FtttG
Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.
User ID: 1175
We don't want to establish a precedent that other states can just ship people they don't want here without our prior consent.
Then why call yourself a sanctuary city?
Simply put, you don't need a signed statement from someone saying "I self-identify as a racist/homophobe" for that to be a reasonable judgment.
So why is my judgement (that many Democrats who claim to support mass immigration, open borders and sanctuary cities are insincere virtue-signallers who only support these policies when they don't affect them personally) unreasonable? Aren't their reactions to Abbott and DeSantis's bussing stunts entirely consistent with them being insincere virtue-signallers?
When large groups of people tell you they believe X for reason Y, you should generally believe them.
Is this a standard you apply across the board? You'll be hard-pressed to find a single person who's opposed to mass immigration (esp. illegal immigration) who admits that their opposition is based on hatred of foreigners - they always claim they're opposed to mass immigration because of the negative socioeconomic impact of mass immigration on their community.
Good luck finding:
- A Holocaust denier who admits that the only reason they think the Holocaust didn't happen is because they despise Jews as a group - they invariably claim that they approached the subject with an open mind and don't find the mainstream narrative convincing
- A person who's opposed to gay marriage and the decriminalisation of gay sex who admits that they're so opposed because they hate gay people or think homosexuality is evil - they will instead talk about the sanctity of marriage or how risky gay sex is relative to straight sex.
- An anti-abortion activist who admits that they don't care about unborn babies one iota and just want to control
women'sbirthgivers' bodies - they will instead insist that they do care about unborn babies and think aborting them is morally equivalent to murder.
I very much doubt you're applying your own stated standard across the board. You say we should "generally" believe people who say they believe X because of reason Y, which implies that there are exceptions, and I suspect that all of these exceptions are people with whom you disagree.
Fair. The difference being, once you actually read the essays from which "Moloch" and "toxoplasma" originate, the terms are easy to understand because Scott explains what they mean in plain simple language. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think Moldbug ever explained what he means by e.g. "the Cathedral" in plain, simple language, even though from my understanding it's a much less complex concept than "toxoplasma".
I think I understood you right the first time around, you think Australian cops are institutionally corrupt but don't know enough about the American situation to comment if it's the same there.
The word "all" is kind of interesting. Taken 100% literally, the slogan "all cops are bastards" means that literally every cop in the entire world is a bastard. But it could understandably be taken to mean "all cops [in this country] are bastards" or similar. I remember one instance seeing a person expressing some ACAB-esque sentiments on Facebook, and then having to hastily qualify that statement by assuring their friends that they were only referring to cops in the UK, not Ireland.
Moldbug's stuff is best read in chronological order.
This sounds suspiciously similar to "yeah dude season 1 is a bit of a drag but it gets soo good after that, it's worth it."
What is he writing for, then?
he strikes me as afflicted with Smart Person Syndrome. Because he's smart, he assumes everyone else is an idiot, especially anyone who disagrees with his viewpoints.
I think there's a problem that affects a lot of writers wherein they get so close to their ideas that they lose the distance and objectivity that would allow them to assess how these ideas would be met by someone encountering them fresh. "Because I understand it, it must be comprehensible to anyone of approximately my intelligence." But there's a world of difference between coming up with a smart idea and actually explaining it effectively, which is why you need beta readers to ensure that your ideas are coming off in the manner you intend. I'm sure if this was suggested to him, Moldbug would of course insist that he doesn't want his ideas to become diluted or "dumbed-down" by making them more accessible to the "lay person", but this defense smacks of insecurity to me. If you live in a democracy and you want to influence policy you have to meet the voters where they are, which means explaining your ideas in a way that makes sense to the biggest possible audience. Maybe Moldbug would claim he's not trying to influence a big audience, but rather a curated intelligentsia who are themselves powerful enough to influence public policy. Not to blow my (our) own trumpet, but this website is full of high-IQ autistic nerds with thousands of postgrad degrees between us who are not shy about giving controversial or even taboo topics/positions a fair hearing - if even we have trouble understanding what he's trying to say half the time, that suggests it's a deficiency with the writing style, not with the intelligence of the readers.
I've noticed a lot of so-called "thought leaders" (I hate that term but I don't have a better one) have the same issue. 10 words when 5 will do, most of which are only tangentially related to the subject at hand. It's a sort of anti-Twitter where an idea is expanded on way past the point of coherency.
Richard Hanania wrote a good article arguing that it's rarely worthwhile reading non-fiction books about ideas (e.g. Malcolm Gladwell, Steven Pinker, pop philosophy, pop psychology etc., as distinct from history books, biographies and so on). He argued that the core idea of such a book can usually be succinctly expressed in essay form (<10k words) with no loss of fidelity - but book publishers have no way to make money from essays, so they get the writer to pad out the essay with numerous examples of the phenomenon they're describing, personal anecdote, and filler passages to bring it up to book length. He gave the specific example of The Righteous Mind, a book which I enjoyed and agreed with the core premises of - but 400 pages, really? Scott has covered more ground than that book in a single blog post of a few thousand words.
Probably a lot of writers who get into the habit of doing this find that the habit starts to infect even their non-book writing, resulting in even the articles published on their own blogs becoming needlessly bloated.
I acknowledge that this comment itself may come off as an example of precisely the negative phenomenon I'm describing.
