FirmWeird
Randomly Generated Reddit Username
No bio...
User ID: 757
Perfect hypothetical world? Who needs that? I can absolutely do a better job that would have far more positive consequences for the future, and I can do it with a single policy statement: Don't start a war of aggression in the middle east so that my friends in business can juice their profit margins at the cost of thousands of lives, billions of dollars and creating not just a refugee crisis but the Islamic state terror group.
I have an intensely heartfelt and deep disagreement with your post and what it implies. There's nothing "academic" about simply not starting a war - there are several US Presidents who avoided starting wars of aggression or invading other countries. The only way I can make sense of your comment is if you're so deeply cynical you believe that the military industrial complex has so much power over the government that the role of President is largely ornamental, and making the decision to avoid the war would have just lead to me getting shot in the head in public so that my war-hungry VP could take the top job.
I actually don't have a single source that sums everything up - I'll go looking for one that ties everything up, but unfortunately all the good summaries I have so far carry the kind of undeniable political valence that makes them not terribly effective at convincing regular people.
He managed the country without it dissolving or getting destroyed.
I disagree - I think he was part of the dissolving. Look at the profits accrued to Halliburton et al as a result of the Iraq war, a war which has had ruinous consequences for the rest of the world. Those private profits came about through the expenditure of the USA's blood and treasure.
He rallied America after 9/11. Getting the nation through that, and stoking feelings of patriotism and solace,
I also disagree here - he (if he actually had much power personally) exploited those feelings to drum up support for a terrible war that he and his friends personally profited from.
The current version of social media is putting your personal identity next to every opinion you ever uttered and storing it for years on end, often making it trivial to search it up later.
This is the main reason that I am happy beyond belief that the majority of my internet posting as a younger man was on 4chan. The quality of the conversations and content that came up was the main motivating factor at the time, but not having all of my stupid opinions and mistaken beliefs from when I was younger and dumber irrevocably attached to my name is such an incredible benefit that it makes me appreciate my time there even more.
To be fair, the more important line of defense would have been keeping China honest on enforcing the rules about live animal markets they implemented after SARS and then stopped enforcing after a few years; I'm having trouble finding a hard timeline on that, but that's definitely primarily Obama's fuck up.
Wet-market origin has been discredited at this point - COVID was almost certainly leaked from a lab doing Gain-of-Function research. Changes to regulations around wet markets would have done absolutely nothing to stop the pandemic.
That said, the idea that the US could have done anything whatsoever to keep China honest in this regard is a joke - too many people in the US government had their fingers in this particular pie for them to be able to do anything about it.
I find it darkly amusing that this is also largely how the writers of new SW stories think about their political opposition. "Somehow, racism has returned. Despite racism managing to defeat our almost total control of western culture, we shall spend absolutely zero effort thinking about how to actually resolve the problem, and instead double down on the same policies that failed last time."
This conversation is about E2EE of Facebook messages, not bank transactions.
Oh, my mistake then - I was under the impression that we were talking about a more general system where all encrypted communications require a law-enforcement decryption key, with Facebook being given as a specific example. If you just want to boil it down to a single company then this discussion is an uninteresting and pointless aside to the broader discussion about banning all encryption without law enforcement decryption keys.
How would it be leaked? It's buried in an HSM that is not connected to the internet and housed in an access-controlled vault. Just assuming a breakage of the first of those conditions (extracting a key from an HSM) utterly breaks all device security guarantees you have for all the devices you own.
This just isn't true. Microsoft can keep the signing keys for some important elements of the OS private, and those keys are only accessed extremely rarely and in specific circumstances. But the threat that I'm talking about is from actors who have legitimate access to the vault.
This super skeleton key that unlocks all encryption and allows you to bypass all security on financial transactions, privacy, government documents, military assets... not only is this going to be the most valuable key in the world with thousands of motivated parties trying to get access to it, there are going to be law enforcement and government requests for it on a constant basis. Think about how many warrants are served in the USA and then remember that every single one of them is going to involve someone getting access to this key. Then remember that this key is also in use everywhere else in the world - it has to be the same otherwise you've completely broken the internet and global economy by making encrypted communication between different nations impossible (it'd be illegal to have communications that don't allow access via this master key after all). So that means that every single time a Chinese, Russian, Brazilian or South African cop wants access to some communications, that vault is getting opened right back up again.
