@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

Trans women are a tiny presence for all the noise they make, and if surveys say 3% of heterosexual men would consider dating a trans woman, I'd bet the number who really would date a trans woman is <1%.

Given the fraction of men who participate in machismo-based homosexuality in places where it is socially acceptable (American prisons, non-Taliban Afghanistan, ancient Greece etc.) or the demand for ladyboys as sex workers in cultures like Thailand where that is the normative way of being a trans woman, I would say that 3% is on the low side for "What fraction of men would dick another guy if there was a non-gay way of doing it?" I would bet that the real number is in the 3-10% range.

Men don't want AGPs and AGPs don't want cishet men, so if AGPs are more visible than ladyboys (and in the West they are) then surveys are going to underestimate willingness to date transwomen.

This is actually extremely easy to do, it's European-descended.

Making it too obvious that you think "Things were better back then because black people didn't have access to white beaches" is exactly what I mean by "stepping on a rake".

"This is what they took from us" works at three levels.

The level it is okay to talk about, and is a real case where something has been lost, is that young people looked better in swimsuits back then because nobody was fat. In that specific sense, society is just uglier than it used to be. (If you look at fully clothed photos like high school yearbooks then the effect is less stark because increased wealth means people have better teeth, hair etc. which partially makes up for the fattitude.)

The level where there is an obvious dogwhistle is the mix of skin colours. I think you can make a case that something has been lost here - the idea that there used to be a time (outside a few cosmopolitan megacities) where you could assume that everyone you meet is a member of your folk community. But you can't put that in words without saying what your folk community is, and (for different reasons) neither British nor American wannabe-ethno-nationalists can do that without stepping on rakes, so they use a pictorial dogwhistle. Given the actual demographics of both the US and the UK, skin colour is a good enough proxy for folk community membership for the implied statistical inference to be valid. But the folk community is not actually defined by skin colour and the only people who actually care about the mix of skin colours on the beach as such are white supremacists.

The last point is the silly one. The period between the post-WW2 cleanup and the oil crisis was a period when the core western countries felt prosperous (even though normal-ass economic growth means that we are a lot richer than that now), so vibes-based economics associates the aesthetic of that period with material prosperity. A Tesla Model 3 is superior in every respect to a 1970 model year muscle car, but seeing a 1970 muscle car in the background of a beach photo creates a vibe of "this was a rich society" whereas a Tesla Model 3 in the background doesn't. The only thing that has actually been lost is in your head.

If you do have a 95% case, you can get insurance against the risk of having to pay the other side's costs. (If your lawyer is taking the case on contingency, he has skin in the game and the insurance underwriter can see this.) This was a fairly standard part of English personal injury litigation until the rules were changed to make it unnecessary.

The Western public is okay-ish with anyone killing anyone in countries they would struggle to find on a map except for Jews and Palestinians.

The amount of foreign interest in the Israel-Palestine conflict (on both sides) is orders of magnitude greater than other long-standing conflicts with a comparable humanitarian cost.

Israel has always been disliked by basically everyone

I disagree with "always".

Israel was popular with the pro-establishment left well into the 1980s, even in countries where the pro-establishment left wasn't dominated by Jews. The Yes, Minister sketch about Israel-Palestine has Hacker and the politicians being pro-Israel because it is the moderate, popular position and Sir Humphrey and the Deep State being pro-Palestine because they want to make nice to the Gulf Arabs. (This was back when the Gulf Arab monarchies were as anti-Israel as the rest of the Arab world). Pro-establishment right attitudes to Israel used to depend on how much the pro-establishment right favoured making nice to the Gulf Arabs for cynical oil-politics reasons vs standing up for Western values.

Why? A combination of Cold War politics (Israel's worst enemies where Soviet clients), Holocaust guilt, straightforward preference for civilisation over barbarism, and a belief among non-Communist socialists that Israel back when Labour was the natural party of government was a socialist success story.

