MadMonzer
If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your
No bio...
User ID: 896
My understanding is that the purpose of the Security Council was to proactively deal with "threats to international peace and security" (like minor royals being shot in Sarajevo or less-than-perfectly controlled great power client states invading each other) before they escalated to possible great power conflict. I don't think it did this - in particular the list of US-Soviet proxy wars in banana republics is long, and the UN system did basically nothing - escalation was prevented by some combination of MAD and the post-Cuban Missile Crisis steps taken to ensure bilateral communication between the superpowers.
‘Never again’ with regards to WWII refers to the litany of unprecedented and unrepeated human rights crises in the war, not to the existence of a war.
As a comment about the cocktail-party talk of Anglo-Jewish in elites early 21st century America, this is probably true, but as a statement about the global political response to World War II, it is profoundly false. The people who live through WW2 and the institutions they set up were all about "Never again" with regard to total war between the great powers.
The first test is how the Western allies handle Stalin's post-war demands, and given a choice between "Never again" as in don't commit/assist/cover up epic human rights abuses and "Never again" as in don't risk a war with Stalin over petty shit like human rights, the West chooses peace. The Cold War begins with conflicts over spheres of influence, not Soviet crimes. The rhetoric of the Truman doctrine is about defending democracy against totalitarianism, but the actual policy it was first used to justify was supporting what were effectively right-wing military governments in Greece and Turkey against probably-popular Communist-backed revolutions.
The Preamble to the UN Charter begins "We the Peoples of the United Nations, determined to save succeeding generations from the scourge of war..." and sets up a whole bunch of conflict-resolution institutions, some of which were intended to have teeth (although the Cold War meant that the Security Council never functioned as intended). It specifically declined to set up human-rights enforcement institutions - Article 2, Principle 7 is "Nothing contained in the present Charter shall authorize the United Nations to intervene in matters which are essentially within the domestic jurisdiction of any state "
The Schuman Declaration setting up what would eventually become the European Coal and Steel Community specifically states that the aim is to make another war between France and (West) Germany impossible, but does not mention human rights. The EEC/EU doesn't even acquire a formal commitment to human rights until 2000.
This isn't surprising - World War II was an order of magnitude more deadly and destructive than the Holocaust. Comparing these Jewish Holocaust death tolls to these total WW2 death tolls, the only country where Holocausted Jews were a majority of the dead was Czechoslovakia (which was spared the worst of WW2 in a paradoxical but genuine success for Neville Chamberlain's appeasement policy).
In Russia and China, "Never again" obviously refers to the invasion and ruination of their countries by Germany and Japan respectively - it is a call to make sure that you are at the table and not on the menu next time. So not "Never again a war", but "Never again a war without a quick victory". For obvious reasons, not about the Holocaust.
It is easy for Americans to think silly things about WW2 because the United States was spared most of the negative consequences. Continental Europe was basically trashed from Saint-Lo to Stalingrad, as was China. The UK was bombed, blockaded, and bankrupted. Japan was nuked. As the people who actually lived through all this die off, Americanised western Europeans are starting to think the same silly things. This is bad.
In England, the St George's Cross flag is primarily associated with support for English national sports teams - many sports originated in the UK with the first "international" matches being England vs. Scotland, so the various British countries maintain their own national teams as a kind of historical curiosity. There are enough wokestupids with Grauniad columns who think that supporting your own country in international sporting competitions is racist for there to be a controversy about the flag every time there is a major international football tournament.
Neither the core Red Tribe nor the Haredi/Hasidic/etc. strains of Orthodox Judaism are a good model for whole countries because they are dependent on outside money to maintain a first-world standard of living (even if you accept the Red Tribe cope that the net flow of transfer payments to red states goes entirely to African-Americans, getting paid to fight the Blue Tribe's wars isn't a business model which works for a sovereign state). The Modern Orthodox in the USA appear to be fiscally self-sustaining - whether or not they are in Israel is a ranting issue over there.
