@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

Wickard was a federalism case, not a natural rights case. It concerned which government had the authority to decide whether you could grow grain on your own property to feed to your own horses. A state law doing the same thing would have been constitutional, but probably ineffective given the nature of the national economy, under founding-era jurisprudence. (It might have been ruled unconstitutional under Lochner-era jurisprudence, but we now consider Lochner anticanonical for good reasons.)

As a separate issue, the law at issue in Wickard was a stupid law. But there are non-stupid laws which regulate the growing of your own grain on your own land to feed your own horses, like a law restricting stubble burning. The law pre-Wickard was that a state government could ban stubble burning, but the feds couldn't.

Yeah but having America on your side is basically cheating, isn’t it? A massive country with immense resources surrounded by oceans, and founded explicitly as a liberal nation? What if America never existed, or was a much smaller nation the size of say, New Zealand? Then we would all be saying the same thing except it would be fascism (or communism) which is the most “evolutionary fit” ideology

The British won the 19th century for Liberalism without those advantages.

The 20th century is slightly harder. Can the British Empire and USSR win WW2 if the USA is a nothingburger? Without nukes, probably not (it's closer than the American schoolboy view of history would suggest), but in that world most of the refugee scientists who staffed the Manhattan Project end up in Canada so all we actually need to do is to hold out until we get the Bomb in 1945/6. If the USA exists as it does in our timeline but Pearl Harbor doesn't happen, I am reasonably confident that the UK/USSR can win the war without nukes with the US as a sympathetic neutral and, again, we eventually get nukes.

Consider the book Nineteen Eighty-Four. Orwell proposed a theory of history where, from time to time, the middle class overthrows the upper class with the help of the proletariat.

The "Middle" in Emmanuel Goldstein's Theory and Practice of Oligarchical Collectivism isn't the middle class - it is a potential counter-elite (like the Bolsheviks and their base in the organised working class and the army). Goldstein explicitly says that there is no Middle in Oceania because the regime has successfully prevented a Middle arising - my reading is that Orwell intended it to be obvious that the Outer Party are part of the Low who are fake-promoted in order to compromise them sufficiently to allow them to do particular kinds of dirty work for the regime (such as Winston Smith's day job falsifying history). To use the language of Ribbonfarm's Gervais Principle, the Outer Party in general and Winston Smith in particular (Julia slightly less so) are Clueless.

I think there are some similarities to the current situation. 2024 can be seen as a revolution of the middle class tech elite against the upper class deep state.

The tech right isn't the middle-class - it's a relatively small number of billionaires with massively powerful platforms. As Orwell/Goldstein points out, they are a counter-elite, a true Middle who threaten the High. And its story is consistent with one of the two ways of a Middle appearing that Orwell/Goldstein point out - a Middle can split off from the High if a faction of the elite become disgruntled, or from the Low if a newly important class is excluded from power. Musk and Andreesen were absolutely part of the elite in 2015 - we can argue about why they became disgruntled enough to join a movement throwing rocks at the system they had done so well out of, but they clearly did.

The link between Orwell's Middle and the middle class is that the social changes driven by the Industrial Revolution means that there are true Middles arising from the Low consistently from the 18th to the 20th centuries which the High need to co-opt to stay in power. This isn't just the classical merchant bourgeoisie - in many ways it is the class of educated technicians like artillery officer Napoleon Bonaparte that is more dangerous (this is the group which right-populists call the PMC and which Richard Hanania calls elite human capital). Orwell writes about this class as a potential tool to overthrow both the traditional elite and the merchant bourgeoisie in the context of WW2 in The Lion and the Unicorn

Possible essay prompt for someone good at wrangling an LLM: "Compare and contrast how Napoleon Bonaparte and Elon Musk parlayed the ability to land a large rocket on a small target into supreme political power."

withdrew

It's a Russel conjugation - I withdraw, you run away, he is routed.

My understanding is that, although the people's of Europe were divided by religion, they were still WEIRD in the modern sense. They were fighting for their own universalist religions, not for their clans. They were wars of ideas, rather than of peoples.

The most important intra-European religious conflicts in my lifetime have been in former Yugoslavia and Northern Ireland. In both cases religion was very obviously a proxy for tribal identity, not a religious thing. Unfortunately this doesn't answer the question, because they both happened in transHajnal Europe.

It is, of course, the whole point that religious conflict in cisHajnal Europe is unheard of, except in so far as it involves immigrants from transHajnal places.

Absolutely - although it is the kind of fraud you are not going to catch at the point of disbursement because the frauds are more sophisticated than that.

