@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

If blank slateism is true, yes.

Although the sex/gender distinction is still useful even in the real world where blank slatism is true. In a sane society (i.e. one which sets up a default where men are gently steered towards being Real Men TM and women are gently steered towards being Real Women TM) gender is a structure built on top of biological sex. Some of that structure (like war being for men and child-raising for women) is close to the root and necessary, and therefore conserved across cultures. But "blue is for boys and pink is for girls" is an accident of certain western cultures.

The LDS Church is notoriously full of affinity frauds and MLMs. When arranging my babymoon, I remember wondering why hotel room rates were so high in SLC in the summer, and discovering when we got into town that there were two large MLM conventions on at the same time. Sitting at one table in the brunch room at the Grand American Hotel planning a hike while at the next table over a Mormon with a blinged-out name badge was explaining to two evangelical churchladies with rather less blinged-out name badges how they could convince their church members that God wanted them to buy MLM crap was an eye-opening experience.

and a job as a Lecturer (no idea if this implies full tenure) for four years

In the traditional British system of academic titles, "lecturer" is the lowest of four grades of permanent academic staff (lecturer/senior lecturer/reader/professor) which loosely correspond to the tenure track in the American system. American-style tenure doesn't exist, because all UK employees benefit from protection against unfair dismissal after two years full-time work on a permanent contract. Taking 14 years to be promoted from lecturer to reader (per Wikipedia) was quite normal at the time for academics who were not seen as superstars by their colleagues.

So if we are going to draw a direct equivalent to the US system, Higgs was 4 years into his first tenure-track job when he published his Nobel paper, but the importance of the paper wasn't recognised for another decade+.

Coup has two meanings in a way which makes this confusing. The term derives from the French "couper" meaning "to cut" in common French but closer to "to strike" in fencing terminology, which is where the relevant English idioms get the word from, including coup d'etat, coup de theatre, coup de grace etc.

So we have "coup" meaning an achievement analogous to a well-executed hit in fencing - the dictionary describes it as "successfully achieving something difficult" but I think it is only idiomatic if the achievement is an apparently sudden and surprising victory in an adversarial setting analogous to a duel. In this case Pelosi and other Democratic elites removing Biden cleanly is clearly a coup.

We also have "coup" used as a shorthand for "coup d'etat" - specifically the idea of a sudden violent replacement of a government (although again "coup" is only idiomatically correct if the success is so spectacular that only minimal violence is actually needed - otherwise it is a civil war or a revolution). The replacement of Biden by Harris is clearly not a coup d'etat - the rules as written were followed and there was no threat or use of violence.

(whereas 3 body problem only won the Hugo award, which I agree is meaningless now)

If it hadn't been for "puppy" votes brought in by Vox Day as part of an attempt to gank the Hugos, Three Body Problem would have lost to Katherine Addison's The Goblin Emperor. So it wasn't just a meaningless award, it was a meaningless award with an asterisk

If most successful professionals are excluded from the professional-managerial class because they are partners in their firms, then surely it would just be the managerial class?

The original Barbara Ehrenreich essay defining the term is less helpful that I would expect. It defines "self-employed professionals" as part of the legacy petit bourgeoisie (which she calls the "old middle class" and consistently with mainstream Marxist theory but incorrectly predicts is on the way to extinction) when she is trying to define the PMC at the beginning, but later on in the article she gives accountancy as an example of a core PMC job even though accountants are frequently self-employed professionals. Ehrenreich also says that class should be defined based on the economic substance and cultural context of class relationships, not on legal forms. The emphasis of the article is on the role of the PMC in disciplining the working class to accept capitalism, not how they get paid.

