@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

If you want to burn down the District of Criminals, do it yourselves this time. No need to involve the Canadians. Plus an all-American DC fire would probably have better music.

β€œIs life so dear as to be purchased at the price of chains and slavery? I know not what course others may take; but as for me, give me liberty or give me death! β€œ - Satan

Is that from Milton?

I wouldn't know - partly because Ford corporate try very hard not to know the details of how their dealers are screwing retail car buyers, but mostly because the stuff I did learn about the car market was specific to the UK in my youth.

The core fact about the UK car market in the late 20th century was that most new cars were sold to fleet buyers. The reason for this is that, as long as you drove at least 2,500 business miles a year, you qualified for relatively favourable tax treatment on a company car. For most of my youth, my mum did the school run in my dad's company car while he commuted to work by train - and this was completely normal for the middle class. In order to market to fleet buyers, the list price (dealers normally paid 90% of list as in America) was inflated - making the fleet buyer feel he had got a better deal because he negotiated a 12-15% discount. (The way the cost of the discount was split between corporate and the dealer who handled the face-to-face aspects of the sale was the subject of brutal negotiations, and one of my tasks as an intern was to access the computer system that the middle managers didn't understand and pull a list of all fleet discount disputes that had been outstanding for more than a year, and then walk round the accounts receivables department telling a whole bunch of low-end white-collar drones who were mostly 10 years older than me that if they didn't know how to put an update on the system then they had better let me do it because their grandboss was going to be Noticing in a few days' time.) So in the 1990's UK, "How not to get screwed at the dealership" was basically "Never enter a negotiation where the starting point is the list price." The easiest way to do that was to buy nearly new.

Some of this came up in our antitrust training - there was a competition enquiry going on while I was at Ford about why new car prices excluding tax were higher in the UK than in Continental Europe, and we had to learn what we could and couldn't say about it. The official reason was:

  • We don't update prices instantly in response to exchange rate moves, so there is a temporary effect where the strong pound pushes up UK prices.
  • Manufacturers absorb part of the new car tax, so pre-tax prices were lower in countries with higher taxes. The real reason was the point about fleet buyers.

I interned in finance at Ford. The dirty secret is that nearly-new sales through franchised dealerships are a key part of the business model (effectively as a form of price discrimination between the idiots who happily new prices and the price-sensitive customers who want a new-car quality car but without paying the premium), so a dealer is relatively happy to repo that car in a way a bank isn't. So they care less about creditworthiness as long as you have a down payment that covers the difference between the "new" and "nearly new" valuations.

America doesn't have well-enforced unique identities, so there is a high risk that someone past their early 20's with no credit history has fraudulently adopted a fresh identity in order to conceal their uncreditworthy past. Lenders don't want to touch that with a bargepole.

It didn't happen in the Anglosphere, but the main left-wing newspapers in France and Germany reprinted the Danish Mohammed cartoons, on the basis that it was progressive to mock religious pretension. The Four Horsemen were notoriously anti-Islam - that is why the New Atheism fell out of favour in prog circles.

Speaking as an atheist in a country where Christianity is the official state religion, I do not think that actually-existing American Christians would be willing to make the compromises that Anglicanism made in order to survive as a state religion in England, let alone the greater compromises needed in a country which is deeply committed to the idea that all Christian denominations are equally valid. Nor do I think that "mere Christianity" would work - the differences between Christian traditions matter. I wouldn't want to deal with the fallout when someone prays the Hail Mary over the tannoy before a Notre Dame vs BYU game.

Upvoted for capital-T Truth.

We can argue about the allegorical meaning of Genesis 2 and how it relates to human sexuality until we are blue in the face, but you should always start with the literal meaning.

The literal meaning of Genesis 2, if you give it its usual context in the Christian story (as, for example, represented by its use as the first lesson in a standard Christmas carol service), is that the original sin was independent moral discernment. Satan's promise is not money, or sex, or power - it is to possess the moral wisdom of God. There are plenty of other scriptural passages reinforcing this. And certainly when I was taught Christian morality, both as child in nominally-Christian schools in the UK and as a potential convert in university, the key message was that the only real sin is rebellion against divine authority, and the drinking and sabbath-breaking flows from that.

All the Abrahamic religions are fundamentally about total submission of human will to God's. Judaism, Islam, and Protestantism all have a tradition of religious scholarship where all moral wisdom that humanity will ever have is already written down in a closed canon of fundamental works (either directly from divinely-inspired authors, or preserved commentary based on lost divinely-inspired sources) and the work of religious scholars is just to interpret it. Catholicism and Orthodoxy both claim that there is a still-living tradition capable of generating new moral wisdom, but that there is no access to God outside it.

