@FtttG's banner p

FtttG

Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.

7 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 13 13:37:36 UTC

https://firsttoilthenthegrave.substack.com/


				

User ID: 1175

FtttG

Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.

7 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 13 13:37:36 UTC

					
				

				

				

					

User ID: 1175

I've made this argument before. I suspect the overwhelming majority of people expressing public opposition to AI art are wearing shoes which were mass-produced in a factory with little human input. What's more, the machine that assembles these shoes was designed by a human who borrowed techniques developed by trained cobblers (analogous to how generative AI is trained on images created by artists). Everyone seems to have made their peace with this, and while of course they recognise that shoes made by hand and tailored to individual specifications will usually be of superior quality to shoes mass produced by machine, on the margin the mass-produced shoes are good enough for the ordinary consumer. Moreover, the fact that ordinary consumers can afford high-quality shoes is an unalloyed good, as shoes should not be so expensive that only the wealthy can own them.

I'd be a lot more interested in AI art if I had a reasonable degree of confidence that the AI was conscious, and that it created the piece with intent and drew from its conscious experiences as inspiration.

Which invites the question of what it means to be conscious and if any of us are in the sense you mean.

It wasn't that long ago that scifi regularly depicted AI and robots as having difficulty creating and/or comprehending such things.

There's a widely memed exchange in the movie I, Robot where Will Smith's character asks a robot something to the effect of "Can a robot paint a masterpiece? Compose a symphony?" and the robot replies "Can you?"

Nowadays he'd just respond yeschad.jpeg.

I think you're referring to a style transfer, which could produce remarkably impressive results even five years ago.

I'm laughing just imagining what that would sound like.

I saw a tweet the other day which was pleading with big companies not to use AI art, because by doing so they're indirectly signalling cheapness: it sends the message that the company is so underresourced that they can't afford to hire graphic designers etc., and have to resort to using Stable Diffusion instead. It reminded me of this article which argued that companies spending extravagant sums on advertising campaigns is a hallmark of the confidence they have in their product or service: "we're so sure that you'll love this that we'll put our money where our mouths are to put it in front of you".

On the one hand, this argument is unassailably true. On the other hand, it strikes me as an awfully exclusive position to hold for a person who presumably considers themselves socialist or at least left-leaning. "If you didn't spend at least $100k on your ad campaign, don't even bother - we don't want broke boys here."

Years ago I had a similar debate with a musician, who pointed out that a lot of metal and punk records from the 80s and 90s have a very raw, scuzzy DIY feel because the band couldn't afford anything better. Nowadays many modern punk and metal bands are purists about recording to tape and will spend a small fortune trying to replicate that "raw", "organic" sound that records from the 80s and 90s have. But this guy pointed out that the modern inheritor of the raw 80s approach to recording your demo (at least as far as being DIY and budget-conscious goes) is to plug your guitar into a Scarlett 2i2 and program the drums with Superior Drummer.

I've never for a moment thought that people opposed to AI art were actually fine with it but were just pretending to hate it to own the libs tech bros.

The best way to understand people on the other side of a culture war issue is to start from the assumption that they really do genuinely believe what they say they believe.

I believe in the virtue of charity, but - come on. Do you really think that a person's private motivations for being in favour of/opposed to X are identical to their publicly stated motivations more often than not? At every point on the political spectrum?

Also, people who have objections to AI painting also tend to have objections to AI music and AI voice acting, even if those areas don't overlap with their personal skill set. Which is evidence that the objections are principled rather than merely opportunistic.

Alternatively, they believe (correctly, in my view) that generative AI is a war with multiple fronts, and if you want to win a war you have to win it on all of these fronts lest you fall victim to a rearguard action down the line. If AI visual art was banned but AI voice acting was seen as fair game, it's only a matter of time before lots of people start noticing that this seems kind of arbitrary and unfair.

I'm upvoting not because I agree with you but because I appreciate you articulating your position so clearly.

Have you seen Scott's AI art Turing test?

An analogy I'll keep returning to is that when The Abyss came out in 1989, it was submitted to the Oscars for consideration under the best visual effects category, but did not receive a nomination - because the Academy decided that using CGI was cheating. 5-10 years from now, every film that gets nominated for best visual effects will use generative AI in some capacity and people will be wondering what all the fuss was about.

I just don't think the film is anywhere near as one-sided or morally black-and-white as you're making out. The German sniper in the clock tower has the opportunity to shoot Caparzo, but refrains from doing so until Caparzo returns the little French girl to her parents, presumably for fear of her getting hit in the crossfire. After killing Mellish in a vicious hand-to-hand mêlée, the unnamed German soldier can't bring himself to kill the cowering, snivelling Upham who clearly poses no threat. Perhaps we aren't strictly invited to sympathise with Steamboat Willie when he's pathetically sobbing and begging for his life, but I think we are at least invited to understand Upham's reluctance to kill a POW in cold blood. If Miller's squad had executed him, it would have been just one of several war crimes the Rangers are depicted committing: I don't think the audience is expected to cheer at their decision to shoot surrendering Czech conscripts at Omaha, or needlessly prolonging the deaths of several German soldiers by allowing them to burn to death rather than quickly finishing them off.

