when it's indeed crossed, well, pick your battles, "this is not the hill to die on," and David French may have a point with his latest "the Conservative Case for [Insert latest left victory here]" piece, don't you know?

Once the question is answered to the affirmative

It never will.

it seems to me that autoloading cartridge smallarms largely go to the sidelines.

In favor of, what, McVeigh truck bombs? Light aircraft crashed into IRS offices (full of nothing but entirely replaceable cogs in the vast Federal machine)?

if blues can successfully confiscate personal firearms,

I think they'll mostly just keep salami-slicing, plus anarcho-tyranny if you use them in self-defense, plus demographic trends, to make that increasingly small and irrelevant without any big, triggering mass confiscation

inflict serious social and legal consequences on non-woke Christianity

Beyond what they're already doing? Plus, again, demographics ̉— sure, the Amish and Mormons have the birthrates, but the Left have education, and Wisconsin v. Yoder and homeschooling are both doomed long term

and maintain something approaching the current economic and socio-political conditions,

This, I don't think they can do, but one can very easily stay on top in a decline. Tocqueville's Law — it's when improving conditions begin to slow that people rebel. When things decline, people are too busy fighting for their own individual "slice" of the shrinking "pie" to meaningfully rebel. And the Iron Law of Institutions — better to reign in Hell, and all that. There's a lot of ruin in the West, and Industrial civilization has a lot of seedcorn needed for its maintenance that can be diverted to propping up the system instead, allowing them time to crush all rivals before the arrival of the inevitable crash (which thus proves so devastating that we're knocked so far back into pre-industrial conditions that it's impossible to ever recover).

But nevertheless, it's also important to keep in mind that we did in fact make great advances.

Read Gregory Clark's The Son Also Rises. Most people tend to both overestimate modern inter-generational mobility (note that wealth/income only partially correlates with social class), and underestimate past intergenerational mobility. Clark argues that, except for the uniquely low social mobility in India thanks to the caste system, intergenerational class mobility has been pretty uniform across periods and societies (where societies are large and complex enough to have stratification, that is), and the present is no exception.

Monarchy, as we have seen in the past, would just make them go "actually, I deserve this",

Counterpoint: Toby Young's "The Fall of the Meritocracy." If anything breeds "I deserve this" attitudes among elites — and the belief that the people beneath them deserve their station too — it's the view that they earned their position via "merit" (and those lower are so because they lack merit), and not mostly due to being born to the right parents (a better description of the reality). Whereas, when you openly acknowledge that the people on top are only really there thanks to mere accident of birth, "there but for the grace of God go I." It looks to me like you can't really have noblesse oblige without the noblesse part.

and physically fight against security

Why would they need to? Security will be the ones helping them "lock the new guys out of the building" and "keep[ing] the other guys coming in."

Oh, plus, BTW, we need to infiltrate whatever organization manages their pay system to keep the paychecks going

No they won't, because, in a sense, they already have. Even if it's "some other agency," it's still fully-captured, still staffed by the same sort of people, in full agreement. The managers of their pay system will side with them automatically. It's all one big, totally-captured Permanent Bureaucracy, the "separate parts" in lock-step with one another.

Do those Senate-confirmed appointees file their TPS reports? If so, problem solved.

How does that solve the problem?

Each of these people almost certainly can carry out the duty of listing the new Schedule F slots pretty much on their own, if they have to.

Again, how do they enforce this duty?

So Trump fires a political appointee whose nominal subordinates refuse to obey, and replaces them. What prevents the agency from continuing to #Resist the new Trump appointee?

If they do it, he can just bring in security from one of the other agencies

Who are just as captured and will side with them against a Republican president. The whole point is that nobody is going to obey. Every group with the power to enforce any firings outside the direct appointment level is already part of the #Resistance, and are going to side with their fellow Defenders of Our Democracy against Cheeto Hitler's ordering them to help make him Führer.

risking prison for themselves

How so? Who's going to arrest them?

The judicial system is not partisan enough to go along with this, and judges tend to deeply resent being threatened in their own courtrooms.

“John Marshall has made his decision, now let him enforce it.”

