@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

Every city in history would be best served by a rural dictatorship running it.

Singapore and Hong Kong are merely the most obvious exceptions. More seriously, one of the things that makes early modern Western Europe generally, and Northern Italy (which was the richest bit of Europe at the relevant time, hence the Renaissance) in particular globally unusual is the degree to which cities were not run by monarchies with a largely rural power-base. Max Weber wrote the book about this - it certainly looks like a pre-condition for the transition to capitalism.

During America's rise to power, New York was run tolerably well by Tammany Hall and the only reason why the rural areas were run better was because they were de facto run by railroad barons who took their orders (and their capital) from J P Morgan Sr in New York. Functional big-city municipal government remains the norm in the 1st world outside the United States.

Ray Dalio's Principles is a good example of an actual "Bible" of a cult-of-the-founder.

Stage one is people who are out and proud about their partisan identity showing off their ballot receipts.

Stage two is this becoming a social norm in environments where "everyone" votes the same way, such that not showing your receipt with a correct vote is defecting (cf pronouns in wokestupid spaces or prayers in secular-but-tribally-Christian ones).

Stage three is defectors suffering professional consequences such that there is no longer a meaningfully free vote.

I think this could happen within 2 years given the current level of partisan bitterness in America.

But isn't that a good thing, from the side of the pro-choice?

No. Although it is impossible to say this in Blue spaces because of wokestupid purity spirals, pro-choice normies want abortion to be safe, legal and rare. Herschel Walker's behaviour made it significantly less rare.

There are also a lot of people, not all of whom are religious conservatives, who think that having unprotected sex outside committed relationships is inherently discreditable, quite apart from whether or not an abortion happens as a result.

Some of the specific claims Trump - in particular the Dominion voting machine conspiracy theory - almost certainly qualify as delusional, and the main reason why they might not is that Trump could have known they were false all along, making them dishonest rather than delusional. IIRC Trump made various claims to have won a landslide, which would also count as delusional - the plausible Trump win scenarios were squeakers.

The "bog standard mainstream GOP" claim that the normal run of petty incompetence that we see in American elections represents co-ordinated fraud by Democrats on a large enough scale to flip multiple states with 5-figure leads (which is what would have been needed to steal the 2020 presidential election) is clearly false and clearly sincerely held by significant numbers of sane people, so whether or not it is "delusional" is a boring argument about the meaning of words.

In an actual maths class targetted at maths majors, you won't need to take that attitude into the class because a good prof will teach it. "Maths for physics and engineers" is "Here are handles you will need to turn to solve the problems you are going to need to solve. I will tell you how the handles work in case you are interested, but it won't come up on the exam and if understanding it is too much effort the prof next door is teaching the same material without the explanations." If you ask too many questions and try to understand the answers you won't have the headspace for the physics and engineering you actually care about. "Maths for future world leaders" is a gut course where everyone wants to get the A with the minimum effort and the prof is in on the scam. Asking questions makes getting the easy A harder for everyone. "Maths for premeds" is presumably somewhere in between, but medicine is an extended undergraduate degree in the UK system so I have no experience of premeds.

Premise 3 is wrong.

From the perspective of woke morality, the reason why it isn't okay to discriminate on race is not that race is an unchosen characteristic which doesn't track desert. If "don't discriminate on unchosen characteristics which don't track desert" was the rule then discriminating against adults based on religion would be fine (because American society is set up so that religion is a choice), and discriminating based on looks or intelligence would be wrong. The actual rule is "don't discriminate based on attributes which track historical patterns of social oppression in ways that reinforce the oppression", or in plainer English but woke-unsympathetic language that you shouldn't use in a college essay, "don't discriminate against members of a protected group".

The problem is that this doesn't get you out of mandatory bisexuality because women and gay men are protected groups. So a straight woman who refuses to date other women is expressing internalised misogyny (and possibly lesbophobia as well), and a straight man who refuses to date other men is expressing homophobia. (When I spent more time in woke spaces, exactly this argument was made to me by a predatory arsebandit who was sexually harassing me).

So the cleaned up argument is:

Premise 1: It is wrong to discriminate in a way which reinforces historical patterns of social oppression

Premise 2: Refusing to date members of historically oppressed groups is discriminating against them in an oppression-reinforcing way

Premise 3: Women and gay men are historically oppressed groups.

Conclusion: It is wrong for a woman to refuse to date other women, or for a man to refuse to date gay men, therefore bisexuality is mandatory.

