MadMonzer
If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your
No bio...
User ID: 896
That's bribery
That's lobbying. The professional lobbying industry is rife with legal-but-sleazy cash-for-access schemes. It is completely legal, and SOP in DC, for a government official to meet with people because they hired a lobbying firm that donates to their campaign/hires their failson for a cushy job/promises to hire them for a cushy job after they leave office/block-books a large number of rooms in their hotel at an above-market rate. A lot of this stuff can't be banned, because petitioning the government is 1st amendment protected activity.
The difference between selling influence and selling access is hard to prove, but it is critical to bribery law. It also matters to the situational ethics of the DC swamp - selling a policy change for cash is against the "Code" even if you manage to do it in a way which skirts bribery law.
Bank records showing dirty foreign money flowing to Joe or Jill Biden (or a for-profit company owned by them) would probably cause the Deep State to flip on Biden, and the MSM would follow the Deep State.
Evidence that Joe Biden did a favour for one of Hunter's clients that the Deep State didn't want him to do would also probably work.
Parts of the MSM would flip on Biden if Hunter turns out to have taken money from Russian oligarchs who were still in Putin's good books. (Hunter's only Russian client according to the House Oversight Committee report was Yelena Baturina who had bugged out to London in 2010, and hired Hunter in 2014).
days before the firing.
Days before the December meeting at which Biden is supposed to have demanded the firing.
By the time Shokin is actually fired in March, essentially everyone has turned against him. There is timestamped publically-available information that the EU, the IMF, Victoria Nuland, Shokin's deputy Vitaly Kasko, Radio Free Europe (US government-owned), the Kyiv Post and various Ukrainian good-government groups all praised the firing when it happened.
The 2-3 month gap between Biden demanding Shokin be fired within 6 hours and the time Shokin was actually fired is inconvenient for both the pro- and anti-Biden theories of the case, as is the fact that the proximate cause of Shokin going was Kasko resigning on February 15th.
An even more bizzare complication is that Shokin applied for a freezing order against Zlochevsky's personal assets (the founder of Burisma, although he had sold most of his shares and was no longer an executive by the time Hunter Biden joined the board) on 4th February. As far as I can see, this was the first public move in the Zlochevsky/Burisma investigation since Shokin was appointed.
This is the famous paper, but rereading it, I realise that it only looks at the effect of regulations requiring hygienists to work under dental supervision, showing a 10% wage drop (and an even larger loss to consumers). But it doesn't estimate how much hygienists gain from restricting competition. Other work tends to give a premium >10% for licensed workers, which would imply that hygienists are net gainers. In general, most of the literature focusses on the cost to teeth of excessive regulation, not the cost or benefit to hygienists.
This is the only paper looking at both effects that I could find with a quick Google, but the author appears to have run the wrong regressions. One thing it does point out is that Connecticut is the most deregulated state on both metrics (anyone can become a dental hygienist by passing an exam, with no requirement to study at an accredited school or serve an apprenticeship, and hygienists can set up their own practices) and has the highest hygienist incomes - although this is obviously confounded by the fact that it is a high-wage state generally.
Peppa pig is whimsical and nonsensical.
Daddy pig is portrayed as a doofus sufficiently consistently that both my wife and I found Peppa Pig problematic. We can't stop our kids watching it, but we don't seek it out for them.
The Orthodox are squishier than the Catholics about contraceptive use by married couples (although they are still basically against it). From an uberconservative Catholic perspective, married priests are evidence of lax sexual morality as well.
In the EU (and still in the post-Brexit UK), a significant part of HGV driver training is about how to stop illegal immigrants stowing away in your truck.
FWIW, the consensus of the anti-occupational licensing crowd is that dental hygienists are underpaid because the law requires them to work under the supervision of a dentist, and the cut they have to pay the dentist is higher than the benefit they get from being licensed themselves.
Hairdressing and interior design are the canonical examples of jobs that are licensed in most states but shouldn't be (neither is licensed in most European countries).
Hunter didn't pull a fast one on Joe. Joe is familiar enough with politics to know that Hunter was selling access to him, and happily continued to meet with Hunter's "clients" in order to facilitate Hunter's scheme. On Joe's part this is sleazy, but it is neither unusual nor illegal - selling access to politicians is what professional lobbyists do for a living, and meeting with clients of a lobbyist who donates to your campaign/hires your relative/might hire you after you leave office is SOP for DC swamp creatures. On Hunter's part it is a FARA violation and, it seems, tax evasion. (But FARA is almost certainly unconstitutional).
