FirmWeird
Randomly Generated Reddit Username
No bio...
User ID: 757
Well, that's largely symmetrical to Trump's Russia investigation:
This is extremely wrong and a sign that you haven't done the required research to talk authoritatively about this topic. There's absolutely no symmetry to the Carter Page warrant, Crossfire Hurricane, Mueller panel etc, and vice versa with the Hunter Art shows or Laptop photos.
Of course, I could be totally wrong about all of that, I acknowledge it's a particular narrate that progressive sources are trying hard to sell me on right now. I think it's more plausible from the outside view than a lot of other things they try to sell me on that I dismiss as silly, but it could also be sillier than I'm seeing.
I don't normally agree with your posts on here but I actually do think that you've got an accurate picture here despite the downvotes. I'm legitimately surprised to hear that this is a narrative progressive sources are trying to sell you on, because it reads to me like pro-Trump campaign advertising. "Last time, Trump was held back by the Deep State and the RINOS - but this time he's SERIOUS" - I could see that maybe as an attempt at encouraging progressives to get motivated to go vote for Biden, but I can't help but feel that it'd be counter-productive in the general.
Please forgive me and disregard my post - I misinterpreted your comment and saw it in the wrong context.
wait for the mutual search of possibility-space to return something unsurvivable for our current social context
I don't have anything really novel to say but I think that's a great way of phrasing what's happening.
I honestly don't have any good suggestions for preventing physical crossings or handling deportations of the unwilling, but surely someone has some.
Sure.
First of all, you implement an immediate 40-year prison term that explicitly pierces the corporate veil for any hiring of illegal immigrants. E-verify? Mandatory. Second, you remove any and all sources of aid or welfare to illegal immigrants until they voluntarily sign up for deportation. Third, you go over to the NSA building and get them to run a search through their system for all the undocumented and illegal immigrants in their system. Every single one of them that is currently employed has a letter sent to their employer informing them that they're either going to fire their immigrant employee or go to prison for the rest of their life. The number of crossings will go dramatically down when there's no way to profit or sustain an existence in the US as an illegal immigrant, so you'd be able to save on the border defence as well.
That's because it wasn't the current Democratic Party who set this up and got the program started. The roots of the immigration crisis that America is in right now go back to Hart-Celler at least.
Was everyone who died during the Iraq War a terrorist? likely not, some innocents died and it was an acceptable loss.
An acceptable loss? An acceptable loss for what? The war in Iraq was a massive negative for the world and was responsible for a lot of suffering, all for the sake of failed geopolitical gameplaying and war-profiteering by the American MIC. Not a single one of the innocent deaths in the Iraq war was an "acceptable loss". I really can't understand your point here - the outcomes of the Iraq war were so terrible that I can't think of any of those deaths as being acceptable. "Yeah sure we murdered a bunch of innocents and gave islamic terror groups a huge amount of propaganda fodder, but in exchange we got to have Islamic State show up a few years later."
Do you think the fentanyl crisis is caused by people who are legitimately ordering their fentanyl for medical purposes?
(this comment was dumb and I misread the post I was replying to)
They are actually still a source of instability in the region due to their contentious relations with the other arab states, and the current state of affairs involves large sums of money being given to their neighbours in order to stop them from attacking Israel. Get rid of the Palestinians and you solve nothing - you give the entire Islamic world a causus belli against Israel and then they do things like attack international shipping vessels to disrupt the region.
And as for keeping the Israelis... ever read much Roman history? The Israelites made absolutely terrible imperial/hegemonic subjects to the point that they brag about it - an efficient hegemon would just exterminate them for good and resettle the territory.
You may have your own metric of what is "efficient"
As has been pointed out below, my metric is actually energy returned on energy invested, i.e. input vs output on an energetic level. To the best of my knowledge this is actually what people usually mean when they use the term "efficient" and I'm not trying to play any language games here. Organic farming turns 1 calorie of input into 10 calories of output, petroleum/modern agriculture turns 10 calories of input into 1 calorie of output. To go back to slavery, slavery might even be incredibly inefficient, but the slaveowner doesn't care because he's using other people's resources without compensating them - slavery isn't really about efficiency.
As for changing economic incentives, I think there's actually a very substantial chance of that changing over the next few decades - go look at a chart showing conventional oil discoveries over time (you can look at the non-conventional discoveries too, but they need to be accounted for differently due to depletion rates etc). Modern industrial agriculture relies on petroleum and there are no substitutes, so expect economic incentives to change dramatically as oil's price changes.
