@FirmWeird's banner p

FirmWeird

Randomly Generated Reddit Username

2 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 23:38:51 UTC

				

User ID: 757

FirmWeird

Randomly Generated Reddit Username

2 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 23:38:51 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 757

That's really interesting - I hadn't seen any sources which made the claim that they were overrepresented in those areas but I freely admit to not looking at the situation throughout history. Do you have any good links for more information on that topic? Most of the sources I can find compare Sephardim/Misrahim to Ashkenazim, which really doesn't do them any favours.

You don't apply the same standards to Trump, otherwise you wouldn't support him.

I'm not an American, but you're right that I don't apply the same standards. Trump isn't dependent upon his donors, Desantis and Haley are - this distinction matters quite a lot.

I think that's a fairly likely outcome. Hell, given Fox's actions as of late I wouldn't be surprised if they throw the case and just give in anyway because the legal settlement would be worth paying in exchange for the political outcome.

I once made a comment on here and then saw a high profile twitter account referencing the exact same metric I was talking about shortly afterwards. Obviously there's no way to prove it (and if there was I wouldn't want to do so!), but I think there are a fair few prominent people reading/posting here.

https://revolver.news/2023/07/against-all-odds-rap-legend-tupac-shakur-shot-down-ray-epps-defamation-claim-against-tucker-and-revolver-news/

Revolver news agrees with you.

Turns out that there's actually legal precedent that calling someone a government agent doesn't count as defamation.

The counsel for Tupac’s estate contended that the allegedly defamatory statements at issue were not capable of defamatory meaning. In other words, they contended that accusing someone of working for the federal government may harm that person’s reputation with some, but it nonetheless cannot be considered defamation from the standpoint of law.

DeSantis attacked Trump from the right, Trump attacked DeSantis from the left.

I don't believe this is meaningful at all when looking at Trump and what he represents. The policies that got him elected and which he tried to implement, are in direct opposition to the bipartisan consensus of more forever wars, more outsourcing, more illegal immigration and more corruption. I don't think that the Left/Right divide is really that useful when you look at Trump's politics and his base. Opposition to or support of the existing elite and their chosen policies is the far more meaningful divide. Desantis and Haley have donors which the Trump base find intolerable, and the Trump base is a big enough constituency in the GOP base to give them effective veto power over future candidates.

He didn't build the wall the first time, why would he do it now?

Trump's first presidency was hamstrung by multiple factors, some of them explicit (Crossfire Hurricane and the Mueller investigation it turned into) and others less visible (entrenched resistance from the deep state and republican party). The last eight years have seen substantial shifts in the GOP, with many more pro-Trump individuals getting involved in the actual political machinery of the republican party, and he's going to have a lot more leverage in a second term.

  1. Personal Loyalty: This is close to the Richard Hanania theory. Personal loyalty would make sense if Trump was loyal in turn to his supporters, but he isn't. How many of his lawyers have gone to jail? How many orange-blooded Trump fans lost their jobs or got arrested for believing in him too hard on January 6? He could have pardoned these people, but he didn't. Orange Man good because Orange Man good.

The moment Trump pardoned the J6 protestors he would have been impeached by the Republican party - the threat was even made explicitly in the media IIRC.

  1. Perceived Injustice: Yes, Trump has been treated unfairly by the media and the Washington establishment. Lots of people have been. I can understand why this would be seen as a necessary condition (e.g. "nobody liked by the 'elites' could ever be a good president"), but why would this be a sufficient condition? Surely electability and general competence matter more than an extra standard-deviation worth of grievances against the media.

Every single person who has been trusted and liked by the media/Washington establishment has immediately abandoned the particular policies that Trump-voters want and support once they get into office, and it isn't like this is an accident - the only way to be liked by the media/Washington establishment is to preserve and extend the same policies which they like and the Trump base hates. This is also why Desantis and Nikki Haley were immediately rejected by the base - they're just more representatives of Conservative Inc who want to return things to business as usual, and business as usual has gotten utterly intolerable for a lot of the people supporting Trump.

