MadMonzer
If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your
No bio...
User ID: 896
I still (as of 2016, when we had kids and stopped travelling adventurously) find it remarkably easy to get away from the tourist traps - just throw the guidebook away and go for a wander! There are a few places (like Venice and Florence) where the whole core city is now a tourist trap, but even somewhere like Granada you only need to get half a mile away from the Alhambra before hanging out with the students becomes more interesting than acting like a tourist. (I suspect this relies on you being young enough and having a good grounding in the local language). Places can also acquire a reputation for being dangerous that keeps the tourists away despite the actual crime levels being lower than most US cities - Naples (the city proper - not Pompeii/Ercolano/the Amalfi Coast) felt mostly tourist-free, and also safe to someone who grew up in south-east London.
The other problem, that a quick random sample of local culture will probably find locals imitating London/LA/NYC badly, is harder to fix. Hanging out with students is basically the same experience anywhere in the Christian or post-Christian world - only the architecture and the weather change from city to city. And if you speak to someone in thickly-accented, broken <local language> the response almost always comes back in thickly-accented, broken English. It may be boring, but it is victory.
I call it the Unculture. This originally came from an article about culture shock in the launch issue of Monocle magazine (incidentally an utterly Unculture rag) which complained about the "global unculture of international chain hotels and airport business lounges". It works because the people who live in the Unculture believe (falsely) that they don't have a culture (which they express as "white people don't have culture") because they see "culture" as funky ethnic foods and costumes, not Shakespeare/Rembrandt/Mozart/etc. My wife also sees it is a pun on the Culture in Iain M Banks' Culture novels, which was intended as a techno-utopia but reads as a dystopia to people who don't live in the Unculture.
On this site, the most usual term is "Blue Tribe" per Scott Alexander's I Can Tolerate Anything Except the Outgroup, but that only really works in the US culture, and globohomo/Unculture is (as it's name suggests) global
I didn't peg you as hating the Chinese that much. That is a level of vitriol that I would expect to see reserved for an attempt by the Trump Organisation and/or George Soros' Quantum Fund to open mines in Afghanistan.
and the Feds had backed them up
Too late - Brown vs Board was in 1954, the Montgomery bus boycott was 1956. The Alabama authorities knew that Rosa Parks would win a federal case, so they tried not to give her one. The non-poster-girl bus protesters (most famously unmarried teen mum Claudette Colvin and long-time activist Aurelia Browder) were not treated with kid gloves, did get their federal case, and won it (Browder v. Gayle).
Ironically, it leads to a case for an interesting question - if Trump had merely attached his vibe to Ted Cruz' political platform in 2016, would he still have won?
No, if Ted Cruz's platform includes monkeying about with Social Security (which he supported as a Senator, but went quiet about once he started running for President). The fact that Trump was not affiliated with the traditional right wing of the Republican party and was therefore credible when he promised to protect Social Security and Medicare was critical to his ballot box success.
DeSantis can't win the presidential election even if he takes the primary, Trump can.
Trump would have lost to an empty suit in 2016 in the Democrats had managed to run one and did lose to an empty suit in 2020. Thinking that Trump is unusually popular with the median voter is "How could Nixon have won? Nobody I know voted for him" level stupid. DeSantis, on the other hand, was re-elected by a landslide in what used to be considered a purple slate.
A stirring speech, but the paean to martial honour that it is built around has always been the minority view among those who fought and bled in industrial-age warfare. The politics of Reconstruction-era America, like the politics of inter-war Europe, was defined by never again. So, in a more uplifting way, was the politics of post-WW2 Europe. War is the price we pay to preserve peace, not something valuable in its own right. This view, too, is in the old books, because things change less than you think. I think it is most eloquently put by John Adams in a letter to his wife:
The science of government it is my duty to study, more than all other sciences; the arts of legislation and administration and negotiation ought to take the place of, indeed exclude, in a manner, all other arts. I must study politics and war, that our sons may have liberty to study mathematics and philosophy. Our sons ought to study mathematics and philosophy, geography, natural history and naval architecture, navigation, commerce and agriculture in order to give their children a right to study painting, poetry, music, architecture, statuary, tapestry and porcelain.
