@FtttG's banner p

FtttG

Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.

7 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 13 13:37:36 UTC

https://firsttoilthenthegrave.substack.com/


				

User ID: 1175

FtttG

Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.

7 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 13 13:37:36 UTC

					
				

				

				

					

User ID: 1175

I'm not sure if I understand the question. If you mean "has it ever been alleged that a murder was committed for the specific purpose of filming it for commercial release?", I believe the answer is no. My understanding is that every alleged "snuff film" turns out to fail one of the two criteria: either it isn't a real murder but just an unusually convincing special effects job; or it is a real murder, but it wasn't filmed specifically for commercial release (e.g. ISIS and cartel beheading videos are intended to be released but not sold; serial killers filming their kills but never intending to release them at all).

But if you're asking "has a murder ever been committed for the purpose of filming it?", I think essentially all ISIS or cartel beheading videos meet that description. Or at least filming the murder (in order to publicly release it and hopefully intimidate one's opponents) is a primary purpose, along with the immediate purpose of killing the person who currently finds himself on the business end of your machete. It wouldn't surprise me in the least if some of the people filmed being murdered by ISIS or a cartel did absolutely nothing to antagonise either group: the group just found themselves falling behind schedule in their content creation pipeline and the victim was in the wrong place at the wrong time.

I hate to say it, but the selection effects are nearing completion, and on most major culture war issues this place is effectively an echo chamber. Even our token woke progressive hasn't posted here in nearly five months (not that I found his contributions particularly interesting or productive, but their absence is the canary in the coalmine). Mod actions tend to be in response to people being inflammatory or antagonistic, and most people have little interest in antagonising or insulting someone they're largely in agreement with.

~80% of the way through The Goldfinch. Not as good as The Secret History, significantly better than The Little Friend. While earlier sections of the book were pacy and engaging, I'm now finding it a bit of a slog.

Sometimes footage of people being killed finds its way into commercial releases:

Brilliant. The Wilde one is so dead on.

Honestly, after the "basket of deplorables" comment, Hillary had no one but herself to blame for losing the election. Years and years of "Russiagate" cope, and that sentence in isolation probably decided it.

FWIW, I don't think Kamala is a "serious" politician (or person) either. The absurdity that she's the current sitting VP and presidential nominee - and her campaign up to this point has been primarily focused on how "brat" she is rather than any substantive policy position - honestly, it's rather sickening.

Counterpoints:

Love him or loathe him, the man is famous for hurling juvenile insults at his opponents and going off on weird random digressions about whatever crosses his mind. I think "unserious" is a perfectly valid adjective to describe such a man, regardless of what you think of his politics. You can describe him as such without questioning his bravery or the sincerity of his patriotism. "Serious" does not imply "speaking calmly": fire and passion have their place in politics. But I don't think it's too much to ask for a politician to be able to string a coherent sentence together.

Is this referring to Trump? He owned hotels, casinos, of which visitors could be called clients.

True, but "the only client he's ever had is himself" is an artful way of describing someone who is pathologically selfish and doesn't care about others. My understanding is that Trump has been involved in multiple fraudulent business ventures, which ties into this.

Thanks so much, this is really helpful.

I didn't like that movie at all.

What I think @Jiro is getting at is that companies often have itchy trigger fingers and mistake Xitter for real life, and erroneously believe that, because they've received 100 DMs in the last hour urging them to fire Alice, this is representative of a broader trend outside of Xitter and Alice has seriously embarrassed the company. When in fact most (if not all) of those DMs came from people who have never done business with the company (and never will, regardless of how they handle the Alice situation), and Alice's ability to perform her job would not have been impacted in the slightest.

Punishment being disproportionate is how people build moral systems that are effective in keeping people from breaking them all the time.

Whatever happened to "an eye for an eye"? Or to use Scott's preferred historical example:

Chen Sheng was an officer serving the Qin Dynasty, famous for their draconian punishments. He was supposed to lead his army to a rendezvous point, but he got delayed by heavy rains and it became clear he was going to arrive late. The way I always hear the story told is this:

Chen turns to his friend Wu Guang and asks “What’s the penalty for being late?”

“Death,” says Wu.

“And what’s the penalty for rebellion?”

“Death,” says Wu.

