@FirmWeird's banner p

FirmWeird

Randomly Generated Reddit Username

2 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 23:38:51 UTC

				

User ID: 757

FirmWeird

Randomly Generated Reddit Username

2 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 23:38:51 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 757

Your response is trying so hard to be unclear.

I don't know how much clearer I can be given that the question doesn't have a yes/no answer. I'm not sure how communication broke down totally like this because I have never encountered anyone who hasn't been able to grasp the concept like this before. Energy returned on energy invested is just so straightforward that I don't understand how I can make it any clearer. To use solar as an example: we only account for the energy invested in creating and installing the solar panel, because we don't invest anything to make the sun keep burning and hence don't care about the energy content of the fuel (in this case sunlight). If you are putting oil into your car, you care about the energy of the fuel because that's on the "energy invested" side of the equation.

For some purposes, yes.

Calories are extremely relevant when determining whether or not a food source can sustain a human population, which is the purpose that matters here. If you can find someone who stays alive without any calories, please let the world know.

The latest update pushed the pollution people significantly into the future (magically, btw, being one of the biggest differences from past predictions).

They changed their accounting method for pollution - the statistic they're tracking is different, which is why the curve is different. They focused much more on carbon in the atmosphere, both because that's going to be one of the most significant sources of pollution-related economic damage and because fossil fuel usage is decently correlated with activities that produce other types of pollution (plastic, nitrogen fertiliser runoff, fracking, chemical processing etc).

The peaks in those images are clearly pre-2025. The drops are precipitous. Why would you need another fifteen years to see the drop?

First of all, this particular data can be pretty noisy. Sharp spikes up and down in various numbers can happen for a variety of reasons without actually changing the longer-term trends that underlie them. There's a chance I'm extremely wrong and what we're seeing is a small dip before those curves turn back up and go exponential as humanity metastasizes across the stars - or we could get something more negative. The Middle East is currently on the verge of a large regional war, and if that war breaks out at least one side has said that their planned military strategy is to completely destroy all petroleum-related infrastructure that isn't theirs, and there's a decent chance they could actually achieve this. While it would be immensely destructive and bad for the global economy, it would have a massive impact on the depletion curve for a lot of those resources (petroleum is used in the extraction of almost all other resources and a rise in its price will have dramatic flow-on effects).

I still have no idea how to use numbers and math to determine whether something is on a "timescale relevant to humans".

Ok here's the easy version - if it takes longer than a million years to renew itself, it isn't relevant to modern humans.

Could you please provide some examples and quotes of Putin talking about his desire to Make Russia Great Again by bringing back the empire? I've read multiple interviews and talks with him and don't recall him making similar claims in any of them. I'm entirely willing to believe you, I just want to see some evidence - most of the sources I've seen describing Russian politics in this area believe that Putin is actually more restrained and less eager for conflict than most of the people waiting in the wings behind him.

Furthermore, if Russia were to have encountered no opposition in the forceful seizure of Ukraine, how long would it be before they went after the Baltics? Poland?

Actually, they'd just stop there and not go any further. They had specific reasons for getting involved in the Ukraine that aren't there for Poland and the Baltics. I don't even think they're going to want to retain control over Ukraine in the end either - I think they're going to want to turn it into a thoroughly dysfunctional rump state that's utterly unable to credibly threaten Russia or prevent them from interfering in internal domestic affairs.

If you want an example of a military force that forcefully seized territory and was then emboldened to claim more, you're going to have much better results looking at the Middle East - who owns the Golan Heights again?

So do you count the energy content of fossil fuels?

We care about the energy content of fossil fuels to the extent that we have invested energy into them to render them usable. The actual energy content of the fuel is immaterial, because what matters is the usable energy we can extract from it, minus the costs of extracting that energy and converting it into a useful form. Not all fossil fuels are created equally - there are differing grades of oil, and the extraction methods required to harness them are different too. The kind of light sweet crude that burst out of the ground in the early days of America was a substantially better and more useful fuel than the output of shale fracking or deep-sea oil platforms.