  1. Hatred: I'm not talking about "Hate™". I'm talking about a genuine desire to see one's political enemies suffer. It's not even clear to me that Trump would be better at this than other Republican candidates, but I feel I would be missing something if I didn't put it on the list.

Have you been paying attention to how much weeping, moaning and gnashing of teeth even the prospect of Trump getting back into power has caused? Nobody's writing lengthy thinkpieces about how the election of Nikki Haley would mean the end of democracy/sunlight/good things in the world.

My apologies for being unclear - please replace "criminal conviction" with "prison sentence".

I've laid out my reasons for why Ray Epps does not appear to have been treated unusually when comparing his charges/sentences to other comparable J6 defendants.

Could you please show me where you actually did this? I gave the post I was responding to the and the links a few looks, but I couldn't find any where you went through the claims made in the Revolver piece in great detail.

Also, I'd just like to add as an aside that I don't think "being the victim of a conspiracy theory" is actually what is responsible for his lenient sentencing - rather, it was due to him being a federal informant or otherwise working for the government. I think that the conspiracy theory claim is being used as a figleaf for those other reasons. And finally...

The "suffered enough already" factor might sway judges/prosecutors at the margins, particularly for petty or questionable offenses, but I can't imagine a scenario where it would justify leniency for someone accused of running an underage sex trafficking ring.

Petty or questionable offences? Epstein was just running an underage sex trafficking ring, and the government didn't even think that was a big enough deal for him to go to prison the first time he did it. They haven't even gone after many of the confirmed customers of the sex ring - Ehud Barak is still a free man, as is Prince Andrew. In contrast, I've been repeatedly informed by "reliable sources" that what took place on January 6 was a violent insurrection that attempted to end our democracy, and is actually legally comparable to raising an army and literally waging war on the US government. The idea that people being mean on twitter could make up for that beggars belief.

Is there a Jewish group anywhere in the world that doesn't massively outperform their countrymen economically? No, there isn't.

Yes, absolutely. Sephardic and Mizrahi jews don't noticeably outperform their countrymen, and they especially don't do it in Israel. IIRC (but I may be wrong, so don't trust this without verification) it was actually the Christians in the middle-east who outperformed economically and on IQ tests.

Here's another way to look at it. Put 10 million random Americans into a tiny strip of arid land with no resources and check how they are doing in 70 years.

This is a silly hypothetical because you have selection effects for Israel which aren't actually completely random. Exactly who counts as American is different as well - are you drawing this 10 million-strong cohort from the America of today or America as it was when Israel was founded? But even if you correct for that, throw in all the resources that Israel receives from America and the jewish Diaspora and the random Americans would most likely be doing better, if only because they don't have to support a population of non-working, non-military serving orthodox.

I can see the tenuous basis/linkage here, and I appreciate you providing an answer to my question. But, unfortunately, it isn't enough to change my mind on this matter - I can't understand how Ray Epps gets away with what he did on the basis of people saying mean things about him online when this same principle is not applied to anywhere near the same degree when it comes to others. Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell were the target of far more online conspiracy theories than Ray Epps was, but that hasn't impacted their sentencing or prosecution in the slightest.

Ask an antisemite why Jews are over-represented in the Ivy League, and they will probably say that it is because the Jews in academia collude to favor Jewish students over gentiles, helping them cheat and so on. If you convince them that the over-representation is due to raw honest brain power, that will conflict with the antisemitic trope.

I think that there's an element of both of these in play to be honest. The Ashkenazim verbal IQ advantage is real(and I believe it is also tied to the same alleles that are responsible for so many of the genetic disorders they encounter) but not sufficient to explain their overrepresentation in certain fields (you can just go and do the maths on that if you want) - but ethnic nepotism in combination with the IQ advantage explains it perfectly. I don't think you need to be an antisemite to point out that jewish identity is fairly strong, and it isn't like that ethnic nepotism is hidden or obscured in any way. You can just go look at various institutions and bodies set up by the jewish community to support their own, it isn't a secret at all.

In terms of how judges have treated other defendants, what other defendants have been the target of conspiracy theories like Eps?

