JeSuisCharlie
Sumner, Hebdo, Kirk
Formerly "SandwichWarrior" and "The Upright Man", may or may not be feral, is most certainly quixotic.
User ID: 4009
But it seems that people think "victim" must mean "innocent."
When you say that someone is a "victim" of something you are saying that their situation is not one of choice but rather something that has been inflicted or forced upon them. This is why there is a taboo against victim blaming.
Decarlos Brown can not be both "a victim" by the common understanding of the word, and responsible. This begs the question; If Brown is not responsible, who is?
Ok, but then what should be done? Who should be held responsible for the killing of Iryna Zarutska?
What does it mean for Decarlos Brown to be a "victim of circumstance"?
Would you support charging whoever it was who decided to release Brown after the 14th time he'd been arrested with reckless endangerment and negligent homicide?
Brown is clearly not in the drivers seat of his life
Just so that there is no misunderstanding, do you believe that Brown not being "in the drivers seat of his life" should absolve him of responsibility?
I'm not trying to suggest that Trump is anywhere in the same league as Lincoln, but it is interesting how closely the contemporary complaints about Lincoln and the nascent Republican movement mirror those about Trump and MAGA today.
He is shrill. He is crass, He is uncultured. He is not even a proper gentleman, he is a backwoods bumpkin who grew up in a log shack. Electing him would be an insult to the institution of the presidency, and make an already tense situation worse.
Republicans in turn would point to the Caning of Charles Sumner and the ongoing civil unrest in the Kansas and Missouri territories claiming that the Democrats have shown zero interest in reigning in their violent fringe while the Whigs care more about losing gracefully while getting fat off the public trough than they do tackling the serious problems facing the nation.
I imagine there is an alternate timeline where moderate Democrats did more to police their extremists or the Whigs showed more spine and as a result Abraham Lincoln never became president. Is that the better timeline? I do not know.
As I said during the whole Charlie Kirk thing...
I do not know we will see a second American Civil War in the next 5 - 10 years but If we do, I imagine that future historians will draw parallels between the killing of Charlie Kirk in 2025 and the Caning of Charles Sumner by Preston Brooks in 1856. As bad as the act itself was, being seen celebrating it is what did the real damage to the social fabric.
- Prev
- Next

I'm trying to explain to you why people naturally infer that victim must mean innocent.
More options
Context Copy link