I suppose this means the ultimate answer to that question is "Yes, but it is complicated." The raw energy content of a given fuel is obviously relevant when working out how much usable energy you get out of it, but it isn't the whole story. I'm not going to go to a financial metaphor because that seems to have just caused confusion, but imagine that there's a town with two oil wells. Both of them produce completely identical oil - but one of those oil wells requires complex machinery, expert knowledge and significant electrical expenditure to extract that oil, while the other well is so pressurised that it simply bursts out of the ground with so much force it costs nothing at all. Both of those oil wells are producing a fossil fuel with the same energy content, but the energy we invest to actually make it usable in each case is different.

I mean, are we? I thought we were talking about agriculture. Why is energy the real topic when we're talking about agriculture?

The caloric content of food is generally considered extremely relevant information, to the point that listing it on the label is required in all first world countries. Calories are the unit we use to measure the energy required for human bodies to stay alive - and I think you're going to have your work cut out for you if you want to talk about food, diet and agriculture without bringing up calories.

In that case, you could probably say something relevant concerning my remarks on the data contained therein, rather than simply resting on one of their quotes.

Why? I agreed with their position and from where I was standing it argued against your own interpretation. It looked to me like you had simply found an article with datapoints that ostensibly supported your position rather than reading through the entire article to see what was actually being communicated - sorry if I was wrong and you actually seriously engaged with the article and interrogated the claims within seriously. I actually still agree with their conclusion - global population growth is starting to slow down, and I can look out the window right now to see the impacts of pollution on the environment.

I think there are absolutely things in these predictions worth betting on, but the problem is that the short term can be extremely noisy - a major war or climate disaster could shift the precise dates around by a few years, for instance. If you actually do want to bet on those figures, the shape of the curves in question can only really be worked out sometime around 2040, but if you don't have anything else you'll need to spend the money on in the next 16 years I'm down.

You need to choose one or the other option. We do work on both things to make them usable. Either we only count the work we do on it, and we do not count the energy content of the fuel, itself... or we do count the energy content of the fuel, itself, because we do work on it. Please clearly pick one standard to apply evenly.

Energy returned on energy invested. I don't know how much simpler I can make this! We care about fuels to the extent that we have invested energy into them to render them usable. We don't care about supplying the fuel required for the sun to burn, but we do care about the fuel required to build and install a solar panel. We don't care about the energy required to make uranium during the formation of the earth, but we do care about the energy required to dig it out of the ground and process it into fuel pellets. The dividing line is just the amount of energy that we actually invested.

Your current response doesn't tell me anything about how I go through the process of factoring in consumption rates. When I'm determining whether something is on a "timescale relevant to humans", I need to do some math on some numbers, and one of the variables I have is, possibly, consumption rates. How does that variable fit in?

When it comes to fossil fuels like petroleum and coal, the answer is simply that if we have some kind of horrific catastrophe that dramatically cuts population and destroys the economy, the problem will get pushed forward a few hundred years. A Carrington event, nuclear war, some other novel WMD (a biological weapon that reduces global population by 95% would qualify), a supervolcano erupting, a megatsunami, a meteorite impact... there are a lot of potential events that could cause a decrease in consumption rates enough to matter.

But in order for new fossil fuels to form it will require several million years - many multiple times longer than anatomically modern humans have existed on earth. The USA currently has issues with plans longer than 4 years - I don't trust them to accurately plan for something multiple millions of years in the future.

You can tell me, in basic terms, why energy is the fundamental unit of investment. You didn't seem to think that it was just one sentence ago. You seemed to think it was dollars for some reason.

Energy is the fundamental unit of investment because the measure under discussion is ENERGY RETURNED ON ENERGY INVESTED. That's an appropriate measure to use when discussing sources of energy! We are talking about energy, but finance makes for a good metaphor that's easy to understand. If it makes it easier to think about, then picture an incredibly tiny power plant which costs 100 calories to build and fuel, which then generates 90 calories worth of usable power as a result.

Ok. Do you think modern farmers are getting less money than they put in?

In many cases, modern farmers actually are getting less money than they put in and are under significant financial stress. But the actual answer is that we're talking about energy rather than money, and so they don't care that modern fossil-fuel based farming practices are inefficient at the level of energy because they are much more efficient at the economic level. Financial and social pressure means that we are converting this energy to food in an incredibly inefficient way due to the immense surplus of energy that we currently have access to, but in a real-world financial sense they're doing what's rational for people in their position. I don't just think that this is a bad idea, but I think that it is a bad idea that is already bringing forth nasty consequences.