Is there any legal basis for this at all? Would I be able to escape a criminal conviction by having a bunch of people on twitter talk about how I was a federal agent? If this is actually a criteria that's being used to adjust sentencing and shift legal outcomes, I've just come up with an incredibly profitable new business idea that will help get people out of sticky prosecutions even when there's direct video evidence of them committing the crime! Of course I don't actually believe that's the case - he's not being let off due to an actual legal principle. There are hundreds of conspiracy theories circulating about Donald Trump, and I highly doubt that he's going to be able to dodge the charges by using a similar precedent.

-- Plagiarism has become such a complex and overinclusive concept that it's impossible to actually do academic work at volume without either committing plagiarism or specifically acting to avoid plagiarism while still technically doing the same thing

I think that this is completely wrong and that you haven't actually done anything to demonstrate this at all. I can see multiple groups and people putting out original scholarship, and it isn't hard to avoid plagiarism if you're actually doing an experiment and trying to replicate something. People put out original research and academic work all the time without plagiarising - for example, look at the work that's being done on reading the Pompeii papyri.

On the other hand, I think that plagiarism is a huge problem in the field of academic functionaries who aren't capable of doing actual academic work, and those are just a lot more prominent at the moment because there are so many useless midwits in academia staffing various diversity sinecures. In that world, you get your job on the basis of your identity and your friends, with the academic work being little more than a paper requirement. These people aren't trying to study or advance human knowledge, they're trying to claw down a fat paycheck for doing nothing/pursuing the political goals they wanted to pursue anyway. Plagiarism is going to be a big problem in this cohort because as far as they're concerned the actual work of academia is not something they're there for, so why not plagiarise?

This is mostly resolved by my adoption of Taleb-style localism as an ideal.

I've been a non-Catholic Distributist for the past several years and have made comments to that effect even on the old reddit. Given what you've just said, I highly recommend looking into that philosophy - and at the very least it means you get to read more G.K. Chesterton, which is always a treat.

I'm more than open to the possibility of this argument being true, but there's a single big sticking point which can't help but come to mind - the nature of migration to European states and how that changes the statistics. Are you able to provide statistics tracking these changes over the same population, and analysing migrants and their children separately? It seems like you'd very easily be able to cover up the increase in misery if the new migrants are are happy enough (and to my knowledge, a lot of them are substantially more happy in Europe than in their previous homes).

I also don't think the fat acceptance movement will have any success - but mostly because fat people are actually viscerally uncool and status-damaging to hang out with. I just don't think their disrespect for science and material reality is going to be what does them in, because observably false beliefs can survive just fine in society without any serious pushback.

No worries, it happens! I've definitely left comments unreplied to when I start airing my unpopular opinions too.

In general, making fun of reactionary youtubers (which still happens on the farms, but is mostly less popular) is more a pastime of rationalwiki users and a few other leftist online communities.

This isn't actually true. A huge portion of the site is devoted to going after Ethan Ralph and his ostensibly right wing crowd, and there's another devoted to Nicholas Fuentes and his bizarre cult. They make fun of a lot of the online/internet right, it's just that nobody cares about the internet right getting bullied.

To be fair, the guy in question seems to have a superhuman level of obsession with keeping his project alive, I don't think an average person could reproduce that.

He is also trapped - the anti KF crowd made sure that everyone in the entire world knew who Joshua Connor Moon was. He has no possibility of getting gainful employment in the west, because there's zero chance that the crowd currently trying to make sure KF goes down would be ok with him just having a regular job. They've made sure that he has no other choice - if he stops maintaining KF, which is how he supports himself, he doesn't have any other options.

which is part of why many antisemitic wignats spend a lot of time online trying to disprove the substantial body of evidence that suggests Ashkenazim are around 2/3 of a standard deviation smarter than gentile whites.

Just as an aside, my interpretation of the studies I've seen was that ashkenazim had a higher verbal IQ but lower visual intelligence, and these differences were largely caused by the same alleles which are responsible for a lot of the sphingolipid disorders that are so prevalent in the community.

The argument made by the more intelligent nationalists I've seen is that the Askhenazim IQ curve isn't so far ahead of the white curve as to explain the disparities in outcome (the gentile population is so much larger that there are more gentiles at just about every point on the IQ spectrum), and that jewish nepotism plays a big role in their overrepresentation in a lot of areas. I think this is fairly plausible, not the least because you can point to actual specific instances of this kind of nepotism and discrimination in regular life - see Ivy league admissions offices penalising applicants for rural activities and jewish overrepresentation in admissions offices.

