@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

NFT hatred was a thing on day 1 because people accurately predicted that the NFT space would become full of lies, fraud, scams etc.

As someone who was an anti-Bush, anti-war liberal in the 2000s its been incredibly black pilling for me to see the Democratic Party become the very thing I was fighting against.

I don't think the Biden administration has gotten involved in any new land wars in Asia - in fact they got out of one by implementing Trump's surrender to the Taliban.

In the UK, where non-Jewish boys are not circumcised, they explicitly tell parents that they don't need to worry about UTIs in boys. It isn't a big risk. I did frequent urology clinics back in my mis-spent youth (I smashed up my dick in a cycling accident). Invariably I was the only man under 75in the waiting room.

I was more thinking of Average Centrist Dad as an achievable example of pro-social masculinity - if you think that you need to be Audie Murphy to be a real man then you may have been huffing too much feminist propaganda about how husbands and fathers aren't masculine because women can do that to.

When District 9 came out in 2009 it wasn't 100% clear if it was supposed to be about apartheid or about illegal immigration. (South Africa was having a problem at the time with illegal immigration from Zimbabwe). It was a critical and commercial success.

If one's orientation is to be intolerant of those acts outside of the priesthood, there is no ideological reason for you to hesitate to punish them when it happens within.

The reason why people tolerate sexual abuse in organisations is not ideological - it is office politics. Every organisation which provides male authority figures with access to women or boys has had sexual abuse scandals. If the organisation has a culture of strong hierarchy, it has engaged in the same type of cover up. If the organisation is affiliated to a religion which says that women and boys should not publicly criticise adult men, then the abuse probably happened on an industrial scale. Why? Because once you are senior enough to be a political player, helping your colleague cover up his sexual misconduct is a cheap-but-valuable favour in the Game of Thrones. If you are cynical enough, also because people who are mutually compromised can co-ordinate better by using blackmail as an enforcement mechanism.

Even with the theoretically absolute power of the Pope over the Catholic Church, fortified by an explicit command from a God that almost everyone involved actually believes in not to do this kind of stuff, coming down on this kind of stuff once it is widespread is a political challenge. The Pope can only piss off so many bishops at once, and the paedo-enablers had become a sizeable faction. There is a fairly widespread theory that Benedict XVI resigned because he couldn't do it.

I mean, it was about both.

Obviously - the point I was making was that the part that wasn't about plagiarism was about a backlash against anti-Semitism that is entirely consistent with the well-understood rules of woke leopards eating woke faces, not some kind of more general backlash against wokeness.

And Rufo leveraged twitter as the platform to get eyeballs on the allegations and increase pressure on the organizations

The damage was done by a cabal of Jewish big-dollar donors (of whom Ackman was the public face), and to a lesser extent by MSM coverage of the Congressional hearings. Both the Congressional GOP and the Jewish donors were co-ordinating offline, not on Twitter. There is no way a powerful Blue Triber resigns due to a campaign by Chris Rufo's social media followers.

Hence, Elon being a very visible source of open dissent

More visible than the fricking President of the United States? Not only did Trump have a bigger bully pulpit than Musk, his being elected was a very public single that tens of millions of normies liked what he was saying. DorseyTwitter didn't ban Trump until after Jan 6th.

Even if you ignore Trump, right-wing views that the NYT considered cancellable (e.g. "Blacks do most of the crime", "Transwomen are men" or "Hunter Biden is selling out America") were mainstream on Fox, in the WSJ and NY Post, on talk radio and on Boomer Facebook. The idea that the right was operating by samizdat until Elon bought Twitter is silly. (HBD was beyond the pale in those right-wing venues, but unobfuscated HBD still doesn't fly on ElonTwitter).

Twitter wasn't important because the masses were on Twitter. Twitter was important because aspirant elites who needed to publicly push the party line used Twitter to work out what the party line was in real time. These people . That the sort of person who had a bluecheck on DorseyTwitter hasn't changed their political views is convincing evidence that Elon buying Twitter isn't what is changing the discourse.

The simplest explanation (not necessarily the most correct one) for woke losing ground is that the elites are much more equivocal in supporting it after 10/7 when it became clear that wokestupid can turn anti-Semitic at the drop of a paraglider.

