@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

This sounds like an analogous problem to the way my wife and I chose a London neighborhood to buy a house and settle down in. (Any given Midwestern state has a population of the same order of magnitude as Greater London). Key points:

  • Know what you want - for us it was a manageable commute to Central London, houses with gardens affordable on a UMC salary, and proximity to woodlands for walking.

  • Know what you don't want that other people are willing to pay a premium for, and avoid it. I grew up using London commuter trains, so I wasn't willing to pay a premium to live on the Underground network. Given that other people are willing to pay a large premium for this, we could rule out any neighbourhood with a tube station as poor value for money. Obviously relevant examples are good schools if you are not planning to have kids (or are planning to homeschool), walkability if you are happy living in American auto-orientated suburbia, a lack of rush hour traffic if you work remotely.

  • Make a shortlist of suitable towns based on your criteria. You are doing internet research at this point unless you can ask someone who lives in the general area. Relying on stereotypes is fine - most stereotypes are mostly accurate.

  • Visit the places on the shortlist, walk around a lot, try to understand who lives there (Are they like you? Mostly like you with less money is also okay. Mostly like you with more money is dangerous unless you are early-career and expecting large payrises), do the things that matter to you (hiking in the woods for us).

  • If you experience a "problem with no name" in most or all of your target areas, then one of your criteria is wrong and you need to go back to step 1. After looking at some outer-suburban neighborhoods in SE London we realised that we cared about neighborhood walkability more than having a large garden, and went back to more inner-suburban neighborhoods with smaller gardens. (We now live in Greenwich, and love it. The small garden is quite large enough for the kids and we do indeed have a wooded park which the kids will be able to walk to on their own by the time they outgrow the garden).

I don't know enough about the Brazilian situation to confirm if it is the same, but calling his supporters out for a riot was Trump's plan D after his plans to overturn the election before January 6th failed.

  • Plan A was the plan announced at Four Seasons Total Landscaping focused on changing the results in the swing states by state-level political action including trying to get lawsuits in front of sympathetic state-court judges, jawboning Republican secretaries of state, and lobbying Republican-controlled state legislatures to intervene in the certification process. I don't know how surprising it should have been that Republican state-court judges and Republican secretaries of state were completely uncooperative with the plan, but they were.

  • Plan B was a more conventional military autogolpe - the plan proposed by Gen Flynn to declare the Dominion hack/fraud a foreign attack on US democracy and rerun the election with hand-counting under military supervision. Assuming the Jan 6 committee report is accurate, this plan was being taken seriously until it became clear that there was no way the military would co-operate.

  • Plan C was the plan to get Pence to overturn the election based on the legal theories in the Eastman memo. I don't know what the plan was to consolidate power after Pence announces Trump's re-election and Nancy Pelosi orders the House Sergeant-at-Arms to arrest him for couping. Pence refused to co-operate.

  • Plan D was to use the mob to carry out Plan C over Pence's objections, either by intimidating him or by causing enough chaos that the Secret Service removed him to an undisclosed location and someone else (probably President pro tem Chuck Grassley) could be convinced to do it.

This is consistent with my theory (which appears to be shared by most Mottizens) of how American conservatives feel about the use of power. Plan A is to do things legally, plan B is organised violence, and plan C (probably) and D (definitely) are disorganised violence. At any point before January 6th, getting his supporters to riot makes plans A-C harder.

A very long shot but any idea if in any western european country it's practical to go to a gun range as a tourist, particularly as one with no prior experience?

The UK has a massive shotgun culture which you probably wouldn't expect given foreign media coverage, and any range will offer clay pigeon shooting taster sessions. For rifles, Bisley (near Woking, about an hour's drive SW of London) has multiple ranges and a good reputation. Recreational handgun shooting is banned in the UK.

History class was life-changing for me, so I feel duty bound to defend it. Why? Because it is where I learned to write. And in my school, it was the only subject apart from English where I could have learned to write. This Paul Graham essay is basically an attack on the idea of teaching writing entirely by getting kids to write about English literature, and I agree with it.

Why is history a good class to teach analytical/argumentative writing in. Firstly, because it isn't bullshit (in the Harry Frankfurt sense). There have been times and places where the history curriculum was full of lies, but it is only full of bullshit in late-stage totalitarian regimes. Literary criticism, on the other hand... This means that the teacher can insist on a distinction between valid and invalid arguments, and between good and bad use of evidence. Secondly, history is traditionally an "essay subject" so the teachers have the skills required to teach writing, which (say) geography teachers generally don't. Thirdly, the skills you need to "do history" at a high school level - i.e. assessment of documentary sources and developing a functional understanding of a complex sequence of events - can be tested through essay-writing (a pop quiz on dates and facts is a useful formative assessment, but the final summative assessment is all essays), whereas even if they include essay questions a geography exam is mostly mapwork and a physics exam (at least at high school level) is mostly demonstrating understanding by working out the correct formula to apply to a problem and plugging numbers into it.