This is why "Abrahamic religion bad" comes so easily to non-religious Americans - the great American social experiment is fundamentally about allowing independent moral judgement at the lowest possible level.

Also that mortgages are widely priced off FICO scores despite the fact that Fannie and Freddie both have in-house credit scoring models which are more accurate for mortgage lending than FICO, which is designed for unsecured lending.

Growing up in the UK in the 1980's, you normally saw national flags in schools in two situations - classrooms usually used for foreign language lessons, and displays of large numbers of small flags (either because you were in a geography classroom or because some piece of silly internationalism was being celebrated). Schools were technically government buildings, so a school that had a flagpole would fly the Union Flag on the 10-15 days a year when flags were supposed to be flown from government buildings.

As a parent of school-age kids in the Current Year, the two standard use cases are still common. Actual cloth Union Flags still seem rare, but schools in immigrant-heavy areas are expected to teach "British values" which in practice means that there is usually a wall display of kid-coloured paper Union Flags up somewhere in the school. I don't know if this happens in outer-suburban whiteopia. The other thing that changed is that since the 2012 Diamond Jubilee, low-key celebration of royal occasions somehow stopped being cringe. So my son's school was all done up with red, white and blue bunting for the 2022 Platinum Jubilee and the 2023 Coronation.

There was a large Pride flag in the visitors' entrance lobby during Pride Month, but my impression was that Pride was otherwise low-key in the way you would expect at a school where muslims and west African evangelicals together make up almost half of the parents.

free on bond pending sentencing

Or pending appeal. This case is messy enough that as long as Trump keeps paying his lawyers he can tie it up in the appeals courts until the only sentence that makes sense is house arrest in his nursing home.

The 14th Amendment is rather quiet about how it's insurrection rule is to be enforced: it's not clear who actually gets the power to decide "insurrection" occurred. The federal courts? The states? Local officials setting up ballots?

All the amendments are similarly quiet. The idea that it is specifically the courts that are responsible for enforcing (say) the 1st amendment is quite recent. At the time of the founding, the dominant view was that all political actors were obliged by their oaths of office to act constitutionally - that legislators should not pass unconstitutional laws, presidents should veto them if they do pass, etc.

The same approach to section 3 of the 14th is that it is incumbent on everyone not to allow insurrectionists into office. Parties should not nominate insurrectionists, secretaries of state should not put them on the ballot, voters should not vote for them, presidential electors for insurrectionists should go faithless (the Constitution overrides faithless elector laws) and the joint session of Congress should object to the electoral votes if they don't. The job of the courts is then to handle the inevitable litigation when people disagree about whether Trump really is an insurrectionist. Obviously, this is bad and puts you straight in a constitutional crisis.

But America is already in a constitutional crisis. Either Trump is right and you are a country where elections are routinely rigged, or Trump is lying and you are a country where there are no electoral consequences for spamming false allegations of vote-rigging the way most politicians spam promises of other people's money and demanding criminal investigations of local election officials for doing their jobs, or Trump is delusional and you are a country which is about to elect a madman as chief executive.

This is scary, man. And I don't even live in America.

Given Baude's politics, I suspect the motivation of the original law review article was "Dear Conservative Movement, if you want to yeet Trump and replace him with a more electable candidate, here is how to do it without having to beat him in a primary." At the time he published the article, it had only just become clear that Trump couldn't be beaten in a Republican primary, but non-MAGA Republicans were still assuming that Trump would go down to Biden in a landslide given how badly MAGA candidates did in 2022.

This isn't an area of law where a judge is going to worry about setting a dangerous precedent, so I think the average GOP-aligned judge would disqualify Trump iff he thought doing so would help the GOP. Right now, the core MAGA vote is sufficiently behind Trump that any attempt by the GOPe to change candidate would blow up the party, so Trump is probably safe.

Rather more than half, given that 1st-world Asian countries did in fact prevent 80-90% of the deaths relative to a US baseline, and "the best SV companies" are presumably claiming to be more competent than Taiwanese bureaucrats (are they? Good question, and I don't know the answer). In terms of the combined cost of COVID mortality and morbidity and of unnecessary and ineffective preventative measures, the US was shockingly bad (and the UK was almost as bad - the only thing we got right was the vaccine rollout).

Preventing 1/2 the US deaths isn't the level of competence of the best SV companies, it's the level of competence of a slightly-above-average first world government bureaucracy.

