FirmWeird
Randomly Generated Reddit Username
No bio...
User ID: 757
I think the acceptable number of birth defects caused by the use of your weapon systems in an unprovoked war of aggression against another state is zero, and the depleted uranium rounds used in Iraq have handily surpassed this number.
this is factually incorrect, but more importantly, it's stupid
Factually incorrect? News to me. I was told there'd be a wall, mass deportations, crackdowns on civil liberties and the manifestation of Gilead into reality. I guess I actually did miss the fascism, because I didn't see any of that shit - have you got a source for any of this that's more rigorous than your arse?
this is obviously a deflection
I'm pointing out that every single thing you're threatening is on the way due to Trump IS ALREADY HERE. Why should I believe your stated motivations when you're supporting and condoning people who are far worse according to your own standards?
Rotterham can, of course, still shock the conscience for any number of other reasons. But those pushing us to outrage should state those reasons out loud. If they think it is genuinely worse when a Paki commits a crime than when a White does so, they should say so out loud.
I don't believe that Rotherham is worse because the men were foreigners - I would be just as outraged if they were native Britons, Americans, Australians, Dutch or Israelis. What is actually responsible for my outrage is the total dereliction of duty on the part of the police, legal system and media... but that wouldn't happen, because the explicit reason for their dereliction of duty was to avoid inflaming racial tensions.
That's a good point. My understanding was that those certain kinds of leftists tried to stop this, but were hamstrung by the problems in their own ideology and personal lives. They preferred keeping in step with the largely unpopular ideology of the then-elite (social justice) to actually reaching people, and they chose to give up those communities rather than give up their own ideology. I don't think those communities have really been cleaved apart either - I'm in a bunch of them and I can see people from all over the ideological spectrum in most.
Fascism is a word that has an actual meaning. I understand that outside the motte it has become a snarl word which basically just means "political ideology I don't like" but I was under the impression that people here actually try to use the word properly. Donald Trump isn't a fascist - though I have no doubt that if he fails to do what his base want him to do his replacement most likely will be. He's already had four years to be in power, and none of the calamities that your crowd promised were on the way ever actually showed up. If you want to look at the actual actions committed by people in government Trump represents the only break from the Beltway consensus in living memory, and that consensus is responsible for so much more evil and destruction than anything Trump has done. Can you actually look at the long history of military interventions undertaken by the US since the defeat of Hitler and tell me that Trump represents some brand new evil that deserves a revolution to overthrow? How exactly is building a wall with Mexico some grand act of fascism but dropping agent orange on Vietnam or using depleted uranium rounds in Iraq to help establish a hardline Islamic theocracy is just business as usual?
But on top of that, if you're actually serious about opposing people using the military to expand their borders and impose second-class citizen status on a bunch of poor people of the wrong ethnicity, why aren't you talking about Israel? They build walls, they set up apartheid, they kill children in terror attacks, invade foreign states, ask the US to invade others and supplied military equipment to all sorts of distasteful regimes. You still get to attack Donald Trump when you do to boot!
Does Mass Migration Always and Everywhere Lead to Populist Backlash?
Does starting a small fire in a dry forest always and everywhere lead to a forest fire? No - sometimes it rains, sometimes the fire brigade comes and puts it out, sometimes the wind just forcefully extinguishes it before it can get started. But there's no denying that starting an uncontrolled fire in a dry forest full of tinder is almost definitely going to start a forest fire.
It is more accurate to say that mass migration always creates the conditions required for a populist backlash - you can head that backlash off in a variety of different ways, but the consequences of mass migration are the dry tinder required for a populist backlash. Mass migration depresses wages(and eventually salaries) and drives up the costs of housing and other essentials of life. Simultaneously, it has a negative effect on social trust and cohesion (ever read Bowling Alone?), makes people less charitable and less likely to support their community. Of course, it isn't all bad - it makes things better for the wealthy and upper classes, at least for a while. Employers can treat their workers like shit and exploit them to a greater degree than before, and that might lead to some economic benefits (somebody is very clearly making a lot of money off replacing workers with H1B visa holders or illegal immigrants after all).
