@FtttG's banner p

FtttG

Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.

7 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 13 13:37:36 UTC

https://firsttoilthenthegrave.substack.com/


				

User ID: 1175

FtttG

Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.

7 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 13 13:37:36 UTC

					
				

				

				

					

User ID: 1175

melanin content

In the comment of mine you linked to, I was discussing the differences in educational outcomes between middle-class students attending private schools and working-class students in state schools - in Ireland. Ireland, as you may be aware, is about 90% white. Almost every student in either the private or state schools under discussion is white. In my experience, if anything the private schools tend to be more ethnically diverse than the state schools, which doesn't impact on their having consistently higher educational outcomes than the state schools. If you think that the comment you linked to proves that I think poor black people are less intelligent than rich white people - well, it doesn't. You are simply, unambiguously wrong.

Perhaps the most striking example is this comedy film from 2002 about a basketball player who gets suspended from the men's league and tries to pass himself off as a woman so he can compete in the women's league.

Well there's a scene in either season 1 or 2 which consists entirely of House aggressively berating a woman for refusing to vaccinate her child, so.

In my follow-up comments to the comment you linked, I made it abundantly clear that when I said "it's all genetics" I was exaggerating for rhetorical effect, and I do not, in fact, believe that culture plays zero role in educational outcomes. My hyperbolic assertion that "it's all genetics" was intended to contrast with the attitudes of certain education researchers who do, apparently, believe that genetics plays no role in educational outcomes, and that educational outcomes are entirely determined by culture, upbringing and school quality.

I've made my actual position on this matter abundantly clear to you, and I think it's rather tiresome and dishonest of you to quote this off-the-cuff comment out of context. You seem convinced that this off-the-cuff comment I made in passing was some sort of "mask-off" moment for me, and all the follow-up comments I made expressing my actual position in more nuanced detail were simply lies. I don't know how you arrived at this position and I don't appreciate being misrepresented.

I would greatly appreciate it if you would knock it off and stop involving me every time you want to make a point about how evil and wretched HBDers are. And don't tell a story that you're only pinging me because I'm "one of the Motte's most prominent HBD proponents" or whatever: I barely discuss the issue at all, and the comment you linked is from seven months ago. In the interim, out of the dozens if not hundreds of comments I've posted here, I've discussed HBD in any capacity a grand total of three times, in one case because you were pinging me about it, in another case to explicitly refute the claim that HBD is the cause of disproportionate homicide rates between ethnic groups in the US. It's not a topic I know much about, claim any expertise in or discuss with any great frequency.

If you're so convinced that rabid, unqualified endorsement of HBD is the median position on this site, it shouldn't be remotely hard for you to find a better example to illustrate your point than me, a guy who has never claimed any expertise in the topic, doesn't find it particularly interesting and barely talks about it. Given that you know all of the foregoing, it's really obnoxious of you to repeatedly bring me up any time you're trying to score points in a HBD debate, especially now that you've been explicitly requested not to do so in future.

Understood, apologies.

Or at least that you can't depict a character behaving like this if they're intended to be a likeable anti-hero the audience can sympathise with (up to a point). Nowadays a character could only be depicted behaving like this if they were an out-and-out villain without any redeeming qualities.

I recently rewatched seasons 1 and 2. One that jumped out for me was a season 1 episode in which a black politician is running for President. House scoffs at the idea that a black man could ever be elected President, and by the end of the episode the man himself admits that he doesn't expect to win, but thinks it's worth it in hopes that the act of doing so might inspire change.

In the second episode of season 2, there's a nine-year-old girl with terminal cancer who asks Chase (a thirty-year-old man) to kiss her, as she doesn't want to die without having been kissed. He's reluctant, but eventually does it. His colleagues tease him about it, but it's presented as an essentially compassionate act.

In the third episode of season 2, the cause of a Mexican day labourer's illness is a disease he contracted from a rooster at the underground cockfighting ring he works in. One suspects that this plot point would be decried as promoting harmful stereotypes against Hispanic people if it happened today.

There's a season 2 episode featuring a couple who practise consensual RP and BDSM. It's eventually revealed that the wife is trying to murder the husband for undisclosed reasons. You could argue this is stigmatising people with kinks.

I hadn't thought of that. When I think about immigrants coming to Australia I immediately think of Chinese and Vietnamese, but I suppose there are a lot of Lebanese as well, aren't there? Would you happen to have stats on the most biggest immigrant groups by source nation over the last few decades?

Wow I can't remember the last time someone accused me of being "triggered" by something.

Ballard, who was played by Jim Caviezel in the hit film Sound of Freedom, is said to have sent at least one woman a photo of himself in his underwear, festooned with fake tattoos

I was reading your account and, because I don't know what Ballard looks like, I was picturing Jim Caviezel sending a woman a sexy mirror selfie. I looked up the man himself and he looks like a weird cross between Ray Liotta and that one blond guy who was the villain in every movie/TV show made in the Noughties.