AFAIK, DC still hasn't given Dick Heller his carry permit. As others have noted here, the people targeting Masterpiece Cakeshop looked at his court win, shrugged, and just kept on without the slightest change in behavior. They already ignore unfavorable court rulings, so why not more so?

I don't understand how people who are in favor of mass-immigration can just so completely throw caution to the wind. Even with high confidence that mass immigration won't be a problem, if you're wrong, it's game over.

Well, there's the Nathan Smith "How Would a Billion Immigrants Change the American Polity?" position — from people often given to repeating Milton Friedman's comment about mass immigration and the welfare state and, like him, arguing for picking the former over the latter — which holds that the pressures of mass immigration will force the system to adapt (in ways these sorts of people find personally favorable) to keep functioning. While Smith makes analogy to Rome, the better point of comparison is the UAE.

And, I think it was back on Twitter a few years ago, I remember Bryan Caplan making similar "the system will have to adapt" arguments, and someone pushed back, pointing to our politicians and asking what happens if they don't make the changes open borders libertarian types ask for. He gave the same response he's given some other times: mass immigration is ultimately a self-limiting problem. Immigrants tolerate the language barrier and cultural difference issues because they're outweighed by the economic benefits of living in a country like America or Canada. Thus, if the effects of this immigration become increasingly detrimental, the economy and quality of life will decline, reducing that incentive to keep coming. Once America is reduced to a level near Mexico, Latin American immigration will stop, and perhaps even reverse (and similarly with Canada versus the sources of its immigrants).

Sure, someone argued back, but then you've still wrecked the country, even if the process eventually stalls out. That, Caplan replied, is just another reason to support immigration — because if that does happen, well, English is enough of a lingua franca in academia that a famous economist like him can get a job teaching at pretty much any university anywhere on Earth. (And as for those who aren't famed econ professors like him? That's their problem.)

And I think it was Tyler Cowen who made the point that "3rd world countries" aren't uniformly terrible; that in the cities you can find pockets where the elites live in "1st world" conditions with the added bonus of cheap personal servants — you just have to be able to afford it. But, much in line with Smith's position, if you're one of those who isn't in job competition with immigrant labor, but instead positioned to benefit from it, then your economic gains will allow you to pay for the gated community, the private security, etc. to let you maintain your 1st world lifestyle even if most the rest of the country ends up immiserated, with the added benefit of affordable personal servants and cheap chalupas.

So, IME, a lot of "f— you, got mine" attitude, and confidence that no matter how bad it gets, the consequences will only fall on the little people beneath them.

Well, that and a lot of "bleeding heart" types who simply don't think about long-term or large scale consequences, and who, at their worst, deny that unintended and second-order consequences are even a thing.

For reasons I've gone into before on here, I say absolutely not.

This is the sort of thing you really ought to get on tape.

This was the mid 1990s, so it would have had to have been literal cassette tape. And usually the type of thing teachers would confiscate if you brought to school.

A school administrator told me to my face that, with regards to state education law and their ongoing violation of it in my case, "The law doesn't matter. The law can say whatever it wants," but what matters is what you can get a court to enforce "and I know your parents can't afford a lawyer."

But when a friend of mine was about to be in the exact same situation, except this friend's last name is on a major street of this city and a whole bunch of buildings (including the former mall that is now the school district's headquarters), suddenly they were able to shake loose the supposedly-nonexistent resources to do for him what they couldn't possibly do for me, law or no law.

Because I'm a peasant nobody, and he's local petty nobility. It's that simple. Over two centuries of "the American Experiment" attempting so hard to create a society free of hereditary class in line with those "deep-rooted egalitarian sentiments," and look at how little we've accomplished. Apparently, most people think the response to looking at this utter failure should be the conclusion that we need to double down and try even harder. Me, though? It may be that us autists are apparently resistant to the "sunk cost fallacy" and other common forms of human irrational persistence, or it may just be that I'm personally given to calling it quits on things, but I look at that, and I just see trying harder as "throwing good money after bad," that we should just accept the sunk costs as sunk, admit the goal, however noble, looks impossible, declare the whole "experiment" a failure, write it all off, and just openly acknowledge who are born to which class and how that still matters (will always matter).

