@FtttG's banner p

FtttG

Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.

7 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 13 13:37:36 UTC

https://firsttoilthenthegrave.substack.com/


				

User ID: 1175

FtttG

Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.

7 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 13 13:37:36 UTC

					
				

				

				

					

User ID: 1175

we should treat any willingness to speak like Hitler and court the pro-ethnic-cleansing vote as disqualifying

Per my earlier comment, the Biden administration repatriated as many or more immigrants than the Trump administration. By any objective measure, Biden has done as much or more to promote "ethnic cleansing" in the last four years than Trump did in the four years prior. But that's okay says you, because while Biden's actions may have promoted ethnic cleansing, he wasn't "speaking like Hitler" while doing it. He refused to "court" the pro-ethnic-cleansing vote in his speeches or public statements - he merely gave them a significant chunk of the policy package they wanted.

This is politics of the symbolic from top to bottom. You can do whatever you want as President, as long as you're "nice" and "civil" about it, and don't remind people (even inadvertently) of old Adolf.

I understand if you'd rather not get any more specific, but mind my asking what kind of media? Anime, manga, video games, erotic literature?

and deaths in detention will be later found to have been underreported -- 75%

What does "later" mean? During the following administration? Within a decade of Trump taking office? Twenty years?

I think you should put a hard time limit on this prediction, and if no persuasive evidence has been presented to this effect before that time limit expires, you should admit you were mistaken. Without that, this has all the hallmarks of dragon-in-my-garage conspiratorial thinking - "I can't prove that Trump is Literally Hitler, but the evidence proving it will out before long! Any minute now..."

that detentions will happen at a scale, brutality, and death rate high enough that most of the world will view it with horror once the truth comes out -- 25%

This one is sort of meaningless, because "most of the world" (and half of the US) already views anything Trump says or does with horror. Even if what he's doing is objectively less severe in scale to what Democrat Presidents have done (e.g. the aforementioned greater number of deportations under Obama than Trump).

Regardless of whether he wins, he'll call for pogroms more and more explicitly -- 75%

What, in your opinion, would an explicit call for a pogrom from Trump look like? Do you think any public statements he's made to date could reasonably be characterised as such? If so, which ones?

What's the hobby? Drawing fetish art?

Of course not.

Funnily enough, Jesse posted this just an hour and a half ago:

I haven’t become a conservative since [I was 23 years old]; I’ve just become more skeptical, and much, much more aware of the fact that conservatives have no monopoly on groupthink, intolerance, and other forms of bias. I also no longer think that you can just flip a “Liberal Policies” switch and it will fix things, at least not in real life. Just look at cities like San Francisco, which are run entirely by liberals and leftists and beset by serious problems stemming from or exacerbated by the governance decisions these supposed “good guys” have made.

Any information on whether these females are disproportionately children of divorce?

FC?

Well... there is a significant drop in life expectancy associated with being gay vs. straight, although it's narrowing year-on-year since the nightmare of the AIDS epidemic.

For reasons I don't understand, sexuality seems far less susceptible to social contagion than gender identity. Sure, the proportion of Gen Zs identifying as "bisexual" or "queer" has skyrocketed, but this hasn't translated into elevated levels of same-sex sexual activity in that generation. If anything the opposite is true and Gen Z are the most sexless generation probably ever. Hence, Dem staffers and activists can promote homosexuality to their heart's content without fear of the leopards biting their face.

And even beyond that, I genuinely believe that the median Democrat would be far more chill with having a gay son or lesbian daughter than a thot daughter trans child.

I've apparently reached the point in my life in which I'm concerned about hair loss/lack of hair growth. Laugh it up. Any recommendations for supplements I should be taking?

Expecting me to read 17 pages because you don't want to actually make an argument yourself strikes me as poor form. Perchance a TL;DR?

You missed the part where Chinese doctors have privately admitted to harvesting the organs of Uyghurs in these camps; that numerous Chinese people have given testimony that they were told they would be able to receive a vital organ transplant on a specific day (only possible if the surgeons in question knew that a specific person with a viable organ would die on that day i.e. it's impossible that the organ came from an unforeseen traffic accident); that the rate at which China conducts organ transplants is far in excess of the number of people who have signed up to the voluntary donor list; and that even the number of people China executes every year is insufficient to explain the shortfall (even assuming that any transplanted organs came from people who had been executed - not a doctor and open to correction, but I imagine a lethal dose of sodium thiopental would probably irreparably destroy a heart or liver).

No offense intended, but in 2016 we were repeatedly told all of the above would happen if Trump was elected. Trump was elected, and none of it did. In fact, Trump deported fewer people than the previous President, who also first got elected on an aggressive anti-immigration platform, having previously voted in favour of a 700-mile fence along the Mexican border to deter illegal immigration.

In 2016, these predictions about Trump carried weight precisely because he was an unknown quantity: not only had he never been President before, he'd never held an elected office of any kind. That is no longer the case - we lived through four years of a Trump administration and have a very good idea of what to expect from one, and a much better idea of what to expect compared to a Harris administration (unless you believe that Harris has been secretly pulling the strings for the last four years - I mean, obviously someone other than Biden has been calling the shots, but I don't know if I buy that it was Harris all along). If history is any guide, if Trump is elected, his administration will immediately witness a steep drop-off in deportations and repatriations compared to the preceding Democrat administration (Biden expelled 2.8 million migrants in his first two years in office, and "the Biden administration’s nearly 4.4 million repatriations are already more than any single presidential term since the George W. Bush administration").

