@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

As in the US, the system is more worried about the types of abuse noncustodial fathers might commit than the types of abuse an involved noncustodial father might prevent.

The fathers who were arrested were arrested for violating court orders enforcing the mother's custody - up to and including violating restraining orders taken out by mothers claiming domestic violence (being the sort of man who rescues his daughter from a dangerous rape gang is somewhat correlated with being the sort of man who would attract credible DV allegations).

given Liberalism and Marxism joined forces on the most destructive war in human history

I know arguing this kind of point with SecureSignals is flogging a dead horse, but the point he is making is one of the Big Lies of schoolboy history, so I will make an exception.

Marxism didn't join forces with Liberalism to stop Hitler. Marxism (or at least Stalin's USSR) allied with Hitler to destroy Liberalism, and ended up allied with the UK and USA by accident after Hitler double-crossed them. This forms part of a pattern of interwar Soviet policy where all non-Communist forces are treated as roughly equally hostile-by-default.

Orwell in Animal Farm has Napoleon decide between Frederick and Pilkington based on pure calculation. This is a better model of Stalin's policy (which was based on a realpolitik assessment of the USSR's interests) than a story where he was trying to work out whether liberal capitalism or fascism was less anti-Marxist.

The position of the not-coincidentally now-defunct political tradition that claimed that feudalism and chivalry were worth preserving was simpler. Throne-and-altar (or Protestant equivalent) conservatives from Papen to Quisling lined up to be useful idiots for Hitler, frequently betraying their countries to do so.

Western blacks who convert to Islam in prison (not sure if this is the case here, but it seems quite likely) generally didn't pick up the internally consistent version of Islam. Batshit crazy is a better model than smart-evil or intellectually-coherent-but-wrong for that group.

No - it was an academic journal article. But based on the free intro, Kulak is making the same point.

The performance of the Royal Navy did improve after Admiral Byng was shot. I remember reading an academic article making the argument that this was causal - that the knowledge that you would have to fight even against the odds changed the way that captains trained their crews and planned engagements. One difference the article pointed out was that British doctrine favoured engaging from upwind (which gives you superior mobility and allows you to determine the pace of the engagement) whereas French doctrine favoured engaging from downwind (which gives you better chances of successfully running away if that is what you later decide to do).

There is also the point that shooting Admiral Byng made harsh naval discipline a lot more tolerable to the men who suffered it.

"Nothing is so good for the morale of the troops as occasionally to see a dead general".

Field Marshal Slim

"It makes no difference which side the general is on".

Unknown British Soldier

What I mean is that the noisy left sound like they support open borders, and that it sure looks to the average man-in-the-street (certainly in the UK, the US, and most of Western Europe, though not as far as I can see in Australia, or Canada before Trudeau fucked things up) as though the current immigration policy is de facto open borders through deliberately ineffective enforcement.

The median voter does not support open borders, either de facto or de jure, and so the immigration debate when both sides are talking to the median voter is about trying to credibly claim not to support the status quo. The actual substance of a sane immigration policy is less relevant. Telling people that you want to kick out their immigrant friends/colleagues generally goes down like a lead balloon with people who are close to the median voter on the left/right axis.

I don't think the median voter understands immigration numbers. If you focus-group the question of which legal immigrants we should kick out, the answer you get in the UK is basically "violent Muslims" and not much else. Dominic Cummings says that moving to an Australian/Canadian points system (which would not mean a large drop in overall numbers) is hugely popular in the UK. There are definitely people who don't like using European immigrants for seasonal agricultural labour, but they are closer to the typical Tory/Reform switcher than to the median voter. (Before mass immigration, Ireland was poor enough that the Irish did a lot of migrant work in the UK, and they don't really count as foreign.)

No path to citizenship in the Gulf monarchies. "Lots" as in two of my British classmates spent multiple years working in the Gulf (one as a petroleum geologists, the other as an accountant). My current employer has a Dubai office staffed entirely by PMC immigrants.

Anecdotally, permanent residence (usually after 5 years) and citizenship (after 10 years) are pretty automatic for skilled migrants in Singapore, although Brits working there often don't take them up because it exposes your kids to the draft. There are about 500k non-citizen permanent residents in Singapore out of a population of 6 million, and the vast majority of them entered as skilled migrants or dependents of skilled migrants.

Both Vote Leave (Cummings, with Johnson as figurehead) and Leave.EU (Farage) made blaming the EU for specifically Muslim immigration a crucial part of their message. Cummings continues to insist (plausibly, given how close things were) that the Brexit referendum could not have been won without the "Turkey is joining the EU and then millions of Turks will come to the UK" lie. Cummings was also quite frank (on his blog during the period where he was out of UK politics) that "Get rid of the Eastern Europeans", while popular with core Brexit supporters, would have been a losing message with swing voters.

