MadMonzer
If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your
No bio...
User ID: 896
Also that living in a rich community in a poor country gives you access to cheap servants without needing to learn Spanish or Tagalog and commit a felony.
"Ugly rich" Brits are happy to admit that this is the best aspect of living an expat lifestyle, and I assume it works even better if you are a upper-caste local.
Until the British bring democracy, railways and cricket to India, China is consistently more civilized. The only period where historical GDP per head estimates are higher for India is when China is recovering from being ravaged by Genghis Khan. The only areas where India has world-leading achievements are pure mathematics and classical music.
There are three civilizations - Persia, Rome and China. (Western Civilization is Rome under new management, which is why its hegemonic state is governed by a Senate which sits on Capitol Hill in a building decorated in the Corinthian order). From macro-demographic trends, we can tell that India is dramatically better off when governed by Persians (the Mughals), Romans (the Raj), or Romanized Indians (post-independence democratic India).
I don't think the cradle of Chinese civilization looks bad, although I agree that the Yangtze and Pearl River deltas now look better.
Also they are working unsociable hours due to time zones, which means they are probably tired and cranky.
Managing a team across time zones is hell. And managing Indians from San Francisco is doing it on hard mode, because it is a full 12 hour shift.
The Maya Forstater case in the UK wasn't an employment law case ruling that she was unfairly dismissed (she was on a fixed term contract which wasn't renewed, so she had no rights under UK employment law). The court ruled that her gender-critical feminism was a secular philosophy analogous to a religion, and therefore protected under antidiscrimination laws. This makes political views a stochastically protected class (because you don't know whether a tribunal will find a given set of political views to constitute a philosophy).
Firing a permanent employee with the usual employment law protections (which, in the UK, requires 2 years' tenure) for out-of-work political speech is sufficiently straightforwardly illegal that cancelmobs don't bother asking employers to do it.
I am surprised that as many of one third of Irish people who were baptized Catholic and tick the Catholic box on the census believe in God, let alone transubstantiation.
On the specific question of US history books, Howard Zinn's A People's History of the United States is the first woke history to be widely adopted as a high school textbook, and was published in 1980. The first serious pushback against the Dunning School (the academic version of the Birth of a Nation/Gone with the Wind school of history) is by Kenneth Stampp, who published The Era of Reconstruction in 1965.
The culture war is permanent, because there will always people who want to be free, and there will always be people who want to censor and control them. That is baked into human nature. In one decade the censorious will use Christianity, in the next, they will fight it, but it is the same impulse and the same people. One generation's scolds will enforce patriotism, the next will condemn it, but the underlying impulse is the same. The church lady is the schoolmarm is the SJW.
The Culture War isn't fought between free speakers and censorious arsehats. It is fought between the Red Tribe (the white South and its allies) and the Blue Tribe (New England Yankeedom and its allies), and dates back via Albion's Seed to before the English civil war (with notable lulls during the Era of Good Feelings and the New Deal era). There have been multiple episodes during that period when one side or the other (more often the Reds) had a bout of censorious arsehattery. Right now, the Blues are quite exceptionally censorious in a way which is biting them in the arse when they suddenly can't work out how many intersectional Pokemon points a Jewish cis woman rape victim has. But that doesn't make the Reds pro-free speech, except accidentally. Right now, Elon the Boer is being hailed as the saviour of free speech by the Reds at the same time as he is calling for criminal prosecution of Media Matters for putting a potentially-misleading spin on accurate coverage of how he runs X.
For the Framers, the 1st amendment wasn't a statement of an important free speech principle - it was a part of a negotiated settlement of how the different States could live together in a More Perfect Union. It was quite intentionally not enforceable against the States, several of which had State-level censorship regimes that would never pass muster in the current year. There have always been principled supporters of free speech (notably Jefferson in the Founding era, and the pre-Great Awokening ACLU in my lifetime) but they have always been in the minority.
I am arguing that that bureaucratic power within Alphabet Inc. is less relevant than you might think - the question is at the moment when (and if) Google Deepmind turns on a superintelligent AI, who is the person who is actually setting the direction of the team that determines what said AI. And I think that person is likely to be Demis Hassabis, or someone even lower down the org chart. If Sundar Pichai or Larry Page goes to Demis and tells him to build an AI that is programmed to make Larry technoking of the galaxy, and Demis goes and builds an AI programmed to make Demis technoking instead, I don't see how Larry finds out what is going on soon enough to make a difference.