Having read the essay, it is obvious that Ehrenreich didn't think about lawyers while writing it, but based on what she did say I think she would call it as follows:

  • I think she would assign all lawyers who work for large businesses (or government departments that interact with them) into the PMC, with the distinction between in-house lawyers, associates in law firms, and partners in law firms as formal rather than real - they are all boot-boys for the real capitalists who are paid for their skilled labour, not for access to their own capital. The exception is that a subset of Biglaw partners are sufficiently close to power that they are part of the ruling class. (Ehrenreich talks about this in the context of the management hierarchy of large companies, where she says there is obviously a fuzzy boundary between middle managers who are PMC and executives who are functionally part of the capitalist ruling class even if as non-owners they are not technically bourgeois on a strict Marxist basis).
  • She would definitely put all white-collar professionals in the criminal justice system including lawyers into the PMC on functional grounds, again regardless of how they get paid.
  • The partners in the small law firm that does small business and private client work are petit bourgeois. The status of the associates is not clear - they are not performing PMC functions, so they probably count as skilled workers. This type of firm doesn't have very many associates anyway because a competent lawyer with 5-10 years' experience who still isn't made a partner is better off starting their own firm than continuing to work as an associate.

Ehrenreich explicitly says that trying to assign non-petit bourgeois status to individuals based on asset ownership was foolish as of 1977 when she wrote the essay because the function of the bourgeoisie was mostly being performed by large companies with non-owner senior management. So I don't think she would find the argument that partners in law firms are capitalists exploiting the associates decisive.

I think you are using "PMC" in a non-standard way if you think that partners in law firms are not part of it. A "class" is a group where movement in or out is somewhat exceptional - an associate making partner is completely usual.

To me the defining features of the PMC (as opposed to other elite and elite-adjacent groups) are:

  • A self-image as engaged in meritocratic competition and tribal values that reflect this (including a much stronger work ethic than traditional elites). A rejection of explicit dynastic privilege (while still doing everything they can to help kids get ahead, because even the PMC is the product of evolution).
  • Allocating more status to formal education than it deserves.
  • A focus on professional networks (formed in explicitly professional contexts where spouses are usually absent and children always are) over traditional social networks (mostly formed at dinner parties with spouses present). This has an important impact in the way that privilege is transmitted - traditional elites would personally introduce their teen and young adult children to important social contacts purposively, whereas PMC elites pay for their kids to have access to high-end networking opportunities (e.g. Harvard) but expect them to do the networking themselves.
  • Revolving doors based on those networks as an important way of making money in the second half of your career.
  • Low ownership (relative to income and social status) of tangible capital other than primary residence (except when obfuscated through mutual funds)
  • Avoiding situations where they have line management responsibility for social inferiors (except when obfuscated through outsourcing orgs) - this includes both the types of jobs that PMC members seek out and the way they run their households. A lot of gig economy apps got built because PMC members in Silicon Valley were willing to pay to put a computer into the loop to obfuscate the fact that they were hiring servants.
  • Urban orientation
  • National (and international) orientation as opposed to local - in general elite-adjacent PMC members in the major cities treat local elites in the sticks as food animals.

In America, I would say that the boutique law firm partner who is making a mid-six-figure income based on the combination of "what he knows" and "who he knows" built up over 20 years of experience including stints in Biglaw and government work is at least as archetypally PMC as the 20-year GS-13 career bureaucrat. See this Substack or this FT Alphaville post for some discussion of the unusual degree to which the UK economy depends on this kind of person. Money quote - "The UK is the Saudi Arabia of miscellaneous business and professional services."

Sam Altman was pretty clear that most of the startup founders Y Combinator funds come from PMC backgrounds. The original interview with Tyler Cowen where he talks about it is now behind a paywall, but this blog post has the key quotes.

ALTMAN: There’s a statement here that’s just bad about the world, but I think if you look at most successful founders, they are pretty smart, upper-middle-class people. They are very rarely the children of super successful people. They are very rarely born in real poverty. They are very rarely the absolute smartest people who otherwise would win a Fields Medal. They are never dumb, but upper-middle-class, pretty smart people that have grit and drive and creativity and vision and edge and a different way of thinking about the world. That is what I think I’m good at spotting, and that is what I think are good founders. There’s a whole bunch of reasons why that’s a sad statement about the world, but there it is.

