MadMonzer
If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your
No bio...
User ID: 896
This narrative is pushed in early education and probably also pushed by our intelligence services who want a hyper-stable culture against foreign influences.
It doesn't need much pushing - Thomas Jefferson wrote it into the founding document of the American national mythos. Discussing who is pushing it on Americans is a bit like discussing who is pushing "Muhammed is the prophet of God" on Muslims.
This set of Piketty slides show that the correlation between education and voting behaviour changes sign over the 2nd half of the 20th century. He looks at France, the UK and the US, with and without controlling for income. The big left-wing parties in the UK and France were explicitly socialist or communist for most of this period, so you can't say "the working class may have been left-wing in the past, but they were never socialist".
You can also look at the political affiliation of blue-collar unions back when they were a big deal, which was consistently leftist, and in Continental Europe (but not the Anglosphere) was more often than not explicitly Marxist.
Calling the British Labour Party a "Marxist" party is stretching the word absurdly far.
The British Labour Party was never a Marxist party, but it self-identified as socialist, was committed to seeking "common ownership of the means of production" by Clause 4 of the Party Constitution, and did in fact nationalise the country's largest companies after gaining power in 1945. At the point Orwell complained about the lifestyle weirdness of "socialists", he was a member of the Independent Labour Party, one of those weird far-left groupuscles the British like so much, because he did not consider the Labour Party properly socialist. So he was writing about the lifestyle habits of the weird far-left, which has always been much more middle-class than the electorally serious left.
The quote is taken from The Road to Wigan Pier, which was a polemical book trying to get the Marxist left in Britain to get the stick out of their backside and compete for working class votes. Less than a year after writing the book, Orwell would travel to Spain to fight for the Nationalists. Foreign fighters were assigned to International Brigades based on the Spanish political party their home-country party was affiliated with. The Spanish left-wing group whose militia Orwell joined based on his ILP membership was POUM, which was a heavily working-class movement - it was led by an autodictat journalist from a working-class family and a union organiser.
The model essay contrasted Proctor and Rebecca Nurse doing what they knew to be right and being really right, Hale doing what he knew to be right, realising he was wrong and changing course, Danforth doing what he knew to be right and failing to realise he was wrong, and Abigail being a lying sack of shit from the beginning. "Were Hathorne and Danforth villains or fools?" was a previous year's exam question that you could have used that model essay as a pre-prepared answer for.
The essay I had to write in the exam was "Does Proctor stand condemned because of a futile heroic gesture?" This was bad, because I had never managed to understand the model essay on "The tragedy of John Proctor" because I didn't really understand what a tragedy (in the technical literary sense) was until I studied Macbeth.
I expect that azov will be the first fascist fellow-travelers rehabilitated.
I'd say they already have been, but for a very different reason. Even Joseph Stalin could be rehabilitated if baddies invaded his country. Churchill's position (and I hope we can agree that he was not squishy in his anti-communism) on the enemy of my enemy was "If Hitler invaded Hell, I would make at least a favourable reference of the Devil in the House of Commons."
This may be the discerning and nuanced understanding of the play. It's not the one that high school kids walk out with.
Interesting - American high schools must be worse than English ones. This understanding of the play is literally the basis of one of the sample essays ("Doing what you know to be right") at the back of my high school edition.
Someone should get the York/Cliffes/Spark/whatever kids nowadays use notes on The Crucible and see what they say on this point.
I am British, and as Miller points out to the preface of The Crucible the British are better than most countries at avoiding this kind of political witch-hunt, but in the UK "McCarthyism" means using bad-faith allegations of communism as a political tool, and the people calling it out are entirely agnostic as to whether all the victims are innocent or just most of them. My school history textbook strongly implied that the anti-communist movement had already gone bad by the time McCarthy took over leadership from the HUAC. A quick check of Wikipedia suggests this is correct - the most dangerous communists were the Klaus Fuchs (caught based on the then-classified Venona decrypts), the Rosenbergs (caught by rolling up Fuchs' contacts), and Alger Hiss (found out by the HUAC before McCarthy delivered the "Enemies Within" speech and became a famous anti-communist).
Notably, everyone knew that the Bush-era neocons had mostly been communists in their youth, and nobody held it against them.
In America, the unionized working class were highly sympathetic to socialist ideals for a long while. It's only relatively recently that this has changed.
and
Hence Marxism feels true to an HR lady or a college professor or a journalist in a way it doesn’t to a mechanic or a farmer or a plumber.
