FtttG
Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.
User ID: 1175
One possibility I haven't seen mentioned yet: the longevity of the Chinese response. Covid hawks' utopian ideal is "zero Covid" accomplished via a "short, sharp lockdown" modelled on the Chinese response - lock the entire country down completely for two weeks, no exceptions, and then we can immediately go back to normal. Any (perfectly legitimate) complaints about the ineffectiveness of lockdowns in Western nations could be handily dismissed because Real Western Lockdowns Have Never Been Tried, and if only we'd done a short, sharp lockdown like China did, this would all have been over by now.
Of course, as 2021 turned into 2022 and China was still locking down entire cities at the drop of a hat, it became increasingly hard to take these claims of the effectiveness of the Chinese approach seriously, and "zero Covid" was exposed as the obvious pipe dream it always was, one which could never be accomplished either locally or internationally. And if you recognise that zero Covid is unachievable, how can you still be a Covid hawk? It was their Leon Festinger moment, and the only hawks left are those stubbornly refusing to recognise the impossibility of "zero Covid".
Comments like these are why I come to this website.
in large measure because we didn’t have the possibility of sending millions of office workers home, and didn’t have online shopping.
And because the obesity rates in first world nations were a fraction of what they currently are, and there weren't half as many old people.
I fear the response to the pandemic has been normalised: when something like this happens again, we will shut down schools and places of free association, we will usher everyone inside their homes to look at screens all day, and we will demonise anyone pointing out the utter disaster of this policy.
This is exactly my fear, and why I get so angry when I'm talking about the insanity of lockdowns and the response is "lockdowns are over, you got what you wanted, why are you so mad?" I'll only have "got what I wanted" when the average person and average politician is definitively saying Never Again.
The Johns Hopkins meta-analysis estimated that lockdowns and other NPIs likely prevented about 0.2% of Covid deaths i.e. almost nothing. These NPIs were instated in reaction to a real threat, but they accomplished almost nothing.
Imagine Blanche DuBois from "A Streetcar Named Desire".
Haven't read it, could you explain the analogy?
Killjoy
dudes with TD
What's TD?
I don't see a reason why a study in academia couldn't be constructed that could prove or disprove a link between eating disorders and gender dysmorphia.
I think maybe you meant to say "disprove a link between eating disorders and gender dysphoria" rather than dysmorphia. I'm not challenging your assertion.
I think you may be getting confused between "gender dysphoria" and "body dysmorphia", which are related but distinct.
I think social contagion is actually a completely distinct concept from grooming. When I talk about social contagion I mean "a teenage girl starts restricting her diet/self-harming/identifying as a boy because all her friends are doing it". It's an organic undirected process.
When used metaphorically, "grooming" is more like teachers distributing literature to impressionable children which heavily implies that even banal gender nonconformance may be evidence of clinically significant gender dysphoria, and which misrepresents the efficacy of gender-affirming care.
"Social contagion" is a bit like mass hysteria. "Grooming" is recruitment. Believing that one of them is happening does not imply believing that the other is.
He made the comparison explicitly in section VI here: https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/book-review-the-geography-of-madness
I don't recall ever endorsing HBD, except if you're referring to my belief that IQ is mostly genetic rather than environmental (i.e. a descriptive stance).
Yeah, I didn't agree with all of it. He's right that the term "conspiracy theory" has vastly different connotations now than 20 years ago, but I did bristle when he described gamergate as such.
Your comment reminds me of this video about Deus Ex in which the guy talks about how much the cultural baggage around the term "conspiracy theorist" has shifted since the game's release in 2000.