You can learn to write in school, and it is a transferrable skill. In fact, it is one of the few transferrable skills you can teach (to the minority of kids who are able and willing to learn) in school at all. For me, it was history class where I did - and I strongly suspect that I am not the only one.

I can’t speak for German schoolbooks, but the Weimar Republic and Hitler’s rise to power is an optional topic in the British GCSE history syllabus. The 1918-1921 period is taught from an “Ebert good” perspective and is fairly both-sidesist about the Kapp and Spartakist putsches. There isn’t enough time to cover the Weimar era political parties in any detail, so the only thing that comes up about the KPD is that they wouldn’t support an anti-NSDAP coalition government when it would have made a difference.

Based on the reading around the course I did, this is consistent with the consensus of English-language historians who are not writing explicitly pro-communist history.

Are they Google numbers or Alphabet numbers? DeepMind would drag the London average for Alphabet up quite a bit.

so in my mind taking some time to build an actual coalition around an agreeable leader is a very worthwhile endeavor that doesn't reflect poorly on the GOP in and of itself.

True, but they have had two months to do that since the elections, and given the lack of progress to date, including no progress whatsoever during 24 hours of focussed attention on the issue and 6 roll-call votes, it isn't clear how taking more time is going to help.

Maybe this also serves as a sort of an illustration why, in other countries, the center-right often prefers formally cooperating with the center-left to the far-right, even if the center-right and far-right might agree on many topics. This sort of a "we're not giving a shit about how this process is supposed to work, we hate the process and we hate you!" -behavior is very typical of right-wing populist parties all over Europe, both nationally, locally and within the EU; simple agreement on a number of issues won't cover for the fact that it just makes those parties a highly unreliable partner, moreso than the theoretically opposed center-left parties which still understand the rules of the game and generally agree to play by them.

I agree. It sounds like self-justification on the part of the swamp, but legislatures really do only work if they are dominated by the kind of person who thinks that being in power is more fun than being right and noisy about it.

Well this happened. I see trillions of spending that AOC supported and Republicans opposed there, much of which benefitted her constituents. None of it would have happened with a non-functioning Congress or a Republican speaker. I can also hear the wailing and gnashing of teeth by conservatives who don't like it, and even by Republican squishes like McCarthy. (I also think that the success of the Squad in Democratic primaries and in media noisemaking after their elections has contributed to a vibe shift among Democrats which pushed Biden and Pelosi leftwards in a way that isn't as immediately obvious as a big fight over the Speakership).

If you mean "What goals did AOC obtain that Pelosi opposed then you are asking the wrong question. People don't, or at least shouldn't, go into politics to count coup against their own parties. They shouldn't, but often do, go into politics to induce wailing and gnashing of teeth on the other side of the aisle. They do and should go into politics to pass bills they support and that benefit their constituents.

AOC couldn't beat Pelosi because she didn't have the votes. So she took what she could get, which worked out at more money than you could shake a stick at plus the stick. The same applies to Gaetz vs McCarthy. If he wants more power he should win more votes.

In 2021, AOC and the squad voted for Nancy Pelosi for speaker, despite noisily disagreeing with her, and went on to enjoy the privileges of being part of a functioning majority. Compared to a non-functioning Congress or a Republican speaker, this helped accomplish their stated goals (notably by passing several huge spending bills).

If Gaetz and the Freedom Caucus vote for McCarthy they will help accomplish their stated goals (based on Gaetz's speech nominating Jordan, these seem to be passing the bills that need passing, standing firm against the Senate and White House on the budget, and investigating Deep State corruption) compared to a non-functioning Congress or a Democratic speaker - because these are goals which require being in the majority. Based on this Reason article the main substantive demands include bringing a non-serious agenda (a balanced budget, a large tax cut, a large spending increase on border security, and an unconstitutional term limits law) up for a vote. This obviously doesn't advance Gaetz's stated goals, because it doesn't do anything at all except make noise and waste floor time. I can't work out what the procedural demands the Freedom Caucus are making which McCarthy hasn't conceded (he has conceded on the Motion to Vacate issue, agreeing that any five Congressmen should be able to force a vote to remove him).