Of course the American soldiers are our viewpoint characters and we are intended to sympathise with them (because, duh, the Allies just were more sympathetic than the Germans), but I don't think the film can honestly be said to depict the German soldiers as a formless mass of interchangeable faceless monsters, nor the American soldiers as stalwart, wholly morally upstanding heroes who never put a foot wrong.

However what I find interesting is that people here internalize even completely invalid themes - for instance the boomer vs millenial dichotomy from US. In Slovakia the boomers spent their best productive years during communism or very shady early years after the fall of Eastern Bloc in 1989, with 20%+ unemployment and average salary of $100 a month/$1,200 a year - if you were lucky enough to actually have an average job and the employer was actually paying you on time. Boomers at large do not have any financial property such as stocks or bonds to help in their retirement, because these were not accessible.

I made exactly that comparison about Ireland here.

You're correct, looking it up it's mainly a Scandinavian and British isles thing

"In the evenings I like to unwind by painting Warhammer 40k figurines."

BRAAAAAAAAP

Maybe the message they're trying to impart to women is "no self-respecting woman would date a man who refuses to vote, no matter how physically attractive or financially viable he was. Be like the women in this ad and don't give politically disengaged fuckbois the time of day." And then if it became common knowledge that women as a group considered voting a rule-in criterion for any prospective partners, single men would adjust their behaviour accordingly.

That's even a term for it.

I find it particularly funny because when I was single, I saw a lot of women whose Tinder bios included (or consisted of) "swipe left if you're a Tory/if you voted Leave". You're outright instructing men on which specific beliefs they need to fake to get into your pants!

Damn, is that really all they did? That's so silly.

I'm guessing there are a lot of people who really don't understand how the franchising business model works and don't really get how much autonomy individual franchise owners are afforded.

Also in many European countries (including Ireland and the UK) most police officers are unarmed. So even if you disobey a police officer's orders, in most cases the worst that'll happen to you is that you'll get tased, maced or twatted with a nightstick.

I recently finished the single-player campaign to Titanfall 2. I enjoyed it, 7/10.

Trolling street protesters is good fun. Walking up the street and the Revolutionary Communist Party have set up a stand. One of the members calls out to me and my girlfriend, "hey guys, are you interested in communism?"

I shout back "absolutely not!" without breaking stride. Even he laughed at that.

A few hours later we go to McDonald's. When we're leaving, a bunch of pro-Palestine protesters wearing ghoulish costumes have congregated outside, shaming all the people who enter or exit in light of McDonald's support for Israel (?). One of them calls out to us "you don't have to do this again!" I replied "but I will!"

Everyone says "the first half-hour is incredible, then it becomes corny patriotic schlock". I disagree: I think the film does an admirable job of sustaining the intensity of its opening throughout the subsequent battle scenes, which are almost as gripping and jarring as those in the opening, and which set the tone for how action films would look, sound and feel for decades afterwards.

I think the film squanders an opportunity to tell a genuinely interesting story about how the war was a ghoulishly unnecessary waste of millions of the best young men that the West had to offer.

On the contrary, I think the film did tell this story. Consider the conversation between Miller and Horvath in the church, in which Miller says that throughout his military career, he was able to rationally justify all the lives lost under his command with the reasoning that more lives have been saved as a result. But for this particular mission, he cannot employ that reasoning: many men must die to save the life of one, and the only way the sacrifice will be worth it is if Ryan "invent[s] a longer-lasting lightbulb or something". Ryan's closing dialogue indicates that he's spent more or less his entire adult life burdened with the knowledge that he's only alive because several men gave their lives to save his, as a public relations mission, and wondering if he has done enough with his time on earth to warrant the sacrifice. Spielberg himself openly stated that Miller's mission cannot be justified on moral grounds. If that doesn't say something about the absurdity and arbitrariness of war, I don't know what does. It may not be Joseph Heller but it's a far more disquieting and confrontational message than the movie is generally credited with. (Not to mention the fact that the film's viewpoint character for the back half is a coward who allows his squadmate to die because he's paralysed by terror, and who is clearly intended to represent how the typical audience member would behave in such a situation.)

The only World War 2 movie I would consider rewatching

Have you seen Saving Private Ryan? When I watched Dunkirk all I could think was that it was Nolan directing a PG-13 Ryan knockoff.

Time to rewatch Gattaca everyone, it's on the way.

Unrelated but I love your username. I was thinking the other day that Vanilla Sky might have one of the best licensed soundtracks of any Hollywood movie, it's up there with Tony Hawk's Pro Skater in terms of how many cool artists it introduced me to. Case in point.