@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

Your nose has filters to remove (some of) the particulate matter in incoming air before it gets to your lungs. This is then ejected in snot - if you spend enough time in a polluted environment your snot will be black.

Surely the whole point is that the messaging which appeals to a normie Republican with moderate pro-choice views is very different from the messaging which appealed to Sandra Day O'Connor in a legal brief, or which NARAL uses to pull in the donations from blue-haired feminists. The surprising thing is that the Democrats seem to be getting it right this time, after a long history of getting this sort of thing badly wrong.

Get Big Government out of my wife and daughters!

Do you think it is possible to win a Republican primary in a red state while supporting elective first-trimester abortions? I don't. That is why Dobbs is a political opportunity for the Democrats (as well as, obviously, a policy opportunity for pro-life Republicans). The pro-life right used to be able to define their big tent as "anyone who thinks Roe and Casey go too far - which as you point out includes the median voter in most developed democracies. But once they have to start governing, that ceases to be fudgeable. The gap between the median Republican primary voter (who is to the right of the median Republican because of differential turnout) and the median voter is not bridgeable, and either the Republicans will need to find a way of throwing their base under the bus without being primaried, or to take the heat from supporting an unpopular policy. (Allowing state-level referenda like the one that confirmed the legality of abortion in Kansas is probably the easiest way to do this).

The evidence from the rest of the world is that abortion is important enough that the median voter will get what they want in the end. I suspect that means elective first-trimester abortions in all but the reddest of red states. Their is also a (in my view slim) possibility that gerrymandered state legislatures will be able to enforce the preferences of the median Republican primary voter while telling the median voter to pound sand, but if that happens then those states are not democracies.

It is worth noting that under anarcho-capitalism, you can't own except to the extent that you can defend it. Much like feudalism really - in fact feudalism evolves from the anarcho-capitalism that existed briefly after the fall of Rome as the competing protection agencies (Knights, a word which derived from the old Saxon word for bandits) established local monopolies (Lords), set up the hierarchical system of arbitration between neighbouring protection agencies that David Friedman advocates (Kings), and cut a deal with the local influencers to propagandise for maintaining the system (the Church).

Under feudalism, the effective tax rate on non-warriors who wish to occupy land was also close to 100%.

My guess is the majority of people who self-define as Georgists favour a land tax close to 100% (80% of the rent attributable to land and normal income tax rates on the part of the rent attributable to improvements is what I would favour in dath ilan, but in the real world I am not a full-on Georgist and favour incremental moves towards higher land taxes and lower other taxes).

If you accept the basic libertarian arguments that unavoidable taxes are confiscatory, and that non-sovereigns can "own" land the same way they own chattels, then full-on Georgism is indeed a confiscation of land (but not improvements), and a Georgist-inspired shift towards higher land taxes and lower income taxes is a partial confiscation of land. In fact, of course, you only ever "owned" the land at the pleasure of the State* and Georgism is a change in the terms under which the State allows you to continue "owning" it. Land taxes no more violate the property rights of landowners than Uber violates the property rights of taxi medallion owners.

  • At this point I am only making this as a factual argument, although I think it is more right than wrong as a moral argument.

would you rather be a slave or a serf?

And of course being a employee who rents on a month-to-month basis is even better. If you assume we can't all be lords (and we can't, because useful land is scarce), everyone a free tenant is the next best thing from a pro-freedom-and-equality perspective. This is roughly the relationship between citizen and state under pure Georgism.

The fact that most of the wealth in the UK is in housing is relatively well-known. We are a country that is notoriously obsessed with house prices, to the point where they get used as an economic barometer the way the US uses the stock market. "Pension or property?" (i.e. should you invest your long-term savings in the stock market via a tax-advantaged wrapper similar to 401ks in the US, or in buying residential property and renting it out as a small-scale landlord) is a sufficiently common rich-person financial question that random celebrities get asked it in newspaper interviews. The fact that most of the value of housing in the UK is land and not buildings is admittedly less well known.

I would expect it to be slightly different in other countries (although Piketty's graphs in Capital in the 21st century show the situation as just as bad in France), because in most countries are open-access by default (policy-induced housing scarcity is a feature of a small number of rich cities), whereas in the UK is closed-access by default (it is a problem everywhere except declining industrial towns).