THAT is what makes it so likely to leak - this key is going to have to be accessed by millions of law enforcement officers and government officials every single day, and it is the most valuable key in the world given that it can defeat all encryption used in financial transactions and would make fraud and financial crime as easy as pie, let alone privacy invasion and surveillance. If you think that the Chinese (or American for that matter) government is going to use this access responsibly (or just not keep their word when they say they're not making copies of the key), lmao.
If you really want to talk about minorities I think I'm the only environmentalist/smelly hippy on here.
Anyone had the opportunity to shutdown Steve but no one rose to the occasion.
No they didn't - where's the actual counterargument to HBD? If you want to shutdown Steve you either need to beg/force(presumably with legislation) Elon Musk to ban him, or present a factual and robust counterargument to HBD. The problem is that even if this robust counterargument exists, nobody has ever seen it - and I don't think it does exist.
Also, while I'm enjoying the more substantive parts of this discussion, I'd urge you to drop the high and mighty attitude you've been displaying so far.
My apologies - I was dealing with a rather annoying issue at work and that most likely bled through to my posting on here.
Keeping that in mind would be helpful so that you might ask for clarification if you've misunderstood the argument I was making, instead of leaping to ad hominems that I'm some foolish idiot who "hasn't done the research".
I said you hadn't done the research not because I thought you were an idiot but because I thought there were gaps in your knowledge. I don't blame anyone for not keeping up to date with this story because it has gone on for more than half a decade and involved copious amounts of misdirection, legal wrangling and media perfidy. But if you're going to try and make authoritative statements on the matter, you owe it to yourself to go and do that research. I actually made sure to ask you if you were sure, because I was politely giving you a chance to back down and go do the research before we progressed and I had to say you hadn't done it.
The problem with this line of thinking is that Carter Page certainly wasn't the only reason the investigation started, as Papadopoulos was also an early target and would eventually be convicted. After it started, it was clear there actually was quite a bit of wrongdoing by Trump's campaign, including even the chair of the campaign, Manafort. Not sure what "fruits of surveillance given to his political opposition" is specifically referring to here, so I'll let you clarify before I address it.
Trump's initial crime was becoming the GOP candidate while espousing a set of policies that were in direct opposition to the DC Consensus/wishes of the deep state/etc. The Clinton campaign then had the Steele dossier manufactured, and that dossier was then selectively leaked to the media in order to retroactively add enough credibility to the claims contained within that it could be used to get a FISA warrant (Kevin Clinesmith, one of the lawyers involved, was prosecuted for fabricating evidence that was used in the warrant application). The surveillance of Trump's campaign, and the intelligence product produced as a result, went to Obama's whitehouse in the PDB (this is what I meant when I said "fruits of surveillance given to his political opposition"). Trump's campaign was actively surveilled by the intelligence community on the basis of a document that they knew to be fraudulent (the steele dossier), and even publicly stated had not been corroborated when they got that warrant!
This is why the two situations are just fundamentally not comparable. The Russia connection was fictional from the start, and known to be fictional by the government as it was used as the basis of a surveillance operation that continued even after Trump became the president-elect. The people involved in this surveillance are the exact same people who were then assigned to the Mueller special counsel in order to both clean up their mess and do their best to hamstring the Trump administration's ability to hire staff and function. The Hunter Biden laptop story, in contrast, is a case where the government simply did not want to investigate obvious corruption and wrong-doing. The FBI totally ignored the reports of the computer store owner, and it was only after he gave the contents of the laptop to Giuliani that the government got interested and seized the drives - not because they wanted to investigate, but because they wanted to make sure Biden wasn't embarrassed any further. There hasn't been any substantive prosecution or even investigation of Hunter as a result of true, verified and impeccably well documented evidence of him committing multiple felonies, because these felonies implicate his father and multiple high-ranking members of the intelligence community. Not only did the government fail to investigate, they put out a statement claiming that these actual photos were the result of a Russian intelligence campaign, when the chain-of-provenance and validity of the evidence is crystal clear. They even went to the tech companies and had reporting on this story suppressed, which at least one study has determined changed the outcome of the election.
