@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

Can a president resign via letter on Twitter? Sure, they can announce their intention to resign, but there are formal constitutional requirements to actually resign that a dead Biden would be unable to fulfill.

Per the Nixon precedent, it requires a letter to the Secretary of State, on which someone willing to run this conspiracy would happily forge Biden's signature. (It isn't deliberate, but it is useful the SoS has probably seen more wet-ink Presidential signatures than anyone else except the National Archivist because they countersign documents that require sealing). You can publish the letter on Twitter, but it isn't effective until someone couriers the wet-ink original to Blinken's office. If Blinken isn't on board with the conspiracy and refuses the letter until Biden authenticates it in person, then you probably didn't have enough support to pull it off to begin with.

The killing of the wives and children also has an enhanced deterrent effect. What good does it do to punish someone for crime in the first place? From a utilitarian standpoint, the benefit of punishing crime isn't the pain and loss of the offender as a positive good in itself; it is the deterrent effect. Killing the whole family enhances the deterrent, and thus has the same kind of justification as killing the offender himself, or even flogging him.

This seems wrong in context. SOP in societies where the law of slavery made it a possibility (which OT Israel very much was) was to enslave the women and children of the vanquished tribe. Killing them is salting the earth of Carthage or melting down Ned Stark's Valyrian steel greatsword - it is needless destruction of newly-acquired war booty to make a point (probably mostly to your own side) about how destructive your vengeance can be.

Don't mock. Kamala Harris could win in November and Nancy Pelosi would still be the most effective female politician in American history.

Instead of focusing on a single incident, we should aggregate the statistics and present those. When we do, we see that the problem is vanishingly small. But we will never get to zero in a country of over 330 million with 20,000 homicides per year. And yet that is what Kamala Harris is demanding.

And yet police violence could almost certainly be reduced dramatically by levelling up competence. Peter Moksos (who did 2 years as a beat cop in the rough bits of Baltimore as participant-observation research for his PhD) has collated statistics on the massive unjustified differences in police shooting rates between jurisdictions. Why are cops on the west coast more trigger-happy than on the east coast? If all big-city American police had the trigger discipline of the NYPD, then killer cops wouldn't be a political issue.

The Floyd case was exactly as it appeared once the video was made public. The key thing that came out later (that Floyd had ODed) might get Chauvin off the hook for homicide based on reasonable doubt as to the cause of death (under correctly applied Minnesota law, it doesn't and didn't) but it doesn't change the fact that Chauvin culpably used dangerously excessive force while making an otherwise-lawful arrest, thereby contributing to an avoidable death.

The guilt or innocence of Arbery's shooters depends on weird technicalities of Georgia's (FWIW, not updated since the Jim Crow ear) citizen's arrest law. It was obvious from the video that this was a bad shoot, under normal circumstances, but it was also reasonably obvious that it would have been a good shoot if the McMichaels had been uniformed cops making a lawful arrest which Arbery resisted.

If you interpret a badly-drafted statute maximally in the McMichaels' favour, you can reach the conclusion that Arbery's trespassing on a building site was a felony and the McMichaels were engaged in legally justified hot pursuit of a dangerous felon, which means that the situation is legally closer to the uniformed cop scenario. Unless you are broadly supportive of white-on-black behaviour-corrective violence in the way that the Jim Crow era legislature that wrote the law was, this is an absurd legal result, and it isn't surprising that the Georgia courts didn't buy it.

But morally, the only argument for what the McMichaels were doing was "in a high-crime society, good ol' boys blowing away an outsider acting suspiciously in someone else's neighborhood is pro-social". That argument was, indeed, made on the pages of the Motte.

is an unforced error, which cannot be chalked up to mere carelessness

In this case, it is the ramblings of a crazy woman, and it looks like the cops knew this. On balance, that probably makes the shooting non-criminal (a crazy person with a potentially deadly object making threatening noises is a legitimate threat) but getting to this point was culpably bad policing.