The Bolsheviks were not Lizardman-tier popular. They got 23% of the vote in the Constituent Assembly elections which were the closest approximation to a free election in post-Tsarist Russia (they happened after the October revolution but before the Bolsheviks consolidated power outside Petrograd) including majorities among the voters they were targetting (the urban working class in Petrograd and Moscow, and the enlisted men in the armed forces), and had already demonstrated enough support in the military to defeat the Kornilov coup. It may not have mattered what Vasya Pupkin thought, but given how things played out it sure-as-hell mattered what Private Ivan Ivanovich thought.
e/acc and the Tech Right do not have the level of elite or popular support they need to take over through anything that looks like politics - at the point Hanania wrote the linked essay the people he was lauding as the future of right-wing politics were backing deSantis. In so far as Balaji Srinivasan had a political project it was based on crypto-enabled exit, and it has already failed - it is now very obvious that the world is a sufficiently dangerous place that you want to be under the protection of a US or Chinese client regime if you own anything worth stealing - particularly if you own anything the Feds or Chicoms would want to steal themselves. The Dominic Cummings project (given the people involved, probably supported in the background by Peter Thiel and Robert Mercer) to replace Trump with someone the Tech Right see as competent and biddable ended up not happening, and if it had happened it would need "orbital mind control lasers complete" persuasion tech in order to beat Trump in a Republican primary.
The only way an e/acc is becoming a technoking is if they build a superintelligent AI and use it to pwn their opponents. And then our technoking will be the man (or possibly transwoman, but definitely someone with a Y chromosome and penis) who is de facto goal-donor to the AI (who is probably a first-tier tech lead who can ignore the de jure top management of his organisation until the AI is turned on, and pwn them afterwards). The only gold-owners who are sufficiently close to top technical AI teams to be de facto goal-donors are Sam Altman and Demis Hassabis. If the AI-enabled technoking isn't one of those two then it is some wunderkind we haven't met yet.
The Omicron variant of covid was intentionally developed (by serial passaging through lab mice) as a much more contagious, much less deadly variant that could quickly provide cross immunity against the more deadly variants.
I find "Omicron was a lab leak" to be >10%. But given that it emerged in South Africa, the idea that it was developed intentionally by people who knew what they were doing gives the South Africans credit for more competence than they possess.
Unelected leaders of some US agencies sometimes lie under oath to Congess.
I don't consider bears shitting in the woods to be a conspiracy theory.
One of the reasons why I don't find most Kennedy conspiracy theories plausible is that the patsy was the least difficult element of the conspiracy to get right, and Oswald was an almost uniquely poor choice of patsy for any of the plausible conspiracies. Re. your case, if the people doing the cover-up were worried about the potential for nuclear war with the Soviet Union, why pin the blame on someone who had defected there and back again rather than a domestic criminal?
Depending on who actually did it, a patsy who fits the stereotype of "angry black man", "Southern conservative", or "mafia" would have worked a lot better for achieving the aims of the conspiracy.
The main reason I don't find most Kennedy conspiracy theories plausible is that the vast majority of historical Presidential assassination attempts look like the Warren Commission version of the Kennedy assasination - a lone assassin who is either outright crazy (e.g. John Hinkley shooting Reagan) or who is not quite normal and has weird fringe political views. So I have a high prior on "lone nut" and the problems with the Warren Commission's ballistics are not sufficient to override it without evidence of a specific conspiracy.
I am not quite sure you understand the depth and level of tracking that's taking place here. This Winston Smith character must have had no interactions with the financial system, no bank account, no driver's license, no on-the-record job, no interaction with the political system at all, no tax events, no phone, no internet usage and no education. How many Mowglis do you think there are in the USA?
How do any of those establish citizenship? Lots of non-citizens have US bank accounts - I had one when I was working dubiously legally in the US (technically I was an academic visitor being paid a per diem rather than salary) with no SSN. Driver's licenses explicitly don't require proof of legal immigration status in most blue states (and no state actually checked immigration status for new license applicants when Winston Smith first got his). An on-the-record job requires an SSN, but even if we ignore the possibility of a fraudulent SSN application made back in the days when the checks were less stringent (as I am positing Yossarian did), having an SSN just proves that you were in a legal status that allowed working at the time you got it (and lots of illegal immigrants are doing on-the-record jobs using SSNs that don't belong to them). The only thing on the list which would be evidence of citizenship is voting, and the same people who want to get tough on illegal immigration tend to believe that large numbers of non-citizen immigrants are voting illegally given how lax the checks are.
