@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

Do you think that Zelensky's attitude to Russia changed because a disgraced British politician sat on him, or because the Russian army invaded his country and committed the normal (i.e. large) number of atrocities that ill-disciplined armies commit when they invade a country.

You have to feel for him, ever so slightly, in that he was elected on a peace platform of negotiating with Russia and the breakaway republics... and then was forced into the war by the Ukrainian ultranationalist in the Ukrainian perma-government who would have 100% assassinated him if he'd actually negotiated agreeable terms or peace the Russian tanks rolling across the border and the associated demands for concessions from NATO that Zelensky wasn't in a position to make.

FIFY

The vast majority of sexual abuse is, of course, committed within the family and community, so I certainly wouldn't suggest that 'middle class white kids' are 'immune' from it.

I would say kids raised by their married biological parents are pretty safe from family-based sex abuse, and in the current year being raised by married biological parents is strongly correlated with being middle-class.

But my impression is that sex abuse (of children and young adults) by corrupt authority figures is enough of a problem that saying the "vast majority" of sex abuse happens in the family and community is misleading. I have no idea whether the ratio of "family and friends abuse" to "corrupt authority figure abuse" is 1:3 or 3:1, and I don't think anyone else is keeping count either. As a parent, I would like to know.

Part of the problem talking about this in places other than the Motte is that the media narrative about this kind of thing tends to be heavily vibes-driven, so trying to draw this kind of distinction, or even to try and draw a distinction between abuse of pre-pubescent children vs abuse of young adults, gets your head bitten off by enraged mothers. And of course, if you reduce Pizzagate to vibes, there is zero doubt that Hilary Clinton really did help cover up sexual abuse of young adults by powerful politicians - her husband was impeached over it. If it turns out that the takeaway pizza Monica brought to Bill before blowing him came from Comet Ping Pong Pizza, a lot of people would say that this makes Pizzagate "true", even though none of the lurid accounts of sex abuse of pre-pubescent children being talked about by Qanon types actually happened.

Yes, given that the naming of various high-powered Democrats as Pizzagate child abusers was based on John Podesta's e-mails, not Tony's.

"Tony Podesta is a paedo, so everyone in his e-mail address book has some 'splaining to do or else they go down for aiding and abetting" is a claim of guilt-by-association that doesn't stand up in court, but is a reasonable approach to take when deciding who is allowed access to your kids (or would be, if the evidence that Tony Podesta was a child molester was at least circumstantial rather than just vibes). "John Podesta's brother is a paedo, so everyone in his e-mail address book has some 'splaining to do or else they go down for aiding and abetting" is nonsense. I would have no idea if any of my main professional or social contacts had a brother who is a sex offender, because I don't vet my contacts' siblings, and apart from spouses probably never meet them.

I agree it isn't a meaningful difference to the question "Is Marina Abramovic a fit and proper person to be an honorary ambassador of Ukraine" because she was tight with both Podestas.

And you need to put at least three people's heads on the block to make this scheme work - your own, someone to sign receipts on behalf of the charity (you only get to deduct the appraised value if the charity uses the donated object as part of its charitable activities, so someone needs to confirm this), and the appraiser.

They're pretty much never middle-class white American or Western European kids.

Jeffery Epstein was picking up local white girls in Florida. I don't think any of them would have qualified as middle class, but several of them lived with at least one gainfully employed parent. Virginia Guiffre (the girl in the famous Prince Andrew picture) was working at Mar-a-Lago when Ghislaine Maxwell recruited her, which makes her at least respectable working class.

OTOH, it does look like he was picking on girls who were screwed up in various ways. For example, Virgina Guiffre had already been sexually abused by two men (one in her mother's house, one while living as a runaway) before moving in with her father, and was trying to become a masseuse.

The Roman Catholic Man-Boy Love Association targetted some kids from normie families who were sufficiently functional to be regular churchgoers. (Although the majority of the victims were children in Church-run children's homes, it was buggering the altar boys which gave the scandal legs). In the UK, the sexual abuse extended to pupils at Ampleforth, which was the most expensive and socially prestigious private school in the north of England. The other smaller religious sex abuse scandals tend to follow the same pattern.