Counterpoints:
- Dr. James Cantor, one of the most prominent sex researchers in North America, believes that LGBTQ+ should include the P: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/ENcjI5zX0AAIERW.jpg
- Dr Jacob Breslow was a senior figure in Mermaids, the highly influential charity for trans children in the UK, until he was outed as a pro-paedophilia advocate who has spoken in favour of paedophilia at conferences
- Peter Tatchell, one of the most famous and influential gay rights activists in the Anglosphere, supports lowering the age of consent to 14 and has waxed lyrical on more than one occasion about sexual relationships between young boys and grown men
- The usual laundry list of "trans women" arrested and/or convicted for possessing child pornography or abusing young children (e.g. https://www.bostonherald.com/2023/06/23/former-new-hampshire-state-rep-charged-with-child-pornography/, https://www.coventrytelegraph.net/news/coventry-news/coventry-activist-aimee-challenor-removed-20255359)
- The general refusal of LGBT activists anywhere to consider rowing back on the self-ID standard for women's prisons, despite clear, unambiguous evidence that the policy is being widely abused by convicted child rapists
You can be "amused" by this all you like. Beyond a certain point, acting as if people concerned about the pro-paedophilia contingent of LGBTQ+ activism are just tilting at windmills strikes me as gaslighting.
Unrelated to your post but does Signalis live up to the hype?
Apparently his initial diagnosis of schizophrenia was controversial: https://chicago.suntimes.com/2023/1/20/23559781/charles-manson-sharon-tate-psychological-study-andrew-friedman-northwestern-university
Because I'd actually bet that there's probably SOME guys out there desperate enough to take that gamble. They almost certainly exist.
A data point: I linked this article about Aileen Wuornos (the USA's most infamous female serial killer) downthread. The article mentions that as a teenager and young adult, Wuornos was a homeless alcoholic who had numerous run-ins with the law, which did not prevent her from finding a husband at the age of 20. Granted, he took out a restraining order against her a few weeks later and had the marriage annulled, but nonetheless: a homeless alcoholic future serial killer (with a series of convictions under her belt and probably suffering from undiagnosed hereditary schizophrenia) was nonetheless able to find a husband. How many men meeting that description do you think would be able to secure that deal?
Of course, India has less physical violence than the US does.
Citation needed.
I understand the logic of where male disposability came from. The point of this thread is to raise awareness of the fact that it exists at all, when most of modern feminism seems predicated on the assumption that it doesn't.
Even if we admit that male disposability in some respects may be a necessary evil for a society or tribe to effectively multiply and flourish (I recently rewatched Titanic and am 100% onboard with the Birkenhead drill: I found the sacrifice of the men travelling in first class who willingly laid down their lives that women might escape unscathed far more moving and affecting than any component of the Jack and Rose A-story), I don't think that necessarily implies the "women are wonderful effect" or hypoagency are justified. Male disposability implies that it's wrongheaded to execute a woman for capital crimes even if we would happily execute a man who committed the same crimes, fair enough. But why does male disposability imply that women cannot be held accountable for any acts of wrongdoing, why we must scramble and contrive reasons that someone (some man) other than the woman in question was at fault for the crime she freely chose to commit? The male disposability hypothesis presumes that societies are loath to kill women because they're required for child-bearing and -rearing, but isn't there an argument that a systemic refusal to hold women accountable for their decisions prevents them from learning the skills they will need to be effective child-rearers?
If post-op trans women prefer sex as a woman rather than a man, then I would consider this strong evidence that the woman's role is more enjoyable.
If autogynephilia plays as large a role in the transwoman phenomenon as many posters here believe, then an autogynephiliac trans woman in a sexual encounter is getting off as much (if not more so) on her realised fantasy of being treated as a woman as she is from the actual mechanics of the encounter. This is a massive confounder making apples-to-apples comparisons with the experiences of cis women essentially impossible.
True, although in fairness a man's intelligence is a much more durable resource than a woman's beauty.