Part of what Y Combinator has done (and Altman has also written about this at length) is to turn "founding a startup" into gamified meritocratic competition with a facially similar progression to moving through the junior-to-middle ranks at McKinsey or Goldman. Paul Graham (but not Altman) also did pitched early acquisitions as good for founders, which matched the McKinsey/Goldman pitch of "do this for a few years and move onto your real career with cash in your pocket and an impressive CV." The reason to do that is to make "found a startup straight out of Stanford" a more appealing option for PMC strivers, and therefore shift the universe of startup founders in a way which matches YC's comparative advantage.

I don't think salaried employment is part of what defines the PMC. Lawyers, accountants, and (in the US) doctors are core PMC members who (if successful) end up as owner-partners in their practices. Wall Street types get most of their income in what is in effect commission. Genuine entrepreneurship is exceptional for the PMC, but it is exceptional for everyone. And VC money is designed to de-risk entrepreneurship for founders so the amount of skin in a game a founder has is closer to the Biglaw partner who sets up his own boutique firm than the chef who remortgages his house to buy a restaurant.

I presume that if you had evidence that the actual leaders of the NRA following said revolt were supporters of Jim Crow, you'd have posted it.

The fact that they were Southern conservatives is Bayesian evidence that were supporters of Jim Crow, given that the vast majority of Southern conservatives born before the civil rights era were supporters of Jim Crow. The racist murder that Harlon Carter was convicted of was of a Hispanic, so it is definitely possible that he wasn't shockingly racist against blacks, just unlikely.

In any case the claim I was trying to make was the slightly weaker claim that the leaders of the Cincinnati revolt were people who accepted the moral assumptions of the Dunning School of history (which would have been taught as uncontroversial fact in the high schools and colleges they attended) and would therefore have seen the 1st Klan as an example of righteous-but-doomed resistance to tyranny and the Redemption-era white militias as a good example of successful resistance. The set of people who thought that the 1st Klan were the goodies in Birth of a Nation (which was not small - the movie enjoyed mainstream success) is much larger than the set of people who were actively working to bring back Jim Crow in 1977. The Sons of Confederate Veterans gave Nathan Bedford Forrest a posthumous honour in 1977, so "the 1st Klan were the goodies" was still comfortably within the Overton window at the time.

I am happy to admit that I have no evidence whatsoever that Neal Knox was a segregationist apart from the fact that it was normal for white Texans who attended segregated Christian colleges in the 1950's to be segregationists.

  • -10

The NRA went from being a primarily-sporting group of the type you mention to being a primarily-political one as a result of the Cincinnati revolt. This isn't Michael Moore history - "The NRA leadership was useless until a grassroots takeover put real 2nd amendment supporters into place" is the story gun rights activists tell themselves. The NRA was not a white supremacist organisation either before or after the change, but the new leadership was dominated by Southern conservatives, and the vast majority of Southern conservatives in the 1970's were white supremacists by modern standards. "Jim Crow is protected by states' rights under the Constitution", "Civil Rights law is an unconstitutional expansion of federal power", and "Reconstruction was an abuse of power by carpetbaggers and scallywags" were all standard Southern conservative positions at the time, and "Jim Crow is good actually" was still within the Overton window.

It makes the land generally inhospitable to tyrants.

The practical outcome of the US government being afraid of its armed citizenry wasn't a bulwark against tyranny, it was the enabling of Jim Crow (which, for the avoidance of doubt, was tyrannical oppression from the point of view of its black victims). During WW2, the Feds acquired a large standing army sufficient that the government was no longer afraid of its armed citizenry, the American people elected the man who embodied the values of that army to the Presidency, and the South folded in short order.

