@FtttG's banner p

FtttG

Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.

7 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 13 13:37:36 UTC

https://firsttoilthenthegrave.substack.com/


				

User ID: 1175

FtttG

Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.

7 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 13 13:37:36 UTC

					
				

				

				

					

User ID: 1175

Okay, so /u/Fruck kissing his comatose father on the forehead was "bad" even though it wasn't sexual harassment?

Even with this disambiguation, I'm still not buying it. The phrase "low-status men" is kind of ambiguous, so I want to focus on the specific question of "who presents a greater risk of violent rape to a woman - an 'incel' or a sexually active man?" because the debate started with the claim that women think incels are evil specifically because they think they're rapists (or because they think they're more likely to be rapists than non-incels).

The Intersection of Men’s Sexual Violence Perpetration and Sexual Risk Behavior: A Literature Review:

Research with domestic and international samples has consistently demonstrated a positive association between men’s number of lifetime sexual partners and SV perpetration, using both cross-sectional and longitudinal methods. In domestic research comparing perpetrators to nonperpetrators, perpetrators report a significantly higher number of sexual partners

In international research (African and Indian samples), having a greater number of sexual partners is a significant risk factor for intimate and nonintimate partner rape

For example, a history of SV is associated with an increased likelihood of having five or more partners in the past three months

Research finds having concurrent or extramarital sexual partners is associated with SV perpetration... Casey et al. found that men who perpetrate intimate partner physical violence and sexual coercion report a greater number of concurrent partners than men who perpetrate either controlling behaviors or no abuse

A handful of studies have found a positive association between men’s number of one-night stands (i.e., one-time-only sexual intercourse partners) and their SV perpetration

The review is really long but I think I've made my point.

"Women think incels are evil because they think incels are more likely to be rapists" may be a factually true assertion, but several people in this thread seem to think that this belief is well-founded. It isn't. The more sexual partners a man has, the more likely he is to engage in risky sex, the more likely is to have concurrent sexual partners, the more women he's fucked on the first date, the more prostitutes he's had sex with - the greater the risk he is of committing sexual harassment and violence. Based on this evidence, women have far less to fear from the average incel than they do from a guy who has plenty of notches on his bedpost.

If that's the case, then who the hell is going around interpreting pats on the back as romantic or sexual?

Sure, but there's a world of difference between "assume every man is a potential rapist" and "assume every man is a potential rapist, unless he's conventionally attractive and charming", which is what the OP is complaining about. And given that high-status men are more likely to commit sexual assault than low-status men, the latter heuristic is actively worse than the former.

Sure, but this is a bit like saying it's perfectly natural and reasonable for people to assume that every Muslim they meet is a potential terrorist, or every black man a potential mugger.

Probably not.

Why? By your logic the man's father was unable to consent because he was in a coma. I've read enough feminist discourse about how "Sleeping Beauty" promotes rape culture to know how I'm supposed to interpret this situation.

Right, and to acknowledge that the world is deeply unfair even for many straight white males would cause their worldview to crumble.

When women, people of colour etc. don't get what they want out of life, that's because of sexism, racism, bigotry, transphobia and so on. When a straight white male doesn't get what he wants out of life? Well, if even the white cisheteropatriarchy doesn't think much of him, he must not deserve it.

Wow, this is the first bit of good news I've seen on this site in months. Would be interesting to see a breakdown by generation.

RtR?

from what I've seen, they generally come to believe that they are misunderstood and secretly valuable

Yeah, of the two most common failure modes, "nobody likes me because I'm scum" and "nobody likes me because they're envious of my brilliance", I'm honestly unsure which one is less psychologically healthy for the individual. I've met a few nerdy men who I suspect were bullied as children and to console them their mothers told them "don't mind them dear, they're just envious of how clever you are", and they seemed to have really internalised this. The "former gifted child" phenomenon often referred to on Tumblr and other places like that has a real ring of truth to it.

I completely agree, but there's no shortage of people flinging that accusation at him anyway.