Followed not too long after by Ivy League presidents getting booted out for plagiarism.

That was about Jews. Wokestupid is always blundering around the boundaries of cancellable anti-semitism, and above a certain level of prominence if you engage in cancellable anti-semitism, you get cancelled no matter how woke you are. (Wokists are constantly cancelling their own anyway.) It took longer to cancel Jeremy Corbyn than it did to cancel Claudine Gay, but Corbyn was cancelled when the Great Awokening was at its height.

I think a big difference to keep in mind is that you can choose your own gender (according to the very in-group of gender minded folks) but you cannot choose your own race.

This is not my parsing of the dogma the annoying transactivists are trying to push (unsuccessfully in the UK, even in left-wing circles, though by most of what I read on the internet they are succeeding in Blue America). If you take "gender identity" seriously then people don't get to choose their own gender identity - by the time you go through puberty your "gender identity" is an objective fact about you, and is fixed. The claim isn't "you can choose your own gender", it's "we should believe as a matter of course people who claim to have a gender that doesn't match their biological sex". Transactivists are comfortable with the idea that some people are trans (as a matter of objective fact about their "gender identity") and either don't know it yet or are lying about it due to closeting, and a few of them are even willing to admit that in principle a cis man could pretend to be a trans woman for nefarious purposes (Jonathan/Jessica Yaniv is widely suspected to be an example) - they just think that there are so few of them that letting them get away with it causes less harm than gatekeeping actual trans people.

You get to choose your own preferred pronoun. But transactivists who stop to think don't think agree that this isn't claiming a gender identity, it's just a pronoun. The easy case is that not everyone who is nonbinary uses they/them pronouns, and not everyone who uses they/them pronouns has the same non-binary gender identity. The harder case is that closet cases and trolls exist.

In this model, race, like gender identity, is an objective fact about people. The difference is that it is externally observable, so you don't need to trust people who claim to be black. Kicking Rachel Dolezal out of "Black" doesn't put the blackness of actual black-skinned black people into question in they way kicking Yaniv out of "Trans" or "Woman" puts the transwomanness of non-passing transwomen into question.

I agree "there is an objective fact about people that is completely unobservable externally and which ingroup never, ever lie about" is a silly thing to believe. But I think transactivists actually believe this - they don't believe that genders are clothes you can take on and put off. If you get an older transactivist drunk, they may even admit that they find tumblrgendered snowflakes annoying too.

You also need to have convincingly masculine authority figures for them to emulate. In post-Boomer western culture, the institutions that should be pointing to exemplars of pro-social masculinity as authority figures for young men to emulate are instead pointing to outlaws and women.

This is the motte-and-bailey that is "trans genocide". They want us to think that the genocide is transphobes murdering trans people, and are able to point to a non-zero number of murders which fit that pattern. But the actual motte is that failing to give trans people everything they want is genociding them by driving them to suicide.

LGBT refers to an activist coalition, not a community (there is a gay community, and a largely separate lesbian community which rather famously does not, in fact, include straight guys who self-identify as lesbians). If said activist coalition has shifted from LGB issues to T issues (and it has) and LGB is more popular than T (which it is) then that would be sufficient to make "LGBT" as a dangling signifier less popular.

On a skim of Moore (see here for my earlier post based on the briefs):

  • The IRS wins 7-2 (Kav writing, but it read like a Roberts opinion), on the narrow grounds that a tax on realised income of a corporation imputed to the shareholders is an "income tax" and therefore legal under the 16th amendment. It avoids the question that people were excited about, and which the Court said it would answer when it granted cert, which is whether a tax on unrealised income can be an "income tax".
  • Thomas (who I expected to dissent) and Goresuch (who I did not) dissent. The tone of the dissent is that their real beef is that the majority punted on the big question - their writing on why the majority are wrong on the imputed realisation question they did answer is a bit half-hearted.
  • Barrett and Alito do not join the majority, but concur in the judgement, saying that there is a realisation requirement, but that imputed realisation meets it.
  • Jackson joins the majority, and writes separately that there are lots of ways the tax at issue might be indirect (and thus legal), including the possibility that a tax on Americans holding shares in foreign companies might be an indirect tax by analogy with tariffs and suchlike.

