@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

and thus those who allow feminist age of "consent" mandates (which were the first major "wins" of the modern feminist movement)

The big increases in the age of consent happen in 1885 in the UK and between 1900-1920 in the US - by 1920 the (hetrosexual) age of consent in the UK had reached its current level 16, with an attempt to raise it to 17 failing in 1917, and it was 16 or 18 in every US state except Georgia. In the UK at least, this is part of the Victorian re-moralisation movement, which was heavily driven by women but explicitly dissociated itself from the first-wave feminists, who were still something of a joke. In the US, the timing suggests it was a Progressive thing - I don't know enough about Progressive-era US politics to understand the relationship between Progressivism and first-wave feminism, but they seem to have been allies. So on net I wouldn't say that age of consent laws were feminist laws.

During the sexual revolution, there are attempts (supported by some but no means all feminists) to reduce ages of consent or to undermine enforcement. In the UK, for example, Gillick (doctors can prescribe contraceptives to girls under 16 without the parents knowledge or consent) was widely supported by feminists on harm reduction grounds. Again, age of consent laws are not feminist laws. More recently, you see third wave feminism focussing on abuse of authority (such as teachers banging students) rather than how young the girl is.

As a separate point, the only licit sex with under-16 girls in the pre-age-of-consent era was after marrying them with the father's permission. It has never been socially acceptable for a man to seduce a 14-year-old girl.

To choose an extremely common case, someone who molests a young person who is physically a young adult (because of early puberty, or because society keeps defining the age of adulthood upwards) still socially and legally a child is a child molester by definition, but is almost certainly not a paedophile. I would like to insist on this distinction, but even I struggle to when the child molester in question is a prominent politician on the wrong side of the aisle.

I don't think very many people have much desire to commit rape.

I think the vast majority of heterosexual men have experienced strong sexual desires that could only be satisfied by rape - namely an intense desire to copulate with a specific woman where the attraction is not mutual.

I remember the Nyberg story at the time, and a large part of the pushback was that some of the evidence proving that Nyberg was a paedophile was posts it had made under its previous male identity, which made it easy to shout about gamergaters "outing trans people".

Something similar happened with Aimee Challenor, except on a grander scale.

The serious point here is that "trans people deserve to have their pre-transition identities memory-holed under penalty of strong anti-discrimination laws and norms" and "people can self-identify as trans" implies that anyone can memory-hole their past. And this is particularly attractive to paedophiles and other scum.

The other attraction of epithets is that they scan well. For example, wise Odysseus is polumetis odysseus in the original greek, which has the syllable pattern short-short-long-short short-long-long. The standard second half of a hexameter is long-short-short, long-short-short, long-long, so wise Odysseus fills out a line-end nicely.

Depends on the definition of "few". Rome had an 800-year run from Brennus to the Fall. Constantinople similarly from the founding of the city as a purposes-built capital of the Eastern Roman Empire to the 4th crusade. On a strict definition of "invaded", England is at 950 and counting. In China, based on a quick wiki-check, all changes in dynasty from Jin to Song are due to Chinese domestic politics, not foreign invasion - about a 1000 year run.

Gandhi, of course, should be buried with an ICBM.

I'd prefer if driving with insurance was treated as a right.

It is worth noting that only a small minority of rich, socially responsible Americans drive with adequate liability insurance for the traditional libertarian argument to apply. Most drivers have state-minimum liability coverage, which is something like 25/50 for bodily injury in most states. Even "full coverage" is only 100/300. $100k is not nearly enough to cover a wrongful death or a disabling accident, and probably not enough to cover a broken limb. So the only people who could plausibly claim that their driving safety was between them and their insurer would be the small number of people with 100/300 insurance and a multi-million personal umbrella on top of it. (The UK travel insurance industry treats £2 million umbrella liability coverage as the bare minimum for Brits planning to drive in America).

This raises the question of whether irresponsible Americans impose a larger burden on responsible Americans by commiting crimes or by un/underinsured driving. Looking at the cost-of-injuries tables on https://wisqars.cdc.gov/, the total "cost of injuries" (including medical bills, time off work, quality of life costs, and VSL for fatalities - this is an estimate of what a sane personal injury system would award in damages) is $440 billion for violent crime and $820 billion for car crashes. Given that just under half the car crash number is self-inflicted, and most of the cost is driven by accidents which comfortably exceed policy limits, the answer is that as regards injuries, the two problems are roughly the same size. (I don't know how you would compare the cost of property crime to the property damage caused by car crashes)

The most spectacular example of a nation of shopkeepers who nevertheless fought successfully on multiple continents was, of course, the British Empire. Napoleon wasn't the only former world leader who thought that being a nation of shopkeepers would make the British soft, but he was one of the few who thought that despite being smart enough to know better.