I'm not sure if he quite fits, as to my knowledge no evidence has been presented suggesting that he personally abused the child trafficking victims he ostensibly came to rescue. Abusing your position of power to try to get your subordinates into bed with you is the kind of run-of-the-mill sex scandal not peculiar to any individual line of work.

Thank you for your clarification, but I still disagree with you.

It's not just feminist sources pushing this culture: It's songs, it's movies, it's TV shows. It's in the assumptions college professors

College professors, Hollywood movies and TV shows, and American pop songs being famed for their rabid opposition to feminism.

Do you think most men who expect women to sleep with them on the first date expect this because they are feminists?

Just because the bootleggers gained financially from prohibition, doesn't mean that prohibition wasn't fought for by the baptists.

I'm not saying that the only people saying "hey, casual sex is cool" are feminists - obviously teen sex comedies, sitcoms etc. do that too. But the specific adjective you used was "empowering", and I honestly can't remember the last time I heard that adjective used in conversation by someone who didn't openly, loudly identify themselves as feminist. There may be many kinds of sources telling young women that casual sex is fun, cool, exciting etc. but I think it's reasonable to assume that the only people telling young women that casual sex is empowering are feminists.

Jesus, that's the kind of thing non-verbal autistic children do when they're upset.

If we take the woman at her word and she's genuinely just crying because she's sad, then it sounds like she's just really immature and bad at emotional self-regulation. Describing this behaviour as "emotionally manipulative" implies that it's calculated and deceitful - some people can consciously choose to turn on the waterworks on command, and abuse this skill in order to get what they want from other people. If that's what she was doing, I would have no problem describing the behaviour as emotionally manipulative, maybe even abusive. But if she really is sincerely bursting into tears because she's sad and it's not calculated and intentional, then it's something else.

I think "selfish" or "inconsiderate" might be better words, and neither one is as grave an accusation as "abusive" or "manipulative".

As to the broader question of what constitutes emotional abuse from a woman to a man, I think that most of the red flags people are warned about are gender-neutral. Harsh insults, extremely harsh criticism, controlling behaviour, attempting to isolate your partner from their family/friends, paranoid jealous behaviour, gaslighting, failure to respect boundaries, lashing out, threatening suicide if you don't get your own way - women can be just as guilty of all of the above as men.

Apologies for reacting irritably to your abbreviated version.

Oh not at all, I think the irritation was entirely warranted, but no hard feelings.

would you be interested in engaging on it if I did?

Absolutely, please ping me when you post. If you'd even like someone to read a draft before you publish I'd be more than happy to.

Thanks for expressing the basic point I was trying to make in greater detail. I'm having one of those days where the words aren't coming to me with ease.

I didn't think it was a literal apology. A "non-apology apology" presents itself as though the speaker is trying to make amends for wrongdoing, but if read closely, the speaker is very careful to avoid admitting guilt or accepting responsibility for wrongdoing (hence the weasel phrase "mistakes were made").

I thought it was a similar kind of evasiveness on /u/CanIHaveASong's part to attribute young women coming to believe that casual sex is empowering as a result of the messages sent by "society", as opposed to any more specific agent or group contained therein.

And your rejoinder is to complain that it doesn't throw enough blame on the ideology you personally dislike?

This is an extreme "mistakes were made" non-apology.

Sure, it's not incorrect to say that "society" sends young women a lot of messages which glamorise casual sex - but which components of "society" are sending these messages, exactly? Presumably young women aren't going down to their local mosque, church, or synagogue to hear preachers gush about the satisfaction of being a bad bitch who fucks a dude then leaves him on read.

To fix a problem, you have to identify its source, and you have to do it with more precision than pinpointing it to "society".

I'll report back in one of the Wellness threads.

What's a good source of electrolytes?

My read on all this is that it is a human psychological tragedy, Ballard got lost in his own masculine heroic fantasy. Good men nearly all carry the fantasy of, as they say, wishin' a nigga would. We want a reason to give our World of Cardboard Speech. We have the urge to engage in violence and adventure, but we want justified violence, righteous adventure. We want to fight, but fight for the right.

I'm not proud to admit how often I'm on public transport with some scumbags in their late teens/early twenties being generally obnoxious loudmouths (playing music through their shitty Bluetooth speakers, vaping, yelling at each other etc.) and find myself thinking "man, I wish one of these fuckers would start some shit so I could punch his lights out with impunity".

But I don't think we have any good reason, right now, to believe that this was part of Ballard's motivation/rationalisation. I suspect that he was both sincere in his desire to rescue children from sex trafficking, and also a horndog. Maybe he believed that his "heroism" entitled him to some strange - he'd earned it, hadn't he?

they have the emotional fortitude of a 5 year old.

Agreed. Definitely not abuse though.

People regularly overestimate how much calories running consumes

It's so demoralising when you do a half-marathon in two hours, count the calories and realise that you've only burned about half of a kebab.

Thanks for the source. Apparently Australia only outlawed marital rape in 1990. I wonder how much this contributed to the increase.

Okay, fair enough, I was being hyperbolic.