So on the question that made the case a hot-button case, you have 4 justices saying that there is a realisation requirement, 4 1/2 punting, and Jackson sort-of-saying that there isn't. This means that a wealth tax almost certainly loses if it reaches the Court.

Other comments:

  • Everyone involved (parties and all 9 justices) was very keen to say that they didn't want to blow up the Internal Revenue Code by saying that all forms of taxation based on imputed realisation are unconstitutional. There is a lot of casuistry about whether or not the tax at issue is distinguishable from the long-standing forms of imputed realisation (S-corps, LLPs and similar corp/partnership hybrids, personal service company taxation etc.)
  • Both the majority and the dissent write about the history from the perspective that the 16th amendment redefined income taxes as indirect, not that it made a specific type of direct tax legal. This seems silly to me.

Do you pay off pornstars with company money and cook the books to cover it up, conspire to prevent the duly elected President assuming office, or continue to keep a trove of classified docs at your home after the Feds explicitly ask for them back?

None of the things Trump is being charged with are three felonies a day bullshit. All four criminal indictments involve malum in se behaviour - the theory for the false accounting being a felony based on a predicate campaign finance violation is a stretch, but the fact that Trump committed misdemeanor false accounting was clearly established in Court.

  • -19

If you want your tech providers to work for you, use a paid service.

Is there any reason why Google, Discord, or Protonmail should care about their services being unusable to a non-paying, uncooperative customer?

The problem here is that the ANC have almost all of the power because they have a free choice of coalition partner - they can work with the DA or MK or EFF plus 3 seats from small left-wing parties. MK's ask is that Ramaphosa resigns, which makes that the deal the ANC least wants to do, but if the DA asks for too much the ANC can work with EFF+ instead.

For unclear reasons, the ANC has invited any party who wants to join the coalition even through they only need the DA's votes (knowing that EFF and MK would say no) and the cabinet is expected to include IFP (the right-wing Zulu party) and Patriotic Alliance (Faragism for Coloureds) ministers.

Okay, fair. I didn’t realize Europe was almost totally party list based, I’m familiar with the push for alternative voting in the UK and thought that was an attempt to align with the continent.

There is no push for single-member AV in the UK. Reform and the Liberal Democrats support moving to a proportional system (we prefer STV to lists, but the rhetoric is about the principle of proportionality, not the details of the system); Labour and the Conservatives want to retain FPTP. There was a referendum on moving to single-member AV in 2011 (which failed) because that was the best offer the Conservatives were willing to make to bring the Liberal Democrats into a coalition.

Does this issue just not appear in practice because there just aren't ever that many candidates so the factorial of the number of candidates stays manageable?

Not sure about Australia, but the UK traditionally transported all of the ballots in one race to a central location and mixed them before counting them in order to obfuscate the precinct-level results. (This is logistically trivial if the largest race is a 65,000 elector Westminster seat). So summability is not relevant. For the London Mayoralty (which used an IRV-like system where voters are only allowed 2 preferences) running the whole count at one site is a logistical headache - when the Tories changed the counting system to FPTP this allowed the counters to count the mayoral vote at borough level and sum.

The largest single IRV/AV race is the Irish presidency. Does anyone know how that is counted?

But adding on to that, ranked choice voting is something popular in Europe (which means +10 interest among Democrats and -10 interest among Republicans),

Not really, although I agree that is the vibe. "Ranked choice voting" isn't a technical term, but the specific system that people talking about RCV are actually talking about is usually the system called IRV (instant runoff voting) in the US and AV (alternative vote) in the rest of the world. This is a better way of counting a single-winner election like a President, Governor, directly-elected Mayor or legislator elected from a single-member district. Most of Europe is Parliamentary with the legislature elected by proportional representation, so they don't have single-winner elections that matter, and therefore don't need to think deeply about how to count single-winner elections.

The only country that uses IRV/AV in an election that matters (as opposed to non-executive figurehead Presidencies) is Australia.

The other system that Wikipedia gives as an example of RCV is STV (single transferrable vote) in multi-member districts. It is used for the lower houses of the Irish and Maltese Parliaments, and the Australian Senate. It is also very widely used to elect the governing committees of mass membership organisations like unions.

