So if I understand you correctly, your motivation for this change is primarily that it would put women in their place?
and in fact mix genders in almost every activity now, even the Boy Scouts!
This isn't actually correct. Scouting troops can be mixed gender, in which case they are usually called 'Venture Troops' - and those have always existed. But the majority of troops are either all boys or all girls. As it should be!
When I was in scouts back in the day (probably around 9th grade) we had a few venture events, and they were deeply awkward. At one I remember we boys were playing football and this one tomboyish girl came up and asked to play with us. We couldn't say no, but it ruined all the fun. We couldn't tackle her properly or wrestle with her, even though she actually wanted to do all those things. I think the reason we couldn't is fairly obvious.
All this to say that actually, 'putting women in their place' should look like more segregation, more women only spaces, not more integration.
So if I understand you correctly, your motivation for this change is primarily that it would put women in their place?
This isn't actually correct. Scouting troops can be mixed gender, in which case they are usually called 'Venture Troops' - and those have always existed. But the majority of troops are either all boys or all girls. As it should be!
When I was in scouts back in the day (probably around 9th grade) we had a few venture events, and they were deeply awkward. At one I remember we boys were playing football and this one tomboyish girl came up and asked to play with us. We couldn't say no, but it ruined all the fun. We couldn't tackle her properly or wrestle with her, even though she actually wanted to do all those things. I think the reason we couldn't is fairly obvious.
All this to say that actually, 'putting women in their place' should look like more segregation, more women only spaces, not more integration.
More options
Context Copy link