Given

  • the semi-official status that the Dunning school of history had in the South
  • the relationship between 60's and 70's movement conservatism and Southern resistance to civil rights
  • the fact that the Cincinnati Coup was led by Southerners (one of whom was probably a racist murderer)

we can be reasonably confident that the modern 2nd amendment movement centred around a politically-active NRA loosely aligned with movement conservatism was founded by people who thought that gun culture was good because it enabled Jim Crow, not in spite of it. The viewpoint that the 1st Klan and the Redeemers were justified resistance to tyranny, that Jim Crow was the liberty the 2nd amendment existed to protect, and that the Feds imposing civil rights on the white South was a tyrannical usurpation, was entirely mainstream in right-wing circles in those days.

The problem of political violence does not have a technical solution - there is no substitute for civic virtue. A government that has the technical capability to protect you from warlords has the technical ability to oppress you if it chooses to. And an (organised or unorganised) militia which has the technical capability to protect you from a tyrannical government has the technical ability to overthrow a non-tyrannical government and take up warlordism* on you if it chooses to. Empirically, warlordism is worse for the people who have to live under it than tyranny. The American approach of setting up the nation-in-arms as a counterveiling power to the armed forces of the democratic state has failed - the worst incident of democratic backsliding in American history was imposed on the democratic state violently by a section of the nation-in-arms. The approach to the same problem taken by the French Revolution was to set up a conscript army in such a way that the nation-in-arms is the armed forces of the democratic state. That approach failed fast and spectacularly in France, though it seems to have worked very well in Switzerland. It remains as central to the democratic mythos of Continental Europe as the 2nd amendment and the Minutemen are to the democratic mythos of Red America.

* I am happy to make the mildly tongue-in-cheek claim that the actually existing form of government in the South between the withdrawal of Federal troops in the 1870's and the establishment of functioning Jim Crow state governments in the 1880's and 1890's was warlordism, but defending it would take more space that one Mottepost.

  • -14

Lynch-Chamberlain's defense was that Hussain had handled the money and documents in question, and that neither Chamberlain nor Lynch were (proven to be) aware he was lying, or to the extent Chamberlain futzed some numbers that they were not done to induce HP's deal.

One of the problems with prosecuting this type of case is that there is no command responsibility under civilian criminal law, so although you can assume the founder-CEO (who will get by far the largest personal payoff and so has the motive) is the actual guilty party, you can't prosecute him unless you can prove (beyond reasonable doubt) that he was personally involved in some specific crime. A good criminal CEO (like a good mafia boss) tells his subordinates "make the numbers work, I understand that you might need to fudge them a bit, I don't need to know the details". Even a mediocre one knows not to write things down when criming. And any criminal CEO can turn up at trial and say they are shocked, shocked to find that their CFO is a crook. RICO mostly stops this defence working in a mafia case, but it doesn't apply to corporate fraud.

And in practice the only way to win a case against the CEO is to flip the CFO (who can't avoid hands-on criming given the nature of their role in the scheme, and so usually gets charged first) on him. The classic example is Enron, where Fastow flipped on Lay and Skilling in exchange for a relatively lenient sentence. Lay and Skilling's defence was indeed "We didn't know what Fastow was doing so we can't be criminally liable for it." I don't know why Hussain didn't take a plea deal (based on the reported appeal, he didn't have much of a defence) but his going to trial probably sunk the case against his boss. Under the civil standard things are easier - HP won their civil case in England against Lynch personally.

Personally I favour a RICO-like law for large-scale corporate crime where a CEO can be convicted of running a systemically criminal company even it isn't proven that they personally knew about specific crimes. CEOs in general, and founder-CEOs in particular, have enough power over their own companies that command responsibility applies morally, and I think the law should align. If you genuinely know so little about your own company that it can be as corrupt as Enron or Autonomy without you being involved, then you should resign (as a non-owner CEO) or sell it (as a founder-CEO).

They have created a society in which people have less sex than ever, have fewer children than ever and can only dream of getting the housing their parents had at the same age. They have no idea how to fix it so the result is to find ways to make the people who point out the problems seem illegitimate.