I did. But rather than just trust the words that potentially-motivated authors wrote to describe their own interpretations of the data, I actually went and looked at the data myself and drew my own conclusions.

As I mentioned, I already went through that article 9 months ago. I quoted the authors because I agree with their understanding of their own results - agreeing with something doesn't mean that I just scanned through for a sentence I agree with.

Where are you choosing to spend your time discussing things like the Vice Presidential debate earlier tonight?

Here, group chats. There's no possibility of bringing back contentious spaces that aren't pseudonymous because the risk of saying something that the other side can use to get you fired, turned into a pariah or otherwise cause consequences for your daily life is way too high.

Also, note how smoothly criticism of Israel has become criticism of Jews instead.

I always try and avoid doing this myself, and I think that the argument here is transparently bad from a HBD perspective (those are the IQ results I'd expect from a high IQ ashkenazim population coexisting with lower average IQ sephardim and mizrahim) but I don't think you're really making much of a point here. Israel very proudly advertises itself as The Jewish State, For Jews, By Jews and frequently claims that criticism of Israel is criticism of Jews and their right to exist. It might be a very smooth transition from criticising Israel to criticising jews, but the lubrication here was actually supplied by the Israelis themselves.

I'm confused again. Does "built a solar panel to process and work the energy from nuclear fusion" count as processing/working to make it useful?

Solar panels do not appear out of the ether, fully formed. They are physically made, by people, out of raw materials and processed parts. You have to do useful work and invest energy into a solar panel in order for it to then return usable energy to you. We only care about the energy cost of building the solar panel, because that's what it takes to actually use it. To go back to fuel, we don't care about the energy that went into making uranium ore in the ground, but we do care about the energy investment required to turn a mountain with uranium in it to a bunch of usable fuel pellets for a nuclear reactor.

We also didn't have to invest anything to create fossil fuels, so...?

Wrong. Petroleum products go through substantial refining processes, and we have to build large facilities to extract and export those fossil fuels. There's a substantial amount of human labour that has gone into the petroleum that fuels a modern combustion engine, even if nature has already done most of the real work of creating living beings and then compressing them over millions of years.

How?

If we dramatically lower our consumption rates, the resources we do have will last longer.

I prefer "invest the proceeds of my previously productive business venture into a new productive business venture". If it's argument by analogy, then I don't see why this analogy isn't just as valid.

It is valid. You can invest the proceeds of your previously productive business venture into a new one. But that's exactly what I am advocating for and we aren't doing! Your analogy is valid in the sense that it is a perfectly good approach to the problems we're facing - it just isn't what we're actually doing. We're spending those resources on military conflicts, poll numbers (see Biden draining the SPR), happy meal toys, artificial islands in the shape of a sheik pissing money away and making as many Americans as obese as possible for as long as possible. Did you know that modern industrial farming techniques require 13 calories of energy to create 1 calorie of food? THAT is the kind of investment we're making - and I don't think I'd call an investment productive if it had a -92% return.

What is "productive"?

You get more out of it than you put in. If I build a powerplant for 100 dollars, and it generates 90 dollars of power before needing to be scrapped, I would have been better off not building it.

Is it some measure of calories

Calories is a convenient and easily understandable way to measure energy - I'm not sure how much more basic I can get here.

Got it. You just define adjustments at the type that you like.

No? People could easily make bad adjustments and use energy even more wastefully if they want - but I was talking about potential adjustments people could make to try and solve the problem.

But the good news is that market prices will cause people to take those steps anyway. Sounds like we're all good here.

Are you for real? The market absolutely will not cause people to take those steps, and even a cursory look at the state of the world (let alone history) makes it exceedingly obvious that market prices and forces are not capable of preventing financial crashes, collapses and recessions that result from human malinvestment/bad budgeting decisions. The process that market forces actually inflict on societies in these conditions is called "catabolic collapse" and we've seen it play out multiple times in history. Homo sapiens is not homo economicus, and every single prediction made on the basis that they are has failed. You can play whatever games you want with financial numbers - if there's no more economically/energetically viable oil to extract, no amount of money will be capable of conjuring more of it out of the ether.

bask in the update

Did you actually go and read the article you posted? Here's a section which I think you might have missed.