On the one hand, you have a case where fraudulent evidence is used as the basis for a malicious investigation and prosecution of a sitting candidate for president, which continued after he was actually elected. On the other hand, you have a case where real, verifiable and publicly available evidence of multiple well-documented felonies is simply slow-walked, ignored and publicly discredited with no factual basis in order to shift the outcome of an election. These two cases just aren't comparable in the way you were suggesting.
It's personally pretty clear to me that political bias was probably a factor, but again it's hard to prove definitively.
Read the Strzok/Page messages if you want proof. I also don't think political bias will really be provable here simply because the relevant axis is not republican/democrat but Trump/DC Blob, and that's not really a distinction that the law recognises to the best of my knowledge.
The laptop stuff has long been his personal project, and the fishing expedition ultimately failed to prove anything related to the president himself.
None of the stuff about Giuliani is relevant - and they actually have proved things related to the president. There are multiple whistleblowers testifying to the identity of "the big guy", along with multiple photos showing him meeting with Hunter's clients. The intelligence community hasn't prosecuted him, but why would they?
I will actually grant that I'm not sure making an actual secret backdoor key in those lines is technologically impossible - I thought it was, but I'll freely grant that I may have been wrong there.
You can pretty easily have FB keep a private key in an HSM locked in a vault somewhere, not connected to the internet, and after their legal department has fully vetted the warrant request, they could take the encrypted blob of messages into the vault and use the purpose-built hardware to decrypt it. Sure, add some qualifier about, "..can only be used with a warrant, up to the accuracy with which FB's legal team can determine the validity of said warrant," but then your only objection fades away.
But you depart from reality here.
Think about how many law enforcement requests for this kind of data are made all over the world, every single day. Every single time a person in the UK makes a problematic tweet, that vault is getting opened. Every single minor crime or drug dealer that the police go after? That vault is getting opened. This kind of law enforcement key/bypass would have to be so easily accessible that the idea it wouldn't be leaked is just not viable.
Carter Page was not indicted, nor did he feature particularly prominently in the final report compared to people like Papadopoulos or Manafort
Of course he wasn't indicted! That's the entire point I was bringing up - the Carter Page warrant was transparently a figleaf designed to let the intelligence agencies surveil Trump and his entire campaign while delivering intelligence reports based on that surveillance to his political opposition. Again, I struggle to believe that you've got a real understanding of the situation if you think the problem with the Carter Page warrant was that he wasn't actually indicted. The problem was that the Trump campaign and early days of his presidency were under hostile surveillance by the intelligence agencies, and the fruits of that surveillance were given to his political opposition... and all of it was based on a document that everyone involved knew was fraudulent.
Then there's the issue of whether that stuff meant the investigation was started from partisan motives,
No, this isn't an issue at all. The investigation was started from partisan motives, and if you're familiar with the documents in question and the outcome of the Durham investigation, there's not really any debate to be had on this subject.
levelled in the reverse direction for Hunter.
In order for this equivocation to be valid, the republicans would have had to have manufactured Hunter's laptop and all the evidence on it, selectively leaked portions of it to the media, used it to get a FISA court warrant to surveil Biden's whitehouse, then given regular copies of the intelligence summaries based on the information they gained to the Trump campaign. Hunter Biden's laptop became an issue because he took a lot of photos of himself committing crimes, along with a bunch of records of him selling influence and access to his father, then got super blitzed and forgot about dropping his laptop off to be repaired, then ignored the repeated messages saying "please come pick up your laptop or it becomes our property".
The last time I saw Noah Smith get into a twitter argument it involved him giving an extremely common word (Growth) a novel and unintuitive definition and then "dunking" on people who didn't use it. I'd rather get into an argument with him than the squad to be honest.
Just go by the statements of what was accused and alleged and no interpretation "well of course A is the type to do this so B is telling the truth but C is not the type so D is lying".
I don't think this is really that useful, especially when you look at some of the other statements made and that Trump's team was banned from presenting - like, are we allowed to take into account that the dress she said she was wearing when it happened hadn't been designed yet?
Adding E2E encrypted messaging with a law enforcement decryption key that can only be used with a warrant does not increase the risk further than the non-E2E case, even if that key is ultimately compromised.
...
law enforcement decryption key that can only be used with a warrant
How exactly are you enforcing this? Magic? This is, technologically, an explicitly unsolvable problem. You may as well propose a defence system that relies on a diviner performing tarot readings to determine when missiles are incoming.