The snarky view is that the reason DOGE isn't going after Medicare fraud is that Vivek Ramaswamy was planning to do an awful lot of it with Roviant's bogus Alzheimer's drugs. FWIW, I don't think this is true - if there was fraud at Roviant it was Theranos-style fraud on the investors, who have lost a lot more than Medicare on the whole sorry affair.

I'm British - when I insult the French military record I am strictly trolling. I know you've been holding us to a roughly even record over the last 1000 years, you snail-eating sexual deviants.

We do have a better record against Afghanistan than the USA or the USSR, given that we did beat them at least once. But an honest appraisal of the military leadership of the British Empire is that we were off our game in the mid-19th century due to the lack of serious competition - the first Anglo-Afghan War was an embarassing defeat and the Crimean War and Indian Mutiny were unimpressive victories against weak opposition.

Seriously, I think the point about both Vietnam and the more recent Afghan War is that the US can lose a war despite overwhelming military force if they don't know what victory looks like it. The Powell doctrine (and the general state of opinion in the US armed forces which it reflects) is anti-Clausewitzian, in the sense that Clausewitz says that "War is the continuation of politics by other means" whereas Powell says that once you have started a war you should forget about politics and single-mindedly pursue victory, defined as defeating the enemy. The failure in Vietnam was that the US's political goals weren't to defeat the North Vietnamese in South Vietnam (which they did, repeatedly) - or to defeat the North Vietnamese in North Vietnam (which they didn't want to do given the wider political situation viz-a-viz the USSR) - it was to build a South Vietnam that could defend itself. The failure in Afghanistan appears to be that the US never had the foggiest idea what its political goals were beyond punishing the Taliban for supporting OBL. So having an overwhelming military advantage and beating your chest and saying "I am the hegemon" doesn't actually mean that you can get what you want.

It is part of the Executive Branch, it just isn't part of the State Department. The Administrator of USAID was a senate-confirmed political appointee in the same way as other senior Executive Branch officers.

The reason not to take DOGE seriously was the Musk was saying all the normal things that people who are not serious about spending cuts say, including starting with foreign aid, using headcount reductions as a proxy for spending reductions, talking about waste/fraud/abuse without specifics, and insisting that there is a lot more fraud in simple well-run programmes like Social Security than there actually is.

Most US federal government spending is Medicare, Medicaid, Social Security, debt interest, and the military. Medicaid is mostly block-granted to the states. Social Security and debt interest are about cutting checks to people who are legally entitled to them, so levels of waste and fraud are very low. So if you are talking about cutting waste/fraud/abuse without talking about Medicare or the military, I am going to think you are a bullshitter.

Last time out, Trump surrendered to the Taliban. He should probably have hired the French to give his successor surrendering lessons, because Biden badly botched the implementation of the surrender agreement.

I am going to withhold judgement on whether this makes the United States a super-hegemon.

Looking at a combination of size, strength, and controlled aggression, Rhodesian Ridgebacks are some of the most badass dogs I have met. But I wouldn't want to own one.

If Musk has rooted the Fiscal Service, then he has the operational ability to block payments unilaterally, regardless of whether or not that is legal.

I don't know if he is planning to do this (the benign story where Musk only wants read access is also plausible), but I have no doubt that the administration has wargamed at least some scenarios which involve breaking the law and daring anyone to stop them, and refusing to make legally-required payments as a negotiating tactic is something both the Trump organisation and Musk's Twitter used as something close to SOP.

The ricin-injector umbrella was very much real (one of the scientists involved in the investigation taught me at Cambridge) and used by the Bulgarians to assassinate Georgi Markov in London. A KGB defector later told us the unsurprising fact that the Soviets built it for the Bulgarians.

I don't think Canadian government policy towards drug cartels depends on whether it calls them terrorists or not. The way you deal with a sophisticated, wealthy, armed criminal organisation that you actually care about stopping is the same way you deal with a sophisticated, wealthy terrorist organisation that you actually care about stopping.

If I had time to train them before the SHTF, a female Rottie.

The well-trained Rottie bitches I have met have been the sweetest, most caring, best behaved dogs I have had the good fortune to spend time around. I didn't piss them off, and I don't want to know what would have happened if I had done, but I am well aware that some ne'er-do-well who threatens the owner's family is going to piss the Rottie off, and have a bad day as a result.

I don't know how much harder it is to train a male Rottie, but I haven't met one I felt entirely safe around.