In particular teachers are not ideologues;

Not my experience. (My late grandmother was a teacher, so I've known a few through her. My educational career was an ongoing fight with teachers and administrators. Several of the times I got lectures from teachers it was for expressing the "wrong" political opinion in my writing. I worked as a substitute for a time, and also as a tutor. So I've picked up a fair bit of the general "feel" of at least those teachers working for the ASD. And while some of the older generations, nearing retirement, may fit "rule worshipping slightly smart highly conformist non radicals," the rest seem much more "politically-indoctrinated slightly-dim ('those who can, do; those who can't, teach') conformist activists.'

but there’s not actual indoctrination of teachers going on as far as anyone can tell.

Again, my experience is that for the past ten years at least, they are "actually indoctrinated" — deeply so.

Some of it might just be that political capture has set the rules they worship and the standards they conform to such that "1619 project" attitudes aren't "radical," but only some, and I don't see breaking that consensus is anything less than a "coup-complete" problem.

"CRT bans" aren't working, will not work, because teachers — the entire profession — will openly defy them out of ideological fervor. The Left has totally conquered public schooling like they have everything else. One cannot get hired to work in a public school anymore without being a committed Leftist ideologue. And any attempt by the Right to build an alternative for their children will be crushed. The war has already been won utterly.

support from irl communities invested in protecting them from such things.

Protecting them how? If you have a social worker showing up to "investigate" each month, every month, what can others do to "protect" you from the hassle, the stress, the time loss, et cetera. I say this because there's a non-homeschooling case — involving kids walking home from school a few blocks away, and a neighbor who considered that "neglect" — which immediately comes to mind.

Yeah, that was my point #1. Since you can't prove which ads cause what, it makes the whole industry somewhat insulated from immediate "hard contact with reality" feedback, leading to field-wide dominance of "vibes" and the primary incentives being personal rather than institutional.

It's increasingly difficult to find any refuge from the daily barrage of reminders that your society is signaling it hates you and is excited for you and your kind to die off.

Well, why should your society, given that it hates you and is excited for you and your kind to die off, allow you any such refuge?

Legitimacy, legitimacy, legitimacy

This "legitimacy" thing people keep talking about seems like a spook to me. "Political power grows out of the barrel of a gun." People obey the law and the government because armed men will haul you off and throw you in a cage if you don't (and shoot you if you resist). "The law" is only whatever rules you'll get punished for breaking. "Federal Law" isn't the US Code, it's only 'whatever the FBI, DEA, ATF, etc. will arrest you for' — nothing less, nothing more. And as long as those men with guns keep on enforcing the same rules, nothing changes, regardless of what some old man in some old building might say quoting old words on some old piece of parchment.

Homeschoolers already have a playbook for CPS interest; increased scrutiny is unlikely to do much

Even if it doesn't result in removal, it can still be an ongoing hassle. "The process is the punishment" and all that.

In communities with broad agreement on values, it even works pretty well.

The problem then, of course, is what happens when there's no longer any such broad agreement.

I'll have to homeschool

Until they ban it. Then what?

Representation does matter, but those making the decisions are so ideologically committed that they’re willing to hurt their own bottom line in order to “do the right thing.” They’re so committed to their ideals that they’re willing to depress their own effectiveness by more than 30%.

Except it's not this straightforward, for two reasons. First, try proving that these decisions are actually hurting the bottom line. As the old quote attributed to various famous businessmen goes: "Half the money I spend on advertising is wasted; the trouble is I don't know which half." Advertising is anything but an exact science, and business outcomes are subject to many hard-to-disentangle factors. So how would one convince bosses or coworkers that this isn't the way to get more business?

Secondly, the interests and incentives of an institution are not the interests and incentives of the people within it. As I've seen it put elsewhere (particularly in discussions of the police, but also other fields), the first and highest job duty of any employee is not what it says on their job description, it's to make the boss happy. Of course, the usual way one does so is by performing the specific tasks for which one was hired, but those are ultimately just means to that end. If your boss insists on something being done a particular way, a particular way that's stupid and costs the business money, and instead you do it a different way that saves the business money, how do you suppose it will impact your continued employment if the boss finds out?

