@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

The rise in crime in the 1970's happened across the first world, and it didn't lead to a demand for liberalised handgun laws in any country except America.

Go directly to statistics jail for comparing violent crime in the US when large parts of the country were under COVID restrictions to Australia after COVID restrictions had ceased. If you use the 2019 US figures, it doesn't change the story - the US assault number was 1.7% instead of 1.4% - still well below the Australian level.

IIRC last time I looked it up, UK stats looked similar (assuming US FBI and UK Home Office statistics are a reasonable comparison), but I don't feel like digging for it now.

The equivalent victim-survey based crime numbers are the Crime Survey for England and Wales (I didn't bother looking for Scottish or Northern Irish numbers, but they won't materially affect the UK-wide average). The latest (almost entirely post-COVID restrictions) overall victimisation rate for violent crime is 1.35% - i.e. somewhat below the US numbers. The CSEW does not break down individual types of violent crime because the sample size isn't big enough to produce reliable numbers.

The other thing I looked at, more as a sanity check that the data was comparable than for information, was whether the contribution of domestic violence was the same. Both the US and Australia have about a 20:40:40 ratio of domestic violence/acquaintance violence/stranger violence. The UK talks about "domestic abuse" which is clearly something completely different because the rate is higher than the overall violent crime rate.

Incidentally, can any Aussies on this board let me know how you can have that level of violent crime and not end up with the kind of national freakout about it that the US and the UK go in for?

If we are looking for a US example of pro-tyranny armed citizens rebelling against the government, then the first Klan and the Redeemers (my history is not good enough to know to what extent these were meaningfully different groups) are a more clear-cut example than the Confederacy.

Part of this is also the nature of democracy. It's hard to win a campaign being 'tough on crime.' Generally more feel-good solutions will appeal to a broader majority, as they're far easier to justify and seem less morally fraught. Even if these types of solutions have worse outcomes overall.

Is this some kind of joke? Apart from a few ultra-left-wing cities in a short period after the death of George Floyd, essentially every politician running for election with the intention of winning claims to be tough on crime (some of them are lying, of course). This is most notoriously the case in America, but it is true in every democracy where I have been paying attention. In the UK, the "soft" end of the Overton window is that we should build fewer prisons and spend the money hiring police. (The logic being that a higher chance of being caught more than makes up for a shorter sentence, so you get more deterrence with less punishment). The Chesa Boudin recall tells us that even in San Francisco, being openly soft on crime was a political non-starter by 2022.

Here's a fun exercise for you, can you point out any country that is heavily tyrannical and has very little democracy or protection of basic civil rights... and yet allows broad gun ownership?

Nazi Germany would be the most obvious answer - Weimar-era gun laws were repeatedly relaxed by the Nazi regime (with an initially de facto but later de jure exception for Jews) as part of their remilitarization of Germany and ownership of long guns by non-Jews was entirely deregulated in 1938. A lot of the friends and relations of the Gypsies, homosexuals, socialists etc. who the Nazis persecuted would have been armed. Didn't make any difference - the Nazi regime was a paradigmatic case where the answer to "You can have my gun when you prize it from my cold dead hands" would be "Very well, let's do it your way"

I would like to see an effortpost about the ARM/ASML/TSMC axis of chip design and manufacture and how Silicon Valley stopped making silicon. Given time, I could write a first version and see what came up in the comments.

Closer to the core culture war topics that get overdone, I think two sub-topics I would be interested in effortposts on are:

  • The nature and origins of Universal Culture/globohomo/Blue Tribe/Davos Man - is it Anglo, Jewish, both or neither? Is it the same culture as the Anglo-Chinese culture of Hong Kong and Singapore?

  • Just how unusual are "gayness" and "transness" as understood in Western culture? Male-male sex and people playing a gender role that doesn't match their anatomical sex are found in almost all cultures, but I think there is a standard pattern which is very different from Western gayness and transness.