China has, according to the US Navy, over 230x the shipbuilding capacity of the US. The technical edge? The US doesn't even have that anymore - the Kinzhal missiles they purchase from their now extremely close ally Russia are better than the equivalent western hypersonic. I'm not going to comment on the financial aspect, because I have no idea how much of either the US or Chinese economy is hallucinatory (except that it isn't zero for either).
I strongly agree with your point and this is something that I've been thinking about for a while. That said I think I go a bit further - I think Left/right as a meaningful political divide is going to either go away or simply transform into pro/anti regime/establishment, because neither of them can offer anything which actually helps people deal with the problems they're facing in their daily lives. Trump is just the early foreshadowing of that realignment.
You're being far too nice here from the perspective of an actual global hegemon with no ethical concerns. If you're talking about "whatever creates stability" then the Israelis are going to have to go too - they can either get wiped out and replaced by whatever ethnicity runs the global hegemon, or they can get forcibly mixed with arab populations in order to completely remove the possibility of this ancient tribal conflict starting back up again.
Just to clarify, I'm not actually suggesting this as a course of action.
You're being extremely dishonest here by using polls from before the most recent attempt at wiping out the Gazans.
One may as well talk about how islamic terrorism isn't a problem in the US by taking a poll from September 10th 2001, and a bar chart showing deaths from terrorism that starts at September 12th.
Israel. If they have nothing, Israel needs nothing. But we give them a lot, and they divert much of it to waging terror campaigns.
My interpretation of this sentence was that Israel needs nothing, but we give them (Israel) a lot and they use much of it to wage terror campaigns. I agree with this but I'm not sure that's what you were actually saying.
I don't think any sane person would feel comfortable calling the outcome of with any degree of confidence
Actually I'm pretty comfortable calling that outcome - America loses. There's not enough time to make up for the manufacturing shortfall, and that manufacturing shortfall is so massively brutal that not even the US' slight technical edge will make up for it (if that technical edge is even still there in a decade, which is debatable too).
By the way it is not dissimilar to some issues here an now: organic and ethical farms are less efficient compared to industrial agriculture and that is why we have the system that we have now.
Organic and ethical farms are actually dramatically more efficient at turning energy into food than industrial agriculture. Industrial farming lets you turn petroleum/oil into food, and despite being less efficient (and causing damage to the soil to boot) the sheer amount of energy contained within petroleum lets modern industrial agriculture outcompete organic and ethical farming.
First of all, sorry for taking so long to reply - I only post during working hours to make sure that I keep the culture war and getting mad at the internet portion of my day well contained. Thank you for the compliments!
So as applied to J6, we don't have to rely on the FBI's skewed version of events because we can see people actually storming the Capitol on video.
As the person endorsing a conspiracy theory, I'd just like to clarify that I do not believe the "feds" started the protest. I think they went out of their way to make it easy for people to commit crimes without realising it, by being heavily involved in the leadership of the protest as well as by surreptitiously removing barricades and barriers in such a way that people would commit crimes without realising it. So far (to my knowledge) there hasn't been any footage that contradicts this claim. I think there would have been a protest, but I don't think it would have gotten as far as it did, nor would nearly as many crimes have been committed, without some federal encouragement/assistance.
You're welcome to tell me if there's anything wrong with this reasoning.
Did you go through every single case? I don't see a source stating that you've gone through all the J6 prosecutions and identified the defences being used in each one. If you've actually got a good source explaining every single case I'd love to give it a look. That said, I imagine that any case involving active federal informants or CHSes would be kept sealed or private in order to prevent that information from being released and leaving them utterly useless, and some people would simply receive extremely good plea deals if their defence would actually expose an informant or source. It feels slightly dishonest to say "All of my evidence is in the box marked 'this box cannot be opened except by federal agents'" but c'est la vie.
Regarding Ray Epps's conduct, the fact that some J6 protestors believed he was a fed is not relevant evidence.
I agree! It was actually his actions that I was referring to in that video as evidence, rather than the namecalling.
Baked Alaska, the same guy who starting chanting "Fed! Fed!" at Epps on January 5th still livestreamed himself walking into the Capitol the next day, which eventually landed him with a 60 day jail sentence.