The Penn State sex abuse scandal and similar scandals in youth sports (which is as lousy with sex abusers as the RCMBLA) involved student-athletes as victims, who tend to be middle-class, or at least respectable working class.

So although the "Taken" fantasy is almost entirely a media creation, it definitely isn't the case that normie middle-class white American kids are safe from sex abuse. It's just that it tends to involve corrupt authority figures, not stereotypical predators.

WARNING FOR PARENTS - THIS IS IMPORTANT - YOUR KID IS NOT PROTECTED FROM SEXUAL ABUSE BY CORRUPT AUTHORITY FIGURES BY YOUR MONEY, POWER OR COMMUNITY STANDING UNLESS YOU ACTUALLY DO THE WORK OF PROTECTING THEM. This starts by giving them the tools to talk to you about dodgy shit, and making sure they feel safe doing so.

I'm not going to begrudge anyone the schadenfreude of watching the other tribe beclowning themselves, and this is absolutely fucking hilarious for anyone with a functioning sense of humour even if they are basically pro-Ukraine and pro-Trudeau, but I don't think this means very much.

Legislatures get a lot of requests from members to do small favours for a constituent (see this Atlantic article about the plethora of bills to rename Post Offices for the US version) and generally operate an assumption of good faith as long as the request doesn't come across as partisan. The most famous example is the Texas Legislature being pranked into honouring a serial killer. The US Congress begrudgingly allocates a certain amount of staffer time to vetting post office renamings to make sure they don't honour anyone unsuitable, but the actual legislators wave requests through as long as the home-state delegation are onside. Other legislatures have less staff support than Congress, so they can't even do that level of vetting.

This is a case where you shouldn't have needed to do the vetting - anyone with a clue should know that "Ukrainian patriot fighting Soviets in WW2" implies "Nazi collaborator", but the only person I would expect to do even the bare minimum is Speaker Rota as the constituency MP honouring a constituent. So I think he deserves to go. But I don't think the Canadian Parliament as an institution is more blameworthy than the Texas Legislature was in 1971.

For the avoidance of doubt, the "Slovak Republic" in question was a puppet state set up following the Nazi occupation of Czechoslovakia in March 1939. Tifo was a Nazi collaborator and was quite properly hanged for treason by the short-lived democratic government that ruled post-war Czechoslovakia before the Soviets consolidated thei control.

Everything the "Slovak Aryanization agency" and suchlike did was more or less enthusiastic implementation of decisions taken in Berlin.

He did have relevant experience when it came to investigating terrorist fundraising.

Which is what they were doing and why the Biden administration has been forced by a court to stop talking to social media companies.

There is a big difference between a law enforcement agency asking questions and an individual legislator doing so, in that one carries an implied threat which the other doesn't. Dame Caroline's committee can issue strongly worded reports, and it can recommend future legislation, but it can't arrest or prosecute anyone.

Are they anticipating where the market is going, or where the ADL, NYT, and advertisers are going?

Remember that the Artist Formerly Known As Twitter is a (mostly) advertising-funded social network, so the advertisers are the customers. Russel Brand and his fanbase are the product. Recalling a possibly-contaminated product before confirming whether or not it really is contaminated is very normal commercial behaviour. Trying to get ahead of your customers by responding to a press campaign run by the media they read (which is the NYT for bigcorp marketing execs) is also normal corporate behaviour.

Musk is trying to move to a subscription model because he wants to run a social media network with free speech for right-wing American witches (but not left-wing investigative journalists or dissidents in the dictatorships where his other companies do business). He knows that the only people willing to advertise on media which is full of witches are alt-med and crypto scammers, and is trying to avoid that trap.

Distortion of media based on advertiser preferences is as old as media. "Married fathers are doofuses" predates modern feminism - it happened because the TV sitcoms where the meme originated were funded by adverts for packaged detergent (hence the term "soap opera") and the advertisers wanted to appeal to the women buying the detergent.

This would be much funnier if Rep Peter King (IRA-NY) was still alive.

No surrender, no surrender...

