FirmWeird
Randomly Generated Reddit Username
No bio...
User ID: 757
Maritime/naval usage is indeed the best use-case for nuclear power, and that's one of the reasons why the military uses nuclear-powered vessels.
As for the government regulations, I'm not actually too bothered by them on nuclear. I don't have a problem with laws preventing my neighbours from operating a backyard nuclear reactor or building a perfect replica of the demon core in order to test their reactions and screwdriver control. I'm sure a case can be made that those regulations are badly written and far too onerous, but I'm very happy that we do actually regulate them.
Because their nuclear power system is failing, taking on vast amounts of debt and is on the verge of being nationalised due to financial problems, which is why it isn't an example of a successful, profitable nuclear power system.
I casually dismissed white nationalism recently and received more pushback againt that than for any other opinion.
I didn't see exactly what happened in that case, but as someone who was occasionally part of pushback like that, my perspective is that it is simply because there's a lot of lazy thinking when it comes to criticism of the white nationalists. When you're talking in mainstream society you can just say "x is a white nationalist" and if true that's a devastating critique that destroys someone's reputation by itself, let alone the argument they're making. But that's not the case here - they can actually mount arguments without just instantly being obliterated from the discourse. This means that if you use the same lazy and poorly thought out attacks that get by just fine when the white nationalists have no ability to respond, you'll get destroyed when they can actually mount a defence at all. That's not to say that there aren't any white nationalists here, but I really don't think they're a majority at all.
Why doesn't the US or some other nuclear power Simply (tm) operate nuclear power plants at a profit on foreign soil on behalf of the local government?
Because it is impossible to operate a nuclear power plant at a profit anywhere. I can't find a single example of a nuclear power plant that's run at a profit without a galaxy of government subsidies - the EROEI is not high enough to do so (and no, France doesn't count). You'd have to clear that particular hurdle first, and so far nobody has managed it.
So, there's a difference between
What difference does it make? I never said I thought it was unjust - it transparently is, but that wasn't part of any argument I was making.
Can you grant that, even if it's motivated reasoning or driven by propaganda and disdain, many of your opponents really and truly believe that Trump committed insurrection?
Anybody who does actually believe that is mis/underinformed to such a degree that they don't have anything of consequence to say about the political situation involved. If someone says that Satan planted dinosaur bones in the Earth to test the faith of True Christians, I don't think it's worth listening to their opinions on the fossilisation process because I know that it is going to be garbage already. If someone genuinely believes that what Trump did falls into the category of insurrection, either they're just not thinking seriously or they're grossly misinformed - and their opinion isn't worth listening to either way.
But furthermore, the people who are actively prosecuting Trump (and who I was talking about) cannot really and truly believe that Trump committed insurrection, or they would not have acted in the way that they did (i.e. they would have prosecuted him immediately rather than timing the prosecution and important court dates specifically to interfere with his election campaign). There is a possible world where those people genuinely believed their claims, but that is observably not the world that we live in.
Are you saying these actions (which I disagree about, but that's not important at this step) amount to insurrection?
No, but I am saying that they are actually closer to insurrection than anything Trump did. At no point did Trump deceive a court in order to acquire a fraudulent warrant, for instance.
Is your claim that they planned to use these charges to stop him from taking office in 2016, and somehow maneuver that to themselves staying in office instead?
Their plan was to sink the Trump presidency. Ideally they would have been able to get Pence down too and the entire election nullified, but they didn't actually succeed. Instead, they settled for simply sabotaging his term through the Mueller investigation, which we now know was completely fraudulent from the beginning.
Also, just to be clear, I don't think that this amounts to insurrection. But it is far, far closer to insurrection than anything Trump did during his time in office.
Completely wrong.
It isn't Trump the person that is getting the ire of the security establishment/power elite, but the policies he is claiming to represent and desires to implement. It doesn't matter who the actual person is - any politician advocating for the positions he holds and that his base requires of any prospective leader will immediately end up in the exact same position with more spurious charges. Giving up on Trump sends the message that their concerns can be ignored and brushed over for the sake of petty excuses that don't matter at all for the left. Joe Biden and Hillary Clinton both have committed far more egregious crimes and problematic behaviors when compared to Trump, but nobody cares because they are fighting for the security establishment/power elite. Letting these facile concerns determine the candidate just means admitting that they will never, ever get their concerns addressed.
Are there past presidential candidates who arguably committed insurrection while officers of the state who you think should have been prosecuted in this way? Who are they, and what did they do?