Chins do love to joke about the royal family being upper-middle class, although I don’t know how seriously they actually take that line of argument.

The version I am more familiar is that they are parvenus, having come over from Hanover in the 18th century. This is only partially fair - the late Queen comes from old-established Scottish aristocracy on her mother's side, and of course the Prince of Wales comes from bona fide English upper class stock through the Spencers.

The Atlee government (and the wartime taxation that preceded it) grabbed a lot of the aristocracy's wealth, but the power of a functioning aristocracy doesn't stem from the cash (as long as there is enough to pay for the education of the next generation). It stems from the social networks (formed by shared upbringing, extended family ties, marriage alliances, and a tradition of regular large parties) and the family traditions that prepare the next generation for careers which will maintain the family's social position, including but not limited to military officering. The aristocracy didn't lose those things, so they were able to adapt. The playing fields of Eton still function as they did in Wellington's time.

To defeat an aristocracy, you either need to kill enough of them to break the network, or make the network irrelevant by building a better one. The last time there was a proper clearing out of the English aristocracy was the Wars of the Roses (1455-1487). There is also a fairly serious theory that what actually did the aristocracy in was the slaughter of young officers in WW1 - the major public schools all lost about three graduating classes worth - and screwed up a lot of the rest.

I don't think that religion has ceased to exist to the extent you are suggesting - my experience is that actual aristocrats in England are disproportionately either trad-Catholic (like Jacob Rees Mogg, but less unhinged) or old-time Anglicans whose faith would have been perfectly comprehensible to the high-Church Victorians. The late Queen was mildly exceptional in being a more evangelical kind of Anglican, but the royals were always slightly declasse compared to the established English noble families. (Note that even Victorian high-Church Anglicanism was something American evangelicals would have considered cucked).

One area where the old-time religion has largely ceased to exist (at least for Protestants and American Catholics) is that even the more conservative branches of Christianity struggle to condemn divorce and take it seriously. The British Aristocracy divorce less than American elites (particularly Red Tribe elites), but often enough for it to be embarrassing.

the child of a teacher

And thus middle-class. Schoolteaching is the quintessential middle-middle career. Enoch Powell's education was typical of the near-elites of his day (he went to a grammar school, then to a public school on a scholarship). Enoch's Tory colleagues wouldn't (and didn't, until he went off on one) treat him as an uncultured interloper like Ramsay MacDonald.

I think the second half of the book has three key ideas:

  1. The soft power of pre-WW1 European culture (including somewhat obscure 19th-century authors like Huysmans) is sufficient that our future Muslim overlords will be happy to pay us money to preserve it and perform it for them like well-fed zoo animals. Given Houellbecq's politics and those of the French trad right more generally, this is probably with connotations of "just like our American overlords do now".

  2. European elites and near-elites (like the narrator, but he doesn't show any organised elite resistance to the Muslim takeover from anyone else either) are sufficiently decadent that they will happily accept this, and will (from a purely hedonistic perspective) be right to do so.

  3. That for old and new elites and near-elites, the most important thing is social peace, and that Islamic governance probably delivers this more effectively than the Western status quo.

UK usage of class terms reflects the way we see the class structure as a pyramid - so there are more working class people than middle class people, and more middle class people than upper class people. "Middle class" as a stereotype implies someone around the 80th percentile of the SES distribution and "Upper middle class" implies someone close to but not in the top 1% - although in both cases the words actually refer to culture and behaviour and not percentile rankings.

According to the definition of class used by the market research industry, 4% of the UK is upper-middle class and the upper class is too small to be included in conventional market research. This feels about right, although the NRS social grades don't quite identify the right people because they rely on what jobs people do.

Funnily enough I think we have an extremely salient example of this very thing in Meghan Markle HRH the Duchess of Sussex.

It is worth pointing out for the benefit of American readers that the reason why she isn't welcome in the British elite is because she is an American who refuses to assimilate, not because she is mixed-race (we don't consider her black given her skin tone and ancestry - the fact that she insists she is Black based on the US-specific one-drop rule is part of the problem). The last American to marry into the Royal Family was Wallis Simpson, and that didn't work out well either.