This worked for Cornel West at Harvard (or at least when Larry Summers did call him out for not doing his job, it was Summers who was fired and not West). I don't see why anyone should be surprised that it worked for Kendi.

I suppose you can argue that Cornel West did pretend to do his job.

Legislators have the right to ask questions relevant to potential legislation (and to compel answers if the person being asked is within the jurisdiction) - - in Con Law textbooks this is called the investigative power of the legislature. Since the UK has no written constitution, everything is a potential subject matter for legislation by the Westminster Parliament (and regulation of offensive speech on social media platforms is, in fact, a current subject of active political debate). So she isn't violating any constitutional principle here. She is being a grandstanding idiot, and if I lived in Gosport it would make me significantly less likely to re-elect her. OTOH, in the UK right now everyone hates Russel Brand except the actual fans of his show, so I'm sure she will gain votes on net.

Why is the emotional harm to his wife privileged over the emotional harm to his employees?

In Mormonism (and, to a slightly lesser extent, orthodox Christianity) because one is a violation of a promise wrapped up in a sacrament, and the other is common-or-garden boorishness. It is similar to how lying about office sex having sworn an oath to tell you the truth, and called divine judgement down on yourself if you forswear is worse than casually lying about bombing an aspirin factory. Except more so, because judicial oaths simply invoke the name of god while touching a holy book, whereas sacraments are basically real-world cleric spells.

What I find more interesting is the total inversion of the principle in secular (and secularised nominally-Christian) culture. The thing that crystallised this for me was the Ryan Giggs superinjunction affair - both sides of the debate agreed that the interests being balanced were Ryan Giggs' right to conceal his affair from his wife and children vs. Imogen Thomas's right as a vulnerable victim to tell her own story (and get paid for it). But it goes back further - even Christian conservatives talked about the Clinton sex scandals as if Monica was more of a victim than Hilary. (For the avoidance of doubt, under the traditional Christian conservative standard the "other woman" was also contemptible - terms like "homewrecker" were not compliments).

Matthew Parris wrote a book of famous British political scandals in the early noughties, and one of the points he made in the closing essay is that since the 1980's it has been easier for politicians to survive a sex scandal if they divorce their wife and marry their mistress than if they dump the mistress and return to their wife. This is also consistent with the "the other woman is the real victim" frame.

Modern secular culture no longer believes that we owe our spouses fidelity. It does believe that men owe the women they are fucking (regardless of the official nature of the relationship) some kind of fair dealing which is incompatbile with carrying on with a mistress while planning to return to your wife.

I had always had a high prior that Russel Brand was a rapist since he prank called an actor to boast about having sex with his granddaughter, a joke that is only funny if you have contempt for the women you sleep with.

The existence of the allegations doesn't raise my posterior probability very much above the prior, although if there is hard evidence that the woman went to a rape crisis centre at the time then that would do.

This is one of the strangest things my wife and I disagree about. When I play a sandbox computer game, one of the things I will try fairly early on is going on a violent spree and seeing what happens (normally along the lines of "the city guards come and beat your puny low-level arse"). My wife is horrified by this. My son is getting into minecraft, and when he said "I spawned all these villagers so I could throw them into the lava" my wife came to me and said we needed to do something about his developing violent streak, and I insisted that violence against computer sprites didn't count.

I estimated $300m based on $40m per year over the life of the fund, which is usually 5 or 7 years, plus a conservative estimate of the carry on the assumption that Kushner is a mediocre investor.

The carry is a free option (the fund manager gets paid if the fund beats the hurdle, but keeps the 2% fee if it doesn't) and if Kushner just invested in the S&P500 the Black-Scholes EV of the carry would be about $26 million. With some reasonable assumptions about using leverage to add volatility, I get numbers in the $100-150 million range.

This post is spot on and needs to be promoted. If all 4 of these points were established, then Biden would be sunk. The Republicans' problem is that

  • although (1) is facially plausible, there are plenty of people willing to deny it publicly, and the best evidence is an anonymous FBI informant passing on hearsay from Zlochevsky that dated from long after Zlochevsky had ceased to control Burisma
  • the evidence on (2) is too complicated for the man in the street to understand - the only people who can make sense of it are rabid partisans who only listen to one side of the story

Archer could go to jail if proven to lie

Devon Archer is going to jail anyway for trying to bilk an Indian tribe out of $60 million in an unrelated scam. If he is going to be the Republican's star witness at the impeachment trial, he is going to be testifying in an orange jumpsuit and the first question on cross is going to be "Has Trump promised you a pardon in exchange for this testimony?"

