@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

I'm pretty certain that the USSS are used to a threat model of "one guy with a boomstick". The vast majority of people who shoot at a President are uncomplicatedly crazy.

War is to men what motherhood is to women.

The vast majority of soldiers who are able to speak on the issue have said that war is hell. The vast majority of mothers have said the opposite about motherhood.

Christianity praises (and frequently venerates as Saints) radical ascetics (even if they don't do anything, and just hold out their asceticism as an example to others, like the Stylites), passive victims of persecution (Crusaders who die in battle are not considered martyrs, randos picked up in Roman persecutions of Christians are), and people who make great sacrifices in order to support ineffective charity (like Mother Theresa). From a vitalist perspective, all of these groups are Losers.

Christianity doesn't condemn Will to Power per se, but it tends to reserve its strongest condemnation for the vices which are correlated with it like pride, avarice, and wrath.

I think the core Nietzschean claim that Christianity embodies slave morality is obviously correct. Given the problems with societies that tell every man (or even just every aristocrat) he ought to be a master, I don't see why this is a problem. Even if we take on master morality religion at its own game, the military conflict between Christian civilisation and Islamic "civilisation" had been back-and-forth with no sign of an ultimate winner for over 1000 years by the time we invented the machine gun and settled the issue.

In other words Qatar is the Continental Hotel of the Middle East.

You were putting the onus on the disqualifiers a second ago, are they supposed to grope her?

There is a non-invasive test for having a Y chromosome (you just need a DNA sample, and before DNA testing there was a histological test for the presence of multiple X chromosomes which could be done with a cheek swab). The IOC used karyotype testing from 1958 to 1999 - it was abandoned after a small number of false positives of which the famous ones were cases of Complete Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome - CAIS women have XY chromosomes and testicles which produce testosterone, but their body doesn't respond to the testosterone so they develop female external genitalia in utero and female physiology after puberty. Everyone agreed that in principle CAIS women should be allowed to compete as women because they don't have an unfair advantage, and people who opposed sex testing used this as a lever.

But the practical protocol of "include a karyotype test in the standard battery of medical tests that elite athletes undergo, and discretely make further enquiries about XY women" works if you let it. The problem is that you have to adjudicate borderline cases like Caster Semeneya, and in the rare genuine intersex cases people will hate you for good reasons whichever way you rule. If you say "no gatekeeping - anyone AFAB can compete as a woman" then you are giving the competition away to countries willing to modify birth certificates.

A woman who thinks a man is beating on her, that's who. If she has ever sparred against one during training (and why wouldn't she), Carini knows that against a legitimate male boxer (good, but not necessarily a contender) who is trying to win (even in her weight class), her options are a quick tapout and getting smashed up in potentially life-altering ways. On hearing that Khelif was XY, Carini could have concluded that she was facing a legitimate male boxer. That would probably panic her* in a way which explains her failure to fight properly before taking the big punch and rapid surrender after it.

Broadhurst, on the other hand, assumed that Khelif competing in womens' boxing implied that she was not, in fact, a legitimate male boxer (she may also not have known that there was a question about Khelif's biological sex at all), fought like someone who wanted to win and belived she could, and demonstrated that Khelif boxed like a girl.

* Real-estate guru, youth football coach and Libertarian speaker John T Reed wrote a number of articles about why you need to minimize the ability gap (which in size-based youth sports is approximately equivalent to the age gap) in youth contact sports because athletes will panic and freeze if they expect to be hit by someone a lot more dangerous than them. Unfortunately they don't seem to have made the transition to his current blog.

I think that Jordan Peterson was shellacked for things other than "men should be physically active". I am in the UK, not the US, and certainly not in the deep Blue parts of the US where wokestupid dominates the culture, but over here youth sport (for both sexes, and people are entirely comfortable with the fact that you get more natural interest from boys than girls) is a motherhood-and-apple-pie issue and the main reason why we don't get more of it is that it is politically impossible to say no when some idiot says "Did you know that you could divert even more resources from actually providing youth sport to generating a paper trail proving that the parent-volunteers aren't paedophiles?"

NYC is much safer than other cities with similar demographics.

Every American city is dramatically safer than it was in the 1970's, even if the demographics haven't improved.

It really is possible to reduce violent and property crime by an order of magnitude relative to the demographic-driven baseline (compare crime committed by Jamaicans in Jamaica to crime committed by Jamaicans in the UK) through effective policing backed up by swift and certain punishment of criminals. Most Western European and 1st-world Asian cities do this.

