FtttG
Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.
User ID: 1175
I encountered so many goodthinking midwits during Covid who really had never encountered the idea that nothing is a costless action. I had a hundred variations on this exchange between 2020-21.
"Is it worth opening the pubs/opening the schools/going into the office if it means people die?"
People died because of all of these things before Covid. If "someone dies as a result" is a reason not to allow something, we should immediately ban all motor vehicles.
"Well no, because even though a small number of people die in motor accidents every year, we still need motor vehicles for a functioning economy."
Congratulations, you now understand the concept of a "cost-benefit analysis". Please apply this concept to lockdowns, social distancing and so on.
True, but it sounds like what Innuendo is driving at is the asymmetry of the power differential. You can induce a panic attack in me by pointing a gun at me (or any other of a long list of things which the average person can reasonably be expected to find upsetting), and I can do the same to you - it's perfectly symmetrical. But if I've gone through a traumatic experience that you know about, you can induce a panic attack in me by doing something far less overtly threatening than pointing a gun at me: say, telling a rape joke in my presence. Whereas if I tell a rape joke in your presence, it will have no effect on you. Between us, "jokes involving rape" are assymetric weapons.
Moreover, if you threaten me with a gun you may face legal repercussions (or at the minimum a drop in social standing, if I garner a reputation as a dangerous person), but if you tell a rape joke in my presence, it may have no impact on your social standing at all, while having a devastating impact on my mental health. (Now that I think about it, this may be what woke people were driving at with the whole "microaggressions" discourse.)
In practice I don't think it's anything like as black-and-white as this. Not everyone who's been raped and thinks that trigger warnings are a reasonable accommodation is going to reliably have a full-blown panic attack every time they hear someone tell a joke involving rape, and plenty of people who are opposed to trigger warnings on principle will nevertheless find themselves getting extremely upset about something much less overtly threatening than having a gun pointed at them. Once you know someone well enough, you can push their buttons in all sorts of subtle ways that wouldn't necessarily strike an outside observer as obviously cruel or abusive.
Think of the actors Paul Rudd or Timothee Chalamet (just for common facial references). These faces seem deeply trustworthy to me in a way that I don’t find in a John Krasinski. I don’t think attractiveness is biasing me here, as I would also find Steve Buscemi and Michael Cera trustworthy.
If I didn't know who Michael Cera was, I wouldn't leave my girlfriend alone with him, as I'd think he'd try to fuck her and she'd get creeped out and upset. I wouldn't leave her alone with Timothee Chalamet, as I'd think he'd try to fuck her - and succeed.
Krasinski looks more trustworthy to me than either. Agreed on Rudd and Buscemi though.
So in your view, is a person who "identifies as a member of the opposite sex/gender" but has no interest in medically transitioning a trans person?
And as I said, if "being trans" is wholly uncoupled from "experiencing gender dysphoria", then I'm not sure I even understand what it means to be trans. Maybe you're referring to "gender euphoria", which from context I can only infer is a euphemism for the sexual arousal that autogynephiliac males experience when performing femininity. All else being equal, I would likewise rather not be an autogynephiliac than be one.
Right. I don't have comparable figures to hand for X and Z, but the Tavistock Centre (the UK and Ireland's only dedicated medical centre for treating gender dysphoria in children) saw a 5,337% increase in referrals for female children in less than ten years, which I'm largely attributing to social contagion/awareness-raising campaigns/glamorisation.
I'd be quite surprised if X and Z are 5,000% combined. "Social stigma against trans people fell by 2,500%" essentially amounts to every trans person in the UK being treated like some combination of royalty and Nobel Peace Prize laureate, which doesn't seem remotely realistic.
I agree that everyone would rather not have gender dysphoria.
From which it logically follows that not having gender dysphoria (and by extension not being trans) is strictly preferable to having gender dysphoria, and that if social influences play any significant role in developing gender dysphoria, it's irresponsible to raise awareness of or glamorise it.
I suspect where I depart from many people who believe the prior statements is that I don't think of people being trans or gay as being strictly worse than cis or straight such that society or government ought to be oriented around the minimization of such people.