FWIW, I think Archer is mostly telling the truth. Joe Biden has gone above and beyond in support of Hunter (and James) Biden's sleazy-but-legal schemes since back when he was Senator for MBNA, and putting on a dog-and-pony show for the executives of a company which puts Hunter on the board would be SOP for him.

As far as I can see, there are basically three narratives consistent with the publicly-available information.

  1. Something actually happened between September 2015 (when the first mutterings against Shokin show up) and March 2016 (when he is fired to near-universal praise) such that all important actors in Ukrainian politics turned against Shokin, and Biden was slightly ahead of the curve. Whatever this event was, it left no trace in English-language media.
  2. Someone working for Burisma (either directly or via Biden) pulled off a scheme to discredit Shokin such that everyone apparently independently turned against him and he was fired. But if you can pull that off, why the December request from Biden - a key rule for pulling off this type of scheme is that you spread the rumours first, then demand action on them.
  3. Biden successfully suborned the US Deep State, the EU, the IMF, the Kyiv Post, Vitaly Kasko, and large parts of Ukrainian civil society to tell lies in support of his corrupt scheme, and did so while leaving no fingerprints despite two US and one Ukrainian investigations.

As I was trying to say in my earlier post, none of these are particularly plausible. But whatever Joe Biden's motives were for making the demand in December, it was neither a necessary nor a sufficient cause of Shokin's firing in March. Something else was going on.

Ex-boss. The Burisma investigation related to crimes committed while Zlochevsky was boss, but Zlochevsky had sold Burisma before Hunter Biden joined the board. The UK SFO unfroze Burisma's UK accounts in 2015. The pro-Biden theory is that this is because the evidence of corporate criminality against Burisma (as opposed to personal criminality against Zlochevsky) was thin. The anti-Biden theory is that this is because Shokin's predecessor had failed to file necessary paperwork.

A quibble, but just under a century if you mean "since Teapot Dome", which was 1921-23.

More seriously, it is only the biggest bribery scandal because we don't know what Jared Kushner did for the $300 million or so the Saudis are bunging him ($300mm is my best guess of the management fee he will be getting on the $2 billion investment in his PE fund). The Jack Abramoff scandal is also bigger than Hunter in terms of dollar amount and had sympathetic victims, but it isn't clear it counts as a bribery scandal (Abramoff was prosecuted for bilking the Indian tribes who hired his lobbying firm).

My view is that the worst US bribery scandal in recent years would be the Clinton-era Chinese campaign contributions. Biden isn't accused of doing anything nearly as bad as turning a blind eye to Chinese nuclear espionage in exchange for the money.

If the anti-Biden theory of Burisma/Shokin is true, then Biden has already rolled the Deep State once - by getting Victoria Nuland and Radio Free Europe to change their opinions on Shokin's performance between Biden meeting Poroshenko in December and Shokin actually being fired in March.

And a compromised Biden is far more dangerous to the Deep State as POTUS than as VP.

People who think that the fact that the practice is widespread proves anything doesn't understand how the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act works. This is 100% illegal if we catch companies with a suitable US presence doing it for children of foreign politicians.

Most 1st world countries have laws like FCPA which prohibit their companies from bribing 3rd world governments, with broad extra-territorial application and broad definitions of bribery. It isn't per se illegal to put a relative of a foreign politician on your board, but if you do it in a notoriously corrupt country then you are going to be spending some time helping the police with their enquiries into precisely what your motives were.

The reverse case - a 1st world politician accepting a bribe from a 3rd world company - comes under domestic bribery laws which are far harder to convict under - basically you either need a quo that is so outrageous that no honest politician could have delivered it, or smoking gun evidence linking the quid to the quo.

The people who write the laws think have a much lower prior on a domestic politician accepting a bribe than on a foreign politician accepting one.