Continental Europe almost entirely uses party-list PR to elect its legislatures (some systems, including Germany, have constituency MPs but the top-up is designed so that the constituency results don't usually affect the party composition of the legislature). France uses actual runoffs in single-member constituencies, and Italy uses a hybrid of FPTP and party-list PR.

By normie ideological purity standards sympathy for incels from a man is misogynistic. Pro-HBD guys like Razib Khan and Stephen Hsu are racist. By objective measure standards, wanting smart and beautiful people to have more children is eugenic.

I agree strongly. There is a set of views which society generally considers to be cancellable (in the sense that the currently ruling elite does, as does a supermajority of people who are smart enough to have well-formed views on the issue). Steve Hsu, Razib Khan, Robin Hanson and even Scott Siskind all in fact hold some of these views. So "cancel the rationalists" is, by the rules the Grauniad and NYT are playing by, good journalism. The partisan-flipped version of "don't cancel the rationalists" is "It is okay for communists to act in Hollywood", not "The actors on Joe McCarthy's list are not in fact communists".

I am a pro-free-speech liberal, so both "racists should not be cancelled" and "it is okay for communists to act in Hollywood" are bullets I am willing to swallow. But most people aren't.

Of course, the Guardian gleefully doxxes Scott again

Scott is no longer trying to conceal his real name, so you can't doxx him by publishing it any more. If doxxing means anything, it means either

  • Publishing (or signal-boosting obscure but publically-available) contact information in a way which makes it likely your more deranged followers will harass someone.
  • Publicly linking an online pseudonym to a real-world identity which the pseudonymous poster wishes to conceal.

I think this is giving “rationalists et al.” way too much credit. They aren’t a potential counter elite that’s a threat to the real elite.

There very obviously is a reasonably ideologically coherent right-wing counter-elite hiding in plain sight in Silicon Valley. Peter Thiel is the Grand Heresiarch, Roger Mercer was an early backer from the East Coast, and Steven Hsu, Dominic Cummings and Curtis Yarvin were all early recruited talent. Right now the biggest players are Elon Musk and Mark Andreesen, with David Sacks as court jester. Balaji Srinivasan is pursuing a separate project, but is clearly sympathetic. Richard Hanania's vomit-inducing hagiography of this group makes him the spoony bard of the movement. If the current elite is vulnerable to a coup by a shadowy cabal, then this group have the cash and talent to pull it off. They also control two important power centres - VC money (Sequoia and Kleiner Perkins have the prestige, but A16Z and The Founders' Fund have the cool) and Twitter. The main reason the Thielosphere doesn't matter more is that Trump has cut off all the oxygen for any anti-establishment right movement that isn't MAGA, and the Thielosphere disagrees with MAGA on too many points to be allowed near power in a MAGA regime.

"Rationalists et al." are a group with cash and talent who are close to the Thielosphere on the social graph and are sufficiently hostile to the centre-left establishment that they might have been recruitable in a slightly different world. I am 90% confident that Thiel did spend serious cash and effort trying to bring Eliezer Yudkowsky into his network, and I wouldn't be surprised if he had reached out to Scott Siskind as well. Cade Metz' hatchet job accused Scott, almost certainly correctly, of being widely read within the Thielosphere, and therefore presumably sympathetic.

If I was advising George Soros and Klaus Schwab on emerging threats to their world empire, I would include the Thielosphere on the list of things that aren't an immediate threat but need an eye kept on them if they become one. And if I were the Globohomo Elite, Third Class assigned to dealing with the Thielosphere then stopping them absorbing the rationalists would be part of my job. Obvious options include threatening to drive the rationalists out of polite society unless they dissociate themselves from right-wing heresy (worked on Eliezer) or offering a more attractive alternative.

Amusingly, the flow of money from SBF into effective altruism probably was part of the reason that the Thielosphere and the rationalists parted company. SBF was a (as it turns out, rogue) member of the establishment - even to the point of which VCs invested in him (Sequoia backed FTX largely because they were afraid of A16Z becoming the dominant player in crypto). Peter Thiel couldn't or wouldn't compete with SBF in rationalist-buying. If that was an op, then someone has earned a promotion to Globohomo Elite, Second Class.