Yes - Barack Obama and Joe Biden, who arranged for the surveillance of the President Elect and ginned up a fake scandal involving Russia in an attempt to take back the Presidency despite losing the election. There's a much clearer and easier case to be made for those two being directly involved than there is Trump with January 6.
That doesn't actually argue against the point I was making at all. Heroin and Fentanyl, based on whether or not people use them, are extremely popular and people make the choice to use them on a frequent basis despite the incredibly well known downsides of doing so. A heroin addict declaring that he really likes heroin and wants to do more heroin, and who votes solely to make sure the "don't do heroin" party doesn't get into power, is still going to get addicted and deal with the consequences of heroin.
Why not? What "serious consequences" do you have in mind, and what reason do our elites have to fear them (as opposed to, say, welcoming them as casus belli to crush the hated enemy tribe even harder).
This reaches the point of civil war and potential serious domestic terrorism events. I don't believe you're thinking seriously about the consequences of this if you think that the elites could simply crush them - US domestic infrastructure is utterly impossible to secure in this kind of threat environment and the red tribe at the very least has the ability to reduce the US to a blasted wasteland with no functioning economy at all. Even assuming the elites are as perfidious, powerful, competent and undivided as you claim, their choices are going to be between giving the hated enemy tribe a say in society, or just not having a society at all.
So what if people stop thinking our legal system is principled (assuming they haven't already)?
That section was essentially an attack on AshLael's position - you don't believe that and neither do I, so there's no point discussing it given that I believe we actually agree here.
Greece? Ukraine?
Your idea of a functioning democracy is Ukraine? You are not exactly making a good argument against the claim that functioning democracies don't do this, especially seeing as how Ukraine has actually suspended elections and isn't democratic in the slightest.
Because the alternative is being subjected to severe punishment for no possible gain?
This is going to happen to them anyway if they do nothing, and in fact has been happening for a while. They have a choice between severe punishment, or severe punishment with a chance at victory. Sure, it sucks, but it beats the alternative.
Except I think, based on my experience with my "republican base" family and friends, that is what most will do.
I can't actually argue against your own impression of your friends and family, but I think that the base in general will absolutely get more serious and violent if what is being described comes to pass. Maybe we just see different portions of the republican base?
This was one of the more common right-wing criticisms I used to see of all the Q-Anon nonsense — that, besides being an exercise in unbounded apophenia, it serves as a call to passivity, asserting that right-wing citizens need do nothing at all, because the "patriots" secretly at work behind-the-scenes will fix everything for them.
I agreed with those criticisms, though the bigger issue to me was that Q-Anon was obviously faked.
Others (like the people at Sarah Hoyt's blog comments)
Who?
I think that, for all their passion, very few of them will get violent. Sure, some will, but those that do will do so entirely in the form of "lone-wolf" terrorism, blind lashing-out so poorly targeted and sloppily executed as to make Breivik's assault on Utøya look good in comparison. They will accomplish nothing but giving our government even more excuses to crack down on the right and limit political expression further still.
While it isn't particularly pleasant to talk about, Breivik's assault actually achieved all the aims he was going for. He confessed later on that his manifesto was actually a fake - the reason it was full of plagiarised writing was because he specifically wanted to give the impression that he was inspired by a particular group of writers in order to get the media to attack them. He succeeded, and at the same time wiped out the most promising left wing politicians of the next generation. Breivik unironically achieved the goals he had for the attacks, so you'd probably want to pick a different example.
And just because we’re really beyond words meaning anything: how is this not “disrupting an official proceeding” -> and insurrection?
One of the reasons that I have been so insistent on all these legal attempts to prevent Trump from running is that they are setting precedents which will be astonishing weapons in the hands of a vengeful Trump presidency. What happens if they pull out all the dirty tricks and fail? The Colorado Supreme Court has now set the precedent that an official government body performing official duties can be charged in a trial that lacks basic legal protections (according to the dissent posted above). I don't think that was a good decision on their part for the extremely obvious reason that you've posted - they went and removed the barriers preventing a future Trump administration from charging them with those exact crimes!
I disagree - he's claiming that Trump's actions aren't actually real crimes and never rose to that level. I'm extremely certain that if you offered the deal to Trump, he'd be perfectly fine with a scenario where Biden, losing the election, makes a series of phone calls saying roughly the exact same things he did, and Carlson would be too. Even the actual charges against him are reliant on the idea that he knew he was lying, and I fail to see why the idea that Trump made a mistake is so outside the realms of possibility.