If you are a natural born US citizen who has never had a passport, the only original document that proves your citizenship is your birth certificate. (The situation is even worse in the UK, because we don't have birthright citizenship, so to prove citizenship you need not only your birth certificate but information about your parents' immigration status at the time you were born. The flip side is that a much higher percentage of British citizens have had passports at some point in their lives, giving them simple biometric-enhanced proof of citizenship, because we are a smaller country.)
You haven't presented anything that their panopticon wouldn't be able to resolve
The panopticon didn't exist when the events that distinguished Winston Smith from Yossarian happened. I agree with you that the NSA is probably able to verify the citizenship and/or immigration status of anyone who most recently entered the US after the panopticon was put in place post-911. But as most illegal immigrants stay in the US (they can't get back in if they leave), that leaves out a lot of people. The reason why the debate around the Dreamers exists is because the anti-illegal-immigration right is explicitly not willing to do another general amnesty for illegal immigrants who have been in the US for decades without getting caught.
Which, in my experience, is negatively correlated with being a nihilistic troll.
The OG "banning Christmas" meme was never about removing Christmas from the Christian calendar of holidays, or even downgrading it in importance. It was about secular governments with established Puritan churches (including Cromwell's England and colonial Massachusetts) banning the traditional secular celebrations around Christmas in order to force people to take the religious aspect more seriously.
The unpopularity of Cromwell's "War on Christmas" is a large part of why the UK still has a monarchy. There is a reason why the British secular left's approach to Christmas is to flood the zone with trees and Santas, rather than talking about a "Holiday Season" (which any Brit would assume referred to August).
In a Bayesian sense, following mainstream MAGA Republican accounts on Twitter is very weak circumstantial evidence that someone is a "Nazi" (in the sense that the Very Online left use the term - which encompasses a lot of alt-right politics that has nothing to do with the OG NSDAP) - most MAGA Republicans are not alt-right, but most alt-right Americans are MAGA. Following GOPe accounts on Twitter is circumstantial evidence that someone is not a "Nazi" - the GOPe despise both actual Nazis and the "Nazi" alt-right as much as the left does. Whether DeSantis counts as mainstream or GOPe is left as an exercise to the reader.
But that isn't the context. The question is given that we all know the guy posts 14/88 memes, is he doing so because he actually has "Nazi" political views, or is he posting ironically. And in that context, affiliation with mainstream Republicans is much stronger evidence that the guy is serious - the overlap between "mainstream Republican" and "posts 14/88 memes ironically" is basically zero. People who post 14/88 memes ironically are either nihilistic trolls or lefties, and following mainstream Republicans on social media is good Bayesian evidence that someone is neither of those things.
In any case, I am happy to enforce the Rule of Goats against someone who LARPs as a Nazi absent very strong evidence that their heart is in the right place. As in I actually want to the Nazi character get chased round Europe by an old drunk and a cripple, or at least slip on a banana skin while goose-stepping.
But the Trump campaign didn't want that
Thinking about this, I think I am ready to bite this bullet.
On the balance of the publicly-available evidence, the Trump team in the aftermath of the 2020 election was not trying to get the election adjudicated in their favour - unsurprisingly, because after PA turned out to be beyond the plausible margin of fraud, getting the election adjudicated in their favour required them to flip all three of GA, AZ and WI, which was a very long shot. The tactics the Trump team were using were designed to throw enough shade on the integrity of the election that some other pro-Trump actor in the system (State legislatures in purple states with gerrymandered Republican majorities, the Republican majority on SCOTUS, Mike Pence, a pro-coup faction in the military, or an armed mob of conservative citizens) would toss out the election results and "who is inaugurated on 20th January 2021" would be decided otherwise than by an election.
I think the fundamental problem with Florida 2000 was that the election was so close (on the final official result, a 537 vote margin out of 6 million votes cast), the punch card voting machines were so bad (1000-2000 difference in the final margin depending on how you adjudicated the chad), and there was so little experience of adjudicating close elections, that there was no "true winner". Given that handling ballot papers in order to recount them can affect the status of the chad, it is entirely possible that it was physically impossible to identify the true winner (based on the state of the chad at close of polls) even if there had been a generally-accepted set of rules for chad adjudication.