But ultimately, all of those negative consequences are baked into the cake of mass migration, and all of these negative consequences directly lead to populist backlashes. This doesn't mean that you'll get a populist backlash every time - if you're a globe-spanning empire with the ability to print as much money as you want, you can paper over those consequences with material goods and benefits. At the same time, you can employ a lot of social and cultural messaging to blunt the visible impact of those negative consequences or make participating in/feeding that populist backlash an incredibly bad career move. All of those approaches work, for a time. The only answers to quelling that backlash permanently are rather brutal - there wasn't a populist backlash from the muslim communities after the mass migrations of the reconquista because there weren't any muslim communities left to object.
His son becoming trans seems to have radicalized him as well.
I agree with this too. That definitely had an impact.
Point being, the people who were saying "no, we don't need to IRL organize like Charlottesville debacle, let the memes flow and hopefully they get picked up by powerful people and then the ball gets rolling" turned out to be correct.
That was absolutely the right strategy, but I don't believe getting "elites" to look at those memes was the actual winning approach. What gave the right so much more power, in my opinion at least, was that they completely owned online culture. The left just gave up on gaming and online communities, and then the next generation grew up with right wing/4chan memes as just the general background noise of their culture. The language that used to be restricted to the darker and more forbidden corners of the internet (not talking about super secret hacker forums here, but places like Heartise, 4chan and MPC) is now the lingua franca of the youth. The reason that these memes and ideas reach the elite is that they are common knowledge among huge swathes of the population, and that's also where they get their power - I'd be willing to bet that in an alternate world where only Peter Thiel ever saw all these memes their impact on politics and culture would be substantially reduced.
Isn't this such a validation for Elite Theory,
I disagree. The competing theory (at least how I understand it) is that changes in material conditions have continued to get worse. The extremes of both sides of politics generally recruit from disaffected and suffering people, losers in the race for prestige/elite positions. The Biden administration went all-in on the policies of the pre-Trump consensus (vast amounts of illegal immigration, encouraging outsourcing, etc) and their policies made those material conditions get substantially worse. The established left in America is hopelessly compromised and wedded to the same "elite" worldview - look at how happy they were to get Dick Cheney's endorsement, and how they believed that would actually support their cause. People just stopped giving a shit about Charlottesville and January 6 because it doesn't matter how much the people on CNN talk about decorum or about how great the stock market is going when your own material conditions continue to deteriorate - and the idea that you have to support your continued immiseration because the other guy is rude and says mean things just isn't viable anymore. I highly doubt a majority of Trump voters would support Charlottesville, but what's the alternative?
As for the tech right, I think recent events have actually demonstrated their lack of power. Elon tried to talk down to the base about how they need to accept infinity Indians, and as far as I can tell he's only damaged his relationship with Trump and his base. Furthermore, I don't think Elon seeing a bunch of memes was enough to make him switch - it was the Biden administration's deliberate efforts to destroy the tech industry. Elon was facing lots of politically motivated prosecution and persecution, and Pmarca directly stated that the reason he supported Trump was the Biden admin coming in and letting him know that they were going to crush the startup economy and just pick their own winners while using regulation to strangle competition.
is only going to make everyone poorer.
In the long run, sure. But in the short term it is going to make a few very rich people much richer, and those people will then trickle down some of their wealth to the politicians who helped them out. This might seem like a minor quibble but I feel like it is important to point out that there are people who profit substantially from all of these policies.
Fridman is one of the worst popular interviewers of all time.
It continues to blow my mind that he manages to get interesting guests. He's infuriating to listen to and seems like a very slow thinker. His lack of verbal fluency despite being ashkenazim is the most convincing argument against HBD that I've ever seen. I also don't actually think anybody likes him particularly - his major strength is that he gets interesting guests and then shuts the fuck up, but I think if he just made an interview show where the guest got to talk and he was completely silent he'd actually be more popular.
