@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

Putting pineapple on pizza is a crime against God and Nature (and pizza), and accordingly subject to universal jurisdiction even in the absence of specific local statutory law . I thought this was common knowledge on a forum where high IQ and good taste were the default.

The irregular Georgia electors submitted a "Certificate of Vote" to Pence's office where they claimed to be the primary electors, as did the irregular electors in Arizona, Michigan and Nevada. The irregular electors in Michigan are being prosecuted locally for falsifying an official document. It looks like most of the irregular electors in Georgia have rolled and are going to testify against Trump.

The irregular electors in New Mexico and Pennsylvania worded their certificates to be contingent on their later being determined to be the real electors, which keeps them out of legal trouble, but means the certificates are less useful for the Eastman/Chesebro scheme to have Pence overturn the election on Jan 6th.

All rich countries had a recession in 2008-2011, because of the global financial crisis. The UK and, for different reasons, the sunnier EU countries, show the pattern you mention of never really recovering from it, but most other places don't. If you look at the US, Germany, Poland, or any rich Asian country, then the 2008 recession looks like a blip with growth returning to trend. (A painfully slowly-growing trend in Japan, but not the kind of stagnation you see in the UK or Spain) For example, see this graph

There is a techno-optimist narrative that there is a real possibility, large enough that a VC would bet on it given the size of the payoff, that the Great Filter is in our past (or is in the near future, with a slim-but-real chance of crossing it - the Yudkowskian view on AI), we see no other signs of a civilization that has crossed it, and accordingly given the potential impact of a supercivilization, humanity is the most important thing in the observable universe. This is a major source of meaning to the longtermist-EA crowd in practice, and in a weaker form is a very obvious source of meaning that everyone involved is space exploration talks about.

The fundamental narrative is more general - most religious source-of-meaning narratives are of the form "humanity is special because God made us special" and this is a secular version. It can be relied on by anyone who is part of the load-bearing infrastructure of human civilization (including parents) or who thinks they are.

The old jaibot blog (jaibot was the bard of the early Berkeley rataionality community) recently disappeared, but he had some excellent inspirational posts of this type.

How many potentially brilliant scientists are now working dead end jobs or posting on 4chan from the basement because they made a few socially awkward and politically incorrect jokes early on in life, inadvertently removing themselves from the ability to navigate that system at all?

Not many - neither the physical sciences nor the funded-because-upstream-of-medicine majority of the life sciences are politically sensitive enough to make forensically examining someone's past for hidden wrongthink worth the effort, so people don't do it. To get cancelled, one of three things needs to happen:

  • You ignore prevailing (in the current year, woke, but in Oppenheimer's time anti-Red) social norms so spectacularly that it becomes impossible not to cancel you.
  • You make enemies who find it worth their while to go through your life looking for cancelbait (and with norms as vague as they are, someone who looks hard enough will find something - so this is cancellation for bad luck + having social-media-powerful enemies, not wrongthink).
  • You are prominent enough that people are willing to make an effort to take you down, and find something bad enough that your friends, mentees, collaborators etc. will no longer defend you.

Googling cancelled physicists (and the results are consistent with my own recollection), in the last few years we have

  • John Clauser, who was already 80 and long-since retired at the time he was "cancelled" (taken off a panel at an IMF-sponsored event). This was only newsworthy because it happened the year after he received a belated Nobel prize.
  • Alessandro Strumia, who was fired from CERN for giving a talk that was generally perceived as sexist - although cancelling him was an obvious violation of academic freedom it was the precise opposite of cancelling someone over a youthful indiscretion.
  • Lawrence Krauss, cancelled for weaksauce allegations of sexual harassment that probably would not have stuck had he not been a friend of Jeffrey Epstein.

That isn't many people, and they were all open and notorious heretics as adults. Their being cancelled isn't good (particularly Strumia, who is probably right), but it isn't the kind of cancel culture where a few socially awkward jokes as a teen can be dug up to end a career a decade later.

The attempts to cancel Neil deGrasse Tyson for sexual harassment and James Webb for homophobia failed. Ancient history now, but so did the attempt to cancel Matt Taylor (comet probe shirt guy).