All of the “economic efficiency” is just going to go to the very wealthy,
This is the entire reason - the very wealthy are the ones inviting politicians to their parties, paying for legacy media to broadcast their opinions and convincing people to go into huge debt in order pay money to go to university and become enforcers of their ideology. But if you want to disagree with them that's really uncool and lame and potentially even bigoted - yeah sure you're signing your children and grandchildren up for immense misery and deprivation, but you wouldn't want to look like one of those dirty truckers, would you?
Immigration has always functioned like this in the modern world - a weapon used by the very wealthy against the rest of society in order to entrench their advantages at the cost of society's longer term stability, functioning and prosperity.
Yeah, like what the hell is a "pizza related map" and why would it be important that it is on a handkerchief? That was the biggest one for me - why would a handkerchief with a map on it be so important as to generate an email like the one it did? I also don't think it is children, but it is definitely something.
This one isn't some poorly disguised code for child sex slaves. It's literally a Chicago street hotdog guy flown to DC with his street stand.
I actually wasn't aware of this, the last time I checked there wasn't a good explanation. I just assumed it was drugs at the time, like most of the pizza-gate related emails.
The line from Trump's speech to the riot is that Trump's speech is a but-for cause of the riot. If Trump doesn't assemble the mob and tell them to go to the Capitol, they don't go to the Capitol. No mob, no riot.
There's direct video evidence of one of the people who enabled entrance into the Capitol talking about how they're going to have to go and break into the Capitol building the night before the actual riot. This same person actually skipped Trump's speech so they could help get people into the Capitol and start a riot - so you're just flat out wrong here. How can Trump's speech incite a riot when at least one of the people involved in that riot spoke loudly about their plans the night previously, and then missed the speech entirely so they could facilitate people getting into the Capitol building? This breaks the "but-for" already - if Trump just said "Welp, looks like I lost, everyone can go home" there's at least one rioter who would have already been in the process of breaking in!
This has all been obvious for some time, and people do need to come to grips with it instead of telling themselves "it can't happen, so it won't".
This has been far from obvious. Actually going ahead with the prosecution and sending Trump to prison, i.e. letting his entire voting base know that they aren't allowed to pick their representative and their votes are worthless, is not going to be a decision without serious consequences. Most people believed that they wouldn't go through with it not due to some opinion on the matter of the law, but the political and societal consequences that would ensue. My personal belief was that the whole point of these prosecutions was to hamper his campaigning efforts - and the dates they chose for the trial were as close to confirmation as I thought possible barring another wikileaks incident. I didn't think they would actually send him to prison simply because that would be so good for his re-election chances, but if they actually go ahead with it I'll be extremely surprised. To quote a joke made by another poster, maybe he could use the time in jail to write another memoir about his political struggles.
DC is an overwhelmingly democratic voting jurisdiction, but you would need to be cynical indeed to think there is no chance that even one Democrat juror would refuse to imprison a political opponent on obviously baseless charges
Have you read the news anytime in the past two decades? Are you high? I unironically cannot model the mind of someone who believes that a motivated prosecutor and judge couldn't round up twelve people willing to convict Donald Trump, a man who most members of the blob consider to be worse than Satan, on charges that don't quite hold muster. They were already willing to bend the law much further than allowing a lying democrat into a jury pool with the crossfire hurricane investigation and the bogus Carter Page warrant - they've already gone well beyond what you seem to believe is plausible, and that was in 2015! You have a comical level of faith in an institution that has already been demonstrated as helplessly corrupt - how can you possibly look at the prosecutions of SpaceX for failing to hire enough illegal immigrants for a job they're forbidden to work under law, or the soft-walking of Hunter Biden's countless, impeccably documented felonies, and think that the legal system in the US is actually functioning on legal principles?
You can believe that it's outrageous to deprive people of their democratic rights or you can believe that conspiring to deprive people of their democratic rights isn't a "real crime", but it's incoherent to claim both.
Yes, and there isn't actually a contradiction here - they don't believe that Trump was actually conspiring to deprive people of their democratic rights (rather that he was attempting to thwart a conspiracy to do so by others).
This is the logic of terrorism. Give us what we want or there will be blood.