Obviously you believe that All Cops are Bastards. I'm not even arguing that that's not the case. I'm arguing that what /u/FirmWeird is describing explicitly contradicts the assertion that All Cops are Bastards. If the assertion "all cops are bastards" is only true in parts of the US (as they said), that logically implies that there are parts of the US in which that assertion isn't true i.e. NACAB.
A lot of what you describe might reduce the danger to the police from guilty suspects, while increasing the danger to innocent suspects.
I described in my comment one facet of American police training which is specifically designed to reduce the danger to innocent bystanders at the cost of increasing the danger to the person the police officer is targeting.
I think that ACAB actually does apply, at least in my case (and I'm sure there are parts of the US where this is true as well)
all
parts of
The assertions "All Cops Are Bastards" and "Some Cops Are Bastards" are vastly different. I don't think there's a man alive who would dispute the latter. The claim that all cops are bastards in parts of the US (i.e. certain jurisdictions) by definition implies that there are some cops who are not bastards (or some jurisdictions not staffed entirely by bastards).
I enjoyed that Bioleninism post.
digging back to the ancient year of 2009, Climategate
Am I the only one who finds Moldbug's writing style completely incomprehensible? He rambles on for paragraph after paragraph, smugly self-assured, and at the end of it I come away with literally no idea what he's trying to say. The only thing I'm confident of is that, whatever it is he believes (which is something I am wholly unable to glean from the actual content of what he's written), he thinks it's so self-evident that you'd have to be an utter cretin not to already believe it.
It's an experience not unlike reading TLP/Edward Teach, but at least in that case the incomprehensibility does seem to be deliberate (for whatever reason).
There is no such thing a shooting someone's legs. First of all, leg shots are often fatal anyway because of the femoral artery. But more importantly, if a situation justifies deadly force, it is imperative to maximize likelihood of neutralizing the threat. That means rapidly putting shots center-mass until the threat ceases.
This one in particular infuriates me. I've spoken to so many otherwise intelligent people who seem to think "why didn't they just shoot him in the arm/leg?" is actually an effective or useful suggestion. I've tried to explain to them, very patiently, why this is nonsense, but it never seems to sink in.
I'm sure most of the people reading this already agree with me, but I'm going to reiterate it anyway:
- When a person is running (e.g. towards the police officer whose gun they are hoping to wrestle away from them), their arms and legs are moving rapidly. If they are running directly towards the police officer, the centre of their torso is effectively stationary relative to the police officer, and growing larger the closer they get. It is vastly easier to hit a large stationary target than a small moving one, even if you are an exceptional marksman. Firing and missing the target vastly increases the likelihood of accidentally hitting an innocent bystander.
- Even if the officer succeeds in hitting one of the limbs, the arms and legs are very narrow relative to the torso, which makes it far more likely that the round will penetrate all the way through, potentially hitting an innocent bystander (or ricocheting and hitting an innocent bystander).
- A sufficiently high crackhead or tweaker will shrug off a bullet wound to the arm or leg. To decisively put them down, there's no option other than centre mass.
- As you point out, even if the officer deliberately aims for the legs, the thighs are far larger than the calves, making it disproportionately likely that the officer will nick the femoral artery, in which case the target will likely die of exsanguination at the scene anyway.
For all of the above reasons, American police officers are trained to aim for the torso rather than the limbs in the unfortunate event that they determine gunfire is necessary. You might disagree with the priorities of the training, but you can hardly blame the officer himself for reverting to his training in the heat of the moment.
After the infamous piss incident, someone on 4chan referred to the vocalist as "Urethra Franklin" which is all I can think of whenever I hear them.
their cover of Guerilla Radio slaps even more than the original
Disagree, even though RATM aren't a band I love, I still prefer the original.
Out of interest, have you had anything published professionally?
For the most part I disagree with the OP's post, but I do basically agree with the idea that describing someone as "criminal" is defamatory in a way that describing them as "evil" isn't.
On the other hand, this standard is probably applied inconsistently (hard to imagine a psychologist getting into trouble for describing Trump as a criminal, even if Trump had never been convicted of any crimes).
I also see a small spike around May 2020. I wonder did this coincide with the "protests are bad because they'll spread Covid (unless they're pro-BLM, in which case they're fine)" flip-flopping from public health officials?
I'm glad you enjoyed it. I would also strongly recommend Tulathimutte's first novel, Private Citizens (https://www.amazon.co.uk/Private-Citizens-Tony-Tulathimutte/dp/0062399101). It's consistently laugh-out-loud funny, piercingly perceptive and compulsively readable (I read the whole thing in 2 days).
Amusingly, it's the book Brits are most likely to claim to have read when they haven't.
A lot of people (apparently independently) made the Eastasia/Eurasia comparison, but I think I'm the only person in the thread to date to refer to a different Orwell term, "duckspeaker".
which is why the meme emerged then.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NPC_(meme) the term was first used in a political context in 2018, it predates Covid.
I hadn't really thought of it that way, but that's certainly one way of looking at it.
Brevity has never been my specialty, I'll admit.

I saw Past Lives on Friday and enjoyed it even more than I was expecting to. Gorgeous, sad, moving, funny. Pretty much perfect pacing, it moves confidently from beat to beat and doesn't outstay its welcome. The two leads have incredible chemistry and the dialogue feels so naturalistic and unforced (particularly surprising because I often find screenplays written by writers with a theatrical background tend to feature very stylised dialogue). Well worth seeing in the cinema if you're able. Of the films I've seen which were first released in 2023, definitely the best I've seen.
More options
Context Copy link