I'm actually familiar with Baked Alaska, the moron who livestreamed himself committing several crimes, was responsible for getting a lot of people identified with his footage, and who said "if I didn't turn into an informant I'd get a felony charge" before getting an incredibly sweet plea deal (which he then went and fucked up!). Baked Alaska is a very odd figure and connected with a lot of the more odd-looking parts of the internet right (Nick Fuentes), but he is also effectively a confirmed government informant - so if you were wondering what it would look like for one of them to get charged, his case is right there.
Epps claimed he thought the Capitol would be open on J6, didn't start realizing otherwise until he saw the barricades and scuffles, and was too far forward in the crowd to find an opportunity to turn back.
I can't find this explanation viable or realistic at all given the actual footage of him and what he did when he reached the barriers. It also completely fails to explain why he was so insistent on breaking into the capitol building everywhere he went and spoke to people - I can't square the mindset he's claiming and the actions he took at all. Hell, even when reading the statements put out by his legal team...
He continued to advocate for peaceful protest. That individual and others nonetheless knocked the barriers down and surged forward. Mr. Epps was one of those who followed behind then and again through a second set of barriers. In doing so, he engaged in disorderly and disruptive conduct. He made a mistake, one that he has and will have to live with. But he also had the wherewithal then to try to correct his mistake.
So he gets to the barricade, has a chat with the guy who then goes and takes down the barriers. Then he "followed behind and again through a second set of barriers"? How exactly do you decide to turn around and leave, then end up breaking through security barriers in the opposite direction?
When questioned about this text (pg 63) he said he meant "orchestrated" helping people get to the front and remain peaceful, and also claimed he wasn't aware how violent it got at the time he sent the text.
Thanks for finding that one! I also don't believe his stated explanation, albeit for different reasons.
Ultimately, I'm utterly unconvinced by the argument being made by the government/his defence here. There's no good explanation for his bizarre insistence on breaking into the capitol building or for his actions in furtherance of that goal, nor for his incredibly lenient treatment when compared to a lot of the other J6 protestors. Maybe I'm just outing myself as a midwit, but I think that the case made by the two revolver articles was substantially stronger than the one made by Epps' defenders. Though with all that said I don't believe there's enough publicly available evidence to firmly settle the matter one way or another.
What officials? What admissions? How many informants?
Steven D’Antuono, former assistant director-in-charge of the Washington Field Office, told the House Judiciary Committee that confidential sources attended and other informants went on their own accord.
He said the Washington Field Office knew ahead of time that some undercover operatives would be at the Stop the Steal rally before the Capitol storming.
There were so many, the FBI 'lost track' of some of them and had to perform an audit later to determine how many were there.
D’Antuono said behind closed doors that at least one informant was in contact with his FBI handler when he entered the Capitol.
...
'Well, I think they were both,' he responded.
Jordan replied: 'So, you now know that there were CHSes that the FBI knew ahead of time were going to be here on January 6 and that there were also some unknown CHSes who, on their own accord, decided to come here on January 6?'
'That is my belief, yeah,' D’Antuono responded.
There've been multiple news stories about this, and multiple confrontations in official government panels. Even disreputable media sources like the NY Times have reported on this - https://www.nytimes.com/2021/09/25/us/politics/capitol-riot-fbi-informant.html
And assuming all that is correct, how do you know that the groups 'informant' and 'J6 defendant who avoided jail time' overlap with each other?
I don't even necessarily think that they do. Some of them would receive light or perfunctory sentences in order to keep their cover (most groups recognise what it means when someone keeps joining political groups, commits crimes, encourages lawbreaking and then doesn't go to prison). Some of them were, supposedly, simply government informants for other reasons who went to the protests as individuals. Some of the people who received a vanishingly small sentence may have simply had good lawyers, taken advantage of a legal mistake made by the government or have extenuating circumstances. But I stand by my claim that some of those defendants received leniency because they were actively working with the government. Ray Epps especially given that he's on camera talking about the need to break into the capitol building the night before (to a rousing chorus of FED!).
The practice in federal court that I'm familiar with for defendants is that their informant status is disclosed in order to get leniency at sentencing, and no J6 defendant has ever been outed as having done that.
Publicly admitting that they were there on government orders is exactly the sort of thing that the FBI would prevent these informants/CHSes from doing, because that gives the game away.
