FtttG
Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.
User ID: 1175
Dowsing works?
Of course, but even in the sixties the Democrats were radically more economically and socially progressive than the Republicans. During the campaign, Republicans accused JFK of being a closeted socialist on the back of his healthcare policy proposals, and JFK appealed to black voters by publicly showing his support for Martin Luther King. If the argument is that "white Americans as a group can always be presumed to vote for the more socially and/or economically conservative of the two candidates", that invites the question of how JFK was elected in the first place, given the demographics of the 1960s.
I think by the point at which a conspiracy is "distributed" it can no longer meaningfully called a conspiracy, and is just an ordinary political coalition. The concept of a "distributed conspiracy" just seems to be (neo-)reactionaries attempting to tar a political coalition they don't like by describing it using a scary word. No different, really, from woke people calling everyone they don't like a fascist.
Fair enough, I'll amend to Chinese robbering.
And now he's deleted his Gish gallop/Chinese robbering anyway, along with all of his recent comments. "Don't mind me", indeed.
Yeah, it's an interesting question. My impression is that Republican opposition to immigration has been fairly constant for the last ~thirty years, but I could be wrong.
This seems like a weird heuristic which no one ever applies in any other context. If a company is accused of fraud once, well, that happens; twice, well, accidents happen. But I strongly suspect that you would avoid doing business with a successful company currently facing five or more independent concurrent investigations/lawsuits for fraud. Sooner or later you have to start wondering if there's fire in addition to smoke.
It's also plainly untrue that every sufficiently famous person will eventually face an unfounded accusation of sexual misconduct. There are celebrities who've been in the public eye for decades without once being accused of misbehaving.
If he asserts that Romania is safer than Ireland, I provide evidence to show that Romania in fact has a higher murder rate than Ireland - how does a breakdown of violent crime by ethnicity prove me wrong? I don't dispute that a disproportionate share of violent crime in Europe is committed by recent migrants from outside of Europe. That doesn't change the fact that Romania's murder rate is higher than Ireland's.
You cannot expect to win against people who want your life destroyed, scott was hounded by the NYT, that reporter is still doing whatever he did and a bulk of the people who cancelled NYT subs happily agree to go on their podcasts and talk to their journalists.
This is the problem with stipulative framings and sorting people into arbitrary buckets to suit the rhetorical needs of the moment. No one here disputes that the Grey Lady was wrong to attempt to dox Scott. What on earth does that have to do with how Irish journalists who've lived in Ireland their entire lives cover migrant crime? What does that have to do with how an Irish satire website cracks jokes about Conor McGregor? "Because an American newspaper tried to destroy a blogger I greatly admire, I must show no mercy and give no quarter to Irish journalists who've never worked at said newspaper and have never heard of said blogger" sounds functionally indistinguishable from "I must murder prostitutes because my dog told me to".
You have no evidence that the Irish journalists under discussion are utterly lacking in moral principles, or that they couldn't be shown the error of their ways and gently be persuaded to properly live up to the moral principles they do in fact possess. Not a single one of the examples you cited were from Ireland; two of them weren't even from Europe. Your entire argument rests on the transitive property of "these journalists have demonstrated that they are part of my enemy's team; members of my enemy's team have been known to do bad things and disregard their stated principles; ergo, these specific journalists have no principles and want to destroy me, so I must destroy them preemptively". Compare "@mrvanillasky is Indian; India has a higher rate of sexual assault than many other nations; ergo @mrvanillasky is a rapist, no further evidence required". Obviously you wouldn't like someone drawing that inference about you, so try to extend the same courtesy to members of your out-group.
Your selective use of the murder rate
You're performing a Gish gallop Chinese robber fallacy by citing a dozen emotionally loaded stories of violent crimes committed in Europe by people who aren't European (conveniently ignoring all the violent crimes committed by Europeans) - and you're accusing me of "selectively" using the dispassionate, objective metric of the murder rate to make my case that Romania is in fact significantly more dangerous (and Ireland significantly safer) than you're claiming? Physician, heal thyself.