If you know someone is crazy, you shouldn't be parsing their insane ramblings for subtleties of meaning. Treated as incoherent word salad, it means "I express negative emotions at you in a Biblical kind of way." In someone sane but unhinged (which is not this case), it could mean "I think you are a demon or possessed by one".

Except when posting about his companies' achievements, Elon Musk is usually lame on Twitter.

Politics is a profession where only the paranoid survive, so I am sure Team Trump are going to respond in ways which could be spun as "They're afraid" - even if all they are "afraid" of is that Trump has gone from a 80% favourite to a 75% one. Musk will respond as shitposter-in-chief and will be pretty lame for the usual reasons.

There was a high-profile tumblr called racistsgettingfired whose raison d'etre was precisely this.

The range of views which are de facto illegal to express for an American who relies on W-2 employment to eat is considerably larger than the range of views which are de jure illegal in other Western countries.

The point I am making is not about which forms of voter fraud could be done - we all agree that it is easy for a non-citizen to register and vote in most states. The argument I was making is that non-citizen voting (unlike certain other forms of voter fraud, like filling in your wife's postal vote) is easy to catch if anyone wants to catch it. For example, the fraud in Texas in 1948 was caught, but the authorities declined to prosecute because they were fine with that kind of thing. Attitudes to democracy in America were different then - Illinois practiced blatant ballot-rigging (actual ballot-rigging, in that the published vote counts did not match the votes cast) - again on a bipartisan basis and as an open secret - into the 1960's.

The claim I am making is that: Premise 1) If large numbers of non-citizens were voting, this would be easy to detect. Premise 2) In the current year, there are numerous red state officials with the means, opportunity and motive to investigate non-citizen voting. Some actually have done. Premise 3) We don't detect large numbers of non-citizens voting, even when red state officials go looking for it. Conclusion: There are not, in fact, large numbers of non-citizens voting in American elections.

Bussing illegals into Texas in 1948 is a case where 2 and 3 didn't apply - nobody bothered to investigate, and the perps were caught (but not punished) anyway. In the current year, that isn't happening, and if it was the perps would be punished.

Yes, but even if he isn't on a true national team, Phelps competes (or, given the nature of uniforms in his sport, sits poolside waiting to compete) in a red, white and blue uniform and The Star-Spangled Banner is played when he wins. The right to dress Serena Williams on court is for sale to the highest bidder.

The other very important point is that Trump has convinced large numbers of people that he wasn't in power* between March and November 2020, and therefore should not be blamed for America's buttock-clenchingly pisspoor response to COVID-19 (Americans had more restrictions and more deaths than countries with a competent response like Taiwan, or even a barely adequate response like Germany). This matters, because by far the strongest arguments for "1st-term Trump was an unusually bad President" are the botched COVID-19 response and that he tried to remain in office after losing the 2020 election.

A lot of people voted for Biden (or stayed home despite being natural Republicans) on the basis of "COVID sucks, and it probably sucks more than it needs to because the government screwed up, so vote out the incumbent). The vibes have now changed to "2017-19 were pretty good, so Trump must have been an okay President".

* I can't remember which centre-left memelord said "Who was President in summer 2020 is a key election issue." but the point isn't that people have forgotten who was President, it's that Trump has successfully convinced people that he wasn't making the decisions and the Deep State is to blame for the screw-up.

Non-citizen voting is a crime that would be easy to catch if it was happening on a large scale, that Republican governors and secretaries of state have the tools and an incentive to catch, and which nevertheless you don't see large numbers of people getting caught for.

There have been a few serious attempts to investigate non-citizen voting, and they generally catch a low-double figure number of illegal votes per state.

Post-Omicron variants of COVID, in someone who is vaccinated or previously infected, are less bad than 'flu.

But 'flu kills people as old and frail as Joe Biden all the fricking time.

If the AI is designed by hyphenated-Americans in Silicon Valley, the AI waifus will be miniskirted anime girls who fit the "submissive Asian girlfriend" stereotype.