Is this all meant to be a charade to aver a suspicious public? If so, doesn't the lack of jail time allow scrutinizing observers like yourself to see through that facade?
Not at all. Notice how we're actually having a debate over this rather than simply pointing at the evidence and going "lol fed". Additionally, the FBI actually lost track of all their informants and confidential sources due to the sheer quantity of them involved in the protest. If there are so many of them that the FBI can't even keep track of people who they have on file, I don't think it's impossible that the government could end up charging some of them by mistake.
But to bring things right back to Ray Epps and the FBI, they have a documented track record of instigating crimes for the purpose of making arrests - see the Gretchen Whitmer plot, or the Khalil Abu Rayyan case. "Right wing extremism" is currently their biggest investigation target, and I think it is abundantly plausible that government informants or people otherwise working for the FBI were involved in making sure that otherwise innocent people ended up committing crimes.
If you look at things under that assumption, everything about Epps' conduct makes sense. He spends time telling people they need to break into the capitol building (again, with such insistence that people there in person surround him and start chanting FED), and then he goes and skips the actual speech he supposedly came to Washington to see, in order to make sure that the barricades preventing people from going into restricted areas are removed! Then, he later says in a phonecall that he "facilitated the entrance of people into the capitol" - which is exactly what he would be doing if this theory is correct. (I can't find my source for this quote - google seems to just ignore it and give me articles about how he was let off, so feel free to just ignore this point). I may be making a fallacious argument from incredulity here, but I really can't see an alternative explanation for his behaviour on the day that makes any sense.
I don't think my argument really suffers at all from making that adjustment, so sure.
Because they weren't entirely expelled - there remain populations of mizrahim in various countries, and according to wikipedia at least several of them end up moving to the USA instead. I do agree that they were under less severe pressures than the ashkenazim, but that doesn't mean there wasn't any such pressure at all.
What claim within the Revolver piece addresses whether or not Epps was treated unusually that I did not address?
The actual acts undertaken by Epps as outlined that article are the exact reason why people believe he was being treated unusually. Remember that he said that people needed to go into the capitol the night before the speech, and he even quit the speech early to go make sure people could go into the capitol! There is a much more direct line from his actions to the breach of the capitol building than anything Trump did or said, and they actually are going after Trump for actions that were unequivocally less relevant to the breach of the capitol building than what Epps did. He was also high up in the ranks of the Oathkeepers, one of the groups involved - he's directly comparable to Enrique Tarrio, and the difference in sentencing is extremely stark.
Do you believe that the 37% of other convicted J6 defendants who also avoided jail time were also federal informants or otherwise working for the government?
I believe that a substantial amount were. This isn't a bizarre conspiracy theory or fact pulled out of my ass to justify my opinion, but based on the admission of several officials that there were a large number of informants and government workers in the crowd. I'm sure that some of these individuals were just lucky (or unlucky given they were involved in the process at all), but I would bet a significant amount of money that there are federal informants or government workers inside that 37%.
This is evidently not a material factor for sentencing purposes.
Did you read the opinion? Judge Boasberg (coincidentally the same judge who approved the faulty warrant that allowed surveillance of the Trump campaign) explicitly said that this was a material factor for sentencing purposes. I think he was lying, but that is his actual official position.
The selection effects were importing a lot of mizrahis which you consider unremarkable.
And from a HBD perspective, they largely are unremarkable compared to others. But the point remains that the forces bringing them and the Ashkenazim to Israel were not random at all, which is one of the reasons why it would be silly to compare them to a random selection of Americans.
Please give the following article a read. I don't think you've got an accurate picture or understanding of Trump and the forces animating his campaign. https://www.resilience.org/stories/2016-01-21/donald-trump-and-the-politics-of-resentment/
Specifically, please pay attention to the part where he outlines the salary/wage class and the distinctions between them. It neatly answers and resolves the quandaries you've posted.

This would also entail freeing Europe from having an economy beyond subsistence farming for a generation or two. The actual work required to free Europe from Russian oil would have to have been started at least a decade ago, maybe even more. This doesn't give the US hegemony over Europe - this just pushes Europe into the BRICS sphere and leaves the US even more isolated, because when EU leaders are given a choice between "reversion to third world despotism to keep the USA happy" and "having profitable trade with one of their closest neighbours" you don't have to be a genius to see which one they'll pick.
More options
Context Copy link