I don't dispute that migrants to Europe are overrepresented in crime stats. I don't even dispute that immigration policy into Europe may have been too lax in recent years and may be need to be restricted somewhat. But I am not persuaded that Ireland or any other western European country ought to be an ethnostate. Hell, this entire discussion was prompted by me complaining that Anglophone news outlets cover migrant crime in a dishonest and knowingly misleading way. Why are you so mad at me, of all people?
If Ireland maintains its current immigration levels and the birth rate doesn't increase, the indigenous population will be effectively extinct before the end of the century and in its place will be some amorphous Brazilian blob. I gather you don't care about racial identity, but there are plenty of people who do and don't want to see Western Europe die.
Correct, I don't really care that much about racial identity. Pointing out that other people care about it does nothing to persuade me. Persuade me why I should care.
Conor got accused in the past in Miami too
Doesn't the fact that McGregor has been accused of sexual misconduct by so many different women, completely independently, in different countries or even continents move the needle for you at all? Isn't this exactly why people are so confident that Bill Clinton is a sexual predator, despite (to the best of my knowledge) never having been found guilty even in a civil proceeding?
hypocrisy is not a bad thing
You've lost me there buddy. If at any point you find yourself thinking "my enemies are so vicious that I must preemptively become more vicious than them before they destroy me outright", I think it's worth taking a step back and asking yourself if that's an accurate appraisal of the state of affairs, or if you're just coming up with some half-baked ham-handed rationalisation to do something you know is bad but want to do anyway. Note that your reasoning is word for word the same as that employed by woke people to justify deplatforming, cancelling or beating up conservatives.
Moldbug has echoed similar sentiments and I stand by them
I have never understood the appeal of Moldbug or why he's considered such an intellectual giant. So many of his allegedly profound insights just seem like trite (or even tautological) truisms dressed up with needlessly circomlocutory or obfuscatory language. I think Scott hit the nail on the head with Moldbug's whole approach in 2013:
Reactionaries have to walk a fine line. They can’t just say “people consider liberal policies, decide they would be helpful, and form grassroots movements pushing for the policies they support”, because that would make leftist policies sound like reasonable ideas pursued by decent people for normal human motives.
But they can’t just say “There’s a giant conspiracy where the heads of all the major Ivy League universities meet at midnight under the full moon”, because that would sound ridiculous and tinfoilish.
So they invent this strange creature, the distributed conspiracy. It’s not just people being convinced of something and then supporting it, it’s them conspiring to do so. Not the sort of conspiring where they talk to one another about it or coordinate. But still a conspiracy!
Fair enough. Per this list:
| Country | Crime Index (Numbeo) per 100k | Overall Criminality Score (GOCI) | Safety Index (Numbeo) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Romania | 32.8 | 4.58 | 67.2 |
| Ireland | 46.1 | 5.08 | 53.9 |
| UK | 46.9 | 5.75 | 53.1 |
| Hungary | 33.8 | 4.62 | 66.2 |
| Germany | 38 | 5.33 | 62 |
It really does not seem to me like the differences are as stark as is being implied. Germany has slightly more crime than eastern Europe, and Ireland and the UK have slightly more crime than Germany (although even then Ireland ends up with a lower GOCI score than Germany, where lower GOCI is better). It looks like a trade-off, where in exchange for significant economic growth you get a marginal bump in crime rate. None of the cities under discussion are Detroit or Baltimore (or even, to the best of my knowledge and perhaps more relevant to the discussion, Malmö).
I understand where you're coming from and I don't think you expressed yourself rudely, but this entire comment seems very "boo outgroup" to me. "It's pointless pointing out that your enemies are violating their own principles because they have no principles: the only appropriate response to their lies and deceit is to destroy them and ground them into dust" - I mean, it's fair to say this doesn't pass the intellectual Turing test, now does it?
Of course I'll never persuade the person who wrote that Waterford Whispers post about McGregor that they're being hypocritical, but I think there are people on the margin who could be persuaded that the way the news media covers crime is a bit dishonest and demand them to change accordingly.
