MadMonzer
If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your
No bio...
User ID: 896
The process that selected Kavanaugh, Gorsuch and Alito was designed to select justices who agreed with mainstream legal conservative positions on all the hot-button issues (which very much includes that the common people should have guns). I think the idea that a justice cucked after appointment is more plausible than the idea that a secret opponent of gun rights got through the right-wing vetting process.
Barrett was the most reliably pro-life woman available with nothing else mattering. Roberts was chosen to be easy to confirm in a 50-50 senate. So I wouldn't be surprised if either of them turned out to be a closeted gun-grabber. My impression of Roberts is that he is a judicial minimalist who is generally inclined to uphold the (federal or state) legislation if it is a close call, almost regardless of the issue.
If we're going to be cynical, we should go all the way. The justices don't want to be blamed for spree killings in blue states, and they will be (fairly or not) if they strike down gun laws. Apart from Barrett, I would be surprised if the 5 squishy justices don't hold the same pro-2nd amendment views you do. But I am not in the least surprised that they would rather abandon their principles than see their face in the NYT next to the headline "13 children dead in Brooklyn high school shooting"
While the laptop class (lawyers, accountants, consultants, finance, tech, etc) capture a huge % of the economic value of society, they obviously are not the primary drivers of the massive prosperity we enjoy. They instead exist because of it.
The laptop class includes the software engineers who generate most of the marginal value which makes Americans richer than Europoors.
Another thing that your argument is missing is that many muni services have very high fixed costs.
An even more important point is that paying existing debt is a fixed cost. Most governments (at all levels and almost everywhere - blue state municipalities in the US are just particularly bad) have marginally-payable debt (if you include implicit debt from underfunded pension liabilities, which you should) and adding a net zero-contribution new resident improves their finances by reducing debt per capita. This is a Ponzi process (the population needs to grow exponentially to keep the government solvent) but one that can be kept going for longer than a human lifetime, so a growing city is more sustainable than most phenomena that exist nowadays.
there are ways to make anyone a net productive citizen
Not if they are young or old enough.
73% of Americans not in paid work are either under 18 or over the Social Security retirement age. Admittedly some of the people over retirement age could work, although blue-collar workers are getting a lot slower at this age, and "net productive citizen" is making the stronger claim that they could work enough to, in expectation, pay for their own healthcare. The other groups of non-workers are the working-age disabled (9% - again most could do some work, very few could work enough to pay for their own healthcare), students (5% - these are people who society is already investing in to make them net productive citizens in the future), SAHMs and other carers (7% - most of these people are net contributors, but not in a way that is legible to the GDP statistics), and the stereotypically unproductive (6% across "temporarily unemployed", "early retirement" and "other").
The vast majority of able-bodied working-age people already are net contributors (40 hours a week at the going rate for reliable low-skill labour is enough almost everywhere across the first world). This is obfuscated by measuring contribution at household level - a typical household contains net-contributor parents and net-leech kids.
The US has federalised the cost of subsidising olds and undergraduates, but mostly localised the cost of subsidising kids. This means it makes sense for communities to try to attract retirees and students (the "eds and meds" strategy) and the federal subsidies that go with them, but to try to keep families with children out. This isn't true in other countries where more of the cost of schools is nationalised and more of the cost of social care for the elderly is localised.
I think Trump wants to get out of Ukraine without taking blame for it.
I think this is the core of the issue from a Trump admin perspective. Trump came into office wanting to stop the fighting (and take credit for it), and believed that there was an easy deal to do where Ukraine gives up territory that Russia already controls, the US recognises Russian sovereignty in Crimea and promises not to let Ukraine into NATO, and everyone agrees some kind of face-saving arrangement so that Ukraine can feel safe from Little Green Men XVIII - Whoops I did it again. I strongly suspect (because it was and still is the standard position among most MAGA-adjacent foreign policy thinkers, and because it is consistent with what he says when he is in a pro-Russian mood) that he thought that the only reason why Ukraine hadn't accepted this deal was that the US Deep State was encouraging Ukraine's unreasonable belief that it could regain lost territory.
Trump has now learned that
- Putin doesn't want a deal where there is still an anti-Russian government in Kyiv. The real Russian war aims are about sovereignty (or "neutrality" when pro-Russian voices are talking to Westerners), not territory. And unless and until he takes a bigger beating than he has done to date, he isn't willing to agree to one. Likewise, he isn't interested in a temporary ceasefire along the current front line. (Ukraine has publicly said that they are open to this, but it is likely that they only said that knowing that Putin wouldn't agree, and that the Zelenskyy regime doesn't want a clean temporary ceasefire either).