FDA vs Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine, the mifepristone case, was decided by SCOTUS. Full verdict here. The anti-abortion plaintiffs lose 9-0 on standing, with (quite properly for a case lost on standing) no discussion of the merits. Kav writes for the majority, with Thomas concurring on a technical point of standing law (on one of three theories of standing advanced by AHM the majority think they lose on the facts, but Thomas admits that this is correct under current precedent buy under a correct reading of the Constitution he thinks they lose on the law instead).

Quick thoughts:

  • The unanimous opinion treats this as an easy standing case. It is somewhat longer than an opinion needs to be in an easy standing case, which suggests that at least some of the justices wanted to benchslap Judge Kacsmaryk and the 5th Circuit panel.
  • Standing requirements make lawfare harder. If the right-wing Justices wanted to unleash a campaign of right-leaning lawfare then they could have decided this case differently, so it looks like the small-c conservative aversion to lawfare is holding up even with a right-wing Court.
  • Nevertheless, I suspect the pro-life movement can find a plaintiff with standing - perhaps a Catholic mail carrier who objects to delivering abortifacients could sue under the Comstock Act (which looks like the plaintiffs' best argument on the merits). But nothing is going to be decided before the election if a plaintiff wiht standing files a new suit.
  • The Project 2025 says that an incoming Republican administration should aggressively enforce the Comstock Act (which is prsumptively constitutional post-Dobbs) against pharmacies posting mifepristone to patients. This would render this litigation irrelevant.

The republican talking point isn’t that Hunter and Jim are sleazy. The argument is that Joe was clearly involved. Now you might not believe it, but there is an obvious potential direct connection with Joe and there is documentary evidence supporting that connection. Smoking gun? Doesn’t seem. Enough to get to say more likely than not? Sure.

I don't think we disagree very much here. The Republican talking point is that Joe Biden has probably taken bribes from non-ally foreign countries in a way which is both corrupt and disloyal. Why should anyone think this? Given the lack of direct evidence unearthed by the Comer investigation, the main piece of Bayesian evidence is that Hunter and Jim are sleazy and that Joe presumably could have stopped them, but didn't. We both agree that Hunter Biden's behaviour is Bayesian evidence that Joe is a crook, and therefore is newsworthy - even in the absence of hard evidence against Joe. The question is why some people on this thread (including OP) have trouble applying the same argument to Ginni Thomas's involvement in the events leading up to January 6th.

And Canada has always been, to a point, an empire; if you don't live in the Triangle between Toronto, Ottawa, and Montreal, your vote and your interests don't matter in the slightest when it comes to federal politics. This is slightly less true for the provinces east of that area, and provinces do have some overlap (and it's worth noting that, because the Triangle is not its own province, it can be overruled in Provincial politics especially when that Triangle has made those provinces their enemy... which, naturally, they have).

Thus that Triangle, for all intents and purposes, is Canada, and the rest is just territory that it has empire/dominion over (the "provinces" are more sub-administrative units in the ancient Roman sense; they are not "states"). Quebec's culture is more reactive/resistant to this state of affairs; the West, not as much, but the West has more in common (culturally, legally, linguistically) with the Triangle than Quebec does.

This seems off given the history of the current edition of the Conservative Party of Canada. Stephen Harper is an Albertan, and he built his political career in a party which was initially founded with the explicit goal of providing better representation of Western interests (Reform), and gradually evolved into a generic right-populist anti-Triangle elites party (Canadian Alliance) before doing a reverse takeover of the moribund Progressive Conservative party. Poilievre represents a riding in the Ottawa suburbs, but he grew up in Alberta, was a member of Reform/Canadian Alliance before the merger, started his political career in Albertan student politics, and only moved to Ottawa because he co-founded a lobbying firm with a man who would go on to be Attorney-General of Alberta. I think it is clearly fair to describe Poilievre as Albertan as well.

Even back in the PC era, Brian Mulroney (the last PC prime minister to serve a full term) grew up in (non-Triangle) eastern Quebec and represented a riding in eastern Quebec, although he did have a non-political career in Montreal in between.

The Triangle only dominates Canadian politics when the Liberals are in government and, despite what the Liberals want you to think, that isn't all the time. The Canadian party system in 2024 absolutely represents the interests of Western-Canada-outside-metro-Vancouver - probably beyond the level of representation the population out there merits.