FtttG
Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.
User ID: 1175
Recently I listened to this song (which slaps): https://youtube.com/watch?v=wYsMjEeEg4g
Been around the world and found
That only stupid people are breeding
The cretins cloning and feeding
"Only stupid people are breeding" is one of those Redditor lines that you can only get away with if you make it very clear that you're referring to dumb MAGA hat-wearing, moonshine-drinking sister-fucking rednecks from Alabama. Any suggestion that the observation might be true, and apply just as much to, say, Pakistani immigrants to the UK practising cousin marriage for five consecutive generations, will get you slapped with "umm that's so racist and eugenicist".
A few years ago I finally got around to watching Falling Down, because I'd heard it was funny, disturbing and thought-provoking; and also because Michael Douglas always has a magnetic screen presence even in bad films (e.g. Basic Instinct and Wall St. Yes, the original Wall St., not the sequel with Shia LaBeouf. Fight me.).
Falling Down, huh. What a weird, insipid and unfunny movie. There's this spree killer who, after years of petty frustrations and disappointments, has snapped, gone postal and is plotting to murder his estranged wife, right? How do we get the audience to identify with him? Why, we'll just have him spout inane observational humour about the petty irritations of modern life in between vicious indiscriminate violence. "What's the deal with fast food chains, amirite guys?" This inane observational humour is never funny, never feels remotely in-character and essentially just feels like it's there to pad out the runtime, but - well, how else are we going to get the audience to sympathize with such an unpleasant character? What, explain his situation and motivations to such a degree that we can understand them even if we don't think his behaviour is justified? Bro, I'm a screenwriter, I'm not Cormac McCarthy.
The thriller parts aren't thrilling, the comedy parts aren't funny, the "satire" falls flat on its face, the plot and how it's depicted is so exaggerated, cartoonish and contrived that you could practically call it a preemptive adaptation of Grand Theft Auto V. Baffling how the filmmakers thought they were making some kind of profound statement about American society, masculinity, consumerism, whiteness etc. Even more baffling how so many critics apparently bought it.
For reference, West Indian blacks include people like Marcus Garvey, Stokely Carmichael, Malcolm X, Harry Belafonte, and Sidney Poitier.
Coleman Hughes makes this point about West Indian immigrants in the 60s and 70s, who presumably laboured under the same racism as their slave-descendant counterparts, but had vastly different social and economic outcomes.
There was a bit of kerfuffle in the CW thread about the radical wing of the environmentalist movement, epitomised by Extinction Rebellion and Just Stop Oil. I saw something related last night which some of you might find amusing.
Walking through the street I saw a poster for a charity rave, the proceeds of which go to Extinction Rebellion. Sort of amusing in its own right (especially given that the tickets for this rave are... free?), but when you take a closer look and notice the name of the headline act - well, the jokes write themselves, don't they?
For religious purposes, would a penectomy be considered functionally equivalent to a circumcision (albeit a horrifically botched one)?
/s
It's eerie seeing him be so humble and self-effacing. Typically he gives Moldbug a run for his money as far as smugness and dismissiveness go.
I adapted and expanded my reviews of Barbie and Oppenheimer (which I originally posted as comments here and here) as a blog post: https://firsttoilthenthegrave.substack.com/p/movie-review-barbenheimer
The kinds of people running cancellation campaigns do not see "flirting with Marxism" as a demerit.
don't put anything in writing that you wouldn't have read at your funeral.
I've never heard this before, but it's really good advice.
And now he barely mentions it again.
I don't think this is evidence of Trump "flip-flopping" so much as the fact that Omicron is objectively far less lethal than previous strains of Covid and that society seems to have largely moved on from Covid - bringing it up is yesterday's battle.
Fight me, idgaf
Granted that I haven't seen it since it came out, but I remember it being better than Oppenheimer. Still not a movie I'd call "good" without reservation though.
Well, the most sympathetic/moral character in the movie (Lucius Fox) demands that the surveillance apparatus be dismantled.
He demands that it be dismantled - after successfully using it for its intended purpose. In other words, "desperate times call for desperate measures", which is exactly how the USA PATRIOT Act was justified at the time of its implementation.
I don't believe Nolan is great, and Inception sucks.
How the fuck u make a movie about the invention of the atomic bomb and it has the most underwhelming depiction of an atomic explosion ever committed to film.
Nolan has zero confidence in his own dialogue and the performances of his actors, and uses music as a crutch. In a typical drama film, understated music is used sparingly to accentuate the emotions and actions onscreen. Most of the actors who appear in Oppenheimer express few if any emotions (even though all of them have shown an ability to do so in other, better films), so Nolan instead relies on a relentless bullying score to emphasise everything. If everything is emphasised, nothing is. There's a scene where Opp and the military brass are debating which cities to bomb (and one dude veto Kyoto, probably one of two times this movie made me laugh), and it occurred to me that it was the first time in the movie that Nolan had allowed the onscreen action to speak for itself for more than thirty seconds. This relentless musical score in service of admittedly stylish cinematography, disaffected performances and cliché dialogue produces an effect not unlike watching a really expensive music video that goes on for three hours.
