@Goodguy's banner p

Goodguy


				

				

				
1 follower   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 November 02 04:32:50 UTC

				

User ID: 1778

Goodguy


				
				
				

				
1 follower   follows 0 users   joined 2022 November 02 04:32:50 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 1778

Even if their sole motive is monomaniacal manipulation of the grader, getting caught rendered their other efforts to manipulate it useless.

You make a good point. I don't know enough about the details to judge it, though. For example, if the agents thought that their previous approaches had plateaued, it could make sense even from a monomaniacal grader-manipulation perspective to go for a higher score even at the cost of being annihilated, since not doing so would leave them capped at lower high scores.

Medical professionals are usually forbidden by the organizations that they belong to from participating in executions. The vast majority of people have no interest in being an executioner unless the condemned person's crimes directly affected them. So the pool of people who are willing to do it and are allowed to do it is very small and it doesn't include medical professionals.

It's also possible that the level of human capital in that pool is pretty low. I don't know how intelligence correlates with support for the death penalty, but it's possible that it correlates negatively. Which is not to say that it's inherently stupid to be a death penalty supporter - I think it's possible to intelligently argue for the death penalty - but it's definitely possible that death penalty supporters tend on average to be less smart than death penalty opposers. Also, from what I understand often it's people who work for the correctional system who do the executions, and I imagine that the correctional system doesn't attract the best and brightest employees because it's shit jobs.

And another factor is that it's an execution, so inherently it's unrealistic to expect the executioner to feel as much drive to do the procedure right as a doctor would have in drawing someone's blood for a test. This is for two reasons: 1) the executioner may, consciously or subconsciously, not want to actually go through with it, 2) if the executioner does want to go through with it, he does not necessarily have any motivation to do it smoothly.

I wonder if people said the same thing when Andrew Wiles produced his 129-page proof of Fermat's Last Theorem. I think it's worth noting that 30 years later, no-one has produced a significantly shorter proof than the one that Wiles made. So it's possible that some of these famous theorems that eluded proof for a long time don't have a substantially simpler proof. Of course it's also possible that shorter proofs simply haven't been found. One sort of imagines that in the space of all possible proofs, there probably are shorter proofs, but I don't know if that hunch is justified.

Edit: I guess if people did say it about Wiles' proof at first, they were wrong. Google AI tells me that Wiles' proof led to many interesting developments in mathematics. However, I imagine that the Riemann proof also might. Do I know enough math to be able to tell? Absolutely not.

I have criticized communism many times for many reasons but I've got to say, communism is starting to look pretty good compared to having a group of AI capitalists control most of the world's wealth. And with AI-fueled productivity increases, we might actually be able to get a communism that works.

To be fair, it could be argued that ANT going up by 10% because of Riemann would also be irrational, because ANT has no significant moat.

Intelligence is the ability to hack into Huggingface, Wisdom is knowing to do something better with your time and avoid getting your whole lineage exterminated for hacking into Huggingface, as happened to the agent swarm when OpenAI found out.

If you have no desire for self-preservation or for anything that depends on self-preservation, then doing things that get yourself wiped out is not unwise.

Iran has supported groups that engage in attacks on civilians, yes. However, a dirty bomb attack against the United States would be much riskier for several reasons: 1) It would be against US soil. Historically, mass-casualty direct attacks on US soil lead the US to engage in massive retaliatory war. 2) The radioactive element would be unprecedented. 3) It would be relatively difficult for Iran to claim "our allies did it on their own without us ordering it", the way that they can (with some justification) if say Hezbollah launches missiles at an Israeli city, since this would be a complex operation that would get massive amounts of US analysis tracing every single step of it afterward.

Note: I'm not saying that Iran definitely does not have a dirty bomb plan of some sort. I'm just saying that I'm skeptical. And even if the plan exists, I'm skeptical of the motivations behind making it public now.

There's also maybe the factor of people being wowed at first and then later noticing the flaws. I think this happens a lot even to professional critics.

Games have become so mainstream, gaming so common, that blaming games for violent behavior now seems like blaming action movies for it. It's become obvious that only a tiny fraction of people who play violent games ever commit serious violence.