There are then two attacks you can make within the rules of woke morality, both of which are fundamentally attacks on premise 1.

The first is that sexual autonomy overrides antidiscrimination norms. To use the language of John Rawls' Theory of Justice, sexual autonomy is a basic liberty and the principle that basic liberties should be respected takes lexical priority over the principle that society should be organised to best meet the needs of its least privileged members. Read the Cliffs Notes on ToJ before making this argument in an essay.

The second is that society recognises a number of exceptions to the rule of "don't discriminate on sex" which it does not for "don't discriminate on race". The reason for this is that men and women are actually different that don't reflect desert, but do matter. So (temporarily ignoring arguments about transgenderism) essentially everyone is in favour of allowing sex-based casting of actors, sex-segregated toilets and changing rooms, and a same-sex requirement for certain types of care work. For dating, being of the appropriate sex is whatever you call the non-occupational equivalent of "bona fide occupational qualification".

There is a third argument which should be safe to make even if it is subtly non-woke, which is that heterosexual people are dating with multiple purposes, but typically "find a life partner I can have children with" is one of the main ones, and in a world where 3 cycles of IVF costs a year's average salary and isn't a guarantee of success, a same sex partner simply can't do one of the core parts of the "job". In the trans context, the standard rejoinder from wokists is that we don't insist of medical verification of fertility early in a relationship, and screening out partners who are effectively infertile due to having the wrong sexed anatomy earlier than we screen out partners who are infertile for medical reasons is discriminatory. But this is obviously silly.

You can of course make a non-woke argument that premise 1 is wrong and it is okay to discriminate in personal contexts (friends, dating partners, roommates etc.)in ways it wouldn't be in a commercial or government context. I wouldn't try that in a college essay for a woke-stupid professor.

You will also have classes in subjects which don't touch directly on the culture war where your professors will be both experts and trustworthy within the subject matter of the course. Don't take the attitude of scepticism which JTarrou (and I) are recommeding into a maths or biochemistry class.

It does not mean they will allow an Eastern European country to be against gay marriage.

It looks to me as though most Eastern European countries are in fact against gay marriage. The EU has no problem with this as long as allow gay-married EU citizens to move freely through the EU. The European Court of Human Rights (which is not an EU body) has said that countries which grant rights to unmarried cohabiting straight couples (either automatically or through some kind of registered civil partnership) should extend them to unmarried cohabiting gay couples, but has explicitly not required gay marriage.

The EU is not run by American lefties.

I think the stock market has priced in results close to Nate Silver's final predictions (likely GOP house win, toss-up Senate). I think a surprise Dem hold of the house is positive for markets because it avoids tail risks associated with a government shutdown and/or debt ceiling crisis. Given a GOP house, Senate control doesn't matter that much to the things markets care about - legislation is gridlocked anyway because Biden has a veto, the Deep State can run the executive branch even if people can't get confirmed, and there are no Fed Governors with terms expiring during the next Congress. So I predict no obvious market response as long as the GOP do take the house.

Is Jeffery Epstein just out of shot in that photo?

instead of trying to plan the size of the money supply.

The money supply isn't set by God - someone is choosing it. If you use a gold standard, that is likely to be foreign gold speculators - or in the most famous case of an inappropriate monetary contraction with megadeath consequences, a foreign central bank.

Seriously, the reason why monetary policy is hard is that the use of money as store of value and money as medium of exchange conflict - money which is hoarded is not circulating. Stablish prices and fullish employment require a stablish supply of circulating money, but the demand for hoarded money can vary rapidly due to speculation. So you either need sufficiently and predictably high inflation that the demand for hoarded money is consistently negligible relative to the demand for circulating money, or you need to vary the supply of money to match hoarder demand.

The classical gold standard that actually existed, as opposed to the one which modern goldbugs think should have existed, depended on the ability of the big fractionally reserved central banks (the Bank of England, the Banque de France, the Reichsbank before WW1, the Federal Reserve Banks after WW1) to print money - particularly to carry out their lender-of-last-resort function. The NBER paper I link to makes the argument that when the Banque de France tried to move closer to a full-reserve gold standard without deflating the French economy (in effect by redeeming GBP and USD for gold and hoarding the gold), it crashed the system causing the great depression.

The Liz Truss case is not particularly unusual for third-world countries - it is just that the post-Brexit UK is the only first-world country to be stupid enough to elect a government that is stupid enough to do what Truss did.