If you believe the official story (that Burisma hired Hunter as an "OK name" to make them look more respectable for a possible future US floatation) then no fast one was pulled - having Hunter on the board got them the access they were paying for. If Hunter did pull a fast one on Burisma then this would not be surprising - lobbyists promising influence but only providing access is an extremely common scam.
FWIW, if someone told me they could buy me the VP of the US for a mere 5 million USD, I would consider the offer too-good-to-be-true.
As mentioned in the link above, it wasn't a subtle snobbish thing. The British insisted on disambiguating the country from the island by calling the country "Republic of Ireland" or "Eire" and the island "Ireland", because the country was promoting an irridentist claim on the British-ruled part of the island (i.e. Northern Ireland) that the British quite properly were not willing to play games with. De Valera didn't hide the fact that insisting on "Ireland" for both in international fora was part of a campaign to tar British rule in Northern Ireland as illegitimate. That the Irish objection to "Republic of Ireland" was made in bad faith is demonstrated by the Irish Government using "Republic of Ireland" on the rare occasions when they needed to disambiguate.
After the Good Friday Agreement, the Irish formally dropped their claim to Northern Ireland, and the British Government stopped trying to call the country anything other than "Ireland". As of the current year, British people calling Ireland "Eire" or (less so) "Republic of Ireland" is a dog whistle for opposition to to the GFA.
How is that wishy washy? You have to contort yourself into a pretzel to come to any other conclusion.
It is wishy washy because Hunter Biden is a liar, and it was a statement he made at a time when he was motivated to lie - the foreign crooks he was dealing with wanted to bribe Joe (although paying Hunter for access would be 2nd best), and would be much more willing to pay off Hunter if they thought the money was reaching Joe.
The "10% for the big guy e-mail" is one crook sending a note to another saying he was going to put aside some money for the big guy, but no money was actually put aside for Joe Biden except, possibly, in Hunter's head (unless there is non-public information about a segregated account, but if the Republicans had that I suspect they would have leaked it by now).
The fundamental problem with making "Joe Biden personally was on the take via Hunter" stick based on a jigsaw of weak evidence is that normally a lifestyle that exceeds known clean income is a key piece of the jigsaw, and Joe's lifestyle between VP and President was entirely consistent with what he has always claimed to be in his financial disclosures, i.e. an old guy with a net worth in the low double figure millions.
All the US has to do is send the problem people to prison
Is it really a huge strain on a $26 trillion economy to build some more prisons
America already has more prisons than the countries which don't have these problems - the problem is that you guys need more and better cops to make sure that the right people are in those prisons for the right reasons. (Right reasons is particularly important, because it generates an impact by deterrence as well as incapacitation).
I think of this as "definitely not a bum privilege" and I am conscious of how valuable it is for someone like me who is too disorganised to reliably be able to prove that they are not a bum on request - if you have it, people really do assume you are a respectable person having a bad day and wave off all kinds of minor irregularities (missing paperwork and being in the wrong place at the wrong time are the ones I take advantage of most often). It also makes people willing to do cheap favours like letting your child use an employee-only toilet.
But there isn't a simple cheap signal like knowing where your towel is that is unusually effective in generating definitely not a bum privilege - my suspicion is that it is necessarily anti-inductive in order to work. The key things that seem to make a difference are personal hygiene, vaguely normal physical appearance, broadly conventional dress (clean, non-ripped jeans and a T-shirt is fine - wearing a suit doesn't seem to make much difference beyond that), and accent (upper-class British is optimal on both sides of the Atlantic for different reasons).
Part of what the "white privilege" crowd in the US appear to be talking about is that black Americans need to do significantly more class signalling to benefit from definitely not a bum privilege than non-blacks. This is a little bit true in the UK, but not enough to be worth ranting about.
This looks a an interesting piece of evidence for the relative weakness of the US Deep State. The UK (and, as far as I can see, most other western democracies) has a “policy” of abstaining rather than voting against these bullshit resolutions if they are going to pass anyway (which they usually are, because the slightly evil bloc of third world dictatorships that look to Russia and China for leadership is a majority). The reason for this is that it doesn’t affect anything, and voting against generates friction for the career diplomats whose day job is making nice to slightly evil countries. The elected government, on the other hand, would be better off with the positive media attention it would get for public ally opposing slightly evil UN resolutions. There is a Yes Minister episode about how the UK Deep State pulls this off.
The reason why the US votes against these resolutions is that the multiple layers of political appointees at the top of the State Department are, in this case, able to overrule the Deep State in a way Jim Hacker was not.