Arab != Muslim. A plurality of Muslims in Christian Europe (i.e. not Turkey, TRNC or traditionally Muslim areas of European Russia) are ethnic Turks. They tend to be well-behaved, and whether you think that Turkish immigration to e.g. Germany has been a net positive for Germans will track your position on whether minimally-selective immigration is a net positive in general.

In the UK, South Asian Muslims are pretty clearly a net positive if you exclude Mirpuri Pakistanis (a specific community who came to greater Leeds to take up low-skill textile jobs after their villages were flooded by a dam, and which grows exponentially by fetching marriage). Turkish Cypriots are sufficiently well-assimilated that it is hard to tell, but that probably implies that they are a small net positive. Mirpuris and Somalis are the main source of problems - neither group is Arab.

Absent a real threat of imminent lawless action, all the examples of obviously-banworthy speech you mention are (at least in the US) protected by the 1st amendment. So in the US, regulating calls for jihad much like other exhortations to commit a crime means not regulating it at all, except in the rare case for a call for jihad against X where X is sufficiently specific to meet the imminent lawless action standard.

Looking at politics rather than law, whether vague or remote exhortations to commit a crime should be default-banned (the "stochastic terrorism" theory) or default-legal (the US status quo) is pretty much at the edge of the Overton window on free speech. Add culture war toxicity, and it isn't surprising that this topic generates a lot of heat and not much light.

The left has their "no enemies to the left" policy, and so apparently do the designated pretend-right-wing controlled opposition party.

In the British context, this is "Black is White" level wrong. Keir Starmer has attracted more press attention for purging Corbynites from the Labour party (including kicking out Jeremy Corbyn himself) than for his work opposing the Tories. Re. the current thing, he has made the milquetoast pro-Israel mouth noises you would expect from someone on the pro-establishment left, and doubled down when attacked for it by pro-Palestine voices in Labour.

The issue for the US's current recruitment woes comes from how the generational transition has matched to politics. The 9-11 recruitment cohort is dead, dead, dead. If you look at age averages, the vast majority of US service members were born after 9-11. If you joined just after 9-11, you are that tiny minority of people who serve a full 20 (for a pension) or go beyond. That means people who joined during the Bush years, have gradually and progressively lost during the Obama years / saw the Trump years / are back in the Obama 2.0/Biden years. There's any number of things that could justify a feeling of disenchantment, from perceptions of futility of the wars, to the progression culture war aspects into military culture/life, and so on.

AARGH. I have lived longer since 9/11 than I had lived before 9/11. I am OLD. I will DIE. NOOOOOO. Why did you have to point this out?

Seriously, middle-aged people underestimate how long ago the worldview-forming events of their youth are. The Boomers used to be the main culprits - Vietnam is about equidistant between WW1 and the present, let alone WW2 - but it is starting to hit Xers and Millenials like me. I work as a risk manager, and my number 1 piece of advice to noobs is "The next Great Crash will happen when the people who remember 2008 look like old fogies. And I am part of the youngest cohort who remember 2008, so be very careful if you think I am an old fogie."

Peacefully protesting at the same time and place as other people are rioting (or where there is credible intelligence of a riot even if it hasn't started yet) is going to get you into trouble almost anywhere - there were cities where the police completely stopped policing in summer 2020, but that isn't the normal way "mostly peaceful protests" are policed, even in deep Blue cities.

If you count Blue client groups, being a young black man wearing gang colours is a constitutionally-protected activity that increases suspicion in the way you suggest.

It is worth remembering that reporters do not write the headlines that appear above their articles. The headline over an article in the "Science" section is written by a generalist sub-editor who knows even less about science than a science journalist does.

Top 10 registered UK charities based on paid employee headcount - not sure how I would find the equivalent for the US. Registration is optional for universities which is why they don't dominate the list.

  • SAVE THE CHILDREN INTERNATIONAL 18409 - Fundraises from the public, mostly doing foreign aid stuff. Some advocacy work, but not as much as, say, Oxfam, so most of the staff are on direct work.
  • NUFFIELD HEALTH 17165 - Fee-charging non-profit which operates a chain of private hospitals and a chain of gyms.
  • THE BRITISH COUNCIL 9861 - About 1/2 of the budget is language schools (fee-charging with some UK government subsidy) and 1/4 is handing out scholarships for overseas students at UK universities (ultimately UK government funded). The other 1/4 is annoying nonprofit stuff.
  • THE HALO TRUST 9741 - Removes landmines on UK and foreign government contracts
  • United Learning LTD 9144 - Runs charter schools, mostly on UK government contracts
  • MSI REPRODUCTIVE CHOICES 8993 - Runs sexual health clinics in 37 countries - funding is a mix of UK and foreign government contracts and fee charging.
  • ROYAL MENCAP SOCIETY 8009 - Does some fundraising and advocacy, but about 80% of the budget is providing mental health services under UK government contracts
  • BARNARDO'S 7317 - About 1/2 of what it does is running childrens' homes under UK government contracts, the other 1/2 is advocacy.
  • THE NATIONAL TRUST FOR PLACES OF HISTORIC INTEREST OR NATURAL BEAUTY 6651 - Operates a range of heritage attractions (particularly famous for the stately homes and the trailhead carparks in the UK national parks), mostly funded by admission fees. Has an advocacy arm which makes a lot of noise on a tiny budget because it has become a kind of clearinghouse for wealthy retired NIMBY Karens.
  • CARDIFF UNIVERSITY 6032 - Does what it says on the tin.