Congressional action isn't needed to create roles in the Executive Office of the President that are not "Officers of the United States". Musk could do most of what DOGE is doing legally as a Special Assistant to the President, but he isn't one, he is just a private citizen who Trump has told his top political appointees to share information with.

First, DOGE is part of government (read the EO)

The DOGE created by the executive order is a beefed-up Government digital service, which sits in the EOP, and is headed by a United States DOGE Service Administrator who is an EOP employee reporting directly to the White House Chief of Staff. The job of this DOGE is to co-ordinate the activity of the DOGE teams set up in individual agencies (consisting of agency employees who formally report to the agency head, but have a dotted line to DOGE), with a particular focus on software interoperability. The executive order explicitly doesn't transfer any of the authority of the Office of Management and Budget to DOGE, so as far as I can see DOGE has no authority to block spending.

Even from my mostly Trump-sceptic point of view, DOGE is a good idea, and making Elon Musk the public face of it and giving him some suitable advisory role will make it more effective, as well as making it easier to pull in someone first-class from a private-sector tech company for the crucial full-time role of DOGE Service Administrator.

Elon Musk is not an employee of the EOP reporting to the White House Chief of Staff (and couldn't be while continuing to hold his private-sector jobs), and if the post of United States DOGE Service Administrator has been filled by someone else, this fact has not been publicised. The media is reporting that the people working with Musk on @DOGE are not government employees either, and are mostly still being paid by Musk-owned companies. So the @DOGE that is shutting down USAID and rooting the Fiscal Service is not the DOGE of the EO.

I can't comment on what @DOGE is doing because they aren't saying, but given that USAID and the Fiscal Service were set up by Congress it is probably illegal and definitely irregular.

Canada didn't capitulate. They reannounced the same $1.3 billion border security package they already announced in December, allowing Trump to declare victory.

Trump got the same deal by going full psycho that he already got by speaking quietly and carrying a big stick, except that some of the backchat from the noise he was making cost his pal Elon a $100 million Ontario government contract.

On a scale of kayfabe where SpaceX is 0 and WWE is 100, the Canada/Mexico tariff rows have been about 80, and the Colombia row north of 90.

Did he give any examples of these fraudulent and terrorist transactions?

Musk falsely identified payments made before 20th Jan 2025 to Lutheran Family Services for their work on legal Biden administration refugee resettlement programmes as "these illegal payments", but otherwise no.

The @DOGE team discovered, among other things, that payment approval officers at Treasury were instructed always to approve payments, even to known fraudulent or terrorist groups.

They literally never denied a payment in their entire career.

Not even once.

The main job of the US Fiscal Service (the agency of the US Treasury that Musk and his staff have rooted) is to make payments which have been authorised by other parts of the government. Given Musk is tweeting first and asking questions later, what he almost certainly means here is that (for example) when the SSA tells the Fiscal Service who to pay Social Security benefits to retirees, the Fiscal Service doesn't run any additional checks beyond the ones already run by the SSA. In the case of Social Security, this is obviously the right thing to do - the government should be paying Social Security to otherwise-eligible retirees who are suspected terrorists. It's not just a good idea, it's the law. Whether the Fiscal Service should be acting as a second line of defence to deny payment if e.g. the Department of Defence contracts with a local ally who might be a terrorist is a legitimate question about how to organise the government, with "no" being a perfectly reasonable answer.

There are two plausible stories for what is going on here:

  • The benign one is that Musk got read-only access to the database, which he wanted because downloading the entire database of US government disbursements (including payee, date, amount, and source of authorisation) is the easiest way to do what he wants to do with @DOGE (as opposed to the DOGE established by Trump's executive order, which is something else) and the Fiscal Service was the easiest way to get the data.

  • The malign one is that Musk wants to control the Fiscal Service because Musk and/or Trump are planning to cut spending at the bill is paid, not the point where the expense is incurred. (This is consistent with the way Trump ran the Trump organisation until he tanked his credit rating, and is also something Musk did at Twitter). A world where (even if an invoice is approved for payment by the government department who bought the thing) @DOGE is arbitrarily blocking payments because they don't like the politics of the payee is a world where nobody competent will want to contract with the government. And if the same stunt is pulled with Social Security payments, federal payroll, or heaven forfend bond interest, the results are catastrophic. Trump and Musk are reckless enough, and Trump has joked about defaulting on the debt, so I can't rule out the possibility that the plan is to default on the federal debt, and that taking control of the Fiscal Service is the way to forestall a legal challenge.