It is also worth pointing out that actresses are not PMC by default, although HRH is given her background and worldview.

Unless this is one of those British-versus-American English things and I'm unaware.

No. In BrE, "queue" is a waiting line. "cue" can either be a small signal that activates stored information in the brain, or the stick used to propel a ball in billiards family games.

One would think that the people who said the things that led to Fox being sued in the first place should be fired first, at least?

One might, if Fox's business model weren't built around telling lies its listeners want to hear.

How are you supposed to communicate to your org the sentiment "I think my colleagues are engaging in legally vulnerable activities that could lead to a large settlement against the company"

If you work in.a regulated industry, you develop a kind of spidey sense for when you need to escalate concerns without writing anything down. I can see why US journalists don't develop that sense - New York Times vs Sullivan means that they are the least sueable people in America, so I doubt Tucker developed it. I also suspect he may have been venting rather than attempting to effectively escalate concerns about unethical journalism.

My memory of the Democrats' response to Bush II was that it was a lot more co-operative than to Trump.

  • The Bush tax cuts got 13 D votes in the house and 12 in the Senate, the Trump tax cuts passed on a pure party line vote.

  • That centrist Congressional Democrats were willing to carry water for the Bush administration on Iraq (as was the Deep State, which I think we both agree counts as part of the mainstream centre-left) has been the cause of much Democratic infighting after the Iraq war turned out to be a mistake - Trump didn't try to fight a war of choice, but the idea that he would get the level of bipartisan support that Bush did over Iraq seems far-fetched.

  • Pelosi didn't impeach Bush after the Dems took control of Congress in 2006 - despite widespread calls for impeachment from the left, the media, and from a noisy minority of former conservatives driven into shrill unholy madness by the mendacity, malevolence, incompetence, or simple disconnection from reality of the George W. Bush administration. Pelosi impeached Trump the first time on semi-bullshit charges - the left wanted her to pull the trigger as soon as the Dems took the House in 2018, but she held off until the Deep State were annoyed as well.

  • She then impeached him again - although I am comfortable he deserved it the second time, it was in practice pure partisan theatre given there wasn't time for the process to complete before his term expired.

  • Congressional Democrats shut the government down twice in order to force concessions from Trump on immigration policy. There were no shutdowns under Bush II.

IF you go back to Reagan, he got broad bipartisan support for his tax reforms, and he wasn't impeached for Iran-Contra even though he should have been. There were a lot of budget battles between Reagan and Congressional Democrats with multiple government shutdowns, but I think they were all about the budget, rather than the Congressional Democrats shutting down the government to extract concessions over something else.

You are conflating the overheated partisan hatred that the Very Online progressive left has had for every Republican president since Reagan with the overheated partisan hatred that the mainstream centre-left (Dem Congressional leadership, the NYT, the Deep State etc.) has for Trump.

I am a man, so most of the times I have seen the game played have been in all-male groups. It definitely gets played in mixed-sex groups, but people tend to stay safer with the nominations and stick to celebrities. The way it was played in my social circle, it was normally three "good" choices and the fun bit was distinguishing between which hotties were marriage material and which were only good for a good time.

I realise the other complexity with mixed-sex groups is that there are usually couples present. Asking someone to marry/shag/kill when their SO is in the room is potentially offensive to the SO - although again sticking to unattainable candidates like celebrities makes it less so. I have the type of marriage where I can joke with my wife about the bangability of female public figures, but my impression from my occasional dumpster dives of /r/relationshipadvice is that many people don't. And even then if the woman was ingroup, I would let her raise the issue and not me.

I have been in two fist-fights in my life. One was over cheating at cards in middle school. The other one happened because someone nominated my sister as a candidate to marry, shag, or kill. The game is disrespectful, and it is only safe to play with casual acquaintances if you stick to nominating women who are known not to be respectable, such as actresses.