There are a number of relevant differences between the UK and US that mean the punishment for Truss' mini-budget was much faster than it would be for a similarly stupid US government:

  1. The US dollar is the global reserve currency, so it is less likely that a Liz Truss level of stupid would tank the dollar the way the actual Liz Truss tanked the pound.

  2. The US is a less open economy than the UK (mostly because big countries are more self-sufficient than small ones, not for any policy reason) so the impact of a falling dollar on Americans' cost of living is less than the impact of a falling pound on Brit's cost of living.

  3. British mortgages are much less likely to be long-term fixed rates, so the increase in interest rates has a much more immediate impact on household budgets than it would in the US.

Ballot access is a fake problem - most US states make it unnecessarily difficult because the rules are made by partisan-elected Secretaries of State and State legislatures, who all come from the two pre-existing big parties. But other countries have much easier ballot access for non-Presidential elections and it doesn't cause problems.

For example, in the UK, you need 10 signatures and £500 to stand as a candidate in Westminster elections, so you could run a full slate of candidates for about £350,000 (compared to a minimum budget of about £5 million to run a nationwide campaign). In Ireland you need 300 members (only 150 of whom need to be registered voters) to register a political party to stand in Dail elections, which then gives you automatic nationwide ballot access.

Several British MP's who wrote memoirs said that party whips blackmailing MP's not to vote against the leadership was common. This page is a rare on-the-record discussion of what was in whips' black books of kompromat on their own MPs.

I am not aware of any British MP publically saying "this named whip blackmailed me on this vote".

I am not a fluent AmE speaker, but my understanding is that "douchebag" refers to a generally obnoxious person with a side order of toxic masculinity, whereas "wanker" refers to a generally obnoxious person with a side order of pretentious self-centredness. I would say that Elon Musk is a wanker but not a douchebag, and that Donald Trump is a douchebag but not much of a wanker.

The Australian English words "rort" and "wowser" have no simple direct translation into British or American English and are sufficiently useful that I have started using them. I have heard American English speakers reacting the same way to the British English word "wanker".

Can we think of other words which one national variety of English has and others need?

The American Constitution being the living embodiment and quintessential rejection of such power

The mere presence of the notwithstanding clause means that Charter was always a piece of paper

Both the US Bill of Rights and the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms are literally just pieces of paper. The fact that they say different things determines who can take away the rights they purport to protect, but in the real world you have exactly those rights which the people in charge of the people with the big guns say you have.

The thesis of the US Constitutional tradition is that God granted Americans certain rights, but since He isn't around to clarify what they actually mean, there is a priesthood (i.e. a group of wowzers who are educated at seminaries like Harvard and wear robes to the office) to do it. Regardless of the Constitutional text, the Supreme Court can take your rights away, or give you ones you don't want (like the Lochner right for bakers to work dangerously long hours). Because rights are granted by God, amending the Constitution to restrict them is seen as mildly sacrilegious - there are surprisingly few attempts to amend the Constitution to reverse bad nominally rights-protecting SCOTUS decisions. Instead, political factions mobilise to pack the Court.

The thesis of the Canadian Charter is that the Queen and People, through the Constitutional amendment process, grant rights (as a collectivity) to themselves (as individuals) and therefore retain the power to revoke them, providing they do so with specific intent (by amending the Constitution or using the notwithstanding clause).

I think we can all agree that there have been egregious cases where SCOTUS failed to enforce Constitutional rights (depending on our political views, we may disagree on some cases, but I think everyone agrees that Jim Crow should have been prohibited by the Reconstruction Amendments). The normal reason is partisan entrenchment through the judicial appointments process - SCOTUS justices have been partisan figures appointed to change the meaning of the Constitution in a partisan way ever since the Constitution was ratified. There have also been egregious misuses of the notwithstanding clause (particularly discriminatory language laws in Quebec - and again the main driver was province-level partisan politics). The question of whether Divine Right of Judges or Do Not Push this "I Win" Button is the marginally less problematic procedural safeguard is an empirical one.

And of course even when these safeguards work, the fact that they work is a political convention and not a law of nature. The executive simply ignoring adverse legal rulings and still being obeyed by the troops is a thing ("Justice Marshall has made his decision; Now let him enforce it!"). So are out-and-out military coups.