And yet in spite of this obvious lack of confidence in his writing abilities, the screenplay is peppered with lines that sound like they're intended to be witty or clever. Maybe one or two them produced the intended effect in a trailer. In a movie of this length, no one in the cinema so much as chuckled.
The scene where Opp is speaking and imagines the people in front of him bursting into flames was cool (and then they spoiled it by using the same effects again at the end of Opp's appeal, in a context in which it made no sense). The sequence with Casey Affleck was great. The build-up to the Trinity test was genuinely exciting and gripping, but then the test actually happens and it's the most colossal cinematic cocktease of the year.
I think Nolan is autistic. He doesn't seem to understand or like people at all, a fatal flaw when directing an R-rated drama for grownups about a real people. The early sequences where it's Opp's character drama and strained familial relations drag. None of the characters seem like people - they're robots reciting words. Florence Pugh breaks up with Opp and it sounds like she's a little ticked off at him for forgetting to collect her dry cleaning for her. The pace of the film notably picks up when they get to Los Alamos, when the movie can get down and dirty into Boys' Own detonators and isotopes, then declines again after the war is over. For the last hour of the movie I got the distinct impression that nobody else in the cinema really cared what happened to Opp or Strauss. The strenuous efforts to maintain cinematic intensity during the end of Opp's appeal seemed, frankly, laughable. The pyrotechnics, quick cuts and omnipresent score might work for a sci-fi thriller or action film - they definitely do not work for what by now has become a legal drama. Nolan is ostensibly making a movie for grownups, but can't resist his natural instinct to try to get the attention of the teenagers making out in the back seats. Spielberg, by contrast, always knows what mode he's operating in and never gets them muddled.
Not as bad as Interstellar. Probably marginally worse than Dunkirk, which at least had the self-awareness to recognise that Nolan is hopeless at a) writing believable or punchy dialogue and b) getting the audience to care about his characters; and hence generally didn't really try to do either. Miles and miles from the still-wonderful Memento, which I'm increasingly confident will, years down the line, come to be seen as his only film really worth discussing.
I'm surprised to be saying this, but I'm Team Barbie 100% and it's not even close. Better screenplay, better performances, better production design, better cinematography, better makeup (seriously, that aged-up makeup in the appeal scenes, who do they think they're kidding?), at least some characters I can care about at least a little bit - and most importantly, it didn't outstay its welcome.
At least there was essentially no handheld camerawork. I was pleasantly surprised, given Nolan's reputation, to find the dialogue consistently intelligible, I think there were only one or two lines that slipped past me (and it wasn't because the music drowned them out).
Is this just horseshoe effect?
Hard disagree. The SAT is as close to a perfect blind measure of intelligence as we've got. Why is there such widespread opposition to its use in university admissions? Because a) SAT results are not evenly distributed across ethnic groups, which makes progressives uncomfortable and/or b) SAT results cannot be gamed. So on the one hand you have a system which uses IQ as a proxy for merit, and on the other hand you have people opposing that system specifically because it can't be gamed via affirmative action, legacy admissions etc.
arbitrary and changing benchmarks for "education"
Are the benchmarks for education really that arbitrary? Mathematical ability is widely prized in every nation which values education, and this has been true for as long as standardised education has been a thing.
I’m sure he believes it
I don't think he believes it consciously, in the sense of holding that belief in his head but deliberately claiming otherwise. I think deBoer is smart enough to realise where his beliefs lead, but refuses to fully think through all of their implications, and comes up with complex and convincing-seeming epicycles to avoid confronting the more straightforward and parsimonious explanation. Orwell called it "crimestop".
if the outcome are not equalized it is hard to argue that opportunities were equalized.
No, it's not hard at all. If the person with poor outcomes cannot present convincing evidence that their progress in life was impeded by artificial and unfair barriers (e.g. racial discrimination, classism, insufficient disability accommodations etc.), it's reasonable to conclude that they had comparable opportunities to people who had better outcomes but squandered these opportunities or were never capable of fully pursuing them (perhaps through no fault of their own). If two people do the exact same anonymised exam at the same time (and they went to the same school, had the same study aids etc.), and one of them fails, it's weird to say that this is a failure of "equality of opportunity" because the exam was too hard to be completed by person of X intelligence. The whole point of exams is to discriminate between those who can and those who can't, and not everyone can do everything. You seem to be saying that "equality of opportunity" means that everybody passes the exam (or perhaps that there are no statistically significant differences in the rates at which different groups pass the exam); I'm saying that being black, a woman, gay, disabled etc. doesn't prevent you from sitting the exam or giving you adequate opportunities to prepare for it - without any guarantee that you'll pass, or that group X will pass at the same rate as group Y.