They are fiscally left where it benefits their subpopulation: "work harder for my Medicare, but don't touch my 401(k)"

Precisely the point I was making about Boomercons - I think of them as the "Keep your big government out of my Medicare" crowd. The politics is functionally economic-right and anti-worker but appeals to non-rich pensioners with the same kind of story that a populist movement would use to appeal to workers.

The heavily subsidised farmer complaining about how all their taxes go to supporting welfare bums in the cities is the same species, though mostly relevant as a vibe rather than a political bloc given the continuing decline in smallholding.

In so far as the article is meant to be actionable advice to someone, rather than academic blowhardery, I suspect the aim is to provide the GOPe with a playbook to dump Trump if it becomes necessary. If done while Trump was still viable, this would destroy the Republican party, but there are some fairly obvious situations where Trump is losing and dragging the GOP down with him, but has enough delegates that he can't be dumped in line with the rules.

In particular, the bit about Section 3 being self-executing and everyone involved in the electoral process being obliged to enforce it is an open invitation to Ronna Romney McDaniel to stop the Convention nominating Trump regardless of the delegate counts, should that turn out to be a good idea at the time. (For instance, because Trump has been convicted after a process which leaves the median voter agreeing that he is clearly guilty, or because he ended up running a defense along the lines of "I am so disconnected from reality that I cannot possibly form the mens rea for a crime of dishonesty" and beclowning himself).

Like every other British monarchist, I had been quietly hoping that our new King had a little list of architects. They'll none of them be missed.

Prince Harry's baptismal name is Henry - this is a very common substitution among upper-class Brits and has been around for a very long time - "God for Harry, England and St George" is in Shakespeare's Henry V.

Huh, never thought I'd see the Woke-Wignat crossover game include "New, technical definition of Racism that excludes most historical and colloquial uses of the word, including most of the uses that made it popular."

"Racial and ethnic" strongly suggests that the two words have different meanings, otherwise why use both. If you accept that the two words have different meanings, then per common usage "racial" refers to the major subgroups of humanity like "black" and "white", and "ethnic" refers to more granular groups.

The use of "racism" that made the word popular related to the black/white situation in the US, which falls squarely within my definition of racial as opposed to ethnic conflict.

"You can't be racist against Irish/Jews/Poles because they are white" is an argument that gets trotted out from time to time in the UK, and although it doesn't get taken particularly seriously it isn't treated as cancellable heresy unless it is directed at Jews.

President Camacho codes as both black and Hispanic to me, but I am not American so I would defer to someone who is.

racial and

Is incorrect. All your examples are of trivial-to-outsiders ethnic difference within the same race, whether you define race using the American folk racial categories or the mostly scientifically accurate ones (as confirmed by modern DNA testing) developed by the Victorian biological anthropologists that academia teaches you to denounce as "scientific racists".

Protestant Irishmen and Catholic Irishmen get along just fine in the Republic, and have done ever since independence. They got along just fine in 1798, when the United Irishmen were cross-confessional.

Thanks for asking these important questions. The easiest question is question 1 - the answer is "mu" because there are not, in fact, drastically fewer populists than there used to be. We see this, because political appeals to the populist quadrant of the Nolan chart repeatedly overperform elite expectations. This is true for both appeals reaching out from the rightist quadrant of the Nolan chart (Trump, Boris, Le Pen etc.) and appeals reaching out from the leftist quadrant (2016 Bernie, Syriza, Podemos etc.) In fact, you can make a case that there are more populist voters than there used to be because the Overton window has moved in a libertarian direction since Reagan/Thatcher and has left the median voter behind. Dominic Cummings wrote about this a lot on his blog before the EU referendum - one of his catchphrases for getting through to politicians who are not paying attention is "Relative to the status quo, the median voter is a National Socialist" (I think he would be marginally more accurate if he said "Relative to the Overton window"). He has said that if he could get away with it, his campaign slogan would be "Hang the paedos, save the NHS".