The only thing that can actually protect fundamental rights is a political culture that takes them seriously and armed forces (including police) which are embedded in that culture. The reason why the right to keep and bear arms is protected in America but not elsewhere is not because the Second Amendment exists (RKBA is included in the English Bill of Rights as well, but we notoriously don't enjoy the right) but because a large, organised group of voters is committed to defending it. When there wasn't a large, organised group of voters committed to defending the RKBA, people didn't actually enjoy it.

At the moment, we don't have such a political culture in the Anglosphere, on either side of the political fence. (Even if you ignore rights whose very existence is a matter of partisan controversy like RKBA). The dominant left-wing faction is the wokists. Wokists believe that ending identity group based discrimination is sufficiently urgent to override everything else, and that appeals to fundamental rights are mostly bad-faith attempts by bigots to protect their right to discriminate. The dominant right-wing faction is Trump/Johnson/Ford-style populism. Right-populists believe that overthrowing a corrupt elite is sufficiently urgent to override everything else, and that appeals to fundamental rights are mostly bad-faith attempts by elites to frustrate the will of the people.

I don't like this, but it Is, and rationality requires me to distinguish between what Is and what Should be. For this reason, and no other*, I am in favour of safety valves like the notwithstanding clause. If Doug Ford abuses the notwithstanding clause, and pays no political price for it, then the people of Ontario will have lost their rights due to laziness. Pretending that this can't happen is dishonest.

* There are also federalism-based reasons for the notwithstanding clause, which I don't understand because I am not familiar with the history of federalism in Canada.

Or maybe they just don't want to advertise the fact the main use case for their product is something that is considered kiddieporn in their home country?

More interesting/concerning to me is the implication that Morgan Stanley, BofA, etc. may have some ability to influence these decisions. Are there similar cases in the past of those banks being part of large deals (by financing the individual/corporation making the purchase), and then exerting meaningful control?

Based on my limited professional experience as a risk manager covering lending to private equity deals, I would say that lenders have no meaningful input into management decisions at PE-owned companies as long as they are not in financial trouble. The loans will have covenants (something like "Twitter needs to maintain free cash flow three times the interest on the senior debt and a book debt-to-assets ration of less than 75%") with a provision to call the loans (which would require Musk to put in further billions of his own money to replace them with equity or put Twitter into Chapter 11 with the likely result of the banks ending up as the main equity holders) if they are breached. What usually happens if a PE-owned company breaches covenants is that the lenders (who don't want to become owners) use this right as leverage to take a closer look at the business and decide if they think it is salvagable. Given Musk's negotiating power viz-a-viz the banks, I assume the covenants on this deal will not be binding unless Twitter gets into very serious trouble.

The other equity contributors have whatever rights they negotiated (default is that Musk gets what he wants as majority owner). Non-selling existing shareholders like the Saudis have a weak negotiating position so they almost certainly have no control rights at all.

Musk + Trump's fans want Trump unbanned as the ultimate 'own' on the left. I think Musk stands to lose more fans by not unbanning Trump than he stands to lose by Trump not using twitter if unbanned.

Musk's fanbase isn't own-the-libs tribal conservatives. It is (roughly) grey tribe technophiles who find wokists and San Francisco NIMBYs annoying. What fraction of American Tesla owners do you think vote Republican? Far more importantly, Musk is sufficiently publicly identified with all his companies that he needs to run Twitter in a way which is congenial to the various governments Tesla needs favours from.

Hajnal put all of Scotland inside the line. I have seen arguments that the Scottish Highlands were actually transHajnal, but my understanding was that the Borderers (from whom most of the Scots Irish are descended) were clearly inside it.

The traditional Irish culture is also transHajnal, but the Scots Irish put a LOT of effort into not assimilating into it.

I am trying to promote the terms "cisHajnal" and "transHajnal".

I find a more common problem is going through steps A) to C) above, and then more like:

D) Realising that they are not happy with the thing they thought they wanted

E) Moving on to the next thing they think they want, rinsing and repeating

F) Wondering why they are tired, broke, and don't have any rewarding experiences to show for it.

I can't speak for America, but in the UK the canonical example of family-friendly cross-dressing is panto. The ground rules of panto include that the hero is played by an attractive young woman in skin-tight trousers (usually leather) and the "dame" (the principal comic relief character - this is very definitely clowning) is played by a man in a dress with footballs sewn into the bodice. Panto is explicitly considered child-friendly.

The culture of people who self define as "Drag Queens" is very different, and it appears to be a part of broader LGBT culture.

Dame Edna Everage is closer to "housewife drag" but is clearly drawing on the tradition of pantomime dames.