"women are loved for who they are, men are loved for what they can provide."... "women are loved for who they are" really means is "women are loved for their looks"
That's not my read of that statement at all. I always took this to mean that a woman is loved for her intrinsic traits (of which beauty may be one, but doesn't have to be), whereas love for men is conditional on their being productive members of society. I don't just mean "love" in a romantic sense, but also platonic and familial sense. This is difficult to express and back up with hard data, but I do think it's generally much more socially acceptable for the average woman to e.g. take a "sabbatical" or "career break", move back in with her parents and not work for several months, than it would be for a man to do the same. We have a hundred derisive terms for adult men who live with their parents and stubbornly refuse to find a real job and get their shit together ("NEET", "basement dweller", "hikikomori", arguably "incel"), but the reflexive assumption is that a woman who lives with her parents and refuses to get her shit together must be "going through some stuff" or suffering from some nebulous undefined "trauma". Consider also that there's no distaff counterpart to terms like "deadbeat dad", "prodigal son" or "failson". Generally speaking, a woman who is pleasant, agreeable, talkative and amiable, but who's moved back in with her parents, hasn't worked for six months and isn't actively looking for a job is "figuring herself out"; a man who does the same is an embarrassment to the family. I don't think the situation is fundamentally different if the woman is overweight and unattractive. This, I think, is what the "woman are loved for who they are" concept is getting at.
The phenomenon I'm describing isn't just a negative one (romantic, platonic and familial love being extended to women in spite of what they refuse to do - their "sins" of omission) but also positive (their loved ones extending them love and charity in spite of what they have done). It's variously called the "women are wonderful" effect or "hypoagency" or whatever, but my general impression is that whenever a woman does something bad (including criminal offences) people will scramble to find someone or something to blame other than her. I'm racking my brains trying to think of a time I read about a woman on trial for a criminal offense and her crime wasn't attributed to self-defense/justified retribution, "mental health issues", or manipulation by a (male, obviously) third party. The idea that Ghislaine Maxwell or Elizabeth Holmes could have just done really awful things without a man coercing them to is just too unspeakable to countenance, apparently. I've even read a feminist writer attribute the murder of Sylvia Likens to crypto-feminism. It's not just talk: I think there's a large body of evidence indicating judges give vastly shorter sentences to female murderers than male. And yes, this reflexive assumption of hypoagency does not depend on the woman in question being pretty. Aileen Wuornos was no supermodel, but people were still falling over themselves to attribute her killings to justifiable retribution against would-be rapists and/or pimps, even if the evidence strongly suggested otherwise (although said kid-gloves treatment in the popular imagination did not save her from execution).
So this is my interpretation of "women are loved for who they are": women tend to be loved and respected by their families, friends and romantic partners more or less unconditionally. Crimes of omission, derelictions of duty and shortcomings will be ignored; crimes of commission will be forgiven, excused or explained away. "Pretty privilege" factors into this but is by no means dispositive (e.g. there are no "plus-size men").

Last year I was in a pub bathroom and there was a sign hanging up giving advice for gay men on how to avoid monkeypox, a disease which disproportionately affects gay men. It was full of cheerfully unambitious and undemanding suggestions like "consider using condoms" and "consider only having sex with a small social circle" (as opposed to "every willing participant you come into contact with", presumably). Nowhere did it suggest that gay men should always use condoms, or avoid having casual sex completely for their own protection until a monkeypox vaccine had been rolled out - those demands would be far too onerous to make, apparently.
It's interesting to me that you can shut down every nightclub and bar in the country (including gay bars) for months at a time in hopes of preventing the transmission of a disease (a disease which disproportionately affects people who are so old and sick that they haven't set foot in a bar or nightclub for years, but whatever) — but the idea of temporarily shutting down gay clubs to prevent the transmission of a disease which disproportionately affects gay men (thereby protecting them from serious illness) is absolutely unthinkable. In fact I think it's entirely reasonable to assume that a public official who proposed this exact policy with this exact rationale would be accused of committing a genocide against LGBT people by denying them (even temporarily) a safe space. (How "safe" is a space exactly if going there makes you far more likely to contract an infectious disease than you would otherwise?)
The selection process for which policies sit inside the Overton window seems so fickle and arbitrary.
More options
Context Copy link