I have no idea why other American cities can't get their "crime per member of a high-crime ethnic group" numbers down to NYC levels, but the problem doesn't appear to be fixable by electing Republicans or tough-on-crime Democrats at the local level.

One thing I do think is that the easiest way to reverse the recent trend in shoplifting is to clamp down on the large tech companies running online marketplaces for obviously stolen goods.

That said, for Western countries, states or municipalities facing spikes in violent crime the Bukele approach is absolutely correct and would work.

My understanding is that a key component of the Bukele approach was that the Salvadorean gangs used tattoos as a mark of gang membership, so "lock up everyone with a gang tattoo" put a lot of gang members behind bars with not many false positives. Locking up everyone in London whose tattoo makes them look like a street thug would leave you without enough free men to guard the prisons.

It is worth noting that other right-populist parties have joined in shunning AfD. They were kicked out of the right-wing Identity and Democracy group in the European Parliament (which is dominated by Marine Le Pen's RN) for being too tolerant of actual brownshirts-and-swastikas neo-Nazis.

Less obnoxious right-populist parties like the Dutch PVV are in government.

Nero also has an even worse reputation in the era of Gibbon that he had in the era of Suetonius because he was particularly associated with early persecution of Christians.

On the other hand, he did murder his own mother...

“shame culture” (a nonsensical term)

"shame culture" is a technical term of anthropology where it refers to a culture where people judge their own actions through the lens of "what will other people think of me if I do this" rather than through the lens of law or morality. Like most confusing technical terms, this is not nonsense if you understand the technical meaning. America profoundly isn't a shame culture in this sense.

If "shame culture" is being used by very online people to refer to a culture with a lot of social shaming, then that is dumb and may be nonsensical to boot. But that isn't something I have come across.

Trump's base is the most enthusiastic base in my adult life (Obama's is a distant second, I'm too young to remember Reagan) for a candidate who captured a major-party nomination. He doesn't need to motivate the base. I agree that the 10% most rabidly pro-Trump Americans would be positively excited by a dynastic pick.

FWIW, I think that the MAGA base is sufficiently Trump-pilled that if Trump wins in 2024 and endorses a dynastic successor in 2028, he can deliver the Republican primary with >50% probability. OTOH this would be a good outcome for the Democrats if it happened.

Operation Wetback was able to deport as many people as they did because they had an unusually high level of Mexican co-operation, which was only available in the context of a bracero programme which let in roughly as many legal Mexicans as Operation Wetback deported illegal ones. There were tens of thousands of people who were deported under Operation Wetback, returned to the US as braceros, violated the rules of the bracero programme, and got deported again under Operation Wetback. All within less than a year.

Operation Wetback also operated at a time when America was sufficiently racist that nobody cared if a few Hispanic US citizens were deported accidentally (as far as I can see, nobody has investigated how many citizens were deported, but the Great Depression era "Mexican repatriation" programme had deported hundreds of thousands of them). The reason why deportation is administratively expensive is that America has no list of US citizens it can check people against, and the list of legal immigrants isn't accurate or complete enough (this is pure INS incompetence - in principle the US should have an up-to-date list of all non-citizens legally in the country) for deporting anyone not on it to be "safe".

In America (and, to a lesser extent, other 1st-world countries) the socially acceptable way to not work because you don't need to is to retire early - there used to be a soft norm that blue-collar guys retired at 60 if they could. There are plenty of men in their 60's working who would be retired if they had been able to accumulate more wealth, and for a lot of them the reason why they couldn't accumulate wealth was divorce or child support obligations.

I think you are right that the average guy who is irresponsible enough to knock up a sloot is going to spend the money he saves by avoiding child support on driving a bigger truck rather than saving for retirement. But this doesn't affect the moral point I was making, which is that the male role as breadwinner and the female role as mother have similar death tolls.

If you look at the risk of death, the asymmetry is quite small. In the US, the CDC gives maternal mortality of 22 per 100,000 live births (which is probably overstated). The BLS gives an annual workplace mortality rate of 3.7 per 100,000 FTE workers. An absent father is going to end up spending roughly 4 years working to pay child support (20-25% of after-tax income for 18 years), which would give a death toll from paying child support of 15 per 100,000 live births if child support defendants had average workplace death rates. Since men work much more dangerous jobs than women, the true figure is probably higher than the maternal mortality rate. But the crucial point is that the risks of dying due to giving birth or paying child support are of the same order of magnitude.