Put hard numbers on your predictions, the way Scott did in "You Are Still Crying Wolf" (which he subsequently graded). If Trump is elected, how confident are you that literal concentration camps will be constructed; that hate crimes against Hispanic migrants, Muslims or ethnic groups will be significantly higher than during the current administration; that deportations will be significantly higher than under the current administration etc.?

Unrelated to the main thrust of your post, but I make frequent donations to the Uyghur Human Rights Project, and strongly encourage all of you to do the same.

I think you're misunderstanding the point I'm making. I'm not saying "disgusting fetish art isn't part of human culture": of course it is. I said that human culture isn't enriched by this content. It isn't a net-positive contribution to human culture: it's one of those parts of human culture that we are (or should be) profoundly ashamed of, like child abuse, drug addiction, or pizza with peas and mayonnaise.

I am 100% willing to plant my flag in the earth and say that human culture is worse off as a result of the existence of creepy fetish art, child porn, depraved erotica in the tradition of de Sade etc. Not calling for it to be banned or censored (except for child porn involving literal children, which is already illegal per age of consent legislation), just saying that it makes our culture worse. All things being equal, a culture or subculture which celebrates disgusting fetish art is worse than a culture which doesn't.

So the bare fact of consciousness alone is a necessary, but not sufficient, condition for me to find value in a work.

But again, this just seems like a bit of a cheat. Supposing I presented you with the most movingly crafted novel ever composed, with vividly drawn characters, a delicately paced plot and subtle but resonant symbolism. You read it, it moves you to tears, you're thinking about it for weeks afterwards. Then I tell you that I just gave ChatGPT-5 (which has no upper character limit) the prompt "write me a literary novel which could win the Booker prize". How do you explain your relationship to this hypothetical novel? All the emotions it made you feel, all the thoughts it provoked - they weren't real, because the words were arranged on the page by an entity who wasn't conscious? Nothing about the arrangement of the words on the page has changed - you've only learned something new about the creator. (Asserting "Chat-GPT could never do that" is refusing to engage with the terms of my hypothetical, not an actual response.)

AI art is a different class of existential threat from digital or the camera because it's the first technology that cuts humans out of the loop entirely.

I'm not sure if this is really the case. You still need someone to write the prompts, which is a skill in itself (albeit a radically different one from the skill of being an artist, and one which is much faster and easier to learn).

Yeah but the disgusting, revolting and/or morally abhorrent stuff is typically transgressive. it's done for shock value.

No, it's done for the sexual gratification of perverts.

The AI stuff just feels so bland and generic, like stock photos or those inspiration photos [1]

Well now you're contradicting yourself. Earlier you said that AI art is something no one would bother to actually draw. Now you're saying AI art is overly reminiscent of stock photos or motivational posters - which are things that humans actually put time, effort and money into creating! Which one is it?

Will send you a DM when it goes live.

Animals can presumably feel pain, but cannot create art (as we understand it, at any rate). AIs presumably cannot feel pain, but can create art. I don't understand the connection between consciousness and ability to create art.

I could've written this comment myself. Sitting on my desk are two test presses for the vinyl edition of the album I'm going to be releasing soon. I will not break even on its production.

A few weeks ago, there was a thread asking "what are some things you were wrong about?" or "what are some things you changed your mind on?" To keep myself honest, I want to add a belated example.

Two years ago, I posted this:

Go to the funeral of an 88-year-old person. Sure, people may be a little sad, but the atmosphere won't be significantly different from a golden anniversary.

Then go to the funeral of an 8-year-old person. People will be distraught. They will be tearing their hair out, wailing and gnashing their teeth. Likewise at the funeral of an 18-year-old or a 28-year-old.

In August, I buried my grandfather who was in his nineties. While I stand by my assertion that the funerals of the very young are far more distressing than the funerals of the very old (and I speak from experience, having attended a funeral of a baby who died at a few weeks), it was wrong of me to say that the atmosphere at the funerals of very old people isn't "significantly different from a golden anniversary". All of my grandfather's children were very upset, several of his daughters outright sobbing. I was never particularly close with my grandfather, but even I was more upset than I expected to be.

It's interesting that, as fevered as the opposition to AI art is today, it's nowhere near as hysterical as the kind of Luddism of previous generations. I read an article once that when the player piano was invented, a prominent musician wrote an article calling for it to be banned, arguing that if recorded music became the norm, eventually people would stop singing, our vocal cords would atrophy and we would become a mute species. Apparently he meant this quite sincerely.

Mass produced shoes put many cobblers out of business. I suspect you're wearing mass produced shoes right now, when you could have commissioned a cobbler to make custom shoes crafted for your specific feet, with a six-month lead time and at least 10x what you paid for the shoes you're currently wearing. Do you feel guilty about this? I wouldn't.

Or as @haroldbkny pointed out - when you're hosting a party in your house, do you hire a band or a string quartet to perform music for the duration? Or (like almost everyone who isn't fabulously wealthy) do you get a Spotify subscription and a couple of Bluetooth speakers? And don't tell me "well the artists are still getting revenue from the Spotify streams" - I assure you, we are not. Even the top-performing artists on streaming platforms make a pittance and all their actual revenue comes from touring and merch.

That's perhaps not the pithy gotcha you think it is. Lots of things that humans do actually bother to draw are disgusting, revolting and/or morally abhorrent. It's telling that one group that feels particularly threatened by AI art is artists doing furry commissions. No one can tell me that human culture is enriched by a drawing of the rabbit from Zootopia being subjected to a gangbang.