And in most of the times and places where Marxism was a real political movement that threatened to take power, this was even more true (China is an exception). The Bolshevik power base really was the urban working class and the enlisted men of the Petrograd garrison. The German SDP really was a movement of industrial workers organised through unions. So was the French Socialist Party. So was the (not technically Marxist) British Labour Party. These movements were mostly led by educated men, but that was inevitable. And they actively sought to identify educate smart workingmen and incorporate them into leadership. Friedrich Ebert began his career as a saddle-maker. Keir Hardie was a miner.
21st century PMC Marxism is a LARP - most modern Marxists don't believe in, or even understand, the economic core of Marxism. Most of them run around denouncing slavery as an incident of capitalism, for crissake. But orthodox Marxism absolutely felt true to the mechanics and plumbers (not, admittedly, the farmers) of its day.
The relationship between McCarthyism and The Crucible is more complex than this, in a way which explains why 1950's anti-communism is as thoroughly discredited as it is.
The Crucible begins with allegations, backed by evidence, that a group of young women including Betty Parris and Abigail Williams were dancing naked in the trees (which was clearly illegal and considered dangerous in Puritan Salem, even if we moderns don't see it that way), that Tituba appeared to be casting spells on them (something everyone in 17th century Salem agreed was possible and dangerous, even though it isn't), and that they suffered strange symptoms as a result (which we now believe to be ergotism caused by rotten grain, but nobody knew that at the time). So the first batch of witchcraft allegations are serious and true in-universe. It then moves on to random accusations against low-status easy targets as Tituba and Abigail try to deflect blame (we don't know who most of the women called out are, but we are later told that Goody Good and Goody Osburn were dubiously sane old maids and that Goody Osburn had been homeless at one point). And then in the second act we get the bad-faith accusations against respectable middle-class Salemites. Miller is deliberately vague as to whether these are motivated by factional politics (there was an ongoing feud between the Putnams and the Nurses in real Salem, and Miller's Giles Corey thinks the whole thing is a plot by the Putnams to steal his land), personal beefs (like Abigail being butthurt after Proctor dumped her), or attempts to silence opposition (like the arrest of Proctor).
This is supposed to mirror the decline and fall of 50's anti-communism. McCarthy starts out by going after actual communists like the Rosenbergs, moves on to people on the left who are a bit weird, acquires a reputation for using bad-faith accusations of communist sympathy to silence opposition, and eventually ends up using bad-faith accusations of communist sympathy to pursue personal beefs. Remember the reason that McCarthy ultimately fell is that he dishonestly denounced various army officers who refused to give his lawyer's catamite a cushy job.
So the message Miller is trying to present is twofold:
- Like witches, communist fellow travellers are probably not as dangerous as you think they are (which did not age well)
- If you promote overzealous witch-hunters, you end up with a culture where dishonest allegations of witchcraft are a routine political tool (which did - with swapped partisan valence it is the core argument of liberal anti-SJWism)
Although his first targets are now known to be guilty, there is zero doubt that by the end McCarthy was spamming dishonest allegations of communist sympathy as a political tool, and that the anti-communist movement in the country fully supported him in doing so. This should have, and did, discredit anti-communism, and boost anti-anti-communism as an organising principle for the radical left - with the unfortunate side effect of partially rehabilitating communist fellow travellers. If McCarthy didn't want that to happen, then he should have admitted that George Marshall was a patriot and that Peress' promotion was routine based on the number of years since he graduated dental school.
Although anti-fascist movements spamming allegations of "fascist" against non-fascists are a dime a dozen on the anti-establishment left, they never had an HUAC/SSCI-sized platform until the Great Awokening (I also think they were idiots spamming "fascist" against almost everyone, rather than using it as a calculated tool against political opponents the way McCarthy did with "communist" or the ADL increasingly do with "Hate"). We are already seeing the consequences - organised anti-fascism is seen as a bad joke on the anti-establishment right, and the anti-establishment right is increasingly losing its desire to avoid looking fascist. In Italy, we have an actual fascist Prime Minister, in the sense that Fratelli d'Italia's predecessor party claimed spiritual continuity with Mussolini's Fascist Party and received the endorsement of the Mussolini family on that basis. We are also starting to see the pro-establishment right treat organised anti-fascism as a partisan grift, although they are still afraid of it. We are even starting to see (so far unsuccessful) attempts by the pro-establishment left to neuter woke-stupid the way the Army neutered anti-communism in the Army-McCarthy hearings.
If woke-stupid and dishonest anti-fascism fail, then even the good anti-fascism is going to be caught in the collateral damage, and there will be some inevitable (and unfortunate) rehabilitation of fascism and fascist fellow travellers, and Planet of Cops will have the same kind of reputation that The Crucible does now.
Probably I should just make more spaceships.
So you are trolling on the Motte when you could be making spaceships...