Making frivolous objections to electoral votes based on false claims of electoral irregularities (which wouldn't include 2001, but would probably include 2005 and definitely include 2017 and 2021) is bad and the congresscritters who did it should feel bad. But they are protected from prosecution by the Speech and Debate clause, so this isn't a case of selective prosecution. The House should probably have censured the Reps who made frivolous objections in 2017 - although most of them never got the chance to make false allegations on the record, so it would presumably only have been for disorderly conduct.

Incidentally, the VP doesn't have any discretion whether to entertain an objection - under the rules at the time, he has to accept it and allow a debate if it is supported by at least one Rep and at least one Senator (as in 2005 and 2021), and can't accept it if it is only supported by Reps (as in 2001 and 2017). (It now requires a fifth of the members of each house to force a debate on an objection).

This seems so blatantly inbounds ethically that it amazes me that this is what they're going after him for.

As with the lawsuits, the Trump-Raffensberger phone call is improper (both as a matter of ethics and as a matter of criminal law) if and only if the factual claims Trump made were knowingly false. The Georgia indictment indicts the call as "False Statements and Writings" and "Solicitation of Felony Violation of Oath of Office" (in that Raffensberger knew there was no fraud, and would therefore have violated his oath of office by launching the investigation Trump requested). The Federal indictment doesn't charge individual bad acts, but it describes the phonecall as "the defendant lied to the Georgia Secretary of State".

Filing a false police report is not protected speech.

As a separate matter, Trump threatened Raffensberger with criminal liability for aiding and abetting the (non-existent) fraud. That probably should be a crime, but it doesn't appear to be given that it isn't charged in either the Federal or the Georgia indictment.

Somehow he's only increased his support as he's been found to have committed sexual assault, fraud, and insurrection.

He's increased his support in the Republican primary, but the primary voters switching to him in response to the indictments are die-hard partisans who were going to vote R in the general no matter what.

538 isn't publishing a poll tracker for the general yet, but the Biden and Trump approval polls have been pretty flat since before the indictments, and anecdotally Trump has consistently been a nose ahead of Biden in head-to-head polling.

There is a big difference between using recount laws for the purpose for which they were intended (even if those recount laws later turn out to be unconstitutional) and filing lies with the court. Neither Bush nor Gore was ever accused of filing briefs containing false factual claims - the key facts of Bush v Gore (that recounting punch card ballots accurately was sufficiently difficult that there wasn't time for an accurate statewide recount before the electoral College deadline, and that the margin of error of the original count exceeded Bush's margin of victory) were never disputed.

Trump's State court challenges to the 2020 election are criminal if and only if they were based on knowingly false factual claims. Both the Federal and Georgia indictments promise to bring evidence that they were.

it would eventually have to also make a finding on the free speech issue

Baude's original law review article advocating disqualifying Trump points out the 14th amendment is also part of the Constitution, so the 1st amendment doesn't automatically apply the way it would to a normal criminal law. Under the normal rules for resolving conflicts between two laws of equal authority, the 14th overrules the 1st, both as the more specific provision and as the after-enacted provision.

So it is entirely possible that Trump is disqualified for inciting an insurrection, but is still protected by the 1st amendment from criminal prosecution for inciting a riot.

Trump did not incite a riot in any way, shape, or form. There is simply no reasonable line you can draw between Trump's statements (which, among other things, were not made at the site of the riot) and the riot. Not by the Brandenburg standard, and not by any standard which has been applied to any politician since Brandenburg.

The line from Trump's speech to the riot is that Trump's speech is a but-for cause of the riot. If Trump doesn't assemble the mob and tell them to go to the Capitol, they don't go to the Capitol. No mob, no riot.

The questions "Did Donald Trump incite a riot?" and "Can Donald Trump be criminally prosecuted for inciting a riot, given the 1st amendment?" are not the same question - "incite" has an ordinary English meaning, and on the ordinary English meaning of "incite", Trump so did. The 1st amendment is, for the obvious good reasons, over-protective of political speech - it isn't surprising that it is possible to incite a riot while (just) staying within the boundary of protected speech. Trump shouldn't be prosecuted for inciting a riot, and he isn't being prosecuted for inciting a riot (both the Federal and Georgia indictments focus on his various attempts to overturn the election before Jan 6th). That doesn't mean he didn't incite a riot.

Growing up in the UK, our pro-free speech tradition has tended to rely on John Stuart Mill's On Liberty for the moral (not legal) limits of free speech in contexts that look like incitement.

An opinion that corn-dealers are starvers of the poor, or that private property is robbery, ought to be unmolested when simply circulated through the press, but may justly incur punishment when delivered orally to an excited mob assembled before the house of a corn-dealer, or when handed about among the same mob in the form of a placard.