What changed? The Cold War ended, post-colonial guilt replaced Holocaust guilt, the era where Israel was a plucky underdog receded into history, changes in Israeli domestic politics made it less sympathetic to Western leftists (and, increasingly, with the rise of religious Zionism and the increasing influence of true-believing Orthodox Judaism, fans of Western civilisation more generally), the humanitarian situation for Palestinians in the West Bank (for which Israel is to blame) and Gaza (for which Israel is widely but unfairly blamed) got worse after the failure of Oslo compared to pre-Oslo.

Recklessness with regard to truth is sufficient to establish actual malice.

"I heard it on the internet and it was too good to check" is a textbook example of recklessness with regard to truth.

France has sufficiently strong privacy laws that it probably would not have been reported until Macron came to the attention of the English-speaking press, which is around the time he started running for President.

Weren't fascist movements a reaction to erstwhile aristocracy ?

Mussolini had a large number of aristocrats in his cabinet, and ennobled a bunch of retired WW1-era generals who he didn't have to, as well as his own successful generals and a small number of Fascist politicians. I would say Mussolini had a revealed preference the continued existence of the Italian nobility as a functioning warrior-elite - indeed given the history of the Italian nobility, had WW2 never happened Mussolini would have left Italy with a more functional aristocracy than he found it with. I can't find a list of top people in the Fascist party organisation, so I don't know how many were aristocrats.

The only aristocrat in Hitler's cabinet (after the aristocratic conservatives associated with von Papen were sidelined) was von Ribbentrop, and the aristocracy was notably underrepresented among the Gauleiters. The Weimar Republic had abolished the formal status of nobility, so Hitler didn't have the option of ennobling his generals, but he never came across as someone inclined to do it. Even under Weimar, the German nobility was a functioning warrior-elite, and Hitler was never entirely comfortable with it - arguably the foundation of the Waffen SS is an attempt to establish an alternative warrior-elite on Nazi rather than aristocratic lines.

So I don't think there is a consistent view on fascist-aristocrat relations.

Trump was involved in an unusual amount of litigation for an ex-President, and is now involved in an unusual amount of high-profile litigation as President. You are saying that this is the result of his political opponents waging an unprecedented campaign of lawfare against him. I am saying that it is a result of his behaviour.

The point is that Trump's pre-politics litigation history is evidence that my view is correct and yours is not.

All the support for Charlie Hebdo printing cartoons of Mohammed (and I mean this quite separately from the attacks and firebombing) should also extend to stupid right-wing satire about the left-wing president's missis. I acknowledge it's not very comfortable for Mme. Macron, but her husband should be thicker-skinned because yeah, politics.

Legally, there is a big difference between false statements of fact and disrespectful cartoons.

there are no Etruscans

That the Etruscans were assimilated into the Roman Republic is a matter of historical record.

Gauls

The French consider themselves to be Gauls.

Picts

Controversial in Scotland, to say the least

Carthaginians

I'll give you that one.

Trojans

If we go with schoolboy history, the Romans disagreed. If we go with modern archaeology, Troy was continuously inhabited from the Neolithic through to Roman times, and the Bronze Age Collapse hit Troy after Mycenae, meaning that the Iliad story of "Troy was destroyed by a Mycenae-led Greek army in the late Bronze Age" is proven false.

Deliberate genocide happens, but it is the exception and not the rule.

There are various non-invasive tests for karyotype. If Mme Macron is 46XX, no court is going to order a physical examination.

Owens' only defense here is going to be "I was joking and everyone knows it, so my claims don't count as statements of fact." The US courts are surprisingly willing to accept that defence (see "pedo guy") but Owens calling Mme Macron a man consistently over several years makes it harder.

Can you run two inconsistent defences in a civil trial in the US? You can in a criminal trial ("I didn't kill him, and if I did it was self defence.") But in England that isn't allowed in a civil case. Even if she can, I suspect Owens doesn't ask for medical tests because it makes it harder to make "I was joking" stick.