I was in the blogosphere back in the Instpundit days, so I understand the full range of meaning that can be squeezed into a "Heh" like @stuckinbathroom's. I forget that the internet is full of whippersnappers nowadays.

The Issues

The fact that the gender gap is large and consistent across issues strongly suggests that it is driven by vibes and not issues. In other words, something is causing young men to identify as Republicans, or conservatives, or MAGA, or some similar right-wing identity, and they are then adopting the bog standard right-wing positions on all the issues, and something else is driving young women to identify as Democrats or liberals or some such and they are then adopting the bog standard left-wing positions.

And we aren't looking at a general argument about vibes like "Mummy Party vs Daddy Party" - we are trying to explain something that has grown dramatically since about 2010, in multiple Western countries. (This FT article shows the same pattern in the UK and Germany as well as the US, as well as a similar but not simultaneous pattern in South Korea - notably France seems to be an exception, with only a small gender gap in the exit polls for the recent legislative elections. There is also a minimal gender gap in the exit polls for the 2024 UK general election, but I think that is because so few young people voted for right-wing parties at all that a youth gender gap wouldn't show up in the overall results.

On the Addams family, John Sr was a Federalist, and John Q was a Democratic-Republican.

On W, I am being a bit vague, but the points I was thinking about were

  • that W was running as a Texan and an outsider against the Beltway establishment of which HW was a lifelong member
  • that W's platform was an implicit rebuke of HW's backsliding on tax cuts
  • pre-9/11 W was running on a relatively isolationist foreign policy (no more nation-building) which was arguably an attack on the bipartisan Deep State do-everything foreign policy that HW was an architect of, although you can also read it as a more specific attack on Clinton's foreign policy.

By the time it became obvious that Harry Potter was attracting readers above its target age range (which was shortly after book 2 came out in the UK and before book 1 came out in the US) "JK Rowling wrote this as a broke single mother" was part of the sales story. So I don't think there was ever a serious attempt to pass.

Early promotion to "Senior" is an objective fact which is legitimately impressive. If your current employer is reasonably well-known in your industry, then your next employer will know just how impressive it is.

The simple answer is "because it would kill his appeal to marginal voters even more effectively than Vance does."

Trump has essentially 100% of the anti-establishment right behind him, but that is only 25-30% of politically engaged Americans, and probably only 20-25% of the Americans who will vote in November. The two main groups he needs to win over are the pro-establishment right (who object to Trump because of his personal obnoxiousness, his anti-Deep State foreign policy, and January 6th, but who will probably hold their noses and vote for him for the tax cuts and judicial nominations) and the "double-haters" who despise both candidates and may be persuadable to vote for the lesser evil.

For the pro-establishment right, "America doesn't have a King" is a foundational belief, and putting an obvious nepo baby on the ticket in what looks like an attempt to secure a dynastic succession would make it a lot harder to hold your nose. (John Quincy Adams and George W Bush had both been through the normal cursus honorum before running for President, which the Trump kids have not. In addition, they both sort-of ran against their fathers' legacies, not as continuations of them). There is also the issue that Jared and Ivanka's foreign business interests make Hunter Biden look like a patriot.

For the double-haters, putting an obvious nepo baby on the ticket makes a lot of the reasons why they hate Trump more salient, which makes Harris look more like the lesser evil.

Before Biden dropped out, I would have said the most likely scenario where he beats Trump is that the Epstein investigations turn up with hard evidence that Trump was banging teenage girls. I hadn't considered the possibility of him being stupid enough to make a family member his running mate.

The "if not marketed even younger" image is the box of MB Games' 1990 Space Crusade - which alongside OG Heroquest was a deliberate (and not repeated) attempt to extend the Warhammer IP to mass-market board games (MB was already a Hasbro subsidiary by 1990) through a licensing deal. So it was deliberately targetting an audience that was less geeky than the core Warhammer audience, as well as younger. The aesthetic of the box art is consistent with other MB Games of that era.

GW did a similar deal with Fantasy Flight which lasted from 2008-17, but given Fantasy Flight's business model that was an attempt to broaden their reach within their core ubergeek audience.

The best example of Moneymaker nominative determination remains 2003 World Series of Poker champion Chris Moneymaker, who was the first person to win after qualifying online.

We didn't go full Australia on Covid lockdowns.

Nor did most of Australia. Australia had tough restrictions at the border, but inside Australia lockdowns were localised, imposed only as necessary, and abandoned once the most vulnerable groups had been vaccinated.

The only part of Australia that was locked down for longer than California was Melbourne.