@FtttG's banner p

FtttG

Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.

7 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 13 13:37:36 UTC

https://firsttoilthenthegrave.substack.com/


				

User ID: 1175

FtttG

Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.

7 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 13 13:37:36 UTC

					
				

				

				

					

User ID: 1175

The fact that they did, in fact, eventually assassinate him.

Whatever the underlying reason for it, I think if you want to argue that Country X is more dangerous than Country Y (because of the different policies/demographic makeup/policing approach in the two countries) - your argument falls at the first hurdle if Country Y is actually more dangerous than Country X.

Would Ireland have a lower murder rate if we allowed in fewer immigrants from certain countries? Almost certainly yes. Doesn't change the fact that Ireland's current murder rate with its current population constitution has a lower murder rate than Romania.

I think it's reasonable to conclude that the CIA (despite their best efforts!) never succeeded in securing a huge, unanswerable competitive advantage over their enemies using remote viewing. (One presumes if they had a functioning remote viewing unit in the 1970 or 80s, it would have taken them less than ten years after 9/11 to track down bin Laden.) The fact that they spent a fortune on something that didn't work proves nothing. Thus, Randall's thesis holds.

Well then I'm sure you will have a very different take on this article than I did.

But that's not XKCD's central thesis. I think Randall would be the first to point out that the public sector routinely wastes fortunes on useless extravagances or projects which were doomed to failure from the outset, whereas private sector companies that devote too large a share of their budget to such projects eventually go bankrupt.

The claim is not "no companies are investigating this to see if it works, therefore it mustn't be real"; the claim is "if it was real, at least one company would have found a way to make money out of it". Even if you expand it to include public sector bodies, Randall's argument still holds: it's not "no companies (or public sector bodies) are investigating this to see if it works, therefore it mustn't be real"; the claim is "if it was real, at least one company (or public sector body) would have found a way to make use out of it, either by making money or by securing a competitive advantage".

I would say that past a certain scale even referring to such things as conspiracies is losing an essential component of the definition of the word.

This seems functionally identical to "dog-whistle politics" and/or "stochastic terrorism". As with those concepts, I could certainly see how something like this could be true, but in practice it only ever seems to get trotted out as a stick with which to beat one's enemies.

In any sufficiently large political faction, you'll have leaders who make impassioned speeches about the importance of accomplishing their goals, and subordinates who take this to heart and end up bending or breaking the rules in an effort to accomplish those goals. If caught, the leader will inevitably claim that he never explicitly instructed anyone to bend or break the rules. Should we believe him?

I predict that if we agree with the leader's goals, then the movement is only guilty of having a few overly literal-minded bad apples who have been swiftly dealt with; if we disagree, then the movement is really a "distributed conspiracy" in which the leaders use "dog-whistle politics" to escape culpability for "stochastic terrorism".

I am sceptical of the utility of any political term so susceptible to Russell conjugations.

Doesn't sound significantly more ridiculous to me than "eating lots of carrots enables you to spot fighter jets from miles away, at night".

This article doesn't even credit the CIA's remote viewing unit for accomplishing this. It says the CIA consulted a psychic, which to me sounds like the CIA paid someone who wasn't a staff member.

Do you have a source for the remote viewing program?

Isn't the more parsimonious explanation that the CIA discovered the new Soviet submarine, the location of the general etc by other means, and attributed them to their remote viewing unit as a cover story? (See also the British Department of War covering up the existence of radar, using the cover story that British anti-aircraft gunners were able to spot Luftwaffe planes because they had exceptional eyesight as a result of eating lots of carrots.)

It would be unreasonable to expect anyone to predict a spike of that magnitude, yes.

It's not unreasonable to expect that the Republican share of the Hispanic vote would be broadly commensurate with recent historical trends. The impression I get is that there are a lot of Democrats (perhaps not senior DNC figures, but certainly pundits and ordinary voters) who still can't quite believe how popular Trump is among Hispanics, respond to all the evidence in support of this trend by sticking their fingers in their ears, take the Latin vote for granted, then get continually caught out when a larger and larger share of Hispanics vote Republican each campaign. Every four years, the same chorus of shock and horror: "how could you have voted for him?! Don't you realise he wants to sic ICE on you?!"

It was reasonable for certain Democrats to go into the 2024 presidential election anticipating that 68-64% of Hispanic voters would vote for them, then get blindsided by only 54% of them doing so. A jump of that size is hard to predict.

It was not reasonable for other Democrats to go into the 2024 presidential election expecting only a single-digit percentage of Hispanics to vote for Trump, then get blindsided when nearly half of them did. The idea that only a single-digit percentage of Hispanics would vote for Trump was wishful thinking, wholly unsupported by polling data or voting trends from recent elections. Anyone who believed this ought to have known better.

It is understood he is an Irish citizen who had lived here for many years but was not born in Ireland.