On the topic of Conor, this was a civil proceeding, not a criminal proceeding where a girl retroactively took back her consent. I am not sure if we can even call him a rapist legally since he did not serve time in jail
Legally McGregor cannot be called a rapist, having never been found guilty of rape in a criminal trial. But while the burden of proof may be lower in a civil proceeding than in a criminal trial, it's not nothing. OJ Simpson was found not guilty of murder in a criminal trial, found guilty of murder in a civil proceeding, and now no one feels bad about calling him a murderer, even if news media avoided doing so during his lifetime to avoid getting sued for defamation. I'm applying the same standard to McGregor, who I think is exceptionally unlikely to sue me for defamation or to firebomb my house.
I have been to Romania and other parts of Eastern Europe. I feel markedly more safe there than major cities in Western Europe. Perhaps Dublin is also still safe, I've never been, but its trajectory is tracking towards Berlin and Birmingham rather than Bucharest and Budapest.
Might I humbly suggest that your subjective feeling of "safety" might be belied by the facts on the ground? Romania's murder rate (1.109/100k) is nearly double Ireland's (0.654/100k), and Hungary's murder rate (0.774/100k) is likewise slightly higher than Ireland's. Germany's (0.823/100k) is likewise lower than Romania's. The only part of your claim that really stacks up is that the UK has a higher murder rate (1.148/100k) than Romania. "Dublin's trajectory is tracking towards Berlin and Birmingham rather than Bucharest and Budapest" - any of these four would represent an upward trajectory from Ireland's current murder rate.
Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intentional_homicide_rate
On the other hand, Bucharest specifically was ranked quite far ahead of Dublin in a list of safest cities in the world, so I take your point. (On the other other hand, Munich was ranked ahead of Bucharest on the same list; and anyway this list is based on user surveys rather than criminological data, a methodology they defend here.) But I strongly suspect that the primary driving factor for how safe a city is is its demographics, and I think it's fair to say that those are primarily controlled at a national rather than local level. If X% of Ireland's population is Roma/Syrian/Algerian etc., there's only so much Dublin city council can do to stop them from living in Dublin (and likewise if a Roma family wants to move from the Romanian countryside to Bucharest).
Much of the opposition to inward migration to Ireland and the UK is based on negative (but, in my view, accurate) stereotypes about Roma people (e.g. Jozef Puska is from a Roma background). In which case, Romania is a spectacularly bad example to use to illustrate your point: Roma people make up about 0.3% of the population of Ireland, but 3.4% of the population of Romania. And they are likewise massively overrepresented in crime, making up 17% of Romania's prison population.
"You Irish should stop letting in so many Roma people and become more like Romania" - like, what? Those two things are mutually exclusive. Where do you think the word "Roma" came from?
It's not remarkable that the man who intervened was Brazilian. The average reader, upon hearing that the man who intervened was a Deliveroo driver, would probably have immediately inferred as much.
I personally thought it was suspicious that they were so keen to emphasise that the man who intervened was Brazilian while being so tight-lipped about the ethnic background of the assailant.
Ireland's national TV and radio broadcaster RTÉ aspires to be Ireland's BBC, with much of the same left-leaning stance. There is no direct equivalent of GB News (in the sense of an explicitly conservative TV station) in Ireland.
The print media follow a similar breakdown as in the UK: the tabloids are just as populist as their British equivalents (in many cases they're literally the same paper e.g. the Irish Daily Mail, the Irish Sun). The two main broadsheets, the Irish Times and the Irish Independent, are broadly similar in editorial direction and tone to the Guardian or Independent in the UK, with the NYT trick of having a roster of token conservative columnists to maintain a pretence of balance (e.g. Breda O'Brien has a weekly column in the Irish Times). The Irish Examiner is probably the most conservative broadsheet in the country, although it's arguably more of a regional paper than a national one. The Business Post is probably the closest equivalent to the Financial Times. The Journal, while being online-only, is probably the closest equivalent to the Guardian or the Observer.