I did not say lets also become an authoritarian dictatorship at the same time.
Do you think authoritarian dictatorships announce themselves as authoritarian dictatorships and democratically ask the people to vote on their takeover? The privacy warriors in the US are looking over at places like China, Russia and the UK and seeing almost exactly the things they were warning about being implemented, and you're calling them paranoid when they take umbrage at US politicians talking about how great those things are and wanting to bring them here! One of the major arguments made by the privacy warriors is that even if you give the government this power now because you trust it not to become an authoritarian dictatorship, it is impossible to tell when one of those is coming down the pipe. Yes, it sucks that the one pedophile who was capable of using encryption perfectly to hide his crimes got away, but that's utterly insignificant when compared to the danger posed by our current panopticon if it were to fall into the wrong hands, and there is no way of making sure that it does not fall into the wrong hands. Both sides of politics believe that their opposition will use this power corruptly, and I'm honestly not sure either of them are wrong.
Your argument is essentially saying that it is fine to not have seatbelts because you personally haven't crashed your car and don't think you're going to crash it in the near future (yeah sure other people get into car crashes but you're built different), and the people saying "hey you should wear a seatbelt" are just paranoid, low-status losers who shouldn't be listened to.
The absolute worst that has happened from this is newspaper headline related freak events rather than stuff that happens to everyone.
Are you familiar with the existence of the nation of China? The actual "absolute worst" that has happened from a complete lack of digital privacy is government dissidents and people who report the official who sexually harassed them getting disappeared and their organs harvested. You're talking about how all these silly paranoid privacy people have concerns that could never be realistic, and all the while we can just go look at one of the largest nations on Earth and see what happens when you get your way.
In case you're interested, I had a 3-hour conversation about this topic in the latest episode of the Bailey which covers a lot of the points you raise.
Sorry again for the late reply, but I'll give this a listen tonight. I don't think there's much point continuing the conversation until I have gotten through that three hours.
I'm not saying it is a good thing. I'm saying it already has happened a few times and will keep happening if need be. And it can be done anonymously and Europeans can be left speculating who blew up the pipes.
This trick might work on internet arguments when you can just say "Well there's no clear and undeniable photographic evidence of it happening so we can just never know" but there's no way that it will be taken seriously wrt geopolitical concerns like this. There's no need for speculation, and there wasn't even any need for speculation with the Nordstream bombing either - it was extremely obvious who did it and why, and the only reason there was any confusion was the people who did it also have substantial influence over the western media. In this hypothetical scenario where the EU moves out of the US orbit and into the Russian one, the ability of the US to just surreptitiously blow up pipelines and commit acts of actual war against the EU will be substantially degraded. When the US is forced to just go out into the open and admit that they're keeping Europe poor because otherwise Russia would benefit, what do you think that's going to do to the political situation there? Nationalist parties are on the rise already, and this would just give them substantially more power.
It is possible to be a modern Western nation and not hopelessly dependent on Russian fuel.
Not for long, and especially not if you're Germany (Norway can get away with it for obvious reasons). Fossil fuels are the bedrock of any advanced economy and there is no viable replacement or alternative. The shortfall created by denying Europe access to Russian gas cannot be filled by nuclear or renewables - not only is there not enough time to spin them up, it is doubtful that they can cover the gap and impossible for them to replace the other uses of fossil fuels.
Of course, the other aspect to this problem is that Russia doesn't have any problem finding other buyers for their fossil fuels. Sure, they might make a bit less money selling them to China, but that'll serve as a nice little boost to the Chinese economy and military. These moves don't just hurt America's putative allies, but actually strengthen their enemies. Of course that's not to say the US wouldn't do it - the war in Iraq was a transparently terrible idea with millions of negative outcomes people correctly foresaw and warned about in advance, but that didn't do anything to stop it.
Germany did not. Rather than shut down nuclear power plants in order to replace them with even more imported Russian fuel, Germany could have built more and then have imported less Russian fuel.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_Germany#/media/File:Energy_mix_in_Germany.svg
If you think that building a few more nuclear plants would have obviated the need to import Russian fuel I do not think you have a very good grasp of just how much energy nuclear or fossil fuels provide. You would have to multiply their nuclear power generation capacity by close to an order of magnitude to cover the fossil fuel shortfall. This is just not a serious proposal.
but more than enough to get a good picture.