- Ukraine and Western Europe have credibly signalled that they won't co-operate with a face-saving surrender agreement - if Trump tries to sell out Ukraine the way Chamberlain sold out Czechoslovakia or Nixon sold out South Vietnam, the Ukrainians will probably tell him to pound sand and keep fighting, and Western Europe will continue to support them to the best of our ability. Whichever side wins that war, Trump looks like a loser.
The logic of MAGA thought is that the Trump administration's response to Russia's invasion of Ukraine should be "Not my circus, not my monkeys" but once Trump has said he will fix the problem his ego won't let him do that.
(And while the 9/11 hijackers weren't formally "leftists," their presence in the United States was arguably traceable to changes in American immigration law plausibly attributed to the left.)
This is incorrect. None of the 9/11 hijackers were on an immigrant track (such as the H1B visa). Most of them had multi-entry B1/B2 visas and their most recent entries before carrying out the attach were either as tourists or as students in flying schools (if the course is less than 6 months, you can study on a B1 visa). The decision to be lax in granting visitor visas to Saudis (and other Arab nationals) was part of the non-partisan deep state policy of making nice to the Arabs (driven by some combination of oil, US domestic political corruption, and a shared enemy in Iran). Visitor visas for rich, officially-friendly countries weren't materially affected by the Hart-Celler Act, and I don't think they were affected by the broader trends in attitudes to immigration either.
Have you ever seen a popular end-user technology become unpopular because of some pesky externalities? I can only think of several that produced a stinking trash heap of them and took zero popularity damage for it, like, for example, cars.
I wouldn't say cars took zero popularity damage - anti-car urbanism is a powerful political force even if it isn't close a majority. In so far as nimbyism is about traffic and parking it is an anti-car movement, just a hypocritical one for people who don't object to their own cars. My impression is that between anti-car urbanists and traffic-and-parking nimbys, about 60% of Americans and 80% of Europeans want other people's cars out of their neighbourhood and are willing to vote on the issue. Cars survive despite being the notorious externalities because they are so useful. (More so in poorly-policed places than well-policed ones, which explains why cars are more popular in America than Europe and more popular in Europe than 1st-world Asia)
There are a few technologies that became unpopular due to negative externalities as soon as an almost-as-good end-user alternative became available. Leaded petrol is the most obvious example - unleaded had a noticeably lower octane rating at the same price and yet the ban on leaded petrol stuck politically.
He got 43.9% of the vote.
The 1933 election after the Reichstag Fire wasn't exactly a free and fair election. The Communist leadership was in prison, and von Papen had seized control over the Prussian police in 1932 and a number of other states had Nazi-led governments, so most of Germany was an anarcho-tyranny in favour of the Nazi SA and DNVP-aligned Stahlhelm.
The NSDAP's best result in an election that was a real test of public opinion was 37.3% in July 1932. There was never a right-wing majority in a Weimar election until after Hitler had already taken power - even if you include anti-Nazi right-wing parties such as the Bavarian BVP.
This is of course, a quibble - the Nazis were broadly popular in the sense that 30-50% of the German electorate thought that a Nazi-led government was a good idea, and Hitler would never have come to power if this had not been the case.
Anyone calling Trump a Nazi is an idiot. But you can be a fascist without being a deranged anti-Semite (see Mussolini before he was Hitler's bitch). The argument that Trump is a fascist has very little to do with his views on racial issues and almost everything to do with whether you take his rhetoric about suspending the Constitution, beating up political opponents, arresting political opponents, developing a new culture of lethality in the armed forces for the purpose of waging a war against political opponents, running for a third term etc. seriously or not.
Empirically, right-populist movements tend to drift in an anti-Semitic direction over time. So do left-populist movements. If the leaked chats reflect the sense of humour of MAGA millenials, MAGA is indeed drifting in an anti-Semitic direction despite the best efforts of MAGA boomers. I smell bear scat in the woods, and in a possibly surprising turn of events Pope Leo XIV is indeed Catholic.
I would favour Rosalind Franklin. Agatha Christie is the other obvious candidate.
I don't think anyone knows what Ada Lovelace looked like, and her achievements are overrated anyway. J K Rowling is still alive, which rules her out. Enid Blyton is too politically incorrect to be a serious candidate. Emmeline Pankhurst hasn't been on a banknote, and if she counts as a politician she probably won't be - Churchill is the only politician featured to date.
Edith Wilson got there first.
Amelia Earhart is a very good suggestion. I think my criteria would be pre-1950, not a DEI exaggeration
Earhart's achievements were exaggerated by the 1st-wave feminists of the time for DEI reasons, and continue to be. Dalrock brought receipts
Your list makes me consider Hedy Lamarr. Her achievements as an engineer are somewhat exaggerated for DEI reasons (the US navy didn't take her work on frequency hopping forward at the time, and the people who developed CDMA probably weren't aware of it) but her achievements as an actress are not.