There are a few examples (like the Amish) of high-fertility, low-productivity communities which don't suck on the fiscal teat, but the Amish are poor enough that they would not be an attractive model to a middle-income country like China.
The best example of a high-fertility, high-productivity religious subculture is probably Mormonism. Also, secular Jews in Israel have a TFR which seems to hover around replacement level, which is quite impressive for a group selected for being irreligious.
Re. your original point, I don't think the dates line up for the thesis that Red Tribe vulgarity is a defence against anti-natal Blue memes. The Red Tribe starts seriously trying to fortify itself against anti-natal Blue memes in the late 1970's with the foundation of Christian orgs like Focus on the Family and the Moral Majority. The Red Tribe doesn't become ostentatiously vulgar until well into the 21st century - the Falwell-Robertson era Christian right set a huge amount of store on being politer than their opponents, as the Mormons do now.
I think the vulgarisation of the Red Tribe is driven by secularisation. How many Red Tribe thought leaders in the 1980's truly embraced Jesus Christ as their Lord and Saviour (rather than just ticking the "Evangelical" box on the census and going to church on Christmas, Easter, Mothers' Day and when running for office)? Almost all of them. How many now? Pretty much just Mike Pence and Amy Coney Barret.
It was engaging in what it considered to be a war against the UK (the UK considered it to be sporadic violent crime, rather then war). If you accept the IRA's claim that it was waging war, then it was an enemy of the United States per article 5 of the NATO treaty.
I speak as someone who managed to get concentrated sulphuric acid spilled on the back of my hand
How much? I went to a private high school that was hard-core about chemistry, and at the start of the year the teacher said something on the lines of "if you don't use more than the recommended quantities, the only thing we do here that can actually permanently injure you is alkali in the eye". A few drops of conc. H2SO4 on the hand was considered a nothingburger - it stang a bit. The same amount of conc. HNO3 was embarassing because your hand would be yellow for a few weeks. The worst accident we had was when someone filled the lab with hydrogen sulphide and we had to evacuate.
Of course, it would be hard for them to become Lord or Prime Minister,
There were two pre-eminent Prime Ministers during the era when the British Empire was at its height. Gladstone was ethnically British. Benjamin Disraeli, as his name suggests, was not. He came from a Sephardi Jewish background, although his father converted to Anglican Christianity (taking the family with him) when Benjamin was a teenager.
Amusingly, the first and second ethnic minority prime ministers (Disraeli and Sunak) as well as the first, second, and third women (Thatcher, May and Truss) were all Conservatives.
Wasn't "being struck by lightning" an adverse event included in Pfizer's phase III clinical trial of the BioNTech COVID vaccine?
If you are thinking about the political theory bits in 1984, Orwell doesn't write about an alliance of High and Low against the Middle. He writes about a PvP battle for power between High and Middle and a PvE battle for survival of Low vs grinding poverty.
I'm sure Moldbug was inspired by Orwell when he wrote about the High-Low alliance against the Middle, but Orwell was both using the words differently (in Moldbug's version, "Low" refers to the underclass, and "Middle" to the general mass of productive workers, whereas Orwell uses "Middle" to refer to an alternative elite and "Low" to refer to the proletariat as a whole) and making a different point (Orwell was pointing out that politics is by default a battle between factions within the elite using the masses as pawns, and that most movements claiming to be uprisings of the Low are actually kayfabe).
The linked report doesn't include the cross-tab by age and sex, but IIRC from other coverage (Yglesias?) there was a big sex gap, with young women becoming dramatically more socially liberal and young men becoming more socially conservative in a way which was more than noise.
The fracking USA sent guns to Ulster.
Rep Peter King (IRA-NY) suffered no adverse political consequences for being a terrorist fundraiser, and was allowed to be Grand Marshall of the NYC St Patrick's Day parade (despite provoking a boycott by the Irish embassy) and Chair of the House Committee on Homeland Security (I suppose he did have relevant experience given the main project of the committee under his leadership was investigating terrorist financing). He remained unrepentant until Sinn Fein irritated him by opposing the Iraq war, and continued to befoul Congress until retiring in his late 70's.