I'm confused. "Demographics is destiny" - that literal phrase, not some euphemistic rephrasing - was never a talking point for Democrats. They have always maintained it's racist.
This is exactly the opposite of my experience of how the phrase is used. Consider the opening paragraph of this Time article:
It’s become something of a cliché in Washington for Democratic strategists to assert that “demographics are destiny.” What they mean is that the diversifying electorate—and the shrinking role of white voters—will render Republicans incapable of sustaining power for much longer. After Barack Obama won in 2008, Democratic legend James Caville even wrote a book predicting as much; 40 More Years: How Democrats Will Rule the Next Generation remains a fantastic, if flawed, reading of America’s trajectory.
To your next point:
Of course, the phrase is correct: if America had the demographics of 1960, the Republicans would always win.
Then how come a Democrat won the presidency in 1960?
I don't think liberalism is interchangeable with hedonism. My one-sentence gloss of hedonism is "do whatever you find pleasurable", which quickly spirals into libertine degeneracy. My one-sentence gloss of liberalism is "do whatever you want as long you aren't infringing on anyone else's rights", which quickly spirals into endless debates about distributed effects and externalities and "but how does this affect you personally" and so on. But to a first approximation, I fail to see how this adult woman having sex with a hundred consenting adult men directly infringes on anyone else's rights.
To be pedantic, I gave one example of a foreigner murdering an Irish woman or child. Aidan Moffit and Michael Snee were men, and the woman and child stabbed in November of last year survived.
Why is even one foreigner murdering the indigenous people not enough to sway your mind?
That's not how I perform cost-benefit analyses. A few iatrogenic deaths per 100k population per year doesn't mean we abolish the healthcare system.
Would you be content with a lower standard of living if your country could avoid this?
Out of curiosity, have you ever actually been to Romania?
For years I've been seeing conservatives arguing that that Democrat line about "demographics is destiny" was more the product of wishful thinking than facts on the ground. I'm starting to feel that way myself. After every Presidential election cycle, centrist Democrats redouble their efforts in encouraging the DNC to do some earnest soul-searching and recognise the fact that non-white voters are a demographic (or rather, collection of extremely loosely affiliated demographics, each of which has its own interests, many of which are zero-sum) that must be actively appealed to just like any other demographic, and cannot be simply taken for granted under the increasingly tenuous assumption that "Republicans are racist so people of colour won't vote for them". Then the next Presidential election cycle starts and the DNC immediately resumes taking non-white voters for granted, then react with shock and horror when they lose even more of them than in the last election.
Trump making historic inroads among Latino and black voters in 2016 may have come as a legitimate surprise to the DNC in 2016. No one should have been surprised by it last month. In November 2024, any white Democrat rending their hair and asking "how could a Latinx person vote for Trump??? Don't they know how racist he is???" just comes off as pathetic, like an ostrich. How many times does Lucy have to pull the football away from Charlie Brown before he learns pattern recognition?
I'm honestly wondering if, within the next ten years, we'll see Democrats claiming that they never claimed anything as racially essentialist as "demographics is destiny" and the whole thing was just invented by conservatives as an antisemetic dog whistle.
I think Hanania had an article along these lines a few weeks ago: for a long time "demographics is destiny" was the consensus among Democrats and Republicans. This served as a convenient fig leaf for Republicans who want to appeal to anti-immigration voters without being accused of racism: "we don't hate non-white people, we just want to win elections, which is impossible if non-white voters can be assumed to vote Democrat" (as Democrats themselves openly believe, to the point of it being a major component of their electoral strategy). So the increasing recognition that non-white voters are up for grabs by either party is a bit of a double-edged sword for the Republicans. On the one hand, a new demographic is voting for them, yay! On the other hand, if they want to keep appealing to their white nationalist faction while still appearing respectable, they're going to have to come up with some new justification for being opposed to immigration other than racial animus or the still-unacceptable euphemism of "cultural homogeneity", and so far the replacement fig leaf of "immigrants commit more crimes" doesn't appear to be playing ball. I don't think there's any conflict between being a social and economic conservative while also believing that Diversity is our Strength™ (i.e. we will welcome people of any colour or creed to America, provided you share our values and are willing to work hard), but the impression I get is that is that there is a very large Republican faction who will accuse any Republican politician who isn't aggressively opposed to immigration of being a RINO regardless of their stances on other policy questions - a faction that no serious Republican politician yet feels comfortable marginalising or alienating.