If Wikipedia is correct about the scale and scope of the Mexican Drug War, sending 10,000 extra troops to the border (which is the only concession announced) is a pretty meaningless concession - there are already 300,000 plus Mexican troops involved in fighting the drug cartels, and Mexico's interest in defeating them is stronger than America's. (If the Mexicans are deliberately tanking said fight because the cartels have bought Sheinbaum, then sending 10,000 extra troops to the border won't change this).

Two obvious possibilities for what went on on the call:

  1. Sheinbaum turned on the flattery, and Trump agreed to delay tariffs for a month with the expectation that he can have another phonecall in a month's time where she announces another trivial concession, he tells his supporters that his tough policy achieved a massive concession, and the process can continue indefinitely to mutual benefit in domestic political terms. (cf the kayfabe row with Colombia)
  2. Sheinbaum successfully pointed out that a total breakdown in relationships between the US and Mexico would hurt his political position fairly directly because the US relies on Mexican co-operation to police the border, and a short term bounce in immigration would make Trump look bad.

Given the size of the market rallies (and in particular the MXN rally) on the announcement, financial markets do not expect tariffs on Mexico to come back in a month's time, and almost certainly don't expect any kind of voluntary arrangement that would materially curtail Mexican exports to the US.

America's main source of competitive advantage is software*. Making software is literally symbol manipulation.

Arguably America's second-largest source of competitive advantage is logistics, which is real-world-aligned, but doesn't have the mythopoetic status of manufacturing in real-world-aligned culture, and in any case naturally encourages people towards cosmopolitanism and has done since the Age of Sail, if not earlier. (Walmart and Amazon are the leading examples of American excellence in logistics, as well as notoriously harmful to local communities.)

Compared to resource extraction, manufacturing, or even tourism (where the local sense of place is part of what you are selling), software and logistics are about unmoored, placeless economic activity. This is true both of the doing of the thing, and of the type of financial services that finance the doing of the thing - financialisation is not the problem here. When America was a physical-things country, you had community banks which were as embedded in their community as the general store, and which financed farms and factories and such-like, and you had money-centre banks like JP Morgan which financed railroads and shipping.

* America's trillion-dollar companies and their core competencies are:

  1. Apple (software, industrial design)
  2. Nvidia (designing and marketing chips which are made in Taiwan, although some insiders say the secret sauce is actually software)
  3. Microsoft (software, being evil and getting away with it)
  4. Amazon (software, logistics)
  5. Alphabet (software)
  6. Meta (software)
  7. Tesla (cars and solar panels, but the current stock market valuation assumes a pivot to software)
  8. Broadcom (designing and marketing chips which are mostly made in Taiwan)
  9. Berkshire Hathaway (insurance, arguably logistics)

None of these are going to promote rooted capitalism, and none of them would promote rooted socialism if State-owned either.

Trump's tariffs are a tax on Americans who consume imported physical goods, and American manufacturers who use imported intermediate inputs. The class who mostly consume expensive real estate and their own sense of moral superiority will be relative winners.

but there are some cities in Europe now where, if I go outside, I am mostly among young men who are dressed and act to signal capacity for violence, have strong ingroup bias among themselves, and communicate (often exclusively) in languages that I have little to no knowledge of.

I do not think this is true at the level of "cities" anywhere in Europe*. There are definitely neighborhoods it applies to - particularly for me in the UK as an RP speaker with no understanding of Geordie, Scouse and other similar languages spoken by violent sub-groups of the indigenous population in the chavlands, which are considerably more dangerous than the so-called "no-go zones" of Tower Hamlets.

I am told that there is a small number of cities in the United States where this phenomenon is true across most of the city - again due to a violent subgroup of the indigenous population that speaks a barely-intercomprehensible dialect. And yes I am talking about Ebonics.

* Malmo is the most Islamised city in Europe, and is roughly 1/3 Muslim, and (separately - there are Swedish-born Muslims and non-Muslim immigrants) 2/3 Swedish-born. I am prepared to defer to anyone who has actually spent more than a few days there as to whether this is enough that a majority of neighbourhoods fit 4bpp's criterion.

If she's a MAGA-pilled red tribe American living in London, she is around the 95th percentile of non-Muslim immigrants here in terms of how hostile to British values she is and how dangerous she would be as a potential fifth column.

If she is an American who cheerfully voted for Trump as the lesser of two evils despite the obvious red flags, then having her as a citizen would be mildly negative for British culture and society because right-wing populists being useful idiots for bad actors like Johnson have done a lot more damage to the UK than non-Muslim immigrants. But I suspect her economic contribution more than compensates for that.