If the Freedom Caucus want to get more of their agenda through, they need more power, which means more seats. If a group of 20 reps can overrule 188 reps by threatening to throw their toys out of the pram, then this works for everyone - and the RINOest 20 reps have a stronger negotiating position than the Freedom Caucus, because they can cut a deal with the Dems.

Of course, it is possible that the Freedom Caucus are not seeking to advance their stated goals. Some people just want to watch the world burn, and it isn't that surprising if 20 of them got elected to Congress. There is also the ever-present possibility that politicians are grandstanding rather than trying to advance policy goals. (Never!) But if this is grandstanding, it is an unusually dysfunctional kind - AOC and other anti-establishment Congressmen managed to grandstand without gumming up the election of a Speaker.

I think people in this thread are underestimating how dysfunctional this is. A party caucus in a legislature isn't just a talking shop for mutually sympathetic legislators - it is an agreement to accept party discipline in order to gain the benefits of power. The whole point of a caucus being in the majority is that the caucus votes internally on issues like who to support for the speakership, and then they all vote the same way. If you can't get the caucus to vote together, then you have a majority in name only. Despite the classic meme status of "I belong to no organised political party - I am a Democrat", the Democrats never managed to f*** this up in this way, even when their party was split between Northern leftists and Dixiecrats.

The incoming House republican caucus held its internal vote after the elections in November, and voted 188-31 (by secret ballot, which is the norm for internal party votes) in favour of McCarthy. The whole point of being a caucus is that all 222 Republicans are now supposed to vote for the duly selected Republican candidate (i.e. McCarthy) in the public vote. The rebels (who do not include Jim Jordan himself - he voted for McCarthy like he is supposed to, and indeed nominated McCarthy on the second public ballot) are the real RINOs here - they are not accepting the basic responsibilities of caucus membership. If the Republicans can't agree on a Speaker, then in a very real sense they are not the majority.

This is why we are not seeing a move to choose a compromise candidate (according to gossip on various right-wing websites, Steve Scalise is acceptable to both factions). McCarthy thinks he is entitled to the speakership because he won the Republican caucus vote and the Republicans are in the majority. And if the Republicans were an organised political party rather than a clown show he would be right. And the 188 Republican congressmen who voted for him think they are entitled to the benefits of being in the majority, and the 31 dissidents should vote with the party if they want to share in those benefits. And if the Republicans were an organised political party, they would be right.

If the Republican rebels don't climb down after making their point for the cameras and the majority Republicans negotiate, then there are not two organised parties in the House with the Republicans in the majority. There are three parties (Democrats, Republicans, and MAGAtards) with nobody in the majority. And Scalise wouldn't be a Speaker leading a majority party, he would be a Speaker leading a coalition.

Amusingly, Bud Fox impressing Gordon Gecko by guessing which of multiple possible deals is more likely to happen by tracking executive jets is the turning point of the original Wall Street movie.

This paper (I have seen the same theory in other places, but don't know how many independent sources it has) suggests that Northern European houseproud culture is a lingering effect of home-produced dairy products being sold outside the home in the Early Modern Age - dairying required the highest hygiene standards of any farm activity.

The obvious test is whether olive oil people and their descendants are less houseproud than butter people and their descendants. I wouldn't know how to test this given the obvious issues with the accuracy of intra-European racial stereotypes. This theory is of course perfectly consistent with the idea that Medieval peasants lived in filth - it predicts that Northern Europeans didn't become houseproud until semi-commercial dairying became a thing.

In the UK, class actions are extremely limited. So a "test case" normally refers to a typical case chosen by mutual agreement between the two "sides" of what would be a class action in the US system. This is a different type of situation to a unusually sympathetic test case chosen by the plaintiffs side.

As a separate issue, in all common-law systems, cases decided below a certain level do not create precedent. So a test case can also be one chosen by either or both of the parties post-judgement (to appeal and set a precedent, where the value of the individual case is too low to justify the cost of an appeal if it wasn't a test case), or by the Court (to hear at a higher level than the value of the individual case justifies because of the precedent-setting aspect).

Given most civil cases settle, precedents are in some sense the core output of the trial process.

A lot of them left to Hong Kong immediately after the bankruptcy announcement.

Anyone who has the ability to harm Elon Musk based on flight data (i.e. the ability to stake out an airport) has the ability to get the publically available flight data from the original source. Signal-boosting this information posts no threat to anyone's personal safety whatsoever.

This being done without Elon's direction or consent is highly improbable.

And even if it wasn't, the consensus in the non-MSM Twitter files discussion appears to be that Jack Dorsey was still culpable for moderation decisions that should have been escalated to him but weren't.