In British politics (I was a practitioner in my mis-spent youth), I remember the line being "a root vegetable in a red/blue rosette".

Imagine Iran having nukes and actively and openly fomenting militant Islam movements in every country they can get into, and spending significant money on it, and actually getting high-level people in US government working for them.

You mean like Saudi Arabia did? I don't remember anyone being too bothered, although a fringe lefty comedian called Michael Moore made a documentary movie about it.

Only if either the questioner was female, or the column had an exclusively female readership (admittedly, true of most agony aunt columns). A normie male reader who read an agony aunt suggesting a straight guy try out teh ghey to see how he felt would bozo-bin the agony aunt.

(On a side note, IMO, this is a strawman of why urbanists care about ID. "Reducing traffic" is an explicitly stated goal of a lot of road construction and urban and suburban design, so the fact that congestion isn't actually reduced is an important counterargument. Moreover, the fact that people want to go places but currently can't is not an argument in favor of building more roads: It is impossible to build enough roads to not have consistent congestion in any reasonably populated area. You can certainly reframe ID as "lots of people want to go places but the current infrastructure doesn't allow it" but all this tells you is that roads are an inefficient use of space in populated areas).

Thanks for this - this is the correct version of the ID argument against road building that I was struggling to put in ordinary language. In econospeak, the proponents of the new road promised a first-order benefit (shorter journey times for the high-value journeys which are already being made due to reduced traffic) and delivered a second-order benefit (marginal journeys which would not have been made now are, or journeys which would have been timed to avoid rush hour are now made during rush hour for a marginal improvement in convenience). Traffic congestion is pure social waste (in fact it is worse than pure social waste due to emissions of idling or slow-moving vehicles), but if you use efficiently-collected tolls to reduce congestion by keeping marginal drivers off the roads then you can deliver a social benefit from road building - most of which comes in the the form of increased toll revenue.

Interestingly, in cities with successful, widely-used public transport (which includes all European and 1st-world Asian capitals), you see induced demand effects on public transport as well. For whatever reason, the anti-transit-funding libertarian crowd don't normally raise the induced demand objection, and when they do the "unsuppressing suppressed demand is good" response normally is raised, loudly. Whether the transit case is really different depends on what you think about the social costs of overcrowding on roads vs. transit - it feels different because overcrowded tube trains get you where you are going roughly on time, but overcrowded roads cause severe delays.

If Donald Trump was aggressively censoring media comparing him to an Orange Cheeto, I would be calling him The Orange Cheeto-in-Chief at every safe opportunity.

In 4 of your 5 examples (not TWAW, where the benefit is concentrated on trans women), both the benefits and the costs of the policy are small and distributed. The result is that in debates on most of these issues, normies end up ignoring diffuse costs and benefits and arguing purely from aesthetics.

Going through point by point:

  1. The pro-alcohol argument is about the small benefits to a large number of responsible drinkers. The anti-alcohol argument is about the ex ante small costs to a large number of potential victims of irresponsible drinkers (obviously ex post the cost to the people who are killed by drunk drivers are not small, but the traditional public choice argument for why diffuse costs are ignored works ex ante). Absent media amplification of rare negative events, the that-which-is-seen bias works in favour of the drinkers. Media amplification of drink-driving deaths creates a that-which-is-seen bias in favour of the prigs. For an example of how effective this amplification is, consider figure 5 in this report (the report is by a prig lobby group, but I am co. paring costs to costs so the bias shouldn't matter). According to the anti-alcohol lobby, <5% of the negative externalities of alcohol use in the UK are due to drink-driving. (Most of them are due to drunken crime, including domestic violence). But drink-driving takes up a lot more than 5% of the public debate.

  2. Road building is a typical example of a policy with somewhat concentrated benefits (to the people who use the new road, and to the politicians who cut the ribbon) and diffuse costs (to taxpayers) - the induced demand argument (which I agree is stupid in the way it is normally made, but there is a steelman which is worth taking seriously) is an argument that the concentrated benefits will be smaller than predicted.