I'm not going to deny that's one way of phrasing the message being sent. But a more accurate one would be that they believe the government and the democrats are defecting from the political and democratic order - that they're corruptly using their current authority in order to prevent the opposition from gaining power. Functioning democracies generally don't lock up and arrest the leaders of the opposition party! When the social contract that stipulates democracy and a peaceful transfer of power is torn up, why should they continue to bind themselves by rules that their opponents are clearly not respecting? They're saying "If you don't play by the rules, we won't play by the rules either." - which is not exactly the kind of terroristic threat that your interpretation implies.
he knows he is fanning the flames of their resentment and putting the thought of violence in their heads.
I don't think you've seen much recent conservative social media activity. Do you really think the Trump base needs Tucker Carlson to put the thought of violence in their heads? If the Biden administration announces that the Republican party doesn't get to contest the next presidential election, I don't think the republican base would just sit there and go "Aww shucks, guess that's what the law says! Nothing we can do." if it wasn't for Tucker Carlson whispering in their ears.
All, one presumes, so he can maintain his position in the GOP media ecosystem. What a worm.
I think that he is absolutely a true believer when he makes that claim, no matter his feelings towards Trump the man. I think Trump is flawed, albeit not as flawed as he's often painted to be, but even if I passionately hated the man I would still have no trouble believing that his incredibly passionate base would get extremely violent if they were told that they weren't allowed political representation anymore.
Eggs are currently $3.69 for 18 at my local target.
And? If you read the actual sentence that quote is from, he's talking about a hypothetical future that is at the very least set after the next election. He's talking about how if you "keep doing" what was done during the 2020 election, and mentions that same hypothetical individual believes that their vote was effectively worthless.
DEI is bad generally, but it's not even close to being decisive here.
Agreed, and if the US manufacturing sector had a lot of overhead/spare capacity, it'd be totally fine. I only bring it up because right now the USA's military manufacturing sector is in a hole that will require years of investment to bring back up to the level necessary. DEI is a luxury that the US really can't afford in the military right now.
If that's the way you're going then we'll have to agree to disagree.
Don't worry, I don't believe the CIA has a hand in everything - but if you can listen to the Nuland call and seriously think about what the rest of that communication would have contained and the implications of it, the idea that the US wasn't involved is just farcical. When you take a broader look and go back into the history of events in the region, the idea that this is just Russia deciding to try and reform the USSR just becomes a joke.
As an aside, please don't take a reasonable claim of mine and then inflate it into some bizarre conspiracy - it feels like arguing to win rather than trying to get closer to the truth. I'm not going to intimate that you think Putin is a hypercompetent megahitler who runs the entire world because he made the decision to send the troops in.
It's easier than that: whichever side has their troops on the land of the other side is the aggressor. The US was definitely the aggressor in Iraq + Afghanistan, and Russia is certainly the aggressor now.
There's a difference between a war of aggression and simply assigning blame and declaring one person the aggressor. If my nation shared a border with yours and elected a leader who promised to take over your nation, steal your resources and ethnically cleanse your people, would you consider your nation's strike against my slowly assembling Genocide Taskforce to be a war of aggression?
but not of a total lack of men to hold guns.
They do not have enough men to achieve victory barring some kind of eucatastrophe or black swan event, and these troop quality issues absolutely have an impact on the battlefield. Russia may be encountering issues, but to the best of my knowledge those issues aren't as severe as the ones facing Ukraine.
Escalating the conflict is strongly against Russia's interest up until both sides launch all their nukes at each other, which is just bad for everyone.
To bring those points back together, Ukraine's manpower issues mean that they would require NATO boots on the ground in significant numbers in order to stand a chance at winning. The moment NATO deploys in force, whoever loses presses the button and the world ends. I don't think NATO will deploy in force for several reasons (like needing to deal with the middle east and asia, loudly talking about how the support is coming to an end), but current western leaders are substantially more feckless and incompetent than I was hoping they'd be.
I'm not exactly certain, but I'm not in any hurry to actually do the experiment and find out. If it turns out I was wrong about nuclear winter after we put the theory to the test... well if we still have access to the Motte in our fallout shelters, I'll change my flair to reflect that I was totally wrong on the internet.
Because that’s not what marriage was until yesterday.
This is one of the reasons why I have trouble taking social conservatives seriously when they talk about protecting marriage by making sure gays can't get married - they lost the "protecting marriage" fight several decades ago and there's no meaningful reason to oppose gay marriage when you look at what marriage actually is now.
Personally my answer for them would be to create an explicitly opt-in secondary class of marriage that functioned like marriage did in the past. I don't know how long they'd be able to keep it up in the face of regular society, but I imagine it'd be popular enough with islamic immigrants that they'd be able to call any criticism of it racist.
Sure there's a spin-up time, but it's measured in years, not decades, assuming there's political will.