The virtues of American (and before it, British) commercial culture are deep and wide - and, incidentally, unmatched on the battlefield. They should be celebrated for what they are, not compared unfavourably to the martial virtues that we appear to have given up for them. And we remember those who died to preserve them for what they gave up, not what they represent.
If the dead of Gettysburg could talk, would they agree with OWH or John Adams? Mass literacy continued to advance over the intervening decades, and the dead of Flanders speak to us through their letters. Famously, they agree with the living of their generation - war is hell, and war on that scale should only be fought to end all wars.
We men of the factories and counting-houses are not without honour (serial bankrupt Donald Trump excepted). "Dictum Meum Pactum" - "My word is my bond" - the motto of the London Stock Exchange. "The full faith and credit of the United States Government". These mean something (although unfortunately less than they would have done to John Quincy Adams), and people sleep more soundly at night knowing that they will not be ruined because of them. What are Mensur scars or the broken necks of the polo ground which OWH so admires when compared to the skills and spills of modern football (Association or gridiron) - whether you compare the quality of the spectacle at the top of the sport or the ratio of characters built to bodies maimed at the grassroots. Mathematics and philosophy, geography, natural history and naval architecture, navigation, commerce and agriculture are advanced wonderously.
And perhaps we should be more gracious if our granddaughters want to waste some of their time on painting, poetry, music, architecture, statuary, tapestry and porcelain. Rome, after all, is remembered as much for her achievements in those areas as for her battlefield victories.
Rather famously, Germany has no speed limit on most of the Autobahn. German law-abidingness is a result of three linked phenomena - people believe the law simply codifies expected pro-social behaviour, people generally choose to behave pro-socially, and the legislators making laws (like speed limits on uncongested freeways) which would undermine the other two.
Only in a metaphorical sense. One of the undercover cops is a Fed, the other one is State. Otherwise why the need for two?
How much "real teenage rebellion" did the Boomers engage in? Rock music was just consooming product which your parents disapprove of, which was always the lamest kind of rebellion. White kids whose daddies could afford lawyers were even less likely to be punished for smoking marijuana then than they are now (the War on Drugs doesn't get going until the 1970's, and was pretty much a racist project from day one). And dodging the Vietnam Draft was pretty much expected if you were middle-class or above - look at the CV of any Boomer politician.
Compared to the Civil Rights movement (which mostly preceded it) and the Gay Liberation movement (which mostly followed it), the hippie counterculture drew far less heat from the Man - probably because it was seen as harmless by everyone except the Southern social conservatives who were already marked as losers. If you are old enough to have boomer parents, do they tell stories of getting into real trouble for hippie-adjacent activities? Or just of engaging in hippie-adjacent activities and feeling transgressive with no real risk (or the only real risk coming from within the counterculture, like being beaten up by the Hell's Angels at a rock concert)? There was definitely a vague sense of alliance between hippiedom and radical black and later gay activism, but not many hippies were going south of the Mason-Dixon line to do civil rights work, and even fewer were going to Pride parades before they were cool.
The only "rebel" community where people from middle-class backgrounds routinely turn up with origin stories involving being harshly punished by parents or authorities is the LGBT one.
drink at cricket matches like Aussies?
Like Queenslanders, please.
I have met many sober Aussies in my day, and even a few with a taste for decent beer. They all came from points south of the 29th parallel. The suggestion that "Aussies" in general drink XXXX is as offensive as the idea that "Americans" in general shoot varmints out of the back of moving pickup trucks.
I have also noticed that my highest-rated short posts are ones which contain useful links. Unlike some of the other responses, I think the most upvoted links are not "evidence" (.pdfs and such like from respectable sources) but instead things that people feel it was worth their time to click on.
((This is part of the reason Ward Churchill's "Little Eichmann" comment raised so many hackles. Churchill spoke only in the sense that the victims of 9/11 profited from America's "global financial empire", rather than actually finding any connection to the actual military interventions he had blamed them for. Eichmann claimed to be a cog in the murder machine, Churchill turned the term to cover anyone who was in the same room. Of course, no one has since tried to cancel the man for dropping the hard-g in the same essay: who whom.))
Ward Churchill was eventually cancelled for falsely claiming to be a Native American. The question of "What are the who and whom which explain why was Ward Churchill treated differently from Elizabeth Warren?" is interesting and I don't know the answer.