This is Australia, so "monarchist" means retaining the link to the British monarchy (the King is titular King of Australia, and the functions of a non-executive Head of State are performed by the Governor-General and the State Governors who he appoints on the advice of the relevant governments). It tracks Anglophilia and small-'c' conservatism.
Regardless of casualties, Ukraine has (and needs) a higher percentage of the male population under arms, so we expect them to be working harder to recruit. But, given the nature of modern war, recruiting from prisons is also a sign of desperation. There is a reason why 'moral waivers' in the US army are a minor scandal.
When do you think the golden age of trans acceptance was? People are far more trans-accepting than they were ever were - it is just that the normie majority have responded to the increasing noise level by changing their view from "Whatever" to "Don't trans my daughter".
From watching the movie, there were a lot of clues (the fashion, the cars etc.) that it was not set in 1996. I would have guessed late 70's/early 80's (consistently with the publication date of the book).
racially insensitive (including towards other Eastern Europeans, e.g. gypsies and Albanians)
That's nothing. In Europe, everyone hates gypsies (and pikeys, if they are British or Irish and educated enough to know the difference). Our so-called-liberal-elite just know to shut up about it in public. /r/historymemes is down, but there are some epic memes on this point.
The Triumph of Janet (and follow-up with a mad Boomer who turned out to actually be called Janet ranting about the yoof at the Conservative party conference) has rapidly become the canonical British complaint against "Boomer Reality" after going viral on Substack.
A more intellectual version makes the case that the underlying problem is the moral failure of Thatcherism. Margaret Thatcher thought that subsidising Boomer asset acquisition would cause the beneficiaries to become bourgeois and develop the bourgeois virtues, but it actually caused them to become landed gentry in denial and develop the gentlemanly vices (without the noblesse obilige or martial tradition that kept the real landed gentry safe from the guillotine). Sam Freedman sees the core belief that defines boomer reality as "the asset wealth I was subsidised to acquire is something I deserve because I am more virtuous than younger generations". At this level of generality, I think the argument applies on both sides of the Atlantic.
Female scholars and researchers have done wonderful work in the past - see Marie Curie and Rosalind Franklin
Given the obvious genetic advantages and resulting scientific performance of Pierre and Marie Curie's descendents (only one Nobel prize, but several eminent careers in the third generation despite having only two daughters, one of whom spent her child-bearing years nursing her sick mother and then writing the "authorised" biography after her death), my most heretical opinion about women in STEM is that Marie would have contributed even more to physics if Pierre had managed to keep her barefoot, pregnant and above all not irradiated. WW2 makes it hard to work out the counterfactuals in detail, but I don't see how three of four Curie sons wouldn't change the history of science.
It was when Afrikaans society was forming, I believe. British observers noted the african Dutch to differ from euro Dutch by being poor religious fundamentalists who married their teenaged cousins- which sounds like a pretty good description of partially dehajnalizing to me.
Agreed
Is teen marriage unusually common among Afrikaners? According to Hajnal’s original work, the defining feature of cishajnal societies is that the working and middle classes didn’t marry until they had achieved a degree of financial independence from their parents. In the US, Southerners have consistently married younger than Yankees, even before the sexual revolution.
And Strauss and Howe grokked this in 1990, the year before Douglas Coupland named Generation X. This is a large part of why people took Strauss and Howe seriously.
73.6% looks like the percentage of the US population that is over 21. In other words, brewers won't advertise in media whose audience skews too-young-to-drink.
A lot of Southern whites are descended from the Scots Irish, who are themselves descended from trans-Hajnal subcultures within the United Kingdom.
Progressivism is the ideology of the PMC centre-left in the Anglosphere. You can see a certain commonality of thought, as well as an unbroken lineage of individual progressives, back to the turn-of-the-century capital-P Progressives like Teddy Roosevelt and Bob La Follette. The key constant ideas as I see it are:
-
Society is improving over time both materially and morally because of technocratic elites making correct decisions. We should strive to be on the right side of history.