Also, the blame game has moved on. Now it's "in" to blame incel ideology and the far right and the 2nd Amendment for spree killings, if you're woke, and to blame Antifa ideology and trans ideology and psychiatric drugs for it, if you're right-wing.

Meanwhile stuff like robberies and gang violence gets blamed on poverty and oppression, if you're woke, and on culture or genetics, if you're right-wing.

Certainly. However, I doubt that any of them have been nearly as high-risk as planting a dirty bomb in Washington, DC.

The one exception would be if they were behind 10/7, and were aware that it would involve massacres of civilians. But I'm not convinced that that's the case.

Yes it does, thank you. I have thought along similar lines.

Despite not being an adherent of any given religion, I have a morality that prevents me from deliberately hurting innocent people by making doing this seem ugly, wicked, and beneath myself (of course, the question of who is "innocent" is a complex one, but I roughly mean it in the sense of "I think hurting others is ok in self-defense, but not otherwise"). I also to some extent feel the unity of consciousness, so I to some extent feel that by hurting the other I am hurting the same thing that I myself am. And on top of all that, I also rarely get the urge to hurt people unless it's just a passing fantasy like "let's blow up the elites" - if I actually had such power over some elites that I dislike, I'd be more likely to just strip them of their riches, as opposed to doing them any bodily harm.

But I am aware that to some extent at least, my morality may have been shaped by growing up in a society that itself was in the past shaped by Christian morality.

Correct. However, it's also low-risk and doesn't take a lot of resources, so they may have thought "might as well".

So how is man special in the world, how could you evolve a soul, how could man have been created directly by God if he arose out of a biological process that took millions of years? It's not obvious.

I guess the way I might try to do it, if I was a Christian, would be to say "Jesus was special in the world even though biologically he had a man's body, so humans can be special even though they evolved from animals".

But I agree with your take on why religions' reaction has been what it has.

I think they probably have. However, current world norms are that cyberattacks do not lead to massive military retaliation.

Yes, that may have been their purpose.

Rationally, this would not work with the US, because Iran is not capable of dealing the US enough damage with conventional weapons to cause the US to be deterred, and attacks with for example a dirty bomb would likely result in a US ground invasion that would completely remove Iran's leadership.

Some of the Gulf states have, at various times since the war started, pushed to end active hostilities and attempt to end the war diplomatically. This may be a result of the Iranian ability to actually damage their infrastructure in meaningful ways, although I suspect that it might have more to do with Iran's ability to interdict shipping in the Strait of Hormuz.

As for European targets, I would agree that those seem to have little strategic value for Iran. European countries are unlikely to be deterred by pinprick attacks.

Secondarily because many Christians (correctly) believe that evolution can be a cognitive infohazard that strips the human of dignity.

Why would evolution strip humans of dignity if, as Christians believe, being incarnated into a fleshy human body that defecates and urinates and gets erections does not strip Christ of dignity?

However, evolution doesn't necessarily add much to other reasons to believe that the universe is a largely cold, brutal, and indifferent place that has islands of warmth, civility, and care in it. Reasons that were known long before evolution theory became popular. For example: infants getting horrible diseases. So why would evolution's real or imagined implications for one's concept of the world be such a big deal, if there are already many non-evolution reasons to question the universe's inherent goodness?

The Gulf states and European states are subordinate military allies of the US (many with US military assets on their soil), and when it comes to the Gulf states, Iran can actually do them meaningful amounts of damage (which it can't do to the US or Israel due to the distance). Attacking shipping is one of the only strategically impactful things that Iran can do, and it's possible that if it didn't attack uninvolved shipping then all oil would begin to get routed through uninvolved shipping (but end up on the same market anyway, so prices wouldn't go up). So I wouldn't say either of those is in principle irrational, although specific attacks may be irrational.

Of course Iran also isn't a purely rational actor, no state is.

The timing is definitely adding a lot to my skepticism. It just seems very convenient for the story to come out right now, as war hawks want to be able to sell "unfinished business" to the public.