Nobody wants a heritage-American waifu. The Blue Tribe version is too mouthy and the Red Tribe version is too fat.

It's stag hunt where "Don't build Skynet" is playing co-operate.

It would also need to be a false statement of fact. Statements of opinion can't be legally false. And beauty is in the eye of the beholder. If "is female beauty a fact or an opinion" gets to SCOTUS, "opinion" wins 9-0, or 8-1 with Thomas dissenting if a "fact" ruling would help a Republican.

They were told it’s unconstitutional.

Only in the trivial sense that every time the President breaks a law he also violates the Take Care clause. Biden v Nebraska was a statutory interpretation case which held that the clause in the HEROES act allowing the Secretary of Education to waive or modify student loans in connection with a national emergency (which COVID qualified as) didn't extend to the kind of broad-based loan forgiveness that the Biden administration wanted to do.

They did it anyway.

Having been told that he couldn't use the HEROES act, Biden looked around for other sources of statutory authority which didn't involve such a big stretch. The biggies are Publicig Service Loan Forgiveness (The statutes say that the government can discharge student loans if someone works for the government or certain other "public service" employers for ten years. This used to be almost impossible to claim because of paperwork requirements, but Biden just cancelled the loans for anyone whose employment record showed the required ten years of public service.) and income-based repayment (The statute allows the Secretary of Education to define rates and thresholds, and Biden made them a lot more generous). These are also going to end up in front of SCOTUS, but if statutes are interpreted to mean what they say Biden would win. But this Supreme Court has tended to interpret delegations of power more narrowly than you or I would based on reading the statutory text because they don't trust Congress to protect its own Constitutional role.

I don't even think this is "exploiting loopholes" at this stage. Congress intended to give the Executive broad discretion to write off student loans for borrowers who were struggling to repay them, and they did. Congress may or may not have intended that discretion to extend as far as Biden is taking it - the answer is probably mu because Congress notoriously doesn't have a brain and can't intend things other than explicitly. If America had a functioning Congress, Congress could have said what it meant. As we are, the administration and the Courts are butting heads over who gets to decide questions that Congress negligently chose not to.

The judge's rulings on a point of law are binding unless appealed. That you can't put up a legal expert to explain to the jury why the judge is wrong on the law is Courtroom Procedure 101. In a better legal system, this point probably should have been resolved on an interlocutory appeal before trial, but in the US system as it exists that wouldn't have helped because the appeal would have gone to a NY State appeals court, and what is actually needed is a Federal ruling on a difficult technical point of Federal law.

The US system (going right back to the Constitution making federal trial courts optional and the Federalist Papers explaining that federal law could be enforced in State courts) assumes that state courts can be trusted to get federal law right. The ways a federal court can overrule a State court on a point of federal law are deliberately restricted.

Telling your co-worker she’s beautiful when she’s bummed a date went bad is a crime.

Technically it isn't. Allowing one co-worker to tell another that she's beautiful when she's bummed a date went bad is a tort on the part of the employer, but sexual harrassment laws are not criminal laws, and are not directly enforceable against non-manager employees.

Normally I wouldn't get this technical, but given that a large part of the "the NY prosecution is a stretch" is based on the distinction between different kinds of illegality, I think we should.

Disaffected leftists were warning other leftists that cancel culture was destroying the left from within by allowing leftists to use cancellation campaigns to settle intra-left personal beefs as early as 2013.

McCarthy was cancelled (by the Army-McCarthy hearings) when he started using anti-Communist cancellation campaigns to settle intra-right personal beefs. The left needs to do this for its own sake as well as for the rest of us.

I don't think the kind of security that is able to take over privately-owned buildings which provide rooftop overlooks of a rally site is something money can buy. Nor should it be.

Obviously as a Brit I'm consuming the fictionalised version of the American frontier from a long distance, but in the Cowboys and Indians mythos I grew up with Indians were always Worthy Opponents in the TVTropes sense. I assume this idea dates back to the golden age of the Western as a movie genre because that is where the tropes come from.