Agreed! I just don't think Ukraine has years left. The US is also going to have a bit more trouble now than it did in WW2 due to the rampant amounts of corruption in the MIC, as well as the DEI requirements currently being foisted on the military and their contractors - selecting for diversity over competence means you're going to have competence problems, and US contractors don't have a choice in the matter.
It's nonsense to think the West was the primary antagonist here,
Russia's borders haven't moved nearly as much as NATO's have. I personally believe the reports that NATO promised Russia not to expand to their borders, but I know a lot of people don't - so instead I'll just say that I view this conflict as starting during the Maidan protests, and the US was deeply involved with those, helping to "midwife" a new regime that was more compatible with their goals. Talking about this conflict as being a war of Russian aggression feels the exact same to me as talking about how the Iraq war was justified by Saddam's WMD program, or how the Vietnamese started the war with the (imaginary) Gulf of Tonkin incident.
Also, Minsk died in large part due to Russia not following it.
Please give me a source that doesn't just call people who aren't even communists "tankies" and uses stupid terms like "gasminsking". But none of that matters because we actually have a recording of Francois Hollande admitting in what he thought was a private conversation that the entire point was to let Ukraine arm up and prepare for war. If Russia wanted this war from the beginning, why wouldn't they simply attack then?
"There was the idea that it was Putin who had wanted to buy time, but it was us [France and Germany] who wanted to buy time to allow Ukraine to recover, to strengthen its resources."
"That's why we have to defend the Minsk negotiations, in which you [Poroshenko] played a very important role. It was precisely during these seven years that there were ways for Ukraine to strengthen itself, and this is where Putin was wrong: he underestimated the capacity of the Ukrainians and their resistance."
...
This is just availability bias.
Wrong. The severity of the factual stories that have come out of the current situation reach far beyond the level of anecdote. Regions failing to meet 10% of their recruiting targets and the heads of every single regional recruiting group being fired are simply not things that happen when the situation is perfectly fine. Reduced standards for recruits are another - that's not an anecdote, that's official policy that covers the entirety of the country. Conscripting women, which is another official policy and not simply a matter of anecdotes, is a gigantic, flashing neon sign that the situation is desperate. Look at Ukraine's demographics right now - do you think they would be throwing any fertile women into the meatgrinder if they had any choice in the matter at all? If you want to make the argument that they're just really stupid and incompetent rather than desperate, I don't think that changes the impact on their chances of success.
It could still win fairly handily if the West really geared up for a war economy and treated this like Russia was attacking the West broadly and that Ukrainian soldiers just happened to be in the way.
No, Ukraine doesn't win in that scenario. In that scenario the Ukraine is reduced to a series of radioactive craters and future biologists get to talk about the Holocene extinction event (assuming any humans survive the resulting nuclear winter). Ukraine doesn't win if this becomes an all out war of Russia vs the West - the entire world loses.
A negotiated settlement where Russia keeps most of what it currently occupies looks increasingly likely.
I think the most likely outcome of the conflict is that the breakaway republics get subsumed back into Russia, and Ukraine gets reduced to a basketcase rump state. They've taken on vast amounts of debt, are going to have huge economic problems due to the existing corruption, have already started undergoing a demographic crisis thanks to the war/emigration and have also had huge swathes of productive infrastructure destroyed by the conflict. Russia is no doubt going to saddle them with a puppet/caretaker regime that makes sure to throw in regular tribute payments to Russia to boot. They would have been better off suing for peace earlier and simply accepting that Russia gets to keep Crimea and the breakaway republics - but that's just not an option anymore.
You don't believe it matters if Jews are white,
Correct. I'm not a white nationalist and don't think that "white" is a strong enough basis for any kind of group identity. Whether or not individual jews qualify under that umbrella is just not a question I care about because I don't think that information is useful at all. But when I'm talking about politics at a broader level, jews absolutely fall under the category "white" as defined by the modern left and it isn't even a question.
you also believe that progressives inevitably - and correctly! - regard Zionism as a white nationalist project because only 35 - 50% of Israelis are nonwhite? (Note that Mizrahim are not the only non-white Jews in Israel.)
If a Christian nationalist group arose with 40 - 50% non-white membership, and which demonstrably opened its doors to non-whites and made Christianity, not whiteness, its overriding membership criterion, it would be odd to insist that it was a "white supremacist organization." You can use words that way, but I confess the reasoning looks very motivated to me.