I've seen multiple people point out with respect to the whole Bud Light thing, that while going with Mulvaney may not have been a good choice for the business as a whole, it was probably the best choice for the advertising people who originally recommended that course with regards to their future employment opportunities elsewhere within the advertising industry, particularly as compared to the opposite strategy. "Nobody gets fired for buying IBM" and all that.

So nobody need actually go "I'm doing this no matter how much money it costs me!" They need only have uncertainty as to what will or won't cost the business more customers, combined with a solid understanding of what best suits their own personal, long-term job interests independent of a particular company's interests.

Conclusion: Second US Civil War will be fought with pickup trucks and construction machinery with extra metal plates welded on.

Again, what makes you think it'd ever get to a "Second US Civil War" stage with open military, rather than just a bunch of Wacos, Ruby Ridges, and the arrest and/or execution of a bunch of attempted or actual McVeighs? Just ordinary law enforcement keeping Our Democracy safe from domestic terrorists?

following a complete collapse of the federal government.

Exactly. And I see no reason for it to collapse just because it's made explicit — even more explicit than our current doddering figurehead-in-chief does — that a US President has little more power than King Charles III does.

the breakdown in federal authority

What "breakdown in federal authority"? My point is that there wouldn't be any such thing. Why would there be? Just because a few hundred temporary figureheads are cut out of the loop more openly and explicitly than before?

You are betting that the methods this search has discovered so far are more or less the best methods available.

It's more "what's available to one side that they're willing to use" than just "what's available."

And I don't see the basis for your confidence. I believe that there's basically nothing that the Red Tribe is both capable of and willing to do "to hurt the outgroup badly," and you — and others — have provided no real evidence to change my mind on that.

"Never give up, never surrender" might be great when it's coming from Tim Allen in a movie, but even the Japanese, with their "kamikaze attacks" and "banzai charges," eventually gave up and surrendered. At some point, one has to admit that war is lost. If the Red Tribe has not yet clearly passed this point, then where is that point?

While I wouldn't deny that there are cultural messages that come up here, I'd think that the workplace is a far bigger issue here than the K-12 education system.

Once again, I bring out Osili & Long's 2007 "Does Female Schooling Reduce Fertility? Evidence From Nigeria" [pdf], which found that each year of elementary school reduced the average number of children per woman by significant amounts. (You can also find more results from Africa on the negative correlation between female education and realized fertility rates here.) And while I can't find it at the moment, I recall a Nepalese study that found similar results for "Western-style" grade schools but, interestingly, not for "Islamic" ones. (Whether that's due to differences in the schools themselves, or a selection effect reflecting differences between the sorts of students who attend the two types of schools is a question, though.)

That is not really an issue of not wanting kids but trying to balance them with having a secure career first and failing.

Which, of course, could be addressed with better education about the realities of female fertility, the limits of technology, the nature of the trade-offs being made, and so on.

But certain works of fiction are of such cultural importance that they keep getting referenced by historical figures, so it is very helpful to have read the original so you know they talk about.

I once wrote a little trivia quiz "Bible or Shakespeare," that was full of commonly-used English phrases, idioms, and metaphors that originate in either the King James Bible or a Shakespeare work, and seeing if one could identify which of the two they came from. And then there's the Classical allusions: "Achilles' heel," "Trojan horse," "Herculean task," "siren song," etc. So much of our language at least used to be built around what, again, at least used to be a set of common stories and references, such that it can be hard to understand without it — I once encountered someone here in the US, and "culturally Catholic" at that, entirely unfamiliar with "30 pieces of silver," for example.

Not including this is a bit of an admission of defeat.

Yes, and? What's wrong with admitting defeat and moving on, anyway?

Americans get really nervous around anything that suggests a class system.

Yes, and the incident in junior high that greatly contributed to my becoming a reactionary monarchist (and when I tell people about it, they seem surprised at that, thinking it should have made me a leftist instead) was learning that we still quite clearly have one anyway, all "American Dream" rhetoric to the contrary.

(Most people try to make the system live up to the rhetoric; I say, simpler to make the rhetoric match the reality.)