  3. The benefit of keeping poors out of middle-class neighborhoods through snob zoning is diffuse, but the metro-area-level costs of not building enough housing when every neighborhood is snob zoned are even more diffuse - this is why the NIMBYs have been winning for 50+ years and only started losing when metro-level housing shortages got bad enough to affect the PMC.

  4. The point of a road diet is to benefit non-drivers at the expense of drivers. If the road diet is sane (and I am aware that sometimes insane road diets happen because people support them for aesthetic reasons rather than because any identifiable human being benefits), then both of these groups are actually quite concentrated. A good road diet increases the throughput of human beings going where they want to go because an inefficient use of street space is replaced by a more efficient one.

Winnie-the-Panda getting a third term is not news, although it is an important event. The composition of the new PSC may be - Western media is saying that it is all "hard-liners" and this is unexpected. I am not an expert, so the only thing I can say is that the promotion of Li Qiang (who was responsible for the Shanghai lockdowns) looks like bad news, but I thought it was expected.

The ejection of Hu Jintao arguably is news. I don't know what it means though.

We can't tell how much of the market drop is reaction to the political news because there was a lousy economic data release at roughly the same time. FWIW the FT blames the economic data.

The technique is called serial passage - the Wikipedia article is good on the science but appears to be censored re. use in GoF research on human pathogens. Obviously if the technique has been successfully used to produce a strain of bird flu adapted to ferrets then the possibility exists of using it of using it to produce a bat coronavirus adapted to humans.

Early in the life cycle of the lab leak theory, there was some speculation that this was what had happened, but the furin cleavage site suggests otherwise.

The main thrust of American policy regarding Russia since the end of the Cold War has been to keep Western Europe in line.

Not quite - there are two conflicting goals. America wants a stronger Europe so that they don't have to bear as much of the burden of defending Western civilisation (a slightly silly but clear example - America was annoyed that Europe couldn't police its own back yard in the former Yugoslavia) but at the same time they don't want a Europe that is strong and united enough that it can act in a co-ordinated way to oppose American interests.

Meanwhile this all looks like nothing but roses for China

I agree with you that this is all a net positive for China (yes their ally is being humiliated, but Russia's ability to give China what China wants is unaffected, and Russia's ability to say no to china is reduced). But there are two new pieces of information that are negative for China.

  1. Western weapons actually work when used in anger. This was not entirely obvious given how long it had been since the last non-COIN war.

  2. The West's willingness to actually do things to honour a soft security guarantee is stronger than expected. If China attacks Taiwan and fails to achieve a quick Blitzkrieg victory they have to assume that Taiwan will get even more western help than Ukraine did (because Taiwan is more valuable strategically), that nuclear threats won't stop the West helping Taiwan, and that minor economic disruption isn't going to force a change in policy.

You're confusing torture used to extract a confession with torture used to extract military intelligence. It is possible to have those things entangled in reality, like, the tortured person lies about the location of the bomb because he doesn't know the real location and wants the torture to stop.

I am not confusing them. I am explicitly making the claim that this is a distinction without a difference, because torture to extract confessions works so well that even when you think you are trying to extract actionable intelligence the person you are torturing is actually thinking "what does he want me to confess to?" I make this argument purely from authority because I have no experience torturing people, and I sincerely hope that nobody else on the thread does either. But an argument from authority beats a hunch. Note that the required condition for torture to be a good idea is not "You occasionally get true intel you would not have got by being nice" - it is "In expectation, torture for intel produces a net benefit compared to not doing it"

I don't see any reason for why it won't work.

The authors of the medieval law books, the 1863 Lieber Code, the 1907 Hague Conventions, and the US Army Field Manual on Intelligence Interrogations do. And they have a lot more experience than you.

There have been a number of cases where evil regimes set up permanent corps of professional torturers with doctrine, field manuals, line and staff hierarchies etc. (The CIA torture programme post 9-11 was not one of them - one of the surprises in the Senate report that shocked even the pro-torture Republicans on the committee is just how unprofessional it was) The most famous are the Spanish Inquisition and the Soviet GPU/NKVD/KGB. In all these cases, the aim was to extract confessions. The nearest thing to a corps of professional torturers focussed on intelligence gathering was French military intelligence during the Algerian war of independence. The torturers destroyed their records so we don't know how well it worked, but we do know that the French lost the war.