The alternative to this is the Ibram X. Kendi god-of-the-gaps definition of racism, in which any unfavourable disparity between white and black outcomes is taken as ipso facto evidence of racism at some point in the causal chain, which requires swift and totalitarian public intervention to remedy. (Disparities between blacks and whites which favour blacks are taken as evidence of whites squandering their natural advantage in the hierarchy of a white supremacist society, and require no remedying whatsoever).
You are genetically one of the useless lumpenproletariat and equality of opportunity will do nothing for you or your kids.
Yes, and this is unfair, but no amount of social engineering will fix it. This is why I'm an advocate, not for equality of outcomes, but for equality of opportunity (as far as is practicable) complemented by a strong cradle-to-grave social safety net. The strong social safety net is only feasible because of the surplus wealth and resources generated by high performers afforded the opportunity to live up to their full potential, which is impossible in a socialist state which practises wealth expropriation.
To me it really is not that clear that a programmer developing one of the addictive gacha games shows more merit than literal criminal
The word "merit" can be used in conflicting ways. In the word "meritocracy" it's being used more or less synonymously with "talent". The programmer in your example has a talent which is rare and valuable enough that employers will pay a premium for it. You seem to be using the word "merit" more or less synonymously with "virtue". I would agree that a programmer designing an addictive Skinner box game is not using his talent virtuously, but it's important to bear in mind that most talents are strictly virtue-neutral. The same talent that allows one programmer to design a super addictive Skinner box game could equally allow him to design medical software which would vastly improve numerous patients' quality of life.
We can debate until the cows come home whether an individual drug dealer is making society worse than the guy who designed an addictive video game. What's not open for debate is that the drug dealer has no special talent - just about anyone within reason can be a low-level drug dealer.
If your objection to meritocracy is that some talented people will use their talents for unethical ends - well, yeah. I was about to say that it's a problem inherent in free markets, the solution to which is governmental regulation - but really, I think it's a problem inherent in the human species, and it won't just disappear in a socialist state with nominal equality of outcomes.
some unemployed person who uses his money to do graffiti has less merit than somebody who has ability to worm herself into liberal arts academia financed by government dole.
Hard agree. It disgusts me that someone can get paid a government stipend by passing off their paedophiliac masturbation habits as "auto-ethnographic research", and I think academic reform is long overdue.
Equality of outcomes is really the only way to measure equality of opportunity
Because if the outcome will not improve, you will end up being the guy telling people that they had plenty of opportunity that they squandered
The fact that it hurts people's feelings to tell them that they squandered their opportunities to make something of themselves doesn't mean that they didn't squander said opportunities.
Admittedly there's a bit of equivocation betweeen societal opportunities and biological opportunities. No amount of social engineering will ever give a 90 IQ person the same opportunities as a 110 IQ person. But at a societal level, proponents of "equality of opportunity" are generally advocating that society should place no artificial barriers to pursuing opportunities: your race, sex, sexuality, religion etc. should not stand in the way of personal fulfilment. But even if we abolish all of those barriers, you're still left with the uncomfortable fact (qua deBoer) that some people are naturally smarter, taller, faster, stronger, more charismatic etc. than others and will inevitably have better outcomes as a result, and there's precious little that social engineering alone can do about that.
Perhaps you think that actually we're all born as blank slates and g is a pseudoscientific myth and perfectly equal outcomes are entirely achievable without radical wealth redistribution. If that's the case, I don't really know what to tell you.
Agreed. Freddie is usually a very clearsighted writer, which makes the blindspots where he refuses to follow arguments to their obvious conclusions (HBD, the trans debate) all the more glaring.
It looks like he's beginning to believe HBD but is trying to retroactively justify his earlier highly egalitarian beliefs anyway
Freddie's an odd one in that he's an absolute believer that IQ is mostly genetic and that believing this doesn't remotely imply any other beliefs about the dignity and worth of a low-IQ person - and yet, he is rabidly opposed to any suggestion that there might be IQ differences between ethnic groups, and thinks that believing there are to be an irretrievably racist stance. If you're having a hard time understanding how someone could hold both beliefs in their head at the same time — well, join the club with me and Scott, who describes how Freddie used to send him angry (and completely private) emails attacking Scott for his apparent endorsement of HBD.
I think he would see it as a terminal value. Frankly, I agree. The idea that some people are born into a society in which they are permanently denied even the most basic living standards because they had the poor fortune to be born stupid in a knowledge economy is unconscionable to me.

Uh-huh. Bonus points for the top comment making the exact same GTA comparison I did.
Even Die Hard felt more grounded and believable than this. McClane is a bloody battered wreck by the end of his ordeal, while D-FENS hasn't a scratch on him until he actually gets brought down. And McClane is a cop who deals with hardened criminals every day, while D-FENS is an office drone who's never seen combat, and yet effortlessly mows down Compton gangbangers without a second's hesitation. Whatever Falling Down is, it's not "realistic". I don't even think it was really trying to be.
No I haven't. Does it have a similar plot?
More options
Context Copy link