Trump assembled an excited mob at the Ellipse, told them that the politicians in the Capitol were stealing an election, and then told them to go to the Capitol and "fight". On the John Stuart Mill test, he has (just) exceeded the bounds of protected free speech. Under the Brandenberg test, he (just) stayed inside it. On this point, the law is on Donald Trump's side, so I am going to pound the facts. Donald Trump did, in fact, incite a riot on January 6th.

  • -16

And don't "Jan 6th!" at me, this kind of hysteria was in full flow before ever that happened.

There were warning signs before the 2016 election. At the time I didn't take them seriously, but someone who was better calibrated than me could have done, as could someone who was looking for excuses to hate on Trump. But with hindsight, I think it should have been obvious that Trump was more likely than most other Republicans to do January 6th.

  1. Trump jump-started his political career by being one of the most prominent people to stick with birtherism after Obama's birth certificate was authenticated by the State of Hawaii - and he didn't finally concede that Obama was born in the US until after he had the 2016 primary sewn up. Falsely claiming that the President is ineligible is an attack on US democracy.
  2. Trump engaged in mild brownshirt behaviour during the campaign, like leading chants of "Lock Her Up" and encouraging supporters to beat up protesters. This isn't anti-democratic in itself, but empirically brownshirt behaviour is correlated with someone being a threat to democracy.
  3. Trump either joked about or actively solicited (the GRU didn't get the joke) Russian help in hacking his opponent's e-mails. I don't want to rehash the argument about whether this is collusion or not, but even if it isn't, thinking that attacks on American democracy by a hostile foreign power are a joking matter says something about Trump.
  4. Trump said in the 3rd 2016 debate that he would "keep you in suspense" about whether he would concede defeat if he lost.
  5. Even after winning, Trump falsely claimed that millions of people had voted illegally in the 2016 election and that he was the legitimate popular vote winner.
  6. As President, Trump continues to transgress various norms in a way which constitutes weak circumstantial evidence that he is the sort of person who would transgress the norm that defeated Presidential candidates concede. Notably, he tries to strongarm Zelezny into launching a (probably bullshit) criminal investigation of the Bidens, and to share nonpublic information about said investigation with the Trump campaign.
  7. Before the 2020 election, Trump again refuses to commit to accepting the results.

Trump was a transgressive candidate - for many of his supporters, that was the whole point. The people who said that this transgressiveness was a threat to American democracy were right, for the right reasons - as confirmed by the events leading up to Jan 6th, even more so than by Jan 6th itself.

Immediately after the 2016 election, everyone knows that Trump is publically badmouthing America's democratic institutions. The Orange Man really is saying Bad things. The question is whether he means them, or whether this is just his schtik. "Orange Man Bad" and "Trump Derangement Syndrome" are memes used by the right (and by the centrist punditocracy which is on its last legs before finally being booted out after George Floyd ODs near a cop) to imply that taking him seriously is cringe. But Trump was serious.

  • -11

On balance I do favour a Bill of Rights, but with a get-out - either something like the Canadian notwithstanding clause, or a Constitutional amendment process that is easy enough that a stable 55% majority who know what they want can amend the Bill of Rights in order to get it.

I think the ability of a court to ask the political branches "Are you sure your really want to do this?" is valuable because the nature of politicians is that sometimes they do stupid stuff for a quick headline, and the sort of rights that get put into Bills of Rights ought to be taken seriously. And the possibility of being overruled acts as a deterrent to judges who want to get their inner politician on.

  1. the second amendment and 2) an active movement of conservatives who continually fight for their gun rights.

Wrong order. When there wasn't a large active movement of citizens fighting for gun rights, the 2nd amendment was treated like an inkblot.

Agreed - I was answering the question about "Why do Indian elites stay in a literal shithole rather than moving to a country which has discovered the lost art of street-sweeping?"

I profoundly disagree on the dating. Gamergate isn't a cause of the culture war, it is a reaction to the fact that video game journalism had already been taken over by SJWs, or at least by unethical weasels who successfully resorted to acting like SJWs when called out.

I was still hanging out in left-wing spaces at the time, and I see the key point is around the failure of Occupy in late 2011 - that is when the activist energy on the left switches from economic issues to social issues. Steve Sailer puts it slightly later with the death of Trayvon Martin in summer 2012 and Obama's decision to take advantage of it to run a more racialised re-election campaign. Exiting the Vampire Castle is published in 2013, and takes for granted that left-wing activist spaces are already dominated by wokestupid.