An NPC is someone who can be modelled well enough (like most useful ordinary English words, it isn't binary) as a "stock character" of some type or another. If you can describe them to a friend in ten words or less, and the friend can use those ten words plus standard stereotypes to predict their behaviour well enough, then they are a central example of NPCdom. For example, people who fit the stereotypes of "fat socially awkward programmer" or "MAGA Facebook Boomer" or "Person of Hair Colour" is a good description of someone.
The opposite of an NPC is someone who requires a bespoke model to predict their behaviour.
It seems likely to me that this exists because the bureaucrats charged with writing the standards happily drive their pickup trucks to the office and don't see many pedestrians day-to-day.
P.J. O'Rourke's account of visiting the DoT head office in DC (in Parliament of Whores) is hilarious for this reason - he goes in to the building expecting to find it full of the kind of car-hating eco-weenies that the average American conservative would expect to find in the Civil Service and is somewhat horrified to discover that it is full of car guys who religiously read his car journalism (which, despite his reputation as a political satirist, was probably his main source of income as a freelance writer in the 1980's). So the chapter turns into a sympathetic account of how people who mostly share PJ's attitude to cars end up feeling forced to order a recall of the Audi 5000 in response to senile drivers pressing the accelerator when they mean to press the brake.
In so far as Parliament of Whores has a story arc, it is PJ shifting from the view you would expect of a 1960's-communist-turned-libertarian (that Big Government is a hostile occupying force that Americans need to defeat) to seeing Big Government of something that Americans do to themselves as a result of the ignorance and apathy of the median voter and the fecklessness of the Congressmen they elect.
The other argument for going now is that Biden is just an incredibly weak candidate who will not inspire voter turnout, and the only person who can almost certainly lose to him, and can inspire Dems to turn out, is Trump.
and further down the thread
The Democrat base is, to my perception, exceptionally weak right now.
If the American right genuinely thinks this, they are high on their own supply and deserve to lose. I am not American and don't see the vibes that you guys are relying on, but I can see the election results. Biden won in 2020 on a record high turnout - if that is "a weak candidate who will not inspire voter turnout" then I want to see the kind of Dem landslide that would result if they find a merely mediocre candidate. Midterms and even more so special elections are all about base mobilisation (because of the generally low turnout) and the Democrats significantly overperformed in 2022, and are killing it in off-cycle elections so far this year.
I am guessing here (as I said, no access to the vibes) but it isn't hard to see two reasons why the D base should be unusually energised right now.
- January 6th, and more broadly Trump's attempt to remain in office despite losing the 2020 election. Even if Trump is not the nominee (and as far as I can see only a medical catastrophe or a SCOTUS decision that he is disqualified under Section 3 of the 14th amendment can stop him), the R primary electorate seem determined to double down on this. From the perspective of anyone who thinks that the 2020 election was not, in fact, rigged, and that the Trump campaign knew this, 2024 is a Flight 93 election because the Republicans are no longer committed to the idea that a Republican president should leave office after losing an election.
- Dobbs. I have posted before pointing out that the history of countries other than the USA is that abortion is a sufficiently important issue that in countries where abortion is "on the table" for democratic politics, the median voter ends up getting what they want. The Republicans are more out of step with the medial voter on this issue, at just the time where Dobbs makes it a matter of democracy.
Reading the whole brochure as a Londoner, the most interesting thing is just how much of a personality cult the Greater London Authority is trying to present itself as. The name "Greater London Authority" is only used on internal-facing documents - to the public, the brand is "Mayor of London", and the mayor is photographed at every opportunity while his staff and other politicians are unpersoned. The key aim of the brand guidelines is that GLA publications should create the impression that Sadiq Khan is solving every crime and fixing every pothole himself, or at least hands-on supervising the front-line workers who are. Unfortunately, I think this was the intention of London's Scottish colonial rulers when they set up the GLA - I have heard lots of serious people saying that the secret to fixing local democracy (i.e. getting voters to vote on local issues) is to personalise it. And the previous mayors were Ken Livingstone and Boris Johnson, so Khan has to do a lot of PR-mediated cult of personality stuff to compete with their media personas.
Specifically on the race issue, there are plenty of pictures where Khan is the only non-white person in shot held up as good examples, so I don't think the intended message is "fewer white faces". Interestingly, a lot of the white faces in the examples are police - there are good reasons given the politics of policing in London why if I were the Mayor, I would choose my PR shots to make the Metropolitan Police look more diverse than they are, but showing the police as almost-all-white doesn't bother Khan's PR team. I do worry that someone seems to think that the only person in London over the age of 50 is the Mayor.