All things being equal, I don't think of being gay as strictly worse than being straight. According to some definitions of what "trans" is, it absolutely is worse than being cis, according to the very terms insisted upon by trans activists.
If one assumes that a prerequisite for being "trans" is suffering from gender dysphoria, it just seems obvious that not having gender dysphoria is preferable to having it. All other things being equal, I think pretty much everyone would rather feel happy with their bodies as they are, not experience a sense of profound distress when looking at their reflection in the mirror, and not feel any urge to hack bits of healthy tissue off their bodies.
Analogies with anorexia are no accident. Anorexia is a mental illness in which one experiences profound distress at the sight of one's body. It seems extremely susceptible to social contagion (particularly in female adolescents) and culture-bound (almost exclusively diagnosed in WEIRD countries). I want anorexic people to be treated with respect and compassion, and to get the best treatment available. I also think that being anorexic is obviously worse than not being anorexic in essentially every way, and it's irresponsible to promote or glamorise it.
You may be working off a definition of "trans" in which a diagnosis of gender dysphoria is not a prerequisite. This is long past the point at which the concept has completely collapsed into incoherence for me, so I can't really comment as to whether it's better, worse or indifferent to be trans (according to that definition) or cis. The "trans without gender dysphoria" cohort does seem to contain a disproportionate amount of vocal bad-faith actors, which is bound to colour my perspective.
Thanks a million, I just watched that first video and there's a lot of good advice in there.
Oh congratulations to the newlyweds by the way
Precisely.
My Korean immigrant wife came to America when she was 12
Have you both seen Past Lives by any chance?
Thanks for the detailed response. By any chance would you have any resources for proper deadlifting form? I really have no idea what I'm doing wrong.
I'm not sure if I have enough confidence in my pull-out game or my ability to track my missus's menstrual cycle.
I don't know if it's a deficiency with my form or what, but several times this year I've thrown my back out from deadlifting. It's annoying because I usually only notice the day afterwards. Do you find that wearing the belt reduces the likelihood of that happening? If so, can you recommend a belt for a relative novice? (The first time I ever deadlifted was January.)
It saddens me to know that my younger sister would have had exactly the same reaction as your not-crush.
Had I found myself in your situation, I wouldn't have maced him except in literal self-defence. In my experience in similar situations, it's usually sufficient to interpose yourself between the crazy homeless guy and his target, make yourself look as big and imposing as possible, and loudly tell him to get lost. (Context: I'm a 6-foot broad-shouldered guy. I acknowledge this approach may not have the same effect if you aren't as big as the junkie.) Even the most addled junkie will usually take the hint and leave. I imagine your employer would understand you being a few minutes' late for work, especially if you spin it as you protecting a lone Woman of Colour from the predations of etc.
I snorted.
Who the hell uses condoms for anything but one night stands? You might as well not have sex at that point.
So when you're in a monogamous relationship, your assumption is that your partner will be on the pill? (I'm assuming you're a straight man.)
In addition I've felt like there's a component by which younger people (and even millennials, too) kinda feel like bodies are gross.
In addition to porn presenting a stylised, sanitised version of sex in which all of the participants are impossibly gorgeous and up for anything, and lacking any of the gustatory and olfactory stimuli central to the real thing - you can also watch animated porn, which depicts things that are literally physically impossible in the real world. I'm sure there are young people out there whose entire "sex lives" consist of masturbating to hentai throughout adolescence, without ever having ventured into the comparatively earthy and raw world of live-action.
Another possible contributing factor: rising obesity rates causing reduced sex drive/erectile dysfunction etc.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obesity_and_sexuality
But of course that would contradict the evidence from Japan, where obesity rates are fairly flat over the last fifty years but the rate of sexlessness has skyrocketed.
Sorry for the confusion, it's just an expression when you're really happy with the outcome of a result, like when a footballer scores a goal. "Get in!"
Get in.
What do you find so objectionable about it?

Understood, I'll delete the post.
More options
Context Copy link