Signal-boosting existing publically available information was never an edge case re. free speech. It is an edge case viz-a-viz internet etiquette, where signal-boosting contact information will often lead to someone getting unpleasant e-mails from ikilluufaggot @momsbasement.4chan.com and suchlike. But the reasons for that rule don't apply to public figures at Musk's level who have staff to handle incoming communications on publically-available channels. In any case, Elon Musk's stated position going in was that moderation wouldn't be used to enforce rules of etiquette like "don't be a shit-tier racist troll"

You can argue that the FAA shouldn't publish the movements of private aeroplanes (although even then the location of a large object with a registration number painted on it is still publically available - it just takes some shoe-leather journalism to get to). But Musk hasn't even tried to do that.

Seriously every single piece of evidence we have says that 1100-1900 a single digit percentage of women were employed in prostitution and maybe a very low double digit percentage had engaged in it at some point in their lives. (And yes how people manage to feed themselves and keep themselves alive absolutely seems like the kind of matter of material necessity than can be extrapolated backwards)

A single digit percentage of the total population or a single digit percentage of the urban population? Big difference in a 80+% rural society.

Great post - it is far too easy for us moderns to underestimate the cost and importance of textiles pre-Industrial revolution. Textile production (fibre preparation, spinning, weaving, and sewing, but mostly spinning) was the main work of pre-modern women and was far more labour-intensive than what we now see as housewifery. I first learnt about this from Lisa Jardine's Worldly Goods which spends about half the book talking about how increased Mediterranean trade during the Renaissance gave the urban middle class access to dyes (including the most brilliant colours, and also the fast colours which could survive washing) which had previously only been affordable to the aristocracy - thinking about this in the context of your article makes me wonder if kings and lords losing the uniqueness of their vivid colours could cause social change all by itself.

One quibble - you say that a peasant girl might get a new outfit every several years. I don't know if that was intended as a creative exaggeration, but Brett Devereaux (a Roman historian in his day job, but primarily famous for blogging about the historical accuracy of Paradox games) says in this series of posts that a single full-time semi-skilled textile worker could produce 5-6 outfits a year with Roman technology (spinning wheels, which reach Europe around 1300, double this) with most of the work being spinning, which is easy to multitask with childcare or basic animal husbandry. So one outfit a year per family member was a perfectly attainable goal for an ordinary peasant family (unless they were poor enough that they needed to sell the spun yarn to commercial weavers for additional food, or oppressed enough that they needed to sell it to pay taxes), and a family with an unmarried teenage daughter would be doing better than that - if she did ruin her first date dress she would be able to make another one.

[Raw wool/flax and basic vegetable dyes were cheap - unless you were after Worldly Goods level colour the cost of clothes was dominated by the labour involved in the production process]

Most Silly Valley blowups are not banks. FTX was, in reality, a bank (although it fraudulently claimed not to be, by saying that customer deposits were fully backed by cash and crypto reserves in specie). Bank blowups cause a lot of innocent third parties to lose money - FTX/Alameda didn't just lose all of Sequoia and Softbank's money - it also lost $8 billion of customer money.

In the sane world, we don't let people run a bank the way they run a Silly Valley juice startup.

It is if the marginal campaign dollar is going on paid media (which, in America, it probably is)

If "rough neighborhood" means a rough part of a generally functioning city, then the unanimous view of people-who-are-not-Americans is that cleaning it up is a job for the police, not for armed gentrifiers. If the neighborhood is so bad that even the police won't go there then

  1. You are probably in Sweden and your problem is immigration policy (and housing policy as well, as far as I can see), not self defense law

  2. Sane people are not going to move into the neighborhood because "It is okay if I get mugged, the law lets me defend myself."

Ok so Exxon tells the other firm their spending $100 million defending the case. Now it’s a bet the company case for the smaller but well capitalized firm.

And the judge tells them to knock it off. I am starting to wonder if the real problem is that US civil cases are mostly heard in State courts where the judge is an answer to the joke "What do you call a lawyer with a room temperature IQ? - Your Honor"

With a few exceptions (like the Delaware Court of Chancery), the US is egregiously unable to make sure important civil cases end up in front of judges who know what they are doing. As far as I can see, there are a few things going on that drive this - the thing that is most unusual internationally is elected judges, but I suspect that a bigger deal is the American tradition of handling all first instance cases in the County they are filed in - most states have no equivalent to the English High Court or the Superior Courts in the Canadian provinces as a dedicated first instance court for important civil cases.

Jefferson was sufficiently lacking in the rural virtues that he preached that he died bankrupt and his children (by Sally Hemmings, who he had intended to free) were sold by auction.