The debate between "near-zero immigration" and "continued mass migration but managed competently in the interests of the existing population" (at least in the UK, described as a "Canadian or Australian-style points system") is an intra-right one, not a battle for the median voter. From the point of view of the median voter, the immigration issue is closer to "nobody is illegal open borders extremists should be kicked out of the Overton window yesterday".

Dubai and Singapore have lots of middle-class immigrants too. They get treated better so they don't read as "migrant workers", but that is what they are.

Most of the Gulf monarchies (not sure if Dubai still works this way, but it did when a family member did a lot of business there) are societies where citizens have cushy government jobs and all the real work - blue and white-collar - is done by migrants.

Singapore is a crowded city-state where citizens get subsidised housing and middle-class immigrants pay market rate.

When Roger Bannister ran a 4-minute mile he cheesed the rule against pacesetters by organising a special exhibition race where two other competitors functioned as pacesetters. One ran the first half-mile at 4-minute pace and then slowed down, the other jogged until he was almost lapped, and then ran the rest of the race a lap down at 4-minute pace.

Having a pacesetter run slightly ahead of you at the speed you need to maintain makes a huge psychological difference, even if you don't draft behind them.

Random question about US history - when did US high school and college sport become driven by semi-professional spectator sport? In the British schools which take team sports seriously (now mostly the more trad private schools, admittedly) the core of "Games" was and still is ubiquitous intramural competition, with the unathletic kids expected and supported to participate at their level. And if there were enough pitches, an external match would include "B" and "C" teams so as many kids as possible could participate extramurally. But school matches normally happened on games afternoons when the people who were not playing would be competing intramurally - not spectating. Typically most of the spectators at a British school football game would be the parents of the players.

Certainly there exist societies(eg, in eastern Europe) with short courtships and very high divorce rates simultaneously.

Also Red Tribe America. Marriage in Arkansas is like voting in Illinois - you do it early and often.

???

Britain doesn't think they have a US bailout in 1914. (The possibility doesn't come up until the Germans take up U-boat warfare.) All sides are expecting a war of maneuver similar to the Franco-Prussian war ended by a decisive battle within less than a year, which is a timescale where the US can't make a difference at all.

Regardless of who was influencing Britain in August 1914, we didn't start WW1 and couldn't have stopped it - based on the sequence of events in August 1914, the decision to fight is taken primarily by Russia and Germany, not Britain and France. Germany decides to go to war with Russia as a result of events following the Sarajevo assassination, and invades Russia's ally (France) first for tactical reasons. At the point where the British get to make a decision, it is a decision whether to join in the war or sit it out - German troops have already crossed the French border. You can claim that the French only go to war because they are expecting a British bailout (and had they had a choice, you would probably have been right), but France didn't get a choice in August 1914 either - they were invaded by Germany. Their choice had been taken when the Franco-Russian Alliance was signed in 1894, at a time when Britain was still (genuinely) neutral between the German-Austrian and Franco-Russian blocs.

If Britain doesn't join the Franco-Russian bloc, it isn't clear how this makes WW1 less likely. The basic logic that the decline of the Ottoman Empire was going to turn the Balkans into a zone of Great Power conflict was obvious since the early 19th century (the Crimean War was also fought over this issue) and the fact that this conflict would primarily be between Russia and Austria was already obvious by the time of the Crimean War in the 1850's (Austria doesn't join the Allies in the Crimean war because the Habsburgs' domestic position is still weak after the 1848 Hungarian Revolution). And the Franco-Russian and Austrian-German alliances, plus the Franco-German rivalry, mean that a Balkan war with Great Power involvement is expected to turn into a general European War, and all the Continental Great Powers made war plans on this basis. (The Schlieffen Plan for a German blitzkrieg against France while Russia is still mobilising is first drawn up in 1906, which is after the 1904 Entente Cordiale between Britain and France, but before the 1908 formal military alliance between Britain, France, and Russia.) If everyone expects a neutral Britain, Germany is more likely to win and therefor more likely to choose to invade France, not less. So the argument that anything Britain (or the US via their influence on Britain) could have done to prevent the war depends on the idea that we could have convinced Russia not to defend Serbia and de facto surrender the Balkans to Austria. (Britain did try to mediate between Russia, Austria, and Serbia, but Germany told Austria to reject this offer - the Central Powers were expecting to win and had very limited interest in a negotiated peace).

Amusingly, there is one American who definitely can be blamed for British involvement in WW1. Admiral Mahan wrote the seminal books on naval history which convinced the Kaiser to build a navy. Without a German navy, the British don't see Germany as hostile, and don't try to join an anti-German alliance.