The rationale of Bush vs Gore was that the SCOTUS ruled, correctly, that Florida in 2000 was technically incapable of counting a close election in a constitutionally sound way in the time available between close of polls and the Electoral College deadline. The media-funded recount would go on to determine that Florida in 2000 was technically incapable of counting a close election at all. The remedy in Bush vs Gore was for the justices to decide, on a partisan party-line vote, to throw out one unconstitutional vote tally (the partial hand recount requested by Gore and granted by the Florida Supreme Court) and replace it with another (the machine recount from 3 days after the election, plus some initially rejected military postal votes that were probably-legally cured). This was ugly, but it wasn't "stealing an election" because there was no effective election to steal. The election held on polling day had failed to reach a result and given the timetable the Presidency was necessarily going to be decided otherwise than by an election.
If Florida 2000 had been a close Senate election, it could have been re-run. (As a famous UK example, the Parliamentary election in Winchester in 1997 was re-run because the final tally after multiple recounts was a margin of 2 votes out of about 60,000, and there was a margin of error of about 10 votes due to a faulty punch used to stamp ballot papers). But you can't do that in a Presidential election.
There was a similar problem in 2020. Some of the allegations Trump made were straightforwardly silly (like the Dominion voting machines conspiracy theory), and some could be debunked relatively quickly (like the suitcases of ballots in Fulton County, which turned out to have been storage boxes of correctly-handled ballots which had been on CCTV throughout the process), but some (like the "pristine ballots" which came up elsewhere in this thread) could not have been adjudicated to the standards required to convince sceptics in the time available. An honest attempt to adjudicate the 2020 election in State courts in the time available would have required the Trump campaign to focus on a small number of key issues with the best evidence of malpractice and sufficiently high numbers of votes involved to affect the outcome, the Secretaries of State to provide detailed responses on those points, a trial courts to review the results quickly, and an appeals court to slap down any time-wasting and just tell the parties to get on with it. But the Trump campaign didn't want that and it doesn't look like anyone else, with the possible exception of Raffensberger, did either. If Sidney Powell had been trying to get the Kraken lawsuits tossed on technicalities in order to set up a political argument, she could hardly have done better. And if Trump had trying to get his prima facie serious allegations of fraud lost in the middle of a Gish Gallop of crap, he definitely couldn't have done better than he did. And even if that serious, disciplined adjudication had happened (for the avoidance of doubt, it should have done, and didn't), there would still have been thousands of right-wing "citizen journalists" complaining that their pet allegation had not been adjudicated, as long as they had a ready audience.
One of the straightforwardly good things the revised Election Count Act post-2020 does is that it extends the deadlines for States to adjudicate their own elections by removing the schedule padding originally needed for messages to get between the State Capitols and Congress on horseback.
But the only reason why easy postal voting benefitted the Democrats was because fear of COVID-19 had become a partisan issue. Pre 2020, both parties said, and acted as if they meant it, that easy postal voting benefitted Republicans (Raffensperger's letter to Congress defending the integrity of the Georgia elections pointed out that the Georgia legislature originally adopted postal voting on demand on a Republican party-line vote).
Had there been no pandemic, the large number of Democrats who voted postally because they were afraid of catching the virus at a polling station would have voted in person, the postal vote would have skewed slightly Republican the way it always does (because of military votes), and "the election is invalid because not enough Democratic postal votes were tossed on technicalities" would not have figured in the Gish Gallop.
"We deserved to win the election because Democrats were too afraid of the coof to go out and vote" was an argument that might have worked in front of the right GOP-appointed judge, but it wasn't going to work with the American people, and the Trump campaign didn't run with it.
And of course the Bulgarian ricin umbrella used to assassinate a Bulgarian dissident in London.
I don't think most tax cheats who get caught "go to prison for a long ass time". The IRS only pursues criminal charges in a small number of high-profile cases (see Motte discussion and linked LessWrong post) and normally just drives you into bankruptcy with civil penalties. (There are about 1500 criminal tax prosecutions a year).