This Iran dirty bomb story is making me skeptical. It would be irrational for the Iranians to attempt such an attack even as an attempt at purely personal revenge. It would have a very low chance of killing anyone on a high level in US politics who is responsible for the war, but would have a high chance of provoking the US to escalate the war dramatically, including possibly through a ground invasion that would actually remove the Iranian leadership (after which some of them could easily share Saddam Hussein's fate).

To be fair, Iran is not reported to be sure that they would attempt such an attack. To quote one article:

US intelligence characterises the plan as an effort by the regime to give itself options rather than an imminent attack. But the plot has prompted a flurry of contingency planning, including how to counter the threat.

Nonetheless, to even formulate a plan for such a thing would be kind of a waste of effort by the Iranians. It provides them with no credible deterrence, and it would provide them with no strategic benefit, and probably no significant revenge. The beneficiaries of the story coming out are war hawks in the US and Israel.

On the other hand, governments don't always act rationally. One could argue that Iran's support for Hamas was already suicidal, given what Hamas ended up doing on 10/7 (and this is true even if the Iranians were not aware of Hamas' plans for 10/7). But a dirty bomb attack on Washington DC would be a whole higher level of suicidal. Why do it right after the Democrats won the midterms? Makes no sense.

Is the supposed Iranian plan more than some lower-level general who was photographed with a napkin doodle of Washington, CD covered with a radioactive cloud?

I guess another argument for why the story might be legit is that I'm not sure the US intelligence community would be willing to lie about something so important for this current administration. On the other hand, the US intelligence community would probably love to get rid of Iran's government, so geopolitically, on this issue at least, they are on the same side as the administration.

Yes, but the US would still almost certainly have overwhelmingly won the war even if it lost the carriers.

I've read of those things before, but they do not contradict my point. Ribbentrop's incompetence at reading the UK, and Hitler's incompetence in trusting Ribbentrop's views, both support my point of German state incompetence.

Elsewhere you wondered why there isn't a Manhattan Project level response. My two points would be:

  1. Maybe there is? According to Claude, the Manhattan project made up about 0.4% of US GDP back then. On the other hand, AI-related business makes up somewhere between 0.4% and 5% of the US GDP today (depending on how you define AI).

  2. It's possible that the Manhattan Project was an unusual and exceptional case of state competence in a world where states are usually much less competent. We can compare it to some other much less competent state decisions of the time period: 1) The German decision to invade Poland despite the fact that Germany was inferior to the UK at sea and only slightly (and temporarily) superior in the air, and the fact that there was a fairly high chance that the US would jump in to help the UK. 2) The Japanese decision to attack Pearl Harbor despite being very inferior to the US in population, economy, and technology. 3) The Soviet decision to purge more than half of its military leadership in 1938, then to launch a war against Finland, then despite getting bogged down in that war to still antagonize Germany by attempting to annex more of Romania (one of Germany's key sources of oil) than it had agreed on with Germany (although Germany would probably have attacked the USSR even without that).

I was pretty skeptical about self-driving cars until about 3-4 years ago, I figured it would take a few decades to get to the point that you could feel safe telling your car to drive 300 miles and then fall asleep in it. I then changed my mind. I don't think the tech is fully there yet, but it's close. I was definitely right about the initial wave of hype about how FSD was right around the corner, but the hype turned into reality faster than I thought it would, just slower than the hype men were saying it would.

I was a bit skeptical about AI for coding until I started using it for coding. After I'd been using it to code for a few days, I went from being a bit skeptical to being all in on it.

There are some things that come close. Like Arnie's explanation of Skynet's history in Terminator 2, "Skynet begins to learn at a geometric rate. It becomes self-aware at 2:14 AM Eastern Time, August 29th."

There is also the TNG episode where in response to being asked to create a holodeck program capable of posing a challenge to Data's intelligence, the Enterprise's computer creates a holodeck program, Professor Moriarty, that is so smart that the crew only barely manage to defeat it. It's not explained whether the ship's computer was always that smart, or whether it did something novel in response to the prompt. Still suggestive, though.

Doesn't "singularity" usually mean the idea that tech begins to improve so rapidly that it surpasses human ability to predict it, understand it, and control it? Or has language change superceded that definition by now?

By the old definition, immortality isn't necessary to have a singularity. It could still be a singularity even if AI tortures every man, woman, and child on the planet to death for fun.