In other words, hiring foreign workers should be more expensive than hiring native workers.
This is the entire sticking point and every single word I have heard from the Vivek/Elon crew is just squid ink trying to cover up this incredibly simple issue. If there aren't enough qualified domestic workers, you can pay a substantial premium to bring in these extremely talented geniuses from India or Haiti or whatever. This is such an insanely simple compromise that neatly answers all of their stated objections - but they'll never agree with it because their unstated motivations are directly opposed to it. I'm very firmly against the H1B program and equivalents like it in other countries (like the god-awful deal my country just signed with India), and I have zero trust for the people on the other side given that there's a perfectly acceptable compromise that accomplishes all of their stated goals which they refuse to touch. Why the fuck should I believe Elon when he says he needs to fly in a genius from Delhi when you can see that Tesla is actually hiring H1Bs for positions paying 75k?
But surely you wouldn't make such a big bet on a plane if you have technology this promising coming up?
You'd absolutely make this big of a bet even if you knew the planes were barely functional dogshit, especially if you were betting with other people's money and had an incredibly comfortable job lined up with the manufacturer that will be paid for by the bet you just made.
Yeah, but that wage increase is going to come straight out of the manager's bonus - so they'll just import some indians instead, and by the time the company has been reduced to a smoking ruin the managers responsible will have gotten their bonus and moved on to do the same thing in another, larger company - after all, they oversaw some tremendous profitability increases during their tenure (just don't look at what happened when the consequences hit after they left).
Plate tectonics and continental drift were very explicitly a crackpot theory for quite a while, even though a lot of the evidence had actually been shared already. Sometimes the individual crackpots are right and the entire rest of the field is wrong - just ask Alfred Wegener (assuming you have a Ouija board on hand).
And if your conspiracy includes all high-quality scientists everywhere (e.g. the Science Adventure series of VNs), your conspiracy is isomorphic to the Illuminati.
I don't think you really need to make that conspiracy isomorphic to the illuminati. The heredity of intelligence and other mental characteristics is nakedly obvious to everyone who even takes a cursory look, but research on the topic has been pretty effectively suppressed without the need for any kind of HBD illuminati.
Fighting police officers to the death would not have improved the outcome for his daughter in any way, and most likely would have made things worse for her. The people who you should actually be attacking and blaming in this case are the rapists themselves, the police who protected them and the politicians responsible for the entire state of affairs - not blaming an individual working class father for not turning into Conan the Barbarian and single-handedly murdering several rapists and several more well-armed police officers.
Their dads(well, of the few of the girls who had them) gave up.
No they didn't. There's at least one case of a father being arrested for trying to rescue his daughter - the police weren't just ignoring the systematic rape of working class children, they were actively aiding and abetting it.
The tech industry isn't a monolith. Tesla pay a minimum of $150-200K for a far high class of engineer while some po-dunk IT consultancy sweatshop in Indiana pays $65K.
Industry pay rates are connected. When the wages of a job at the lower-end of the field are lowered, that puts downwards pressure on the rest of the industry. But more than that, you're lying.
https://h1bdata.info/index.php?em=tesla+inc
76k isn't that much higher than 65k. You're kind of right in the sense that the higher end is getting paid a lot of money, but Tesla is still using the H1b visa system to import low-paid workers and drive down the prices and bargaining position of their labour.
A higher wage floor helps his part of the tech industry grow. That kind of fraud is absolutely not helpful for him.
Why would the owner of a single company care if he's helping his part of the tech industry grow? That kind of fraud is absolutely helpful for him, because it helps him pay less money to his employees and extract more value out of them.
Kicking the shit out of IT sweatshops would be beneficial to exceptional Indian (and other) talent. The Elon branch of the GOP would sign up for that in a heartbeat.
The IT sweatshops and their ability to depress tech industry wages is precisely the reason the Elon branch of the GOP supports them. There's no point to importing a new class of desperate workers if you aren't able to use them to make money.