If any focus were placed on the Reich's economic policy or Hitler's command economy, it would fit a lot better; the problem is that to speak of such things is taboo. A socialist hitler never existed, dontcha know?
All war economies are command economies - in WW2 the US less so because the war was less total for the US than most other participants, but you still had pervasive wage and price controls, rationing of key commodities, and residual New Deal restrictions still in place. For the duration, the UK was as much of a command economy as Nazi Germany or the Soviet Union.
And it breaks up when the State troopers lose patience with the FBI agent's increasingly violent rhetoric and decide he needs to be taken out before he blows up a building.
If I was in Epsein's position, I would have killed myself.
If the Mongols felt that it was deserved, they would happily massacre a six-figure number of people after sacking a city (700,000 in Merv, which was the biggest single Mongol massacre). The high-end estimates of the total death toll of the Mongol conquests (military deaths, massacres, and war-related famines) are about half the population of the conquered territory, which is notably worse than Hitler. The macro-demographic impacts of the Mongol conquests can be detected in Arctic ice cores. Once you remember that the Holocaust was mostly the killing of conquered people (the German Jews were encouraged to emigrate, and the majority who did survived), I think you can see the industrialisation of it as the application of modern technology to the old problem of carrying out a wartime massacre.
I think Genghis Khan would have considered the Holocaust militarily stupid, but not ethically fucked up.
Mass murder is as old as humanity, we can wrap our heads around a conqueror setting our cities on fire, looting our treasure, and basking in the lamentations of our women ...
I deliberately put Alexander the Great in my post to make the point that at some point in the past "Conquer the World and kill everyone who resists" was considered OK if it was our guy doing it. But that had ceased to be the case after WW1, and arguably earlier than that. The idea that the 19th-century British Empire required a better moral justification than the sheer rapacity used to justify the 18th-century one seems to have been held pretty universally by the Victorians.
The political culture that is the UK took intentional violations of the lockdown by pro-lockdown politicians and officials very seriously indeed. As well as Johnson and (arguably) Cummings, the list of resignations/firings includes:
-
Neil Ferguson (leading pandemic modeller at Imperial College and SAGE member)
-
Catherine Calderwood (Scottish chief medical officer)
-
Margaret Ferrier (SNP MP)
-
Matt Hancock (Health Secretary)
The Gavin Newsom French Laundry scandal and such like would not have been survivable in the UK.
Partygate was bad because a lot of Johnson's support within the Conservative party was based on the (probably true) belief that his blokey charisma made him an irreplaceable electoral asset, and suddenly he wasn't. The fact that Boris lies constantly about everything was already priced in, and lying to the Commons about Partygate would have been survivable if he was still popular in the country.
In the 1980s and well into the 1990s the Holocaust was on the back burner in the UK for the same reason - as long as significant numbers of people who remembered the Blitz were still alive, no Briton was going to bellyfeel that anything else was Hitler's worst crime. The way history was taught in British schools was that Hitler was the evil Lord of Evil because he was bent on Alexander the Great/Genghis Khan style world conquest long after this had ceased to be acceptable behaviour. This became a Problem that required large-scale British military intervention to stop him several years before anyone came up with the Holocaust.
During the heroic period of WW2 (for the UK, from the Nazi invasion of Poland in September 1939 to El Alamein in July 1942), we couldn't have been fighting Hitler in an unsuccessful attempt to prevent the Holocaust, because the Holocaust hadn't started yet.
FWIW, I still think that the traditional British view is correct (which was also the view of the Nuremberg prosecutors), and that the Holocaust lobby is wrong - Hitler's worst crime was starting WW2. He isn't uniquely evil compared to other warmongering megalomanicas, just uniquely deadly because of the large European population in the 20th century.
Did he take off his jacket and start punching, or did he take off his jacket, engage in a long rant about how he was going to kick ass, and then start punching. I am claiming that the second version (nonspecific ranting followed by violence) is rare.
I was mostly thinking of the race row she kicked off when the sales staff in a Swiss luxury-goods store were insufficiently respectful. It was back in 2013 when the Great Awokening was just getting started, so the Swiss laughed it off.
And the phenomenon is classist, not racist (although America is sufficiently enstupidated by the culture war that most people struggle to tell the difference). The original Karen meme was the "can I speak to your manager haircut" - at heart a Karen is someone who demands that entry-level workers acknowledge her as a social superior, and demands punishment if they don't. I agree that calling a middle-class black woman who pulls rank on white service workers a "Karen" is non-standard usage, but if the shoe fits...