This is called Torrens title, and it is the norm in the world outside the US. The goals of the system are the mirror principle (the register reflects the title, so that anyone who knows they are dealing with the registered proprietor can buy the property without needing to investigate the title or pay for insurance), the curtain principle (anything not needed to deliver the mirror principle, such as the identity of the beneficiaries if the registered owner is a trust, is off the register), and the indemnity principle (anyone who loses money due to the registrar's error, such as allowing a forged deed to be registered, is indemnified at public expense). The details of how this is achieved varies subtly between jurisdictions, but in all case the key is that a State-maintained centralised register is inherently as trustworthy as the underlying State-enforced land title (so blockchain adds no value).

Googling suggests a widespread lack of curiosity as to why the US has not adopted Torrens titles. The best good reason I found is that land law is a State function, and the States cannot impose a register-it-or-lose-it rule on the Feds as applied to e.g. Federal tax liens, meaning that a State-issued Torrens title could not be a true mirror. The likely bad reason is that title insurers have successfully lobbied against the change.

There's another, and much bigger problem, though. If you district by naive algorithm like this, Republicans win the districting process an overwhelming majority of the time.

If compact districts favoured Republicans as much as you think they do, then Republican legislatures would draw maps with compact districts. The fact that Republicans are drawing salamander-shaped districts suggests that the bias inherent in compact districts (which is real) isn't enough to satisfy them.

Incidentally, if you measure bias as "who gets more seats when the popular vote is a 50-50 split" then the largest natural bias is the one if favour of the party whose safe seats have lower turnout.

HS2 is a project to allow more people to commute to London, not to allow people to commute to London more easily - the business case is utterly dependent on the idea that the main line between London and Birmingham is at capacity, and that the marginal cost of building the new line to high speed standards is low. If rail use continues to grow in the way it was growing pre-pandemic, then the existing main lines to Leeds and Manchester will be at capacity by the time HS2 reaches them. If it doesn't then the northern bit of HS2 probably won't get built because speeding up trains that already run at 125 mph is not a good use of anyone's money.

The main way a risk in the risk-free interest rate hurts REITs is by causing a fall in the price-rent ratio, and therefore in property prices. So I don't think the distinction you are trying to make here matters.

Moore's law says that hardware advances exponentially - and a lot of progress in modern AI is about adding more computing power to relatively simple algorithms.

If I needed an AI to tell me how to fight Omega in 2032, I would take 10 more years of Moore's law used to add more nodes to GPT3 over 10 more years of AI research used to implement better algos on existing hardware.

The government was a lot less of an omnishambles before Dominic Cummings sabotaged it by fighting a successful referendum campaign based on lies and impossible promises, and then fighting a successful general election campaign on the basis that the failure to deliver these impossible promises was the result of a shadowy cabal of traitors.

Dominic Cummings is 100% to blame for putting Boris Johnson in power despite knowing that he was unsuited for it - Cummings is entirely open that he did know this, that he thought it was worth the risk in order to gain power for himself, and that he was making plans to remove Boris within days of putting him in power so he had an insurance policy in case he was sacked. Words have meanings and Cummings isn't a traitor, but I frequently struggle not to call him one.

People can use a high IQ to better convince themselves and others of wrong positions, rather than seek correct positions.

People can also use a high IQ to play slick verbal games which cover up for a lack of knowledge. The way Oxbridge teaches humanities subjects (you have to write a weekly essay, which does not affect your grade, but which you are expected to discuss for up to an hour with an academic specialising in the subject) is noted for training this skill. So does competitive debating (which Boris also did). Boris is one of the best people in the world at this particular form of bullshit.

You can also have a high IQ and pretend to be stupider than you are in order to appear relatable to midwit voters. Boris is good at this too.

"Whig" and "Tory" were both originally sneers as well. "Whiggamores" were obnoxious Scottish puritans. "Toruighes" were Irish Catholic bandits.