“Well then…” says Chen Sheng.

And thus began the famous Dazexiang Uprising, which caused thousands of deaths and helped usher in a period of instability and chaos that resulted in the fall of the Qin Dynasty three years later.

Amazing, thank you!

For a one-night stand/fwb, they might make the woman in question more appealing; for a romantic partner, maybe less so. I think the question is underdefined.

Best app for converting your phone to grayscale? Ideally I'd like the best Android one and the best iOS one.

I'll raise your pedantry: a woman has a bosom, women have bosoms.

I've heard it said that Atwood intended the original novel as a satire on Iran, as a sort of "imagine if this happened here" sort of scenario - an interpretation that the TV show largely ignores, as I understand it.

Congratulations!

Why does this happen every time someone posts an old.reddit link?

Anyway it was meant to bring you to this image: https://i.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/newsfeed/000/738/025/db0.jpg

With all the kerfuffle about Imane Khelif, I think we've lost sight of the real issue - how can one profit from this?

The other week I put €15.50 on Lin Yu-Ting to medal, and another €15.50 on Yu-Ting to win gold. I was also looking to place a bet on Khelif, but at the time all of the bookies I looked at didn't seem to be offering odds on them. I've now come back with a tidy profit of €13.50.

Part of me feels proud, given that this is the first formal bet I've ever placed in my life. Part of me feels a little dirty - "in a boxing championship, I bet that the (probably) male fighter will defeat all the female fighters" feels like the kind of bet you shouldn't even be allowed to make.

Why is it important that everyone knows that everyone knows that everyone knows that Stalin sucks?

Because without that, Alice, Bob and Carol are individually carrying out a risk calculus under the assumption that each of them is the only one who hates Stalin. If you hate Stalin and everybody else loves him, the expected payoff for publicly criticising him is that you are shipped off to the gulag. Thus everyone in the society is incentivised not to criticise Stalin, and he remains in power.

But when it becomes common knowledge, the payoff matrix changes: if I hate Stalin and I know that everybody else does too, the expected payoff for publicly criticising him is that it creates a chain reaction culminating in Stalin being forced out. Common knowledge that Stalin is widely despised is the only thing that can incentivise a self-interested agent in the system (an agent concerned with self-preservation) to act to change the system from within.

The scenario I'm describing above is a pretty quintessential Moloch trap. From outside the system, it's obvious that it's in Alice, Bob and Carol's best interest to rise up and overthrow Stalin. From within the system, none of them have any good reason to believe that attempting to overthrow Stalin would end in any other way than being immediately shipped off to the gulag or executed; hence, they all keep their heads down and the system endures.

The concept often comes up in the context of dictatorships, so that's the context I'll use to illustrate it.

Alice, Bob and Carol live in the Soviet Union during Stalin's regime. Alice hates Stalin and wishes him dead. But Alice has never read a column or editorial which was even mildly critical of Stalin (Stalin controls Pravda), and also knows that everyone who criticises Stalin in any capacity immediately vanishes to the gulag, never to be heard from again. For fear of this happening to her, Alice never criticises Stalin in front of Bob and Carol. Unbeknownst to Alice, Bob and Carol also hate Stalin, but have performed exactly the same risk calculus and decided never to publicly criticise Stalin. Hence conversations between Alice, Bob and Carol consist of three people loudly, conspicuously praising Stalin and successfully deceiving the others that they sincerely admire Stalin and think he's the bee's knees - but all three of them hate him and erroneously believe that they're the only one of the three to think so.

There's a sophomoric theory of how dictatorships come to an end: "people admired Stalin, but then a critical mass of people turned against him and the public rose up to overthrow him". The toy example above illustrates why this theory is wrong: a critical mass of people hating the dictator is necessary but not sufficient to effect an overthrow of the dictatorship. It's perfectly possible for a simple or supermajority of the population to hate the dictator, but for the dictator to remain in power if enough of the people who hate him erroneously believe that their opinion is a minority or fringe opinion. It's not enough for Alice, Bob etc. to hate Stalin: Alice must also know that Bob hates Stalin, and Bob likewise - Stalin must be widely despised, and it must be common knowledge that Stalin is widely despised.

Australians are so fucking cringe man. For people with such a funny accent they are remarkably humorless.