-
Planning is possible and desirable.
-
Educated people should rule. Decisions which can be reduced to technical questions should be left to appropriately-qualified technical experts, decisions which have an unavoidable political component should be made by people with a broad education in morally correct thinking.
-
Education is good. More education is better.
-
There is too much economic inequality in the US c. 1900 or 2000. Slightly less economic inequality would be better, but not so much equality that the upper-middle-class can no longer enjoy an upper-middle-class lifestyle. 1950s US or modern Scandinavian levels of inequality are fine.
-
Separately from the inequality issue, real material deprivation (starvation/homelessness etc.) is very, very bad and we should try to eliminate it, first in our own countries and then globally.
-
Political violence (including war between countries) is very, very bad and we should try to eliminate it. (Lots of intra-progressive disagreement about the best way to do this)
-
Highbrow art is a public good and should be subsidised. Lowbrow art and the preferred intoxicants of the working class are corrupting and should be banned if possible. (Also lots of intra-progressive disagreement about what is possible)
-
Traditional religion is bad.
-
Bigotry is bad. (Lots of intra-progressive disagreement over which discrimination is bigoted and which is justified - pre-WW2 progressives being pro-eugenics is the most famous example)
-
These ideas are culturally universal and good people all over the world are already American progressives, even if they don' t know it yet.
Because Marxist socialism never managed to build a mass working-class movement in the Anglosphere, Marxism in the Anglosphere is a weird sub-sect of progressivism. (This isn't true in Continental Europe, where most countries had nominally Marxist parties with mass working-class memberships organised through the unions.) There is clearly a correlation between weird sectarian progressivism (including, but not limited to, being a Marxist in the Anglosphere) and weird lifestyle experimentation such that Orwell as able to say, correctly, that
One sometimes gets the impression that the mere words 'Socialism' and 'Communism' draw towards them with magnetic force every fruit-juice drinker, nudist, sandal-wearer, sex-maniac, Quaker, 'Nature Cure' quack, pacifist, and feminist in England
and still be mostly correct a century later. (He also includes teetotallers and vegetarians in the list in other writings). But most progressives wear suits to their boring middle-management job and listen to NPR/Radio 4 while commuting from their suburban homes where they raise 1.6 children in a monogamous traditional family.
Wokism is the specific hobby-horse that organised progressivism has taken up in the 2010's.

Agreed on the actual historical facts, but my impression is that the historical mythology of WW2 is extremely important to the versions of national identity being promoted by both the Soviet and the Putinist regimes. And the key points of the myth are:
The innocence of the Soviet Union and the utter wickedness of Hitler's unprovoked aggression (the Molotov-Ribentropp pact is ignored, obv), occasionally backed up with ahistorical claims that the Soviet Union was abandoned or betrayed by the western democracies in the pre-war period.
The Soviet Union's underdog status at the start of the war (probably true)
The extraordinary deadliness and destructiveness of the eastern front in WW2 (which is true) which is blamed on Nazi wickedness (ignoring the contribution of Soviet incompetence)
The extraordinary effort and sacrifice of the Soviet people to defeat the Nazis (definitely true)
The idea that defeating the Nazis was a mostly-Soviet achievement while the western Allies effectively sat the war out and watched Nazis and Communists shoot each other, Spanish Civil War style, and that the rest of the world being insufficiently grateful to the Soviet Union for singlehandedly saving the world from Nazism at enormous human cost is a sign of western wickedness. (Ahistorical)
In other words, the myth clearly centres aggression and not genocide as Hitler's supreme crime, and the intended lesson of the myth is that Russia is always at risk of a surprise attack from the west, needs to be stronk so that the attack can be repelled well before the "Nazis" get to Stalingrad, and suffered massively from being insufficiently stronk in 1941.
More options
Context Copy link