Medicine will continue to show that obesity is unhealthy, which will give everyone psychological permission to maintain their aversion.

I want to believe this, but I feel that time has shown that the oppressor/oppressed framework is more than capable of overruling the science. There's a lot of research on IQ, heritability, innate gender differences etc - and people just continue to spout verifiable, known lies that accord with the framework in question.

Well, except if you're with a group of people bonding by bullying someone, you perspective implies I should start bullying them too...

This is a strategy followed by countless schoolchildren worldwide for centuries, so you wouldn't be alone.

It was the central question of the original conversation you jumped in on, here.

Was it? From my reading, the central question of the original conversation was

In what way does the observed evidence differ from what we would see in a world where these officials genuinely care about and want to preserve democracy, and genuinely believe that the Constitution has been violated and that this is the appropriate legal remedy?

Whether or not the ruling was just is largely immaterial to that question, which is why I didn't find it particularly relevant.

'Anyone who disagrees with me is so stupid that it's not worth listening to them' is not typically a stance that ends up with you yourself becoming educated and well-informed on a topic.

I agree with the point you're making and have even made it before on the motte, but that isn't really the case in this situation. I'm perfectly happy for people to disagree with me, but that disagreement has to take the relevant facts into account. We know how the Steele dossier was made, and there's undeniable video evidence that Trump's speech was not the cause of people entering the capital. You can absolutely still make a case against Trump when you take that evidence into account, but you have to deal with that evidence and look at what actually happened.

Again, I'm not saying you can't disagree with me - but if you say that Trump flew a KKK flag and ordered the proud boys to violently take over the capital and pronounce him Emperor, I'm going to dismiss your argument out of hand unless you've got some really compelling evidence to prove your case and I really don't think I'm wrong to do so.

You are of course free to disagree - but the consequences of that include an inability to object to fictional evidence being brought into an argument, which is not a position I think you'd be willing to take (though I'd love to give my imagination a workout if not!)

He's not being prosecuted for insurrection!

I was under the impression that the topic of conversation had broadened to include things like the Smith special counsel. If that's not the case, then your objections are all valid and I don't even disagree - these particular dates weren't chosen specifically to mess with his campaigning, unlike the special counsel ones.

Things like this are why 'anyone who disagrees with me is too stupid to listen to' is such a dangerous position to take. The real world is complex, and if you're supremely confident you already understand it well enough then you're probably just going to miss all the nuance that actually matters.

I agree, which is why I don't take that position. But I don't think "Young Earth creationists are not worth listening to when it comes to proposed evolutionary pathways" is particularly dangerous. To provide another example, I'm perfectly willing to hear people defend the NSA and the current USG panopticon - but if someone says that XKEYSCORE is just fiction and the NSA's existence is a conspiracy theory, they aren't even making an actual coherent argument and aren't worth engaging with.

  1. They provide a variety of other benefits - medical isotopes, etc. But at the same time, I really don't think that "a government decided to build it" is a compelling argument for something being profitable. Governments do unprofitable things all the time for a variety of reasons.
  2. Nuclear energy only deserves subsidies if it actually does enable energy security! If the total lifetime EROEI is negative, nuclear energy does the opposite.
  3. Oil prices play a huge part in the actual cost of nuclear plants. Petroleum is used to manufacture them, maintain them, extract that fuel and then transport the fuel to the nuclear plant. As the price of oil rises, nuclear is going to rise up as well as a result.
  4. This is just a statement of fact that I can't disagree with, but at the same time I don't actually see any evidence for it.
  5. I agree that fossil fuels are actually bad for the environment and the people around them in a lot of ways, but nuclear presents its own problems that we haven't really grappled with yet. What are the lifetime costs of having radioactive material stuck in the environment? That's a question that's going to take hundreds of thousands of years to answer. Of course, climate change and resource depletion are going to cause a lot of damage already, so this does in fact remain an open question in my book.