Are you sure? The things I listed there specifically in my post are what I feel distinguish the two cases. There's absolutely no equivalence to Crossfire Hurricane or the Carter Page FISA warrant in the Biden cases, and I feel it is dishonest to even imply it. There's a huge world of difference there and collapsing the distinction makes your thinking lazier and less clear.
I probably have a similar blindspot for the conservative side of the narrative - I would have guessed that conservatives can't say 'Trump will actually get things done this time' because it would be acknowledging that he didn't get much done last time (beyond his constitutional right to propose SC appointments), and no acknowledging of weakness or failings for Trump is allowed. Maybe it's allowed if they wrap it in 'the deep state stopped him form getting things done' or w/e.
I'm not an American conservative and so I'm not quite sure what conversation is like in their spaces, but in the discourse I actually have access to (and my own personal opinion) that is indeed the case - Trump was hamstrung by a GOP establishment more concerned with preserving their own sinecures and access to power than actually doing anything to help him implement the policies that got him elected, as well as Crossfire Hurricane and the Mueller investigation it turned into (to say nothing of the open disobedience of people like Milley). Maybe my impression is incorrect, but I always felt that the right didn't mind acknowledging Trump's various weaknesses/failures, they just didn't like obsessing over it because whatever the man's flaws there isn't really an alternative willing to fight for them.
No one needs to ask Europe for permission. Pipes can just start blowing up. They are really long and as best I know not practically defensible.
This proposed strategy is utterly moronic and I really don't see how you can think this is a viable approach at all. What, exactly, is the carrot being offered to keep the Eurozone outside Russia and China's sphere of influence when the American offer is just "if you want an economy more advanced than the middle ages we are going to bomb your infrastructure back to the stone age"? The US military is not going to have nearly as easy a time operating in Europe when they're enforcing a zero-development policy against the wishes of the EU.
A modern developed European nation could just not rely on Russia for energy.
For Europe, the only alternative to Russian energy is deprivation - remember that Biden just turned off the LNG exports designed to cover the shortfall in order to get back at Texas. You can't have a modern first world economy (or a modern first world welfare state for that matter) without copious amounts of fossil fuels. Green and renewable energy cannot make up for the shortfall, and neither can nuclear. There is no alternative to Russian fossil fuels - right now Europe is still using them, they just have to pay a big premium to India in order to get around US sanctions and pipeline bombing. I was one of the people who thought the sanctions would have caused massive problems in Europe last winter, I just didn't think the US would accept such an obvious and naked end-run around their sanctions.
I get that transferring from an oil-for-energy scheme to something else is an enormous lift. But they may not be given the choice if more pipeline ""accidents"" occur.
It isn't just an enormous lift - the calculations on exactly when the transition process has to start in order to avoid severe involuntary reductions in societal complexity have been done, and the answer was several decades ago. Switching to a new energy source is going to be a massive, society-wide challenge WITH Russian fossil fuels. Without them? lol
The moment the US switches to an approach of "You are going to stay poor, cold and freezing because we want to hurt the people you buy gas from, and we are not going to make up for the shortfall in the way we promised because our own states are rebelling and need to be punished" the Europeans are going to just welcome the Russians in through open doors. Of course, now that I think about it, that doesn't really seem that unrealistic given the fecklessness of the current administration.
It takes for granted that society is going to exist in much the same way 5, 10, 20 years from now without getting worse, such that personal improvement matters, and I don't think the 70s had that in the same way.
I like the point that you're making, but I think that this is only a partial explanation. There are a lot of people who are now preaching self-reliance/getting the bag/lifting not because they believe society is still going to exist in the same way in the future, but because of the opposite. They think that a lot of the existing support structures are going to go away, and in that context you absolutely want to be independently sustainable and as physically formidable as possible. The idea that society is going through the ragged steps of decline and fall that mark the end of every empire is an incredibly compelling argument for self-improvement.

I think the threshold is so high that it effectively does not exist. From everything I understand about the operation of hte US government, the combination of the Israel lobby/AIPAC, the MIC and the CIA exert far more power and influence over government policy than any number of voters.
More options
Context Copy link