Nonsense - as you imply, the problem is downstream of housing supply, and we know how to legalise housing - the laws banning it are visible on the books, have short titles, long titles, chapter numbers etc. and the process for repealing them is well-understood. Keir Starmer's people know this too - before the election he repeatedly talked (example) about the need to build more housing, including specifically his plans to relax planning laws and allow building on Greenbelt. One of the incoming government's first announcements was a consultation on a new planning policy framework.

There is an ongoing argument about whether the consultation has bottled it by reducing the housing target for London, but there is an offsetting increase in housing targets for the commuter belt around London, and in any case the previous target was not being met, and the new framework makes it a lot harder for local authorities to deliberately miss targets.

Do I think we are going to see the houses built? Probably not - the political logic of bottling it hasn't changed. But building 1.5 million houses in places where people want to live is almost certainly sufficient to unfuck the UK.

My understanding is that they were acting on orders from Moscow in all those cases. So they only looked like buffoons.

Is he necessarily wrong?

Yes, if you have a passing familiarity with Weimar-era politics. The Nazis' allies were right-wingers - primarily Hugenberg's DNVP, but also the right-wing faction of Zentrum that included Bruning and Papen (until he was kicked out for being too right-wing) and various right-coded figures in Hindenberg's inner circle (particularly Schleicher, who favoured a military government once it became clear that a DNVP-led government was never going to win a majority in the Reichstag). The Nazi's sworn enemies were left-wingers (both the SPD and the KPD, although the Nazis occasionally co-operated with the KPD on purely negative projects intended to weaken the Weimar Republic).

Nobody who was around at the time had the slightest shadow of a doubt that Hitler was right-wing. Some of the more perceptive liberals, and even a few perceptive democratic socialists (like Orwell) grokked that the difference between left-wing and right-wing totalitarianism was less important than it looked - but even Orwell writes from the perspective that the right-left and right-wrong axes are separate, and that Nazis were right-wrong and Communists were left-wrong.

Given that the argument here is about crime committed by the British-born son of immigrants, we don’t get to choose at that level of detail. (You get to choose the parents of your 2nd-generation immigrants, but anyone who has raised kids knows that only gets you so far.) If your goal is zero serious crime committed by descendants of immigrants, the only way to get there is zero immigration.

The UK breaks out crime statistics by folk racial categories which don’t distinguish between “Black” sub-populations (Jamaicans and Somalis are the high-crime groups) in the way you would need to do to answer this question properly, but anecdotally immigrants from Christian Africa in the UK and their descendants are better behaved than the natives.

Left-wing poasters on the Imane Khelif row are well aware that Khelif is not trans, and are pointing and laughing at the ignorance of right-wing poasters who suggest that she is. The left-wing argument against policing female athletes' biology (namely that it is demeaning to the athletes, and that the intersex corner cases that it throws up are hard to adjudicate) long predates trans being a shouting issue.

The simple cheating case which sex testing exists to catch (a non-intersex cis man entering a female event) has never happened in the Olympics - and as far as I am aware it hasn't happened in international-level athletics either. What sex testing throws up is arguments about whether certain AFAB (a rare occasion where "asssigned X at birth" is accurate and useful terminology) intersex people are "real women". And the science to adjudicate those fairly while maintaining competitive balance has only been done for middle-distance running.

I think sport needs to decide what a woman is and enforce it - particularly in a world where there are biologically male people with "woman" on their government ID - but I understand the case for throwing up your hands and saying "can't be done" given how destructive intersex-in-women's-sports rows are.

If the only thesis here is that Christianity has different values than pagan warrior types, this is indeed obvious and not a penetrating insight. In that case I have no idea why any of this is worth discussing at all, and the language about "master morality" and "slave morality" is nothing more than vacuous rhetorical dressing invented out of sophistry and a dislike of the Christian values. Maybe that's what it is; I don't have a very high opinion of Nietzsche or his sycophants.