The McGregor verdict and modus ponens
Hypocrisy goes both ways
If you know anything about mixed martial arts, I’m sure you’re familiar with the name Conor McGregor. He’s a titan in the field, perhaps the single most famous sportsperson from this island since George Best, and a rare sportsperson who can honestly claim to have achieved the status of international household name, right up there with Cristiano Ronaldo, Venus Williams or Michael Jordan.
If you only know him from his MMA career, you may be unaware that he is scum. Scum of the lowest order: a narcissistic, immature, pathologically thin-skinned, emotionally incontinent, short-tempered, bullying, coke-addled, vicious thug and rapist. Despite having made a name for himself through his career in MMA, the “controversies” section on his Wikipedia page is nearly 500 words longer than the “professional mixed martial arts career” section, and includes such charming anecdotes as the occasion on which McGregor assaulted a man in his fifties in a pub, prompted by the outrageous provocation of the man politely declining a glass of whiskey McGregor had offered him. Until very recently, his laundry list of well-documented episodes of violent assault, sexual misconduct and general scumbaggery have done nothing to slow down his career, as he pivoted into the film industry with this year’s remake of Road House, and recently announced his intention to run for President in next year’s election.1
It need hardly be said that I think he would be just about the most atrocious ambassador for the nation imaginable, and after running through the list of Irish citizens I most despise, I’m honestly struggling to think of one I think would be a poorer fit. Leo Varadkar? Gerry Adams? Marylou McDonald? Maria Bailey, of Swing-gate fame? Barry Keoghan? Ryan Tubridy? Aisling Bea? Bono? Bob Geldof? The 2 Johnnies? Jacksepticeye? One of those interchangeable (and insufferable) post-punk “musicians” clogging up the airwaves? Jedward? Dustin the Turkey? Any of these, I believe, would represent the nation far better than McGregor.
And what unnerves me most is that I don’t think this is some far-off hypothetical: I think that McGregor has a decent chance of being elected. For anyone who thinks that such an outcome is preposterous, the fact that known gangster Gerry “The Monk” Hutch recently came within a hair’s breadth of being elected to the Dáil should prompt some earnest (and alarmed) reconsideration.
Within Ireland, McGregor is particularly well-known for his mistreatment of women, having been accused of rape and sexual assault on multiple occasions in Spain, Corsica, the US, and of course in his home country. Criminal charges have never been brought against him, owing to lack of evidence (an unfortunately perennial problem in cases of this type); but one complainant, Nikita Hand, was brave enough to sue him in a civil action, and the jury has recently found in Hand’s favour. Now that the trial is over, the injunction on the media has been lifted and they are permitted to disclose various details about the case, including the fact that Hand alleges that, after she filed the civil action, masked men broke into her home and stabbed her partner. McGregor finally appears to be facing some meaningful repercussions for his misconduct as, in light of the ruling, various brands (including IO Interactive, Musgraves and Wetherspoons) have announced that they are cutting their professional ties with him and/or refusing to stock his licensed beer and whiskey.
One reaction to the outcome of the trial I found particularly sharp was from Waterford Whispers News, a satire website which aspires to be sort of like the parochial Irish equivalent of The Onion. Between 2013-16, the website would reliably have a wittingly biting take on virtually every major news story in Ireland (this one was a particular favourite). After that golden era, the website kind of fell off and stopped seeing nearly as much traction on social media. Much like their main source of inspiration, they dropped all pretensions to neutrality and pretty much openly announced that their satire would only be a means to advance a socially progressive worldview, to the point that, earlier this year, they were literally selling merch with the dictionary definition of the word "woke" printed on it, defined as "1. Alert to prejudice and injustice 2. Not a prick" - what is this, 2014?