The MAGA crowd is like someone who found a genie but can't formulate their wishes well.
I don't think this is a terribly accurate view, because this implies that if they simply formulated their concerns properly they could be addressed - and this just isn't the case here. The problems which they were complaining about are the negative externalities of policies which the wealthy donors and power elite who actually run western governments enthusiastically support and profit from. There was no way in which they could correctly word or formulate their desire for lower amounts of migration, because the people in charge of executing that policy had no intention of actually fixing the problems they were complaining about.
It has actually happened multiple times in Australia, but that's more due to corruption than to test scores.
In ancient texts, probably up until really Islam, the idea of Gos was pretty physical. Any God you care to read about has a body. They eat and drink, they occasionally come down to earth and walk around, even in descriptions of the afterlife, it’s physical, a garden or a city, or people eating good food and having drinks and so on.
Are you sure about this? I've been doing a bunch of research on Plato for personal reasons recently, and this really doesn't match up with what he seemed to believe. From my reading of ancient religions, I get the impression that a lot of ancient people understood religious myths as metaphorical, and they most definitely understood the importance of symbols and symbolic meanings - just look at the Eleusinian mysteries.
I can’t say that any ancient human in the Bronze Age ever thought about whether or not animals thought
They don't quite date back to the Bronze Age, but the Pythagoreans came before Plato and were famous for their belief in the transmigration of souls, and advocated vegetarianism on the basis that inflicting suffering on a living being unnecessarily diminished the human soul. Those concepts also showed up in the early Orphic religions as well, to the point that several authors said that Pythagoras was just repeating what he'd learned from them.
, or what makes a woman a woman.
The story of Tiresias directly presents an example of someone changing sex but retaining their identity as a man (despite giving birth to a daughter) and then returning to masculinity. Just to be clear I'm not saying that they would endorse modern gender ideology, but they most definitely understood the idea that you could have an inner self whose gender/sex didn't match up with your body.
Areas with high concentrations of Indian tech workers in California or the northeast don't seem particularly prone to crime
Look back up at the post you're defending - the current program is excessive and causing huge issues already, but you're defending someone importing 200 million fresh new indians. At those numbers you are learning nothing at all by looking at places like San Francisco (not that I'd want to live there now) - you have to go look at the crime statistics for India itself if you want to get a real picture. And that picture isn't particularly flattering, especially not for women.
For these immigrants to be meaningful competitors for the labor of anyone posting here, they would presumably have to be highly-skilled and therefore not incompetent and low human capital. I don't see how they could be both.
Highly-skilled? I think you're confused - we're not talking about the O-1 Visa program. We're talking about the H1B Visa program, the program that brings in bakers, laborers and line-cooks. The reason they're a threat to the labor of anyone posting here is that they accept terrible pay and are essentially an indentured servant class who are unable to leave their employer. Sure, their quality is much worse and in the long run they're usually more expensive than hiring local, but that doesn't mean anything to a manager who can get a massive compensation payout for temporarily juicing their numbers at the expense of long term success (I'm sure you're familiar with the principal-agent problem). At the same time, the existence of this imported servant class has a downward pressure on income and expectation for every other sector of the job market too, as the impact spreads from the lower-income populations they're being used to suppress. One of the stories that got Trump to the white house in 2016 was how H1B immigrants replaced the IT workers at Disney after they were forced to train their replacements.
No, it is because of corruption. The PM who trashed the French deal in exchange for the comedically terrible AUKUS one (America is entirely within their rights under the contract to take our money and give us nothing in return) has an incredibly plumb job with one of the American companies that are going to be profiting from that deal (look up Scott Morrison).

I believe there are international efforts to ban the use of minefields that linger and cause problems after the war, and cluster munitions frequently cause similar issues.
This does not change my position that the acceptable number of mutilated and dead children caused by your advanced weapon systems is zero. I'm opposed to minefields, depleted uranium, the use of white phosphorus in civilian areas, the use of chemical/biological weapons etc.
More options
Context Copy link