FWIW, I agree with you on this point - Nietzsche (like a lot of right-wing edgelords) found civilisation enervating and was trying to make an emotional appeal for barbarism by using the loaded terms "master morality" and "slave morality". But I read your previous post as arguing that Nietzsche was wrong to tie Christianity to what he calls "slave morality" and I call "civilised behaviour". Whereas I think Nietzsche was right that Jesus killed Superman (or more strictly outcompeted him memetically rendering him irrelevant), but wrong about this being a bad thing.

Based on my experience as a tourist in the US, general disorder and quality of life crime is still lower in Manhattan than in the centres of most other US cities (thinking about it, I think the Vegas strip and immediate environs was nicer). Compared to a northern European or 1st-world Asian city, NYC is a bit grubby. San Francisco is filthy.

From the Wikipedia article on Shapiro's private Jewish high school, it looks like doing a semester in Israel was optional, but I assume that once you made the decision to do that the "volunteering" was part of the deal. Whether the decision to do a semester in Israel was taken by Josh or his parents depends on family dynamics.

I don't see any reason to move on from "Red China". If they weren't Red, we could be friends.

The British police were able and willing to contain the 2011 London riots within 72 hours - for those positing political motivations, that was despite the 2011 riots over-representing blacks and nominally being against racist policing (the police had shot a black gangbanger who was wanted for illegal gun possession and who had, but did not fire, a gun when he was shot).

The anti-immigrant riots we are seeing now have been the first thing since 2011 with close to that level of destruction. So unless we see a dramatically harsher response (which is unlikely - the sentences handed down in 2011 were notoriously harsh, as they should be) I don't think this is a case of obvious two-tier policing. Both the UK BLM protests and the recent Palestinian protests were an order of magnitude less violent than 2011 or the last few days.

Right-wing media claimed that the Southend machete fight was an example of minorities being allowed to run riot by the police, but in fact the participants were arrested and at least one has been charged with attempted murder.

A North African Muslim (the Algerian immigrant in Ireland) and a Sub-Saharan Christian (the son of Rwandan immigrants in Wales) are profoundly not the same catalyst - a large part of the anti-immigrant sentiment in Western Europe (including the UK) is in effect single-issue anti-Islamic.

The rioting in the UK started because the rioters wrongly believed that the killer was Muslim and the crime was part of the unfortunately longstanding pattern of sexually motivated crimes against white girls by (mostly) Mirpuri Pakistanis. As with all riots, they spread because it looked like the police were off the ball and there were trainers to be looted.

I wouldn't say "cunt" is a lighthearted form of obscenity in the UK. It is one of the three words you really can't say on TV (along with "nigger" and "Paki"). Using the term to refer to actual female genitalia or to insult a woman would be shockingly misogynistic. Using it to insult a man in earshot would be fighting words. You wouldn't use it to rib a casual acquaintance the way you might in Oz.

The difference between the British and US contexts is that the word is permitted to insult people who it is okay to offer otherwise-unpardonable insults against, such as the manager of your team's arch-rivals or the Prime Minister. There is no misogynistic connotation when the word is used to insult a man.

I am 50-50 on whether "nigger" will turn out to be acceptable (obivously only in the UK) in this context if the Tories elect a black leader, which is less likely than it was a fortnight ago but still very plausible (Jenrick has overtaken Badenoch as the bookies' favourite, but she is still 9-4 and Cleverly is still in the race).

Kemp isn't MAGA-pilled - the reason why the argument is happening is because he knows (and is unwilling to conceal that he knows) that Trump is just another lying politician, in fact one who lies even more often that average. There certainly are men who would re-evaluate the hotness of their wife or whether black is white based on Trump telling them to, but Kemp isn't one of them.

Kemp (and his ally Raffensperger) are unusual in that they have already seen off Trump-backed primary challenges, so they probably have more freedom to oppose Trump than anyone else in the GOP.