This is actually even more misleading than it sounds when you know the local context. Many Irish people emigrate to the US, the UK or Australia in their twenties, have children, then move back to Ireland a few years later. Given the size of the Irish diaspora, there are tens of thousands of Irish people meeting that description, and offhand I personally know at least five people meeting that description exactly (including several cousins and nieces and nephews).

The central example of "an Irish citizen who lives here for many years but was not born in Ireland" is an Irish man who was born to Irish parents (ergo entitled to Irish citizenship from birth) in Boston or Melbourne, who then moved home in time for their son to attend primary school; as opposed to an Algerian man born in Algeria to Algerian parents who subsequently moved to Ireland and applied for Irish citizenship. Utterly shameless.

Did they (or the Soviets) accomplish anything of note using said unit?

Thank you! Still the most popular thing I've ever written lol

I'm not sure if I understand the point you're making.

That's a fair point. I still think Waterford Whispers News was being hypocritical though, given that they are perfectly happy to pay attention to random named scumbags when those scumbags are white Irishmen:

Searching "Ashling Murphy", "Jozef Puska", "Aidan Moffitt" or "Michael Snee" in their website returns zero results. There's an article about the riots in Dublin last November, which does mention the crime which precipitated the riots but doesn't specify the perpetrator's name or ethnicity.

My personal favorite implication which Randall almost certainly didn't intend (and I wouldn't be surprised if this is one of those @FtttG has in mind) is that his logic disproves the gender pay gap (as stated by feminists anyways).

Very close. What I was actually thinking was that it disproves a particular variety of the "female underrepresentation in STEM" claim. If women are just as interested in pursuing careers in STEM as men, but are systematically turned away from jobs in those fields because of a culture of entrenched sexism, then those companies are leaving money on the table by refusing to avail of great talent. Any company which made a point of hiring female coders would make a killing by hiring all the talent that their competitors are turning away for stupid reasons.

Suffice to say, I don't think there is any persuasive evidence that there are millions of talented female CS grads who can't find work as coders or similar because the hiring managers in STEM companies walked in off the set of Mad Men (a particularly implausible claim given the gender breakdown of human resource managers). To my knowledge, tech companies are champing at the bit to hire female talent, if only as project managers, product owners etc.. Female underrepresentation in STEM could still hypothetically be caused by other kinds of institutional sexism (e.g. women applying for CS programs but being turned away by sexist course coordinators, women being passed over for career advancement because tech is an old boys' club etc.), but the claim that female underrepresentation in STEM is caused by sexism at the hiring stage essentially requires us to believe that STEM companies collectively are more committed to misogyny than they are to making money. Which I find rather incredible.

Wouldn't the counter-argument be that, prior to the invention of liberalism, Europe was constantly tearing itself apart in holy wars? I doubt many of the people whose lives were constantly being disrupted as a result felt terribly dignified about the whole matter.

I'm not saying that "I'd rather be dead than compromise my integrity and dignity" is an incoherent or obviously ridiculous statement - there really are certain principles I hold which I would rather die than violate, or certain experiences which I find the idea of going through so humiliating that I would rather die than experience them. But I would like to be reassured that whatever you're proposing as an alternative to liberalism wouldn't immediately lead to hundreds of years of civil war and the immediate cessation of all meaningful human progress and economic development.

Fair enough.

Yeah, 100%. I previously noted with some morbid fascination that the Southport stabbing played out almost exactly the same way as the Dublin stabbing eight months earlier: a mentally unstable man of African descent stabbed one or more underage native girls, the news media were enormously cagey about the identity of the assailant, and riots ensued.

So would you say the Catholic Church was a historical example of a distributed conspiracy?

Who's Freddie btw?

Freddie deBoer.

Thanks for the article though, I had no clue who mary was.

As I said it's not her best work. I wanted to share some of her better articles, but reviewing her Substack it seems she's paywalled some of her articles which were once visible to free subscribers. Annoying.

Here's a weird and kind of dumb article about the stunt that I didn't like very much. Every writer has their blind spots, the topics where their ordinary rigour fails them and they fall victim to the motivated reasoning and logical fallacies they're so careful to avoid on other occasions. Scott's are trans stuff, any and all criticisms of EA, any and all criticisms of polyamory, and anything feminist-coded (and he's only fessed up to the latter); Freddie's are trans stuff and HBD. Mary's is porn and the sex industry. If a factual claim casts the porn industry and/or sex industry in a negative light, she'll believe it, regardless of how implausible it is or how incongruent it is with the other factual claims she's endorsed which are critical of the porn or sex industries.

Here she goes on a bit of a ramble, looking for some way that she can make out that Philips is the victim here, suggesting a bunch of hypotheses in which Philips might be the victim (if you squint) without really committing to any of them, consistently putting the word "consent" in scare quotes. Philips fell victim to audience capture against her will! Philips was possessed by the digital egregore! Philips was slutty before she started her OnlyFans - hey, did you know that a lot of women who are slutty are trauma victims?? isn't that interesting??

Weak stuff all round, far from her best work.

I think this is exactly the thought process underlining all of these apologetics, very well articulated.