Oprah Winfrey is a total Karen. So was that Smith College chick who called in a cancel mob on the cleaner.
There is a simple and relatively general reason why we expect housing costs to have increased relative to pre-pandemic levels. Remote working increases demand for housing everywhere because people who work from home require more square feet of living space for an equivalent quality of life. And the impact of increase in price on demand is greatest where supply is constrained - i.e. in blue-state NIMBY cities.
So we have three effects:
-
A general increase in house prices due to the demand effect of WFH. Positive everywhere, and relatively more positive for the Bay Area than elsewhere.
-
The relative attractiveness of different places changes due to WFH. There is a general flattening effect (within a metro area for people who sometimes need to network in person, globally for people who can be 100% remote) on the value of neighbourhoods, and there is also a shift in value away from places with a convenient commute to good jobs, and towards fun places. This is a small net negative for the Bay Area as a whole, but within the Bay Area it is a big positive for SF at the expense of Silicon Valley.
-
The specific problems with social decay in SF.
It doesn't surprise me that these are net-positive for SF house prices.
NYC has (and has had ever since the Giuliani era - the de Blasio murder spike was part of a nationwide phenomenon) unusually low crime for US medium-large cities. Non-NYC cities make it easier for a white middle-class hospital employee to personally avoid the crime by commuting by car from their home in one all-white suburb to their job in another all-white suburb, but the core city of the "nice Midwestern city" is going to be somewhere between St Louis and Detroit.
To check numbers, Indianapolis is the reddest big city in the midwest, and has 24 murders and 871 violent crimes (per the FBI definition) per 100,000 residents per year. The Bronx is the worst borough of NYC, and has about 6 murders and 650 violent crimes per 100,000 per year. Jacksonville FL, which recently voted out a Republican mayor for failure to control crime, was a red city in a mostly red state and also far more violent than the Bronx.
One of the problems with the crime discourse (and the problem predates the internet) is that there is tonnes of medium crime in a big city - even a low-crime one like Zurich. So anyone with a megaphone can create the impression that crime is out of control using summer-of-the-shark techniques. Very Online red tribers do this for NYC because performatively hating on NYC is part of red tribe identity politics. They are helped by NYC-based media doing the same thing because it sells newspapers. But that doesn't change the fact that "America can't police big cities the way Europe and 1st-world Asia can" is a nationwide problem, not a partisan one, and that NYC is in fact an island of minimally competent policing in a cesspool of dysfunction.
In SF I would agree with you, but NYC is a city which normally votes for the tougher-on-crime candidate. Looking at recent mayors, Koch, Giuliani, Bloomberg and Adams all ran as conventional law-and-order candidates. Dinkins ran on a platform of hiring more cops and getting the mafia out of City Hall, which is still a platform of being tough on crime. Bill de Blasio was the only soft mayor since crime became a major political issue.
You can say that Adams is fundamentally a corrupt machine politician and that his pro-cop positions are performative, but if so he is definitely putting on the performance - he is gratuitously pissing off the type of soft-on-crime white liberal you are calling out as "likely to vote for the politicians who enabled this situation." FWIW, I would give Adams, his team, and his supporters the benefit of the doubt on a "too early to tell" basis - it took years for Giuliani et al to get crime in NYC under control last time.

They are. Lots of things are broadly popular (in the sense that 60%+ of the population support them) but where a large minority are sufficiently fanatical in opposition that being publically associated with them is a net negative. "Normal-ass employer-provided health insurance includes employer-paid abortions" is a prime example where you should do the popular thing quietly in order to avoid a damaging row with pro-lifers. Anodyne expressions of pro-LGBT sentiment like participating in Pride Month are similar - normies expect you to do it, but shouting about it draws unwelcome attention. The supporters of all these things know that there is a noisy minority of haters.
This applies more to companies which sell to consumers than companies that sell to other businesses. The universe of people who consoom product has a lot more Red Tribers in it than the universe of people who are able and willing to take corporate jobs.
Race-based affirmative action is the rare case where you are probably right - I think supporters genuinely don't grok just how unpopular it is with normies because they have successfully silenced opponents in their own spaces.
More options
Context Copy link