But occasionally, WWN can still knock the ball out of the park, as with this post:
"Keep Women Safe": Hundreds of Far Right Nationalists Protest Outside Rapist Conor McGregor's House
The joke is sharply observed. There are many working-class activists who are opposed to inward migration into Ireland, and who will often justify said opposition on the grounds that they are concerned about immigrants sexually assaulting Irish women. With very few exceptions, such people tend to be fervent admirers of Conor McGregor. It would not surprise me if at least one of the men who allegedly broke into Nikita Hand’s house with the goal of intimidating her into silence subsequently attended an anti-immigration protest at which he chanted the slogan “keep women safe”. The hypocrisy is indisputable: either such people only get up in arms about Irish women being raped when it’s foreigners doing the raping (but turn a blind eye when it’s one of their own); or their opposition to immigration is driven entirely by racial animus, and the ostensible concern about sexual assault is a fig leaf. Sharp take, no notes.
Well, maybe one.
Are you familiar with the phrase “one man’s modus ponens is another man’s modus tollens”?
This is a concept in formal logic that it took me awhile to get my head around. A modus ponens argument takes the form “if A, then B; A; therefore B”, while a modus tollens argument takes the form “If A, then B; not B; therefore not A”. In other words, if someone is saying you should believe B because A is true, the success of that argument hinges on whether or not you believe A is true; if you don’t believe that A is true, their argument immediately backfires. The concept is best illustrated using examples (all of which are sourced from this article):
- Spencer Case explaining what finally caused him to leave the Mormon church
I continued to discuss my doubts with my dad and with my new bishop, Bishop Olson, both of whom admonished me to go on a mission. At that point my departure would have been imminent. I recall one phone conversation with Bishop Olson in which he inadvertently nudged me to part ways with the church. He said the fact that I was still in the church having these conversations with him, seeking the truth, was proof that I really did know that it was true. Otherwise, what was the sense in my still going to church? Why would I continue seeking? He had a point. He ended the phone call with “See you in church this Sunday.” I never went back.
- If it’s wrong for people in Asian countries to kill and eat dogs because they can suffer and are intelligent, does that imply that we shouldn’t kill and eat pigs either? Or conversely, does it imply that we should eat dogs too?
- XKCD’s The Economic Argument. (At some point I’d like to write a post about an implication of this comic which Randall perhaps did not intend.)
Perhaps you’ve guessed where I’m going with this. As I said, it is inarguably true that if you’re up in arms about immigrants assaulting Irish women, you should be equally outraged when an Irishman like Conor McGregor does so. But the reverse is also true: if you’re up in arms about an Irishman like Conor McGregor assaulting Irish women, you should be equally outraged when an immigrant does so.
Cast your mind back to January 2022. The country was reeling from the shocking, inexplicable murder of Ashling Murphy, a primary school teacher who went for a run along the Grand Canal near Tullamore, only to be brutally stabbed to death by an unknown assailant. In the week following her murder, social media was agog with insinuations or outright accusations that all Irish men were indirectly complicit in her murder; that her murder was the result of a toxic Irish rape culture which knowingly ignores, downplays or minimises male violence towards women. Both President Michael D. Higgins and then-Taoiseach Leo Varadkar offered their condolences to the victim’s family. Rape crisis organisations called on the Department of Education to implement a national policy on sexual harassment and assault in schools.
Then, less than a week later, they arrested the murderer, and he turned out to be a Roma man from Slovakia named Jozef Puska. Everyone immediately shut up about it. Overnight, it went from being the most talked about story in Ireland to being a page four story at best. The silence was deafening, particularly in light of the furore that had preceded it the week prior.
Google Trends chart showing interest in the case over time. As usual, Google Trends bears out my gut feeling recollection of the period.