The fact is that the recalibrated model again shows the possibility of a collapse of our current system. At the same time, the BAU scenario of the 1972 model is shown to be alarmingly consistent with the most recently collected empirical data.

Herrington (2021) also concluded in her data comparison that the world is far from a stabilized world scenario where the overshoot and collapse mode is brought to a halt. As a society, we have to admit that despite 50 years of knowledge about the dynamics of the collapse of our life support systems, we have failed to initiate a systematic change to prevent this collapse. It is becoming increasingly clear that, despite technological advances, the change needed to put us on a different trajectory will also require a change in belief systems, mindsets, and the way we organize our society (Irwin, 2015; Wamsler & Brink, 2018).

Thank you for posting this great evidence in favour of my own argument - "alarmingly consistent with the most recently collected empirical data" isn't really the sort of thing you would say about an inaccurate prediction! As an aside, this is actually the second time someone has posted this exact link to me in a conversation about this topic on the motte - https://www.themotte.org/post/772/culture-war-roundup-for-the-week/167149?context=8#context

-Do you count the energy content of the fuel?

If the fuel is something that humans have processed and worked in order to make it useful, yes.

-Do you, like Arjin, think that there is some discounting for energy sources that were going to be consumed "one way or another/no matter what"?

No, because I don't believe in that kind of inevitability. All that matters is energy returned on energy invested - we didn't invest anything to turn the sun on, and so we don't account for it in calculating EREOEI. We do, however, have to build solar panels - so the EROEI on an individual solar panel is actually a relevant and useful question.

What is a "timescale relevant to humans"? Do consumption rates factor into this?

Consumption rates could factor into this, but the process of oil/fossil fuel generation is so slow that it really doesn't matter. Our existing fossil fuel deposits took many times longer to accrue than humanity has even existed, and so proposing that we wait another several million years for new oil deposits to form isn't really going to help us deal with any problems that we have right now.

Sure, but is there any factor describing something like the probability of new discoveries, given past developments?

We have a rough estimate of how oil discovery rates will go, but if you mean in terms of discovering a new energy source... that's one approach, in the sense that if you are rapidly burning your lottery win to support an unsustainable lifestyle "hope you win the lottery again" is a strategy that someone might pick. But the consequences of getting that wrong are incredibly severe - and what if it turns out that the discovery we make requires an infrastructure investment that we can no longer afford to make because we spent all that oil growing vast quantities of corn and making artificial islands in the Middle East?

One could also plausibly invest much of that money in productive ventures; how is this taken into account?

You could do that - and it is taken into account in the sense that we haven't done that. EROEI is a method for working out whether or not those ventures are actually productive, and in most cases the answer is that the juice isn't worth the squeeze.

This is getting far afield from the technical questions, which I still think are the core part, but I sort of have to ask - what do you have in mind when you talk about adjustment processes? A normal sort of adjustment process would be a market process - if the demand for some rare resource outstrips its supply, the market price rises.

When I said adjustment there, I meant taking steps to prepare for a future with less available energy and more climate disruptions. That means making your home and lifestyle more energy efficient, using less energy and reducing your reliance on large supply chains. Living a lifestyle with less free energy has some challenges, and you're much better off facing those challenges when you still have access to those global supply chains and massive amounts of energy. You'll also, in some way, contribute to fighting the problem by reducing energy expenditure and pollution creation as a result.

We've had famous examples of the kind of vague "if you use too much stuff now, it'll be painful in the future" predictions that are unmoored from much technical analysis.

There's nothing vague about these predictions - they're based on the technical analysis done for Limits to Growth. To the best of my knowledge we're still following the World3 projections fairly accurately. We're on track for growth to go into reverse in about ten years, give or take, and I haven't seen any really robust criticism of the Limits to Growth studies. They were shockingly accurate for 1972.

Red voters in red states will not switch blue after a natural disaster. Why would they?

The conspiracy theory that's relevant here isn't that a failed disaster response will turn those Trump voters into Harris voters - it'll turn them into corpses or people so busy with disaster recovery efforts that they're unable to vote.

I'm guessing from context that you mean something like that you mean to refer to "the calories required to make energy usable by humans"

Yes. The term that I care about is called EROEI - energy returned on energy invested. That really just says it all.