Agreed. I started a count of white/black/Asian non-Khan faces, but it is skewed by the large-group pictures of "Positive and Optimistic" on p34 which is an almost-all-Asian group and of the African dance troupe on p43. But my casual impression is that the racial mix is only marginally less white than London, and probably not less white than young London (the ethnic minority population is a lot younger than the white population). The most obvious weirdness about the demographics of the photos, which I assume is a message that Khan's team intend to communicate but can't write down for legal reasons, is how young everyone except Khan is. There are zero photos showing Khan (who is 52) with someone who appears to be older than him, and only one picture without Khan (on p44) where a pensioner is in focus.
When Londoners talk about "real Londoners", which is rare, it usually refers to long-term permanent residents as opposed to transients (depending on context, tourists and other visitors, temporary residents such as students or corporate transferees, or rich people with multiple addresses meaning they aren't fully committed to London). The proposition "If you have lived in London for at least ten years, you are a real Londoner" doesn't attract much opposition. There is also a fairly strong consensus that the boundary of London is the M25 and that suburbanites are real Londoners too. The super-rich would be real Londoners if they were long-term permanent residents, but the view that super-rich people are globe-trotting jetsetters without the kind of commitment to any one city to qualify as a real Londoner is widely held.
If a real Londoner wrote that, "doesn't represent real Londoners" means that the people in the photo appear to be either tourists or posed models. I agree that it is possible that some recent (white, thick) graduate of a provincial university interning at a cheap PR agency could think that the family are too white to be real Londoners.
The problem with drunks is that they commit violent crimes (particularly domestic ones) in a way which potheads don't - not that they can't hold down jobs. In most of America, also that it is impossible for non-rich people to avoid driving (rich people can afford taxis) so if you are drinking you are probably drink-driving. Stimulants don't make you as bad a driver as depressants like alcohol.
Fixing housing affordability issues seems is a hard problem. Fixing housing affordability has never been done by any country (as far as I know).
Most places in the US have "fixed" housing affordability, in the sense that someone who works 2000 hours a year at the real local minimum wage (which may be higher than the statutory minimum if the economy is good) can afford a singlewide trailer home and/or a room in a shared house. AFAIK, the only major cities with good jobs where that is true are in Texas.
Japan has "fixed" housing affordability in the sense that an unskilled worker can afford a room in a SRO, even in Tokyo.
In none of these places is homelessness a major problem.
Do members of the electoral college swear an oath of office to uphold the constitution?
No - among other places, this is discussed in Baude essay on Section 3, because it creates an interesting lacuna (a presidential elector who engages in an insurrection is not disqualified from future office, but an oath-taking officer who engages in an insurrection is disqualified from being a presidential elector).
Does Georgia have a law requiring electors to cast their votes according to the election results? These are serious questions, I sincerely don't know.
No - see here (although that is the status now, not as of 2020). According to that map, the only states where being a faithless elector is a crime (and thus the only ones where secondary liability for advocating a crime could conceivably trigger) are both Carolinas, New Mexico and Oklahoma. The more normal approach is to declare the faithless elector's vote void and to allow the other electors for that state to replace them.
In addition, a rando tweeting into the aether would be protected by the 1st amendment in a way that a high government official making a personal phone call to an individual elector backed up by detailed (false) arguments of why the election was fraudulent and vague threats of criminal prosecution for covering up the fraud would not be - the law distinguishes between non-serious and serious crime-encouraging speech.
It's funny to see how it plays out now in that Rich men north of Richmond viral song, where there's a line criticizing fat people on welfare being paid to eat fudge. It's also funny to see in the live show video how enthusiastically a lot of the heavier people in the audience sing along even that part.
The word "welfare" and the height of the fat person (roughly the average female height) clearly point to the "welfare mother" stereotype. White rednecks who rort SSDI for a living don't see themselves as on welfare as such, so they know the line isn't directed at them. The same logic is why PMC white male New Yorkers and Californians aren't bothered when their political allies say that "white men" are responsible for everyone bad in the world.

Even on the most pro-Biden view, Hunter Biden's principal source of income was selling access to his father. If Joe disowns Hunter and stops meeting with his clients, then the clients stop paying Hunter.
That said, if Joe Biden was the kingpin in an influence-peddling operation, then Hunter would be keeping considerably less than 50% - he would be lucky to get 25% and 10% would be perfectly reasonable.
More options
Context Copy link