You are Elon Musk and I claim my 3 months' free Twitter Blue subscription.
Also get off social media and go back to making spaceships, for all of our sakes.
Secondly, we were here first
Given that the first Blues came over on the Mayflower, I doubt that.
Seriously, (unless you believe one of the more radical anti-semitic conspiracy theories) the rise of wokism did not involve a hostile takeover of any institutions - the top universities and most prestigious newspapers in America were run by Yankees and Quakers in 1776, and are run by Yankees, Quakers, and Yankee-aligned secular Jews now. If you do the genealogical research, you will find that most of the individuals in charge are drawn from the same families. (Descendants of PMC Holocaust-era refugees excepted). The rise of wokism (beginning with the Civil Rights movement and the Sexual Revolution, and continuing through 1990's PC and ultimately the current Great Awokening) happened by some combination of conversion and generational replacement. There are several important books still to be written about how and why this happened - Moldbug certainly has a book-length treatment spread over multiple long blog posts, but I don't think his thesis (on my reading, that Yankees were always like this, they just increased in power slowly until they they didn't have to compromise with reality any more) is correct, and his presentation leaves a lot to be desired.
It is worth remembering the background though - in the period 1945-75,
- The atom bomb appeared to render everything we knew about war obsolete (and therefore most of what we knew about masculine virtue)
- The combination of the pill and cheap antibiotics capable of treating the then-common STDs appeared to render everything we knew about sexual morality obsolete (and therefore most of what we knew about feminine virtue)
- The mass adoption of fridges, gas cookers, and washing machines really did render everything we knew about domesticity obsolete (and therefore the rest of what we knew about feminine virtue)
- The mass adoption of private cars really did render everything we knew about human geography obsolete (and therefore most of what we knew about well-functioning communities).
- By-and-large, this was also the period where intelligent, educated people stopped actually believing their religion, even if they didn't abandon it altogether.
Some form of moral upheaval was probably inevitable.
The plain meaning of the enforcement clause of the 14th amendment would authorise federal civil rights laws, although SCOTUS found otherwise during the Jim Crow era.
I agree with you that any approach to interpretation which starts with the enacted text has to conclude that “the people” in the 2A creates an individual right enforceable against the Feds. The question is whether the non-enforceability of the 1789 2A against the States is about the nature and purpose of the right (in which case it still isn’t enforceable against the States) or about the nature of the remedy at the time of the founding (in line with other rights, enforcement of the RKBA against States was supposed to be based on the RKBA clauses in State constitutions, adjudicated in State courts). In the latter case, it becomes enforceable against the States as a result of the 14A.
The other way of thinking about it is about the various founding-era state legislatures who ratified the 2A at the same time they were passing laws against free blacks owning guns. Were they blithely passing legislation that violated their own understanding of the RKBA because they were unprincipled racists, or were they regulating their own militias in an obnoxiously racist way based on a sincere view of the powers they actually held? AFAIK none of the other founding-era laws restricting the rights of free blacks were obviously inconsistent with the Bill of Rights as the gun laws were under the modern Red Tribe understanding of the RKBA.
Lots of securities laws only apply to public companies - in the US this includes Reg FD and most of SarbOx. The general pattern is that public companies are required to disclose a lot more information than private ones, with making a false disclosure punishable as securities fraud. A private company that doesn't make a formal disclosure can't commit securities fraud by making a false one.
If I was trying to prosecute a company for gambling shareholders' money in Vegas, I would argue that they had made corporate disclosures which implicitly said they were not gambling shareholders' money in Vegas, and were therefore fraudulent. That is much easier to do with public company disclosures than private company ones (which are basically just the accounts).
I definitely wouldn't argue that it was a breach of fiduciary duty - under the circumstances in the Fedex story that argument would be a loser in both England and Delaware that would definitely lose in court because of the business judgement rule.
But I am a liberal, and one of them was my post!
Three AAQCs making basically the same heterodox point about modern attitudes to adultery in slightly different ways is interesting - was it the same small group of people nominating all three posts because they were complementary, or have we rooted out a silent consensus among Mottizens?
McCarthy negotiated a deal with Biden for below-inflation increases in federal spending (including cash-flat discretionary spending). In real terms, that is a cut. Given how high inflation was, it would be the biggest real-terms cut in federal spending since the Clinton-era welfare reforms.
The approach McCarthy was taking is a perfectly reasonable approach to cutting spending for a party that can only win elections by promising not to cut any of the big, popular programs.
that our massive deficits come from a budget process that doesn't even follow the basics of a budget process.