There are huge timescale questions here. What is a "temporary increase"?

The existence of easily accessible fossil fuels. If you want to use a financial analogy, they're a massive inheritance that gives us a supply of money far greater than we can actually earn ourselves, which meant that we can live a lifestyle more expensive than our income can support... for a while.

but I'm not sure what the criteria is for being "temporary/not temporary"

Whether or not it is renewable on a timescale relevant to humans. Fossil fuels take millions of years to accumulate and concentrate, so once we use them they're effectively gone.

How does future discovery of other methods to convert things into human-usable energy come into play?

If their EROEI is positive to the extent that it can justify using those methods, great! But you can't just assume that we're going to discover these things when making assumptions about the future, because there's no guarantee that a great new energy source will just appear.

I think we're maybe stuck concluding that all uses of energy are bad in some way.

This is a question of values - but to go back to a financial metaphor, every single expenditure of money drains your bank account. But you're not accumulating money just so you have a bigger number, and we don't accumulate energy so we can have a bigger number. We want to use that energy or money in ways that are productive, enjoyable and beneficial to us, and we want to avoid doing things that cause giant problems in the future. Living a lifestyle that your income cannot support is a choice that leads to very predictable consequences, consequences which are substantially less pleasant than adjusting your expenditures before you go bankrupt. Personally I think that a lot of our current energy expenditures aren't really worthwhile in the long run (mountains of plastic garbage, melting the icecaps, long work commutes, war in the middle east, etc) - but that's a different discussion.

I found it incredibly disheartening to find out that she didn't have the same "resents normies but desperately wants to be accepted by them" complex as me

Why?

This complex doesn't seem particularly helpful or conducive to positive outcomes, and I'd say that her lack of it seems more psychologically healthy. It seems like you're aware that this is a maladaptive pattern - is it something you're working on resolving?

Ok I'm going to reply here because this conversation has gone on for a bit while I was asleep.

When I said human labour, I wasn't referring specifically to work performed by human muscles but to energy usable by humans. We don't need to make the wind blow or the sun shine, but if we want to get work done from that energy we have to invest energy into capturing, storing, transmitting and using that energy. As an example, we don't include the energy spent creating oil deposits in the earth when calculating EROEI - but we do include the energy costs associated with finding that oil deposit, drilling it, extracting the oil, transporting it to be refined, the refining process itself and then the energy cost of delivering that oil to where it is ultimately used. We don't care how much energy it took to get the sun ignited, but we do care about the costs of making a new solar panel and hooking it up to the grid.

To go back to farming, however, the reason that this matters is that we don't actually have infinite free energy yet. We have a certain amount of energy that we get from renewable sources, but fossil fuels are not renewable on any timescale relevant to humanity - they're a once-in-a-species lottery win. Spending 10 calories to get back 1 isn't a great deal, and you don't need to be a genius to work out what happens when a population of animals allows their population to grow to a large number on the basis of a temporary increase in available resources. That's a phenomenon called ecological overshoot, and history is full of examples of what happens when a population (of animals or humans) grows to a level that can't be sustained by the available resource base.

And for something like solar power, how is this computed?

Because the metric you actually, seriously use is energy returned on energy invested. We don't have to invest any extra energy into the sun to make it shine, nor do we have to make the wind blow ourselves. All we actually care about is the return on the energy we invested to capture that energy. The reason we care about sourcing uranium/nuclear fuel is because it takes human labour to convert uranium from ore to fuel pellets.

I didn't see those comments and hence didn't reply to them, but now that I go looking... I don't think anime/manga start people on the trans pipeline at all - it's just that you don't know what younger people actually do these days and hence are unaware of the ubiquity of anime/manga, i.e. "Most murderers drink soft drinks ergo soft drinks contribute to murder". The far more likely contributing factors I can see (among men, women are facing something different) are in-born rates of autogynephilia and social contagion (relentless demonisation of male sexuality followed by "and you can become one of the elect by becoming trans, which sanctifies those terrible urges").

Sorry for being unclear - I meant that I'm trying to model the thought process that leads to this belief. I'm not sure of the actual relationship/mechanisms behind cock size, but I am sure that a lot of people view it as a signal of virility/genetic quality.