Trump being a frequent litigant, even by the standards of real estate guys, long predates his move into politics. He was, and is, in court as plaintiff a lot because he likes to file frivolous lawsuits to intimidate his critics. He was, and is, in court as defendant a lot because he likes to push the limits of the law. He was already notorious for both of these things back when he was a Democrat.

Personal injury is a very different game because, as you say, there are very few lawsuits where there is a real dispute about liability, as opposed to haggling over the amount of damages.

The main problem with US personal injury law is that the conventional 1/3-of-damages contingency fee means that there are a lot of cases where the standard fee vastly exceeds the cost of litigating, and in line with econ 101 most of that surplus gets spent by lawyers competing to sign up the good plaintiffs. And that competition is mostly a negative sum game for non-lawyers, because chasing ambulances is anti-social.

The problem with personal injury law in England (which is loser-pays) is that plaintiffs' lawyers are more motivated to find ways of running up the fees they can recover from losing defendants than judges are to stop them. And each open loophole is a type of case where the collectable fee significantly exceeds the cost of litigating, and so an incentive to chase ambulances.

In both cases, the resources used to chase the ambulances ultimately come from overcharging businesses that injure people relative to the actual harm done. This causes additional harm by creating an incentive for excessive safetyism, and the financial cost is ultimately reallocated to society as a whole via liability insurance premiums.

I'm any event, truly frivolous lawsuits are pretty rare.

And this matters for the debate about whether loser-pays curbs strategic lawfare. The big gain is that loser-pays makes a lawsuit with a negligible chance of winning at trial ineffective as a strategic weapon. The cost of a successful defence is a lot less (because you get reimbursed for most of it) and the cost of suing is a lot greater. The question is what it does to the strategic value of a lawsuit with a 10-20% chance of winning at trial. The consensus among likely SLAPP-victims in the UK (the media, campaigning orgs etc) is that if a deep pocket is using lawfare to punish critics, loser pays makes the problem worse by raising the stakes. Peter Carter-Ruck was notorious for finding ways of making defamation cases expensive to litigate, because when a billionaire is suing a newspaper it doesn't matter that the billionaire is going to end up paying two thirds of the time - the point it to drive the potential cost to the newspaper to the point where they cry uncle.

But in America in 2025, the ability to bring SLAPPS in forum-shopped jurisdictions (e.g. Musk vs Media Matters) probably dominates all the other issues.

But the material rewards are what makes the difference between a slut and a whore.

There is an argument to be had about whether women are getting sluttier. (Survey evidence suggests they are not, but is not exactly reliable). But I'm pretty confident that they are not getting more whoreish.

Why not have literal whores become politicians?

With a little plausible deniability, a whore can already become Vice President of the United States. The list of male politicians who started their career as a catamite would also be interesting if we knew exactly who was on it.

Directional whoring is pretty much the overtly default career of young (and not so young) women in the West.

This seems false to me. PUA's, incels, and feminists with MSM megaphones all agree that young women who are not sex workers are competing harder because they are competing for the attention of a minority of high-quality men (for various values of high-quality), not because they are trying to maximise the financial return on their dating life.

bridgebuilder, but rather as a dicksucker.

The original version of this meme involved goats. I don't think a guy sucking dick is sufficiently transgressive to trigger the meme, and a girl sucking dick (you don't specify sex, and it doesn't matter for the goat version) definitely isn't, even in cultures where hetero oral is taboo. Among the men who metaphorically "built a thousand bridges" while sucking dick on the side, the only one who is more famous as a dicksucker than a bridgebuilder is Oscar Wilde, and only because he sued the Marquess of Queensbury.

Random question to @georgioz - where in the English-speaking world are you where "dicksucker" is more idiomatic than "cocksucker"?

The same site also lists Animal Farm and Nineteen eighty-four as staples of English courses. I agree that Orwell intended Nineteen eighty-four to be a general warning against totalitarianism but both when it was published in 1948 and now it is seen as primarily anti-Communist. Animal Farm is straightforwardly anti-Communist.