Ask yourself: in what universe can it be that a murder case is the most talked-about news story in a particular country, and the arrest of the perpetrator results in the amount of traffic it generates falling to 43% of its peak? That should have been the peak of interest in the story: the murderer brought to justice, the heroic denouement. A sharp drop like this is not what it looks like when a news story organically runs out of steam, the conclusion of one news cycle leading into the next. This is a society collectively choosing to ignore the news story while it’s still ongoing, avoiding thinking about it because it makes them uncomfortable.
Before Puska’s arrest, numerous activists on social media had decided, sight unseen, that a crime like Murphy’s murder doesn’t happen in a vacuum: the perpetrator must have grown up in a culture in which men feel entitled to do as they please with women’s bodies, in which male violence towards women is downplayed or minimised. This is not at all an unreasonable presumption to make. Nothing about Puska’s identity or ethnic background should have changed that supposition: it’s still the same guy doing the same crime for the same reasons. So why, after his arrest, didn’t we hear that argument trotted out quite so often in armchair psychoanalysis of Puska’s motivations?2
Oh. Because that would imply that it’s not (just?) Irish culture which is toxic, misogynistic and dismissive of male violence towards women, but Roma culture. Well, we can’t have that, can we? Wouldn’t want to be accused of being racist, or “legitimising” arguments made by the “far-right”.
Lest you think I’m exaggerating, consider the media’s reaction to the victim impact statement Murphy’s boyfriend Ryan Casey made at Puska’s trial. Casey can fairly claim to have been more bereaved by Murphy’s death than anyone, save her immediate family. Regarding Puska, Casey asserted:
It just sickens me to the core that someone can come to this country, be fully supported in terms of social housing, social welfare, and free medical care for over ten years, never hold down a legitimate job and never once contribute to society in any way shape or form, and commit such a horrendous, evil act of incomprehensible violence.
This statement was conspicuously omitted from the Irish Times's and Newstalk’s coverage of the murder trial. When the statement came up on the BBC current affairs programme The View, journalist Kitty Holland (in a real mask-off moment) criticised Casey for his comments, arguing that his remarks had been “not helpful”, “not good” and had been “latched onto” by the far right.
Imagine it. Your girlfriend has been unexpectedly murdered by a complete stranger, but you can take some solace in the fact that not only your friends, family and community have rallied around you, but the entire country. Then it turns out that the perpetrator is an immigrant, and the entire country immediately drops the case like a hot potato. At the perpetrator’s murder trial, you have the temerity to criticise the legislative framework which enabled the murderer to commit his horrific crime (criticisms whose factual accuracy, to the best of my knowledge, no one has yet disputed) - and your criticisms are either ignored, or you are smeared in the press as a xenophobe for having made them. It would be funny in a Kafkaesque sort of way if it wasn’t so sickening. Casey is suing the BBC for defamation, and I hope he wins.
Always and ever it’s like this when an immigrant to Ireland commits a serious crime. Three months after Ashling Murphy’s murder, two gay men were viciously murdered in Sligo because of their sexuality. Obviously this is proof of a lingering culture of homophobia among Irish people - whoops, turns out the killer is an Iraqi Muslim, time to shut up about it forever. After the unprovoked, indiscriminate stabbing of a five-year-old girl and a care assistant which prompted last November’s Dublin riots, “respectable” outlets like The Journal, the Irish Times and the Irish Independent refrained from mentioning that the assailant was Algerian-born (something known to the tabloids and alternative media by that stage), although the Independent was plenty keen to tout the fact that the man who intervened was BRAZILIAN, in literally the first sentence of the article. I distinctly recall seeing, on the same day of the stabbing, a commenter on the r/ireland subreddit saying something to the effect of: "Imagine hearing about a horrible crime like this and your first instinct is to wonder what colour the attacker's skin is. Despicable." You mean, exactly like you're doing right now?
Irish Twitter and the r/ireland subreddit a few times a year (artist’s rendition).