I think you have a completely inverted view of the culture of modern comics. Western comics are substantially "woker" than anime and manga, and the people making them go out of their way to advertise that fact.

I believe the actual explanation for this is that the nice cock is a reflection of less visible qualities. A person's digit ratio isn't going to have a direct impact on how aggressive they are, but they both reflect subtler processes and qualities that have an impact on both.

Did you know that, roughly speaking, Lebanon has 3 major ethnic/religious groups that aren’t super-friendly with each other?

Yes. I just don't believe that will convince any Lebanese people who aren't already Israel supporters that the dying children are to blame rather than the nation which is currently bombing them as we speak.

Did western media not show you the Syrian opposition groups giving out candy in the streets after the pager attacks? Where do you think that comes from? Or did you not hear of the Sabra and Shatila massacre- blamed on Israel, but perpetrated by Lebanese?

I don't recall ever claiming that Lebanon was some kind of land of milk and honey where all men lived together in harmony, but I don't see how this really matters. If those distinct subpopulations were already murdering and massacring each other, it isn't like being targeted by Israel is going to change that all that much.

I'm totally fine with adopting that as a metric - you just have to include all the calories that go into refining the fuel, building the plant, etc.

why the hell haven't we seen catastrophic impacts to our ecology and agriculture?

Fossil fuels. Fossil-fuel based fertilisers allow us to largely ignore the damage we've done to the environment, and fossil-fuel powered farming vehicles and techniques give us even more energy to make up for it. Petroleum-based agriculture is hideously inefficient compared to traditional farming techniques (because this caused confusion on here in the past, I am using efficiency to refer specifically to calories in vs calories out), but petroleum is such a dense source of energy that for the short-term period where we have access to them we can inflate the global population to thoroughly unsustainable levels. We've just been throwing oil and energy at the problem, which is why we haven't actually noticed.

As an Australian, nope. We're already going through a real estate crisis and have a population that's already causing strain on significant water systems - moving Israel there would make those problems substantially worse. But there's actually a better option on the table anyway - the Israelis should just be moved to the American deep south, where they can live with all the evangelicals who love them so much. There's plenty of room, and I'm sure the Israelis would be better migrants than the Haitians - dogs and cats aren't kosher, last I checked.

This is great, I hope it keeps happening and people treat known Hizballah members like lepers.

Do you really think that would actually happen?

Assuming you live in Israel (given your flair), would IDF soldiers randomly exploding due to surreptitiously placed Iranian bombs cause you to start treating known members of the IDF like lepers? I think it would just bolster your determination to fight back against the Iranians rather than treat the soldiers fighting for you like social pariahs. To use a specific example...

https://www.nytimes.com/2024/09/18/world/middleeast/lebanon-funeral-pager-attack.html

I don't think that murdering this 9 year old girl (which I wouldn't really call "great", personally) is making these people support Israel. In fact, from the photos of the funeral, those Hezbollah scarfs look pretty new - and the quotes they give make it sound like this attack was one of Hezbollah's greatest recruitment efforts to date. I know personally that if my 9 year old daughter was murdered by a foreign state I'd be signing up for whatever military organisation wants to fight back against them as soon as they'd have me.

I mean you can look up the stats yourself. Murder and suicide rates in any country banning guns with the same or close GDP of the USA are a tiny fraction of what ours are. Do I think the tradeoff is worth it? Yes. But it is still there and obvious. Are you really linking me to a comment recommending only your opponents be disarmed? Come on man.

You're playing games with statistics here. Based on your hypothesis here, we'd expect Switzerland (which has incredibly liberal gun laws) to be a hotbed of murder and suicide - but it isn't. Venezuela, on the other hand, has extremely tight gun laws, despite formerly being the homicide capital of South America. It isn't the guns that make people kill each other and you're being dishonest when you imply it.

If the Chinese are so easy to bribe why aren't they giving Israel their full-throated support right now? From where I'm sitting it looks to me like China has no real motivation to assist Israel and they definitely don't act like it (understandably, in my view, given how Israel has treated their last imperial patron). As for Russia, I don't actually believe in the antisemitic conspiracy theory that jews are a fifth column who will abuse their economic power to subvert the will of the nation they live in - so I don't think the presence of jews in industry/manufacturing actually means anything when it comes to geopolitics.