There are unfortunately no published statistics about how likely you are to be criminally prosecuted when there is $1.4m at stake (presumably more likely than for smaller amounts). It looks like the guideline sentence if you do evade this much tax and plead guilty is about 2 years.
A quick check of the right wing alt-media site you link to shows that even they are not claiming that there were 150,000 test ballots improperly included in the count. 150,000 was the total number of postal votes in Fulton County - we can reasonably assume that most of these were legitimate, particularly given that the overall percentage of postal votes in Fulton was close to the statewide average. Nor does the article say that the ballots were lost - it says that Fulton County explicitly says they are not lost, but that one specific right-wing citizen-journalist doesn't believe them.
The actual lawsuit filed by Favorito, a conservative activist and 9-11 conspiracy theorist (the lawsuit filed by the Trump campaign didn't run on this point) is based on an affidavit by Susan Voyles, who saw one batch of 107 "pristine" postal ballots in a box of 8 batches. If you assume that Voyles only looked at one box of ballots to find this batch and therefore that roughly 1/8 of the postal ballots were dodgy, then you get the "possibly 10-20,000 fraudulent votes" alleged by Favorito. And the specific box of votes identified by Voyles was reviewed, and there were no irregularities. So the premise of the Favorito lawsuit is that Voyles misremembered the box number, and that a bunch of randos should be able to go through 150,000 votes to find the needle in the haystack. FWIW, the reason why it has come up again is that the standing issue has finally been adjudicated in favour of Favorito after two trips up and down the appeals hierarchy.
But the important point here is how easy it is to create a Gish Gallop of hinkiness. We have one poll worker claiming (under oath, admittedly) to have seen 107 votes that looked a bit wrong (an argument so frivolous that Trump's lawyers wouldn't touch it), being blown up to 150,000 fraudulently counted test ballots alleged on this forum. And apart from Voyles, who (being under oath) was careful not to allege any specific irregularity, all the amplification was done by randos. There are hundreds of more or less frivolous complaints about the election being exaggerated in thousands of places, and because they get vaguer as well as bigger online, it can take hours to find out what the allegation even is, let alone to rebut it.
Agreed. But the noises that Trump is making now, and that the British Tories were making in the leadup to the Windrush Scandal, are that a de facto amnesty for long-term illegal residents is precisely what they don't want. The problem is with the actual behaviour of anti-immigrant populists, which tends to be "if you have dark skin and no papers we're coming for you". (Joe Arpaio's immigrant roundups in Arizona also caught significant numbers of US citizens by mistake, which is why the Feds eventually stopped co-operating with him.)
A bureaucratic process that takes care not to deport Winston Smith is going to struggle to deport anyone who has been physically present in the US for 10+ years. And empirically that isn't good enough for a grandstanding right-populist government.
This isn't actually true anymore, and hasn't been for a while. The NSA's surveillance and profiling system most likely has a flag for whether or not someone's an illegal immigrant, and if it doesn't it would be able to add one in seconds.
Winston Smith was born in 1970 in a poor rural county which never digitised its birth records. He has never had a passport. The SSA has long-since lost any copies they kept of the documents he submitted when he first applied for an SSN in 1986.
Yossarian was brought to the US by his parents as a teenager in 1983. His shitlib high school guidance councillor helped him acquire an SSN in 1986 using the US birth certificate of a baby who died shortly after being born in 1970. (Back then birth and death certificates were not positively matched, so you could use a dead person's birth certificate). His parents' visas have long since expired, and they were out of status when they died in the 1990s.
How does the NSA know which one is a US citizen and which one is an illegal?
The problem with a mass roundup-and-deport is with corner cases like these, not people who entered the country on a 4-year visa 5 years ago.
In the UK, support for NATO is one of the litmus test issues used to distinguish between the left and the far left. Jeremy Corbyn personally opposes UK membership of NATO, but he didn't try to make pulling out Labour party policy while he was leader because he knew it would have blown up the Labour party.
My understanding is that this is the same in every European country except France (where the Gaullist right saw NATO membership as subservience to the US) and, historically, Spain (because a lot of the Spanish centre-left blamed NATO for propping up Franco).

Also the British in India (notably unlike Ireland) governed through local elites - they had to given that the Indian Civil Service only employed less than 8000 expats - so the idea that local elites lost their initiative due to the effects of British rule seems implausible.
More options
Context Copy link