The coins were bought off-chain, on an exchange.
In the bitcoin economy as it actually exists, most transactions between people happen off-chain (across the books of an exchange, or in the Lightning Network), and most on-chain transactions are people moving money from one hand to another (exchange deposits and withdrawals, opening and closing Lightning channels, transfers to and from cold wallets).
The easiest way to think about it is that Bitcoin replaces gold bullion, not money. Moving bullion out of the vault it is stored in is exceptional - most transactions happen by exchange of warehouse receipts.
They change the portraits roughly every 20 years - Florence Nightingale was on the £10 from 1975-1994, making her the first woman to appear on British money who was neither the Queen nor Britannia.
I don't think the USSR was a particularly feminised society. Blue-haired feminists may consider themselves communist, they may even be communists, but they definitely haven't established Socialism in One Country.
My understanding of 4chan culture is that none of these are remotely homophobic in practice, and the term "fag" has become sufficiently debased that someone needed to coin the term "gayfag" to describe male homosexuals.
They haven't - I think MAGA are wrong about the American establishment being full of communists - even with a small "c". But the whole point of the "cultural Marxist" meme as used by the right is to allow you to call people communists even if they are talking about racial equality and not violently seizing the means of production. Similarly "Bio-Leninism", which is a favourite of MAGA-friendly Motteposters.
But the question "Are left-wing authoritarian wokists communist?" is fundamentally irrelevant - it is an argument about the definition of a defeated ideology. It is no more useful than the question "Are right-wing authoritarian MAGA supporters fascist?" If you abstract out the meaning of controversial words and try to answer questions about the real world, the key questions are "Was there ever a real threat of a left-wing authoritarian woke takeover that would justify a right-wing authoritarian response?" (MAGA think the answer to this one is "Yes", and appear to do so sincerely) and "Is there a real threat of a right-wing authoritarian takeover under the Trump-Miller administration?" (The fact that Trump, Miller, and their supporters in the country all think that the answer to the first question is "Yes" is a large part of why the answer to the second question is "Yes")
True, but building up a cadre willing and able to implement that plan requires significant preparation, and during that preparation the naïve will claim the ideology is all about peace and love, the brotherhood of man, and gradual, incremental, painless reform.
Lenin and Mao did not do that while building up their movements. Both were always clear that their goals required a violent seizure of power, followed by a violent purge of society.
Not quite. There's a sub-set of the right that's very, very much into hating Russia.
Yes - but that is the pro-establishment right, who have been totally pwned in intra-right politics by the anti-establishment right.
There isn't a right-wing faction that are influential in the Trump administration or the MAGA movement more broadly that are "very much into hating Russia"
Yeschad.jpg
If you look at the nature of the thing and not the political rhetoric, fascism and communism are more similar than different. If they were materially different, it would be obvious which Orwell's Oceania is. The whole point of Nineteen eighty-four is that it isn't.
but it wasn't going to be captivated by communist agitators any time soon.
While I agree with you that the US is not actually in danger of imminent capture by communist agitators, a key part of the MAGA worldview is that the Democratic Party, Ivy League, mainstream media, FAANG middle management etc. already have been captured by communist agitators, and that the threat of said communist agitators consolidating power and imposing the Glorious Bugpod Future is an emergency that justifies tearing up the rulebook.
If "Drives support from small-c conservatives by exaggerating the threat of Communism" is a warning sign of fascism (and I think it is, though it is a long way from being pathognomic), then it is one of the warning signs that MAGA triggers.
The vast majority of political domestic terrorists in democracies are regionalist movements - normally full-on secessionists (like the IRA, ETA, and Tamil Tigers) but occasionally groups demanding a level of autonomy that would require the central government and its voter base to compromise their principles (like the first Klan and later the Redeemers in the former Confederacy).
Most such groups think that they have supermajority support among "their people" - they may even be right - but are aware that they don't have majority support or anything close to it in the country as a whole.
I think the same paradigm applies to the Black Panthers, Nation of Islam, and other radical Black groups in the US - the only reason that they aren't secessionist is the absence of a defined territory to secede in.
If there still hasn't been a female President 10 years after Nancy Pelosi dies, then this question will have an easy answer. She is by far the most significant female political leader in the US to date.
Right now, I don't see any advance on Susan B Anthony, who was on the 1979 dollar coin for a good reason. She was also a leading candidate when the Obama administration wanted to replace Hamilton and/or Jackson with women.
It's a good thing we put at very few politicians on British banknotes - the row when feminists decide we need a woman and the only serious candidate is Margaret Thatcher would destroy confidence in the currency.

It's fairly obvious from cultures where ladyboys are a thing (most notoriously, Thailand) that the men who fuck ladyboys are not gay.
More options
Context Copy link