So I would say across these 10 names 20% of the activity is annoying nonprofit stuff and 80% is providing services on a commercial or government-contract basis. My guess is that the US figures would be even more skewed because of the large number of nonprofit-owned hospitals in the US.

You know you're getting reamed when you're buying Zeiss

Especially if you are ASML, who are as dependent on Zeiss for the lenses and mirrors that go into EUV photolithography tools as TSMC and Intel are on ASML for the photolithography tools. ASML offered Zeiss more money than you could shake a stick at for their semiconductor business, but Zeiss is owned by a non-profit with no interest in giving up control.

Is this a claim that prominent birders are mostly women, or mostly low-T men? In the UK, obscure geeky hobbies like birding are generally assumed to be light on both actual XX women and ManlyMenTM.

The noisy bit of the non-profit sector is unproductive. But the big numbers in non-profit employment are in service provision in fee-charging or government-contracted non-profits - the most visible examples are church and university-owned hospitals; private, parochial and charter schools; and private universities.

Government-contracted non-profits have essentially the same problems as government-contracted for-profits. Fee-charging non-profits like university-owned hospitals are notoriously run in exactly the same way as for-profits, including the "sometimes making huge profits" bit. In general, I would say that service-providing non-profits are only unproductive in a Sturgeon's law kind of way which also applies to the for-profit and government sectors.

In Spanish, the grammatical gender of the subject does change adjectives, but not verbs.

The same is true for Latin and French, so I suspect it is true for all Romance languages. Verb conjugations are based on number and person only.

It usually does for living things, including people:

I assume this is correct Spanish, but when I was studying French in the 1990's, it wasn't correct French - words for living things maintained their grammatical gender regardless of the referent. So it was always le chat even if the cat in question was known to be female. This meant that almost all occupation words had male and female versions, because people wanted grammatical gender of humans to track sex. So Monsieur le proffeseur/Madame la professeuse and such like because Madame le professeur feels off.

This came to a head at some point in the 1990's (I think when Edith Cresson was Prime Minister) because the Academie Francaise insisted in Madame le ministre for female cabinet ministers, everyone who didn't have a baton up their derriere about grammatical gender felt this was wrong, and the female ministers in question felt that coming up with a neologism like ministrice would be diminishing their status. I am not sure how the row was resolved because I gave up foreign languages as soon as I could.

Reading closely it seems Macron and his former teacher consider Male-Form-As-Neutral a sensible rule for French; the governing body of language of Laplace, Liouville, and love agreeing with them.

I do remember that masculine-as-generic (and particularly ils as the 3rd person plural for mixed groups) was uncontroversially correct French in a way that it never was in English (with singular "they" drifting in and out of fashion since time immemorial).

Here is the story now I am on a computer which doesn't block "entertainment" websites.

they are not zombies, not lemurs or lares or hungry ghosts, who have to be appeased so that their malevolence at the living who have the good things of the earth will not fall upon us.

Lemures. A very old joke among MtG players.

Social Security retirement is a pure transfer programme - the targetted beneficiaries get cash out of it, which is fungible, flexible etc. in the same way as earned cash, and administrative costs are very low because the eligibility criteria are things the government already knows about you (age and contribution history). The claim that "we" get "very little" out of it is outgrouping the elderly. I understand why you want to do that - I was one of the people who called COVID-19 the "Boomer Remover" like that was a good thing - but it kind of excludes you from real-world political debate with actual voters in it.

If "we get very little out of our government programs" is a claim about government inefficiency, then the place to start looking is other than the most efficient government programme.

They too were eventually forced to eat their words when Trump won.

Sam Wang, probably the most prominent "Nate Silver is over-correcting and Hilary has it in the bag" pollster didn't just have to eat his words - he had to eat a bug on live TV.

Most ethnic Turks in the UK in my experience are actually Turkish Cypriots (Wikipedia confirms this), and are descended from people who took low-grade civilian jobs at the British military bases on Cyprus. So not wealthy, although in practice usually secular.