You do know that the bloodiest wars in world history* have been fought by white Christian Europeans against other white Christian Europeans, or by Han Chinese against other Han Chinese?

So was the bloodiest war in the history of the Americas (the American Civil War).

* Conquests of Genghis Khan being the possible exception.

Given what a replacement-level CEO did to Microsoft, Satya Nadella's value-over-replacement is in the low trillions of dollars, not counting the consumer surplus generated by Microsoft products mostly ceasing to suck.

Mature companies with P/E ratios north of 20 (which includes all the US tech megastars) are being priced on the basis that the business will outlive the current leadership. Not Boeinging a successful mature business is extraordinarily valuable, and apparently harder than it looks given that Bill Gates' chosen successor couldn't.

Part of the pattern where support for the unborn ends at or a few weeks after birth, suggesting (per Barnhart) that the motivation may be something other than Christian charity?

The states building pregnancy resource centres are the secular political culture that supports them are the states and political culture which made opposition to post-birth government help for poor mothers the core of their activism in the Gingrich era. And a demographic that reliably supports said political culture is white, self-identified Christian, rarely or never attends church.

Christianity (allegedly), through mechanisms like banning child marriage and insisting on monogamy

I think the big one was that it was a missionary religion that essentially downplayed ethnic differences.

Both normative monogamy and the idea of a higher identity making ethnicity irrelevant were part of Roman culture before the Roman Empire Christianised.

That isn't top 10%. A top 10% neighborhood in the Slough area would be called "Windsor" or "Maidenhead".

Traditional patriarchy very much did pressure men to marry, and then some. The shotgun in a shotgun wedding was pointed at the groom's back.

Absolutely agreed. Some things are hard, but important to get right. If you want generally low immigration, high-skill immigration is one of them.

If the WSJ article is accurate, then Biden was President, but doing the job badly. The key point is that there is no suggestion that someone else was leading the administration the way Edith Wilson led the administration after Woodrow Wilson's stroke, or that people joked about Hilary running the Clinton administration or Dick Cheney running the GW Bush administration. The ultimate way a disagreement between Biden administration players was resolved was still "put it in front of the President during his six good hours".

There's no way there are that many exceptional people moving to the US each year.

Extraordinary, not just exceptional. Just having a PhD from a top UK university counts as exceptional under US immigration law (and probably should). Exceptional ability doesn't help much with the first visa (it makes you eligible for certain discretionary waivers), but when you are applying for one your green card comes out of a different quota pool which doesn't normally have a lag.

Extraordinary ability means meeting three out of eight criteria, one of which is "high salary" and some of the others of which are gameable. But the intent was "one of the top 100 or so people in your subfield in the world".

My understanding was that Spirit was the US equivalent of Ryanair (the scuzziest and most successful of the EU low-cost airlines). Southwest were low-cost once, but last time I was in the US they generally cost more than basic economy on the crappified full-service airlines.

But the thing that makes Ryanair so successful is that the underlying hard product just works. The planes get you from A to B, on time, and cheaply if you follow the easy-to-understand rules about things like bag sizes. I prefer Easyjet, but probably only because there is something about the aesthetics of stepping onto a Ryanair plane which somehow rubs in the fact that you must be falling out of the upper-middle class.

European airlines absolutely check the size (but not weight) of carry-on bags. Full-service airlines will gate check the bag for free if it is a close call, low-cost airlines will charge you double the usual checked bag fee because you didn't pre-order.

Low-cost airlines now also charge for overhead bin space (or bundle it with speedy boarding) - if you don't pay for bin space, your carry-on has to fit under the seat in front of you.

This is one of those leftover Redditisms that just refuses to die.

No, actually, the religious people advocating for the unborn actually do also do a TON of work for all sorts of people. The society of Saint Vincent De Paul, for instance, or Covenant House.

This is true. It is also true that there are a lot of people (according to both my casual observation, and traditional Protestant doctrine on this point, far more than the first group) of unsaved sinners who tick the "Christian" box on the census as a way of expressing their secular tribal identity, but do not accept Jesus Christ into their hearts as their Lord and Saviour. And that group are somewhat involved in anti-abortion activism, and not at all in any of the other stuff. In the American political context, this group of "Christian" hypocrites is particularly significant because they vote and thus a major political party exists to represent their interests.

So the correct Arminian interpretation of Barnhart's sermon is "If your Christianity is causing you to advocate on behalf of the unborn, but not any of the other disfavoured groups that Jesus mentions in the Bible, then you are doing Christianity wrong and need to do some repenting" and the correct Calvinist interpretation is "If you see a group of self-identified Christians advocating on behalf of the unborn, but not any of the other groups Jesus mentions in the Bible, then you are looking at a group of fake Christians."