The next easiest question is question 3 - the populists are on Boomer Facebook, or propping up the bar at your local golf club. The key fact about the populist vote is that it skews older, less educated, and almost certainly less intelligent than the other three quadrants. There are three things going on here

  • There are weak but well-studied positive correlations between libertarian-quadrant political views, IQ, education, and the big 5 personality trait of openness to experience (roughly equivalent to Myers-Briggs N if you are into MB types).
  • In a world where educated people use their politics as part of their identity, the correlation looks stronger than it is because smart populists hide their power level. The association of populism (particularly if expressed openly) with ignorance and bigotry is real, so trying to raise the status of populist politics is very hard (you have to get people to stop noticing things - something that on race required a 50-year programme of State-backed thought reform, and even then intelligent white lefties demonstrate by their behaviour that they are only pretending not to notice things).
  • Older people tend to be more socially conservative, which is one of the two planks of populism. Because of improving education over time, they also tend to be less educated at a fixed IQ level. Because of cognitive decline in old age, they may be slightly dumber as well.

The upshot of this is that populists are less online, less interested in the type of substance-heavy discussion of political issues that we do here, and in general less politically engaged - in both the post-Trump US and the post-Brexit UK we have seen people being surprised that low turnout no longer helps the right. Non-targetted voter suppression by the right has backfired multiple times, with the Ohio I-can't-believe-it's-not-abortion off-cycle referendum being the most recent example. Jacob Rees Mogg made the unusual mistake of saying the quiet part out loud on this point.

The other important point that fits in here is the nature of modern populism. Given that we are at the tail end of 40+ years of increased globalisation (trade, cultural exchange and migration) during which the economy was not great for poor people in rich countries, the thing that holds modern populism together is anti-establishment xenophobia. The modern populist message is:

  • The reason you don't have nice things is because foreigners are robbing you blind
  • The reason why foreigners are able to rob you blind is because corrupt elites are helping them.

For left-populists, the foreigners in question include foreign investors expecting to make profits. For right-populists, they are mostly immigrants. Both sides are happy to attack multinational companies offshoring to cheap labour sweatshops in the Third World. Right-populists wear their xenophobia on their sleeve, left populists try to dog-whistle it. But if you look at the anti-Englishness of the SNP, the anti-Germanism of Podemos and Syriza, or the anti-Americanism of Latin American populists, it is obvious that xenophobia is core to their appeal.

Turning now to question 2, the reason why this question is difficult is that populist voters are less likely to have intellectually coherent political views, so movements appealing to them are less likely to be based on an intellectually coherent ideology that merits naming. In European politics, the ideology that lived in the populist quadrant post-WW2 was called Christian Democracy, but most Christian Democratic parties (including the German CDU, which is the de facto standard-bearer of European Christian Democracy because of its size and electoral success - the Dutch CDA is the most obvious exception) drifted into the empty space on the right left open by the demise of throne-and-altar conservatism. (Throne-and-altar conservative parties across Europe generally disbanded after being useful idiots for Hitler). A lot of mostly-defunct populist political parties had a support base of rural smallholders and are called things like "Agrarian", "Country" "Farmers'" or, surprisingly often "Centre". But in the Anglosphere populist movements tend to be associated with charismatic leaders (William Jennings Bryan, Huey Long, Boris Johnson, Donald Trump) and not ideologies or permanent mass-membership political parties. Back in the pre-Trump era, there were people who called themselves "paleoconservatives" who definitely lived in the populist quadrant - their biggest electoral success was under Pat Buchanan (and arguably Ross Perot, who they supported from a distance), and their house journal was The American Conservative. "One Nation Conservatism" was a British tendency with deep roots (the term goes back to Disraeli) and lives in the populist corner of the Nolan chart, but like Christian Democracy it doesn't have the anti-establishment connotations of modern populism. Boris Johnson has called himself a One Nation Conservative, but he has also called himself a libertarian, a populist, and a Thatcherite. In general, the term was hijacked by pro-establishment centrists in the Thatcher era. I don't know what the current American terminology is, but in the UK modern populists are called "Blue Labour" if they are coming from the left and "National Conservatives" if they come from the right. See this sympathetic article about why the actual populists in national conservatism are struggling to reconcile with the fake-anti-establishment rightists like Jacob Rees Mogg who they are forced to work with by FPTP.