FWIW, the anti-Nazi lit I was exposed to in school was mostly of the refugee memoir variety (The Silver Sword and I am David) which doesn't represent the USSR very positively either. We also read Animal Farm and we looked at excerpts from One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich when we were studying "Why translating serious literary fiction is hard."

How did this happen? By forcing diglossia (widespread bilingualism) on Singapore. After independence most people spoke some either Chinese dialect at home, Malay or Tamil. The schools taught English, what is a foreign language to everyone.

LKY imposed widespread trilingualism on Singapore. Most Singapore Chinese spoke Hokkien at home, a substantial minority spoke Cantonese, and very few spoke Mandarin. The "Chinese" that is the second official language of Singapore and an effectively compulsory school subject for ethnic-Chinese Singaporeans is Mandarin. So a plurality of Singaporeans growing up post-independence needed to speak Hokkien, Mandarin and English. My understanding is that Singapore Hokkien has now been reduced to a minority language spoken by elderly working class people.

With all due respect, Singaporeans in general don't speak proper English. They speak Singlish, which is a pidgin English with a fair amount of Chinese grammar and vocabulary baked in

Singaporeans born after about 1980 are almost all capable of speaking Standard Singapore English (which is effective British English with slightly more Chinese and Malay loanwords, and a lot more uncles). Singlish is a choice - in much the same way that most native English speakers code-switch between a local dialect and standard British/American English depending on the context.

He wasn't "harassed by police at odd hours". As is normal for people accused of minor offences, he was booked by appointment at a mutually convenient time, bailed immediately, prosecuted and fined £800. This is bullshit and shouldn't have happened, but if you are trying to describe it accurately it is a lot closer to a citation than "being locked up" or some such.

The stuff being stolen most nowadays is high value-to-volume non-perishable packaged goods which are easy to fence. Razor blades are a classic example, but if you look at places where shoplifted goods are being sold online or at what gets locked up in stores, laundry detergent is probably the number one target.

Poors shoplifting for personal consumption happens (particularly for booze) but isn't what is closing grocery stores.

I don't think anything in that article is inconsistent with my claim that things got an order of magnitude worse after 1997. J'accuse identifies a lot of cases with single-figure numbers of victims going back to the 1950's, but nothing on the scale of Rotherham or Telford.

With party discipline in Congress a lot stronger than it was in the Nixon era, there is nothing that can actually stop a second-term President who wants to brazen it out. If the Democrats take control of the House in the 2026 mid-terms (and they probably will) then Trump will be impeached and acquitted. At this point the number of plausibly impeachable things he has done is large enough that the actual charge doesn't really matter.

In terms of public opinion, I think Trump was just correct when he said he could wander down 5th Avenue shooting people and his base would continue to support him - his being an awful person if fully priced in by now and I don't see him turning out to be a kiddie-fiddler as well as all the other stuff is going to persuade anyone who isn't already persuaded. Swing voters know that Trump shouldn't be President, they are just open to the possibility that Dems are worse.

The more interesting question is how the right-wing media ecosystem changes if there is a serious feud between Trump and the Murdochs. Rupert was always an Old School journalist first and a conservative second, and from that perspective filing this type of lawsuit is an unforgiveable sin. Asking for $10 billion is a signal that this is personal for Trump too, rather than using meritless lawsuits as a polite way of requesting a bribe as he did with CBS. I expect this one to run until Rupert dies, and there is a strong possibility that Lachlan is close enough to his father that he will fill obliged to continue it.

Though note that Costco was the first first-world supermarket foster-kid Iomedae saw - she isn't comparing it to the rest of modern retail. The Soviet Union was a lot richer than a sword-and-sorcery fantasy setting, and a random suburban Randalls was sufficiently mind-expanding to flip an important Soviet politician in a way which would eventually lead to the fall of the Soviet Union.

It isn't Costco that is special - it is the abundance of food that a first-world supermarket represents. Given the consistent failure of grocery retailers (Costco included) to compete outside their home countries, I don't think there is a final boss of supermarkets, and if there is it would be Walmart.