The media and the chattering classes will come up with all sorts of sophisticated and self-serving justifications for why they’re so recalcitrant when reporting on these issues, why they’re adopting a clear double standard depending on whether the perpetrator of a crime is Irish or an immigrant. They’ll assert that they don’t want to unfairly tar the entire community of immigrants in Ireland by fixating too heavily on a crime committed by a single member (even if they’re perfectly willing to tar the entire community of, say, UCD agricultural science students with a baseless accusation since acknowledged to have been invented from whole cloth). They’ll say they don’t want to “legitimise” far-right talking points by bringing them up or grudgingly acknowledging that a stopped clock is right twice a day.3 They’ll claim that it isn’t fair to expect a recent Syrian refugee to adhere to the same standards of behaviour that we expect from someone like Conor McGregor, who grew up in Ireland (the soft bigotry of low expectations, as ever).
But at the end of the day, what it ultimately boils down to is wilfully ignoring or downplaying crimes when they are committed by a member of one’s in-group, or someone you see as a member of a political faction whose good side you want to stay on. Which, you may have noticed, is exactly what anti-immigration protesters are doing when they turn a blind eye to Conor McGregor’s sexual misconduct.
None of all of the above is to imply that I agree with any and all criticisms of Ireland’s policy on immigration, or that I am personally opposed to immigration into Ireland - I am not. All I’m saying is: before you lecture anti-immigration activists on their hypocrisy, first ask yourself whether you’re guilty of the exact same hypocrisy in the other direction.
1A clarification for international readers: the President of Ireland is a largely ceremonial role, and the holder wields no actual political power.
2Indeed, why did we hear more armchair psychoanalysis of the perpetrator’s motivations before we even knew who the perpetrator was, compared to after? Isn’t this completely backwards?
3One might reasonably ask: if the act of making a truthful assertion constitutes “legitimising” a complaint made by the far-right, doesn’t that suggest that the complaint might be, you know - legitimate? Either a topic is legitimate to discuss, or it isn’t. It doesn’t simply become legitimate because the “correct” people are talking about it, and remain illegitimate as long as they ignore it. There’s something weirdly nihilistic about this, the idea that the “legitimacy” of a specific grievance or complaint is a purely social matter (like whether or not distressed jeans are in this season), and wholly untethered from any claims of fact or ethical standards.
Show me the moral/ethical/virtue system that says "Sex with 100 strangers in an hour" is permissible. Aside from moral relativism, out and out hedonism, or nihilism, it doesn't exist.
To the extent that it's a moral system in addition to a political one, it's called liberalism.
I see your point, but to extend the metaphor further, I feel like a man who marries a woman without knowing her full sexual history is a bit like a man who buys a used car without giving the tyres so much as a cursory kick - caveat emptor and due diligence has to kick in somewhere. Of course people can lie and keep secrets, but if you know someone well enough to consider marrying them it should be fairly obvious that there's something they're keeping from you, unless they're a truly consummate (so to speak) liar.
Everyone here can laugh it up about the men who'll marry these open prostitutes. But, y'know - at least they'll know what they're getting.
On the other hand, many pornstars have a fairly brief career under a stage name and then retire and go into teaching or something. There's a recurring scandal when a primary school discovers that one of their teachers used to be a porn star and fires her (e.g.). For obvious reasons, the porn industry is keen on insulating porn actors from the social consequences of pursuing a career in the industry: some guy compiled a database of porn actors and their real names (so that men could find out if their girlfriend had ever done porn before they popped the question), and Bang Bros bought it for the express purpose of shutting it down.
Perhaps this "one and done" approach is less viable in the OnlyFans era, but still, I have to assume that a significant proportion of "content creators" are performing under stage names. Many even film their videos in such a way that their faces aren't visible.
No one in the left elite professional classes supports alcoholism or drug abuse among themselves
Strong disagree, I think the left tends to have this massive blind spot around marijuana where they simply refuse to acknowledge any evidence that chronic usage has been implicated in psychosis.
Well, duh. I got the impression that doglatine was making a stronger claim than that though.

Why do they only use the Cathedral in reference to the "distributed conspiracy" of left-leaning academia, news media etc.? Why, to the best of my knowledge, is there no equivalently ominous term in NRx circles for conservative lobby groups, the Koch brothers etc.?
More options
Context Copy link