I think question you may have meant to ask is a slightly different take on question 1: Why are there so few political movements appealing to the voters in the populist quadrant of the Nolan chart given the obvious opportunity? I see three big reasons for this:

  • The grift - given the age and education issue, there are not enough smart, young populists who are willing to go public with their populist political views to staff a nationwide political movement, let alone a populist government. So you see a lot of grifty fake populist movements run by people who are not populists, want populist votes but don't actually plan to deliver a populist agenda. Trump and Berlusconi are plutocrats, not populists. Boris Johnson is a megalomaniac with utterly flexible political views, but the people who put him in power were the same hard-core small-government rightists who would go on to back Liz Truss. All of the above are also crooks. Dominic Cummings may be a neo-reactionary hiding his power level, but if not he is a pro-establishment centrist who favours the Silicon Valley establishment over the British one and is using populism as a tool.
  • Boomercons - the welfare state for the old in most countries operates largely separately from the welfare state for the poor. So you can have a political movement that picks up the votes of retired and soon-to-be-retired voters in the populist quadrant without being meaningfully pro-worker by promising to protect the big old-age welfare programmes (which, in practice, means expanding them to keep up with population aging). See this subthread on "Boomer reality" for more discussion and some relevant UK-based links. Trump does this. Boris does it even more. I don't think it is as much of a big deal in Continental Europe, where going single-issue against Muslim immigration appeals to all age groups.
  • Specifically in the US, race. To support an economic-leftist agenda in America, you either need to support fiscal transfers from whites to blacks, or you need to be openly racist and say that poor whites should get help that blacks don't. Hence the golden era of American populism was in the Jim Crow South. The populist constituency is still majority white (because the electorate is) but is blacker than the electorate as a whole (because almost all blacks are populist on issues other than race relative to the median white voter). So to unite it, you need to keep both the black churchladies and the confederate-flag-waving rednecks in the same tent. Wokeness has got sufficiently stupid that this probably can be done, but so far Donald Trump has only managed to increase the R share of the black vote from roughly 5% to 10%, which doesn't amount to actually doing it.

Well of course buying into GOP culture war has positive influences for ADOS- even if black culture were no worse than average, ‘you need to fix your culture by focusing more on schooling and family values’ results in more focus on schooling and family values for people who buy into it. These are highly correlated with good things.

This would probably be true pre-2016, but right now "you need to focus more on schooling" is pretty deeply left-coded. Although there are right-wing memes telling young men to work hard and learn a trade, the dominant right-wing meme is "lift weights and learn to shoot" - which would not be an improvement to ADOS culture. The very online right is claiming Kayne West as one of their own for God's sake.

I mean you can create a metric of ‘is it possible to be poor in this country’, but realistically Mexicans and Chinamen who can afford cars strongly prefer them. It’s not as if there are large numbers of people in these countries who live otherwise affluent lifestyles except for not having cars or whatever; it’s the poor that don’t have cars there.

True of Mexico and China specifically, but not of actually-first-world Asia (mostly Japan, South Korea, Taiwan), where middle class people living in cities without a car (or more commonly with one car shared between multiple employed adults such that most trips are not by private car) is even more normal than it is in Europe.

I'm certain that people became more care-free outside and at various worksites after consequences of unlucky cut changed from likely gangrene or tetanus to basically nothing.

The opposite - life was just cheaper back then, and people tolerated workplace death rates that we wouldn't. The CDC reports a 90% decline in workplace death rates between 1933 and 1997 (and a bigger drop for specific dangerous industries like coal mining). The trend in the UK is even more stark, but I can't find data before the 1980's online. In the current year, workplace deaths in the US are mostly on-the-clock shootings and car crashes - i.e. not deaths amenable to improvements in traditional health-and-safety.

As someone who does cook:

  • I don't bother if I am on my own. It isn't worth it.
  • It isn't difficult to get to the point where you like your own cooking better than cheap restaurant food or ready meals.
  • It gets really awkward when your family know that you can cook better food (or at least food that they like more, because you adjust the recipe to taste) than cheap restaurants, because it means you can't go out to get a break.
  • I can only combine cooking daily with a full-time job because I mostly WFH. Pre-pandemic, there were 2-3 cheat days a week - mostly pasta with packet sauce.