Occasionally it'll happen that someone will say "omg X is such an incel" and I'll point out "X? You mean the happily married man with two kids? How can he be an incel?" and the person will reply "well he just gives off incel vibes" which is vague enough that it could mean anything.

I had to watch one episode of it in college and it seemed unusually intelligent and thought-provoking for a legal drama. My parents love it.

I can't consider it because I've never seen it except in these scenarios where i'm assured it's true by its detractors.

https://faroutmagazine.co.uk/ben-shapiro-calls-joe-biden-the-kurt-cobain-of-politics/

https://youtube.com/watch?v=nAaZvlYc71w&t=205

https://www.thedailybeast.com/sarah-silverman-savages-pathetic-incel-elon-musk-on-daily-show

https://www.lipstickalley.com/threads/incel-elon-musty-backs-out-of-fight-with-incel-mark-zukerberg.5352488/

https://youtube.com/watch?v=xGGKJ3REusg?si=PnJxvLZlcauYMGxs

https://variety.com/2022/film/news/jordan-peterson-cries-olivia-wilde-incel-hero-dont-worry-darling-1235388024/

https://thespectator.com/topic/delete-facebook-zuckerberg-incel/

A cursory Google (I'm on my phone) to provide examples of public figures being described as "incels". All of these men have been married at least once, all but one of them are still married, all of them have fathered at least one child, at least one is known to have fathered multiple children by multiple women, and at least one is known to have had multiple extramarital affairs.

This whole "incels/nice guys are actually rapists" thing gets trotted out every time this debate comes up, and I'm still not buying it.

I still don't think a group of trans men on T for a few years poses nearly as much of a threat as a group of males. Has there even been a single example of a trans man who was able to compete (not even win) in male sporting events?

As for OP, there are many women in the Philippines and Ukraine who would be happy to have you.

That's kind of a cheap shot.

https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/08/31/radicalizing-the-romanceless/

Admittedly our culture has moved on from this specific discourse, but in 2013-4 the "Nice Guy™" debate was all the rage. The essence of the debate was intelligent, gainfully employed but nerdy men complaining about being unsuccessful with women, sometimes for the claimed reason that they are "too nice" or "women don't go for nice guys". In some cases the claim was a bit hard to take seriously ("fuck u u dumb whore ur ugly anyway") but in other cases the lonely men in question gave every indication of being kind-hearted individuals who treated men and women alike with unshakeable respect and decency.

The stock retort from feminists in this era was "of course women go for nice guys. If they went for assholes they'd be all over you", an argument which still occasionally gets trotted out as recently as this year on this very site. Note what this framing implies: that if a man is romantically unsuccessful with women and has the temerity to feel even a little bit upset or frustrated by this, he must be a bad person i.e. exactly what the OP is talking about. This was a key tenet of internet/nerd feminism for years.

I've been meaning to write a blog post which touches on this topic for months. Here's the bullet points:

  • Being morally good and being likeable on an interpersonal level are orthogonal traits. Many people are both, many people are neither, but it isn't hard to find examples of people who are likeable but unvirtuous (e.g. charming con artists), or who are morally upstanding but hard to like (e.g. socially awkward and arrogant nerds who join EA and donate vast sums of their own money to charitable causes).
  • The assumption that people who are likeable are also morally upstanding (and vice versa) is so widespread that it might as well be instinctual (for evolutionary reasons). How often do you hear people say "I like him, he's a really nice guy", as if the former by definition implies the latter? It takes immense courage to assert, without a trace of irony, that you like someone even though he's an actively nasty dickhead.
  • We assume that our friends and lovers are decent people who only occasionally behave badly under unusually stressful circumstances (i.e. the fundamental attribution error), whereas people we don't like are assumed to be actively nasty (even if we've forgiven our friends for worse crimes than our enemies have ever committed).
  • Many people are extremely poor judges of why they find someone attractive (either platonically, sexually or romantically). Asking people to enumerate the kind of friend or husband they want is a task extremely susceptible to being confounded by social desirability bias. Most people (especially those lacking in self-awareness) will list off a bunch of socially commendable traits and fail to notice that none of the people they've been involved with historically have ever met that description.
  • If you've internalised the idea that anyone you like is good and that anyone you dislike is bad, if you're approached by a person who's obviously attracted to you or wants to be your friend, but you don't feel the same way, the only way to resolve the cognitive dissonance will be to decide that that person is a bad person.
  • Sometimes the person will, by coincidence, be a genuinely bad person (because interpersonal likeability and personal virtue are orthogonal), but sometimes they'll be a morally upstanding person guilty only of being physically unattractive or somewhat lacking in social graces. For this eventuality, there's the all-encompassing cop-out that "he just gave me creepy vibes". If a woman says that a guy is "creepy" or "gave off creepy vibes" but is unable, when pressed, to provide a single specific example of a creepy thing that guy said or did (e.g. groping her, being pushy, making inappropriately sexual conversation on a first date etc.), you can reasonably assume he did nothing wrong besides not being the kind of guy to whom she's attracted. I don't care if it's been memed to death, this comic is a 100% accurate depiction of the behaviour of modern Western feminists in particular and the human species in general.
  • As I said, sometimes you might find that a person you don't like is a genuinely bad guy, but don't think the cart is before the horse - likeability comes first, then assessment of personal virtue. If a person says "I don't like him because he did XYZ", you may well later find him or her explaining away the XYZ committed by someone they like (platonically, sexually or romantically). XYZ isn't the reason you dislike so-and-so: you dislike him because he's boring or has an irritating laugh, then you tell yourself a story that the real reason you dislike him is because he did XYZ (even if you'd be perfectly happy to excuse XYZ if committed by someone interesting with a normal laugh).
  • This is most pronounced in the case of sexual/romantic relationships, but all of the above applies just as much in platonic relationships too. If someone wants to be our friend and we don't like them or enjoy their company, the human default is to insist that they are morally bad, not just boring or lacking in social graces. Many socially maladroit people end up with the erroneous belief that they are morally bankrupt on the basis of not having many (or any) friends, because they've fully internalised the "likeable = morally good" framework and all it implies.

And before anyone starts urging me to secure a mail-order bride, I'm in a happy relationship with a conventionally attractive woman. You don't have to be an incel to empathise with them.

If you haven't met your quota yet, consider me volunteered.

I discovered the band that I've listened to the most in the past 10 years by just by hitting the random article link on Wikipedia

What's the band?

The one saving grace is that the recent spike in trans medicalisation seems to be primarily concentrated in adolescent females (ROGD, social contagion etc.). Governments have less to fear from a cohort of infertile, underdeveloped and purposeless females driven to anti-social behaviour than they do from a cohort of infertile, underdeveloped and purposeless males.

There's no conflict between being polite and expressing yourself with creativity and individuality. Nahman isn't complaining that corporate communications require politeness (indeed, an absence of politeness would be a big red flag for an unpleasant work environment), but rather that corporate communications in the Anglosphere tends to be extremely dry and deracinated and heavily reliant on prefab canned phrases ("going forward", "if you could just circle back to me", "per my last email"). In other words, corporate drones are NPCs. Politeness isn't an inherent hallmark of robotic speech (it would be fairly trivial to make a ChatGPT knockoff which swears like a sailor), but speaking in canned phrases absolutely is, because a computer program can only do what it's instructed to.

Speaking as an extremely online weirdo who has fried his brain with a mental diet of years of image boards and social media, it really isn't that hard to make me laugh, chuckle or smile. If I scroll through my Instagram feed for ten minutes, I can reliably expect to laugh at at least one image I see, whether it's a meme or a screenshot of a tweet or a silly video. (I would say the overwhelming majority of content that makes me laugh isn't political at all.) And yet this is a bar that explicitly woke/leftist memes, jokes and standup consistently fail to meet. Oftentimes the purpose of the ostensible joke seems less about making the audience laugh (even in a supercilious "ha ha our opponents are so lame and stupid" way) than merely signalling allegiance to the cause i.e. clapter.

Not as extreme of an example as these, but perhaps relevant: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/!!!