I'm not trying to be glib or motivated here, I'm basing my opinion on what I see people on the left saying and doing. Are you familiar with the Proud Boys? They were a right wing political organisation that was explicitly christian, and they've been called a white supremacist group as well... despite being led by a black cuban and not having any racial requirements for prospective members. It isn't like they're the one exception or anything - here's Al Jazeera saying that Zionism is "white supremacy" and not jewish supremacy. https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2019/1/9/the-zionist-fallacy-of-jewish-supremacy Here's Newsweek talking about how orthodox-raised jew Jared Kushner's white supremacy "shines through" https://uscpr.org/jared-kushners-white-supremacy-shines-through-opinion/ (though Newsweek later edited the title to remove the term white supremacy, they didn't change the URL and the author kept the original title for his website).
I actually agree with you that this is a bad use of language, and political thinking is made less clear by simply terming everything "white nationalist", but that's the world we live in right now and that's the approach that the left has decided to take. If you want to go and tell the left that they're being a bit too free and flippant with accusations of racism and white supremacy, I think that's an admirable goal and you should definitely pursue it if you're rich enough that you never need to worry about working again.
In terms of ammo and military supplies, yes Russia seems to have the advantage... because the West doesn't see Ukraine as a sufficiently galvanizing issue to make serious commitments. I think we're basically in agreement here.
I don't think the West is actually capable of spinning up their weapons and arms manufacturing capacities in time for it to be relevant. Even if the political will appeared overnight, there's a big lead time which would prevent this from being relevant on any timescale that would help Ukraine before Russia wins.
I think the West, especially the US, could afford to lose most of Ukraine at relatively little cost.
The problem is not that the west would lose Ukraine - the problem is that this would demonstrate that it is possible to stand against the hegemon and succeed. The sanctions which failed to destroy the Russian economy have succeeded in convincing the rest of the world that de-dollarisation is a great idea, and that trend has picked up speed since the conflict went hot. I agree that the Ukraine is largely worthless to the West at large, but the symbolic value of the US being defeated by Russia in an actual armed conflict would be extremely significant.
On the other hand, Russia's (really, Putin's) decision to invade
This conflict was instigated by the west - I don't think Russia particularly wanted this war, but they weren't given a realistic choice. They're not going to agree to any peace negotiations now either, seeing as how it has since come out that the Minsk accords were explicitly made in bad faith (well, that and the fact that they're currently winning and have no incentive to stop).
I'd be surprised if Ukraine's casualties were greater than 175% of the estimates the US makes, for instance.
I will agree to this with a bit of hesitation - actual classified estimates that are meant for people on the inside would likely be more accurate, but anything released for public consumption deserves a more sceptical eye. I don't think the US is incapable of finding this out, but is motivated to paint an optimistic picture for the Ukrainians.
Ukraine's manpower anecdotes are indicative of problems specifically of its recruiting pipeline being corrupt and leaky.
There are far too many stories for this to be a matter of "anecdotes". Conscription efforts are failing to meet 10% of their goals, and when you have to amend your conscription rules to allow more disabled and mentally ill people into the army that's a sign of serious crisis. You don't fire the head of every single regional recruitment centre if you don't have serious, systemic problems that go beyond the level of "anecdotes". Furthermore, knowing that the pipeline is corrupt and leaky doesn't actually fix the problem - and I don't think they have the time and resources to spare in order to fix it right now.
I feel like you're doing a motte and bailey here of implying force quality issues (which are legitimate, and exacerbated by casualties) will become a decisive factor when Ukraine effectively runs out of men to hold the frontline (a goofy idea that won't happen).
That's an understandable reading of my position and I wasn't as clear as I should have been - mea culpa. To state my position more clearly, I think that Ukraine's current manpower issues are severe enough that there is no realistic path to victory for them moving forward. They have lost too many experienced soldiers and their current training efforts aren't capable of producing enough qualified soldiers in time to make a difference. Right now, they don't even have a realistic hope of obtaining any concessions from Russia - all they can do is slow down the Russian advance and hope for some kind of eucatastrophe.

I'm talking about the actual EROEI - this means including all of the energy required to build, staff and maintain the plant over its lifetime. Actually digging up the uranium and transporting it to the power plant might indeed be les than 1% of plant operating costs, but that doesn't mean you get to ignore the other 99% and leave them out from your calculations. A "couple of thousand tons of reinforced concrete" does actually require gigawatt years of power when you remember the complicated machinery that goes into nuclear reactors and the incredible importance of regular maintenance.
More options
Context Copy link