Drafting a budget that reflects the terms of the debt ceiling deal and taking it through the legislative process would be following a budget process. This whole row kicked off because Gaetz and the Freedom Caucus didn't want to do that - it isn't clear from the press coverage how much of the issue is that they want even larger cuts than the ones Biden and McCarthy negotiated, and how much is that they want to use the budget process as a lever to change policy on other issues (like the Trump prosecutions and immigration enforcement) rather than to pass a budget that reflects their spending priorities. But in the FY 2024 budget cycle, the reason why the budget isn't the result of a budget process is because the Freedom Caucus don't want it to be.
In the early stages of the war, Putin wasn't interested in negotiating with Ukraine - he said that Ukraine was a NATO puppet and that he wanted to negotiate with the organ grinder rather than the monkey.
Putin's eve-of-war demands were not even within Ukraine's control to give - they were a commitment from NATO never to admit Ukraine, and a withdrawal of NATO troops from Eastern Europe.
If we start the story with the beginning of the Great Awokening in c. 2012, then the orthodox left (actual Marxists like Freddie de Boer) starts pushing back against woke-stupid almost immediately - the first famous left-wing anti-woke essay is Exiting the Vampire Castle in November 2013 (which, incidentally, defends Russell Brand from charges of sexism - that didn't age well) - i.e. less than 2 years in. FdB was already blogging from a woke-sceptical left-wing perspective at that time, but he wasn't famous. Will Shetterly wrote Social Justice Warriors - do not engage - a book-length attack from the left on the woke-stupid take over of science fiction fandom - in 2014 in response to RaceFail. (I think the use of SJW as a perjorative probably traces back to Shetterly via Vox Day and Gamergate, but I am not sure). And 2016 vintage Bernie promotes a class-first leftism that is at least implicitly anti-woke, and is treated as such by wokists. Within the establishment left, Jonathan Haidt has been warning about this sort of thing since day one, and Matthew Yglesias has been openly heterodox on multiple occasions. The Harpers letter in 2020 may be the first time that left-wing opposition to woke-stupid makes the establishment listen.
If you go back to the 1990's era Political Correctness, then left-wing pushback against woke-stupid was very normal. You have Democratic presidential candidates and British Labour leaders publically calling out far-left PC idiocy in order to win elections.
The intended purpose of the second amendment was to protect the States' right to regulate their own militias, not to abolish it - the people who wrote the Bill of Rights were either anti-Federalists or Federalists negotiating a compromise with them and would have been horrified if they thought they were allowing Federal courts to strike down State gun laws. The Heller line of cases say that the due process clause of the 14th amendment created an individual right analogous to the 2nd amendment but enforceable against the States and are probably correct, but this isn't an argument based on 1789 original intent.
It's more that the OG Bill of Rights was only enforceable against the Federal government, not the States.
It is more likely than not that the Reconstruction Congress intended the privileges and immunities clause of the 14th amendment to make the Bill of Rights enforceable against the States ("No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States") but the corrupt pro-South Supreme Court ruled otherwise in the Slaughterhouse Cases. Rather than doing the sensible thing and just overruling Slaughterhouse alongside Plessey as bad Jim Crow law, the Civil Rights era SCOTUS used substantive due process to enforce these rights - as late as 2010 SCOTUS rejected the argument that the 2nd amendment was directly enforceable against the states under the privileges and immunities clause. So there is a whole line of silly doctrine that takes the 14th seriously while claiming not to.
In my view, there is a good originalist argument against incorporating the 2nd amendment against the States. The corresponding argument against incorporating the Establishment clause of the 1st amendment has been endorsed by Clarence Thomas in some of his dissents and concurrences. Based on the text, the original purpose of the 2nd amendment was to protect the State militias against Federal interference. (This is perfectly compatible with the idea that the 2nd amendment created an individual right enforceable against the Federal government - State militias were not required to and often did not keep membership rolls at the time, so many militia members were "just private gun owners" on paper). Incorporating the amendment against the States takes away the States' right to regulate their own militias, so it changes the nature of the right protected, whereas incorporating a right like trial by jury only changes the scope of the remedy available. Similarly, the Establishment clause was intended to protect State-level established religions (like Massachusetts puritanism) from Federal interference, not ban them.
Obviously nobody is going to make that argument, because it gores both sides' oxen.
I suspect the Democrats would say McCarthy hit "defect" first by trying to pass a bunch of spending bills or CRs that departed downward from the spending levels agreed on in the debt limit negotiations earlier this year.
Based on a quick check of the Hellsite Formerly Known as Twitter, they are saying just that, loudly.

Why does it matter? Actually existing fascism and communism are fundamentally the same in nature and only differ in rhetoric. The family is, of course, utterly unlike either in rhetoric so the comparison has to be based on substance.
More options
Context Copy link