Playing with close friends, or with people who are equivalent such as team-mates on an all-male team with an appropriate level of team bonding, is part of the way groups can bond by engaging in mildly transgressive behaviour. Even so, there are limits, and a female politician who was not clearly outgroup would be pushing them.

I thought the problem with Tucker viz-a-viz the Dominion lawsuit was that he had provided some of the best discovery evidence for the plaintiff by being unusually frank about how he didn't believe the stuff his colleagues were saying on air. Being the guy who gets caught on tape saying "Yes, we are lying scum and we know it" isn't going to endear you to your boss or colleagues - even if they are all lying scum and know it.

Are you defending people's right to discuss which governor you'd most want to have sex with in the workplace?

It is worth pointing out that there is a bog-standard conservative argument against this type of behaviour, not just the feminist one that it might be overheard by a woman who would need to retreat to the fainting couches in a way which affected her job performance. This s*** is rude, and tolerating it coarsens the culture. The right correctly understands that there are places where the culture is unavoidably coarse, and where locker-room talk should be tolerated, but white-collar workplaces like Fox News are not those places.

If Robert E Lee had overheard two young lieutenants in the Army of Northern Virginia joking about what they were going to do to Mrs Lincoln after they got to Washington, he would have made them stop. (Enlisted men, probably not). Trumpy conservatives don't care about that any more, but old-school conservatives like Rupert Murdoch do.

I hope we can agree that Trump is uniquely bad from a mainstream centre-left perspective, given the behaviour of the mainstream centre left. Scott Alexander defended Trump against the charge of being uniquely racist here, but not against the charge of being unusually bad, even by Republican standards, for other reasons. Trump is uniquely bad (from a mainstream centre-left perspective) or good (from a burn-it-down right-populist perspective) because of his willingness to violate norms, and because he doesn't believe in American democracy as it currently exists.

I poasted that the scary thing about Trump is that he treats elections as kayfabe - and nobody disagreed, because post-Jan 6th it is obvious.

I agree that the problem is solvable in an organisation that actually cares, although I disagree that it is easy. Banks (which probably care more about securing money than the military does about securing classified information) do in fact do all these things. And even they run into the problem that any system that requires busy executives to do their own admin will be circumvented. The US army (and, frankly, every peacetime army) is the type of organisation where every colonel has given his keys to the janitor at some point. Quora is absolutely full of "war stories" of the type "I, as a lowly PFC ordered to guard the outer door of a SCIF had to point my rifle at a colonel who was mishandling classified information, and the following morning the brigadier congratulated me." Colonels wouldn't do that if the more normal response was for the PFC to let them.

As a long-term Liberal Democrat and statistics geek, I resent this aggressive moderation of a factually accurate. After three or more pints of Real Ale (20 oz pints - we're British) the finer points of the Single Transferable Vote and Site Value Rating are quite exquisitely interesting to sad and overly political nerds such as myself.

Perhaps there could be a "This user has been convicted for committing securities fraud on Twitter" tag. Or even a "This Twitter user has declared under oath that reasonable people do not treat his tweets as factually accurate" tag.

Part of what makes a University a University and not something else is a degree of self-government. An institution that teaches a 13-16th grade curriculum determined by the politicians and/or bureaucrats in the sponsoring Education Ministry may be doing something valuable, but it isn't continuing the tradition that began with those communities of scholars in Paris, Bologna, Oxford and Cambridge in the High Middle Ages.

FWIW, I don't think that the legislature abolishing tenure (something that happened long ago in the UK without causing serious problems) or regulating non-classroom DEI initiatives gets close to the point where it turns a public University into a Even Higher School. But (for example) a law prohibiting the teaching of books by paedophiles would be pushing the boundary.

SB16 seems different, in that if it is enforced as written, it prevents the University teaching that correct social, political or religious beliefs are superior to incorrect ones. An organisation where the curriculum is subject to government sanitisation to remove controversial topics is not a University.