Except, again they have the same food environment we do.

Not really. I'll skip HFCS, which is both over-discussed and probably not a key driver of the blubber gap, and point out that America is the only country where bread is routinely sweetened. Notoriously among VAT geeks, Subway is legally candy in Ireland because there is so much added sugar in the bread.

Seriously, the amount of added sugar in mass-market bread in the most European countries (I am only directly familiar with the UK, Ireland and France) is zero. If you want sweet bread, you spread honey on it.

In my experience, all the diets which actually work for large numbers of people involve severely restricting refined sugar (including fruit juice) and somewhat restricting sugar in whole fruit. That is a lot harder if staples like bread have hidden sugar in.

I think affluent African parents are more relaxed about their kids marrying white than many Asian (especially South Asian) and Arab/North African parents, possibly for cultural and religious (they're usually Christian) reasons.

Since you mention the UK, it is worth noting that the 1st priority for middle-class Black African parents is that their kid shouldn't marry a Jamaican, which is a likely outcome if they pick up an African-American-inspired generic "Black" identity at school.

It isn't the schools - in the first world the problem is always the students. There is one very obvious explanation for why non-ADOS blacks do better in America, which is that they (or their parents) were pre-selected as desirable immigrants. But this doesn't seem like the whole story - Caribbean blacks in the UK seem better off than ADOS blacks in the US despite their ancestors moving here to take on low-skill jobs at a time when migration within the British Empire was unrestricted.

There are two obvious HBD just-so stories:

  1. Slave ships reached the Caribbean first, so the American cotton planters got the crappy slaves the Caribbean sugar planters didn't want.
  2. The process of maintaining a self-sustaining slave population in America between the ban on the slave trade in 1808 and emancipation in 1865 was highly dysgenic because masters preferred dumber slaves who were easier to control.

There is also the obvious cultural theory.

There are plenty of people in the UK who campaign against airport expansion on climate grounds but whose lifestyles rely on cheap flights - I don't think the climate movement is excusing leisure air travel.

I think part of the problem is that climate activism in general and Sunrise and Just Stop Oil in particular are run by people who are good at talking money out of left-wing foundations, not by people who understand climate. (This is recent - Al Gore knew what he was talking about when he was the public face of climate activism). So they tend to think of the policy problem as a fundamental moral problem whose solution needs to be enforced by the State, not as a fundamentally technical problem whose solutions need state support to implement. And the preferred frame on the stupid left is something like "All major social problems are easy to solve and the only reason they haven't already been solved is that the people in charge are mean." So there is a lot of climate left effort going into allocating blame to a small number of rich people, rather than the general mass of middle-class people consooming carbon-intensive product.

The problem is that blame is not something you can measure with a thermometer. It doesn't matter whether the carbon emissions produced by commuting to a desk job in a F150 are morally the fault of Ford shareholders, Ford executives, Ford employees, Oil company executives, oil company shareholders, oil company employees, the banks that financed them, the politicians that set up the system they operate under, or the driver. Whatever the moral arguments, at a practical level the person who has to change their lifestyle to stop those emissions entering the atmosphere is the driver.

Try not to do this.

To decide that you've had it up to here with the three or so well-funded idiots who make up Just Stop Oil and that you are going to hold your nose and sign up with the "I don't mind if the third world fries, it's hot out there I'm not surprised" crowd is a perfectly normal human response, and if at least some people do it it creates good incentives for activists not to be idiots. (Although I suspect that giving noisy idiots rent-free space in your head is bad for the soul). But that is a change in political tactics - changing your views on a factual question based on the noisy idiocy of a bunch of randos is irrational. If 550ppm CO2 is in fact as bad for humanity as the IPCC says it is, then this is the kind of fact that does not care about your feelings.

The description ("blazon" in heraldry-speak) includes "supporters" - i.e. animals that hold up the shield similar to the lion and unicorn on the royal arms. Not sure why they are not in the picture on wikipedia. I tried to find a picture of the shield with supporters, but my google-fu only found the wikipedia version.