@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

Bukele has said that the US is paying El Salvador to hold the prisoners on an ongoing basis. If he is telling the truth, this looks awfully like "the seller would make minor changes on normal commercial terms if the buyer asked them to." In reality, it may also be "the seller can tell if the actual buyer (i.e. Trump, not America) actually wants the thing, and a request that is obviously made under coercion will be ignored"

There is a common asset protection strategy of putting your wealth in the name of a trust lawyer in an offshore jurisdiction. The legal arrangement is that the lawyer has broad discretion to manage your wealth in the interests of a long list of extended family members. The practical arrangement is that the lawyer will manage your wealth to your instructions unless you are acting under a court order in favour of your business creditors, your ex-wife, the parents of the kid you ran over while drunk, the IRS etc. The US courts typical response is to throw the clown in jail for contempt and tell the trust lawyer that his client would very much prefer not to be in jail, so send money now. Unfortunately the US courts can't jail the President for contempt.

I saw this video on YT about the tariffs from the perspective of a dropshipper, and they are actually less than they might seem. In his example, on an item that retails for $600, 50% tariffs apply to the wholesale price of the item of $200, and the overall tariff tax burden is $100, or 17% of the retail price of the item.

If you are doing dropshipping (so no investment in the actual material business of retail, just running ads to send people to your portal to someone else's store) and taking a 200% profit margin, you are hustling idiots. In general retailers aim for a 50% markup, and give back a big chunk of that in discounts. So if the dockside price is $200 and port-to-store shipping is $10, the sticker price will be around $315 and the average price actually paid somewhere in the $250-300 range. So the tariff is taken on well over half the retail price.

I am aware of the possibility that Putin is the remarkably sane kind of nuclear madman, such that handing him Ukraine on a plate would lead to the return of the status quo ante except for the unfortunate Ukrainians, and failing to do so will eventually lead to nuclear armageddon. I do not consider this particularly likely, but were it true the current western policy would be disasterous.

The claim that there was a good deal on the table at Istanbul until Boris Johnson sabotaged it is a mildly conspiratorial take on the "The war is the West's fault because Ukraine should have surrendered." The deal was rejected because it included a binding treaty commitment by the UK and the US not to help Ukraine if Russia restarted the war.

The Senate rules make it possible for Cory Booker to do that without the co-operation of other senators. It takes the organised opposition of 60 senators to break a talking filibuster.

The revealed preference of other senators was to go back to their offices and dial for dollars while waiting for his bladder to give out rather than making him stop.

Trump EOing the income tax to zero without cutting defence or entitlement spending would be far more destructive than the tariffs - it would be full Weimar/Zimbabwe.

The income tax is a bad thing that we tolerate because the spending it pays for is good and at certain margins it is less bad than borrowing.

I am often surprised at the complete lack of Bavarian separatism.

I am not in the least surprised at how angry a citizen of Baden-Wurttemburg gets if you mistake them for a Bavarian

Both Trump and Musk have enough fanboys that they can surround themselves (including in their social media feeds) with admirers - indeed being surrounded by sycophants is the default if you are that rich and powerful. Both have unusually devoted fandoms - even Reagan didn't have supporters calling for him to be put on Mount Rushmore while he was still in office.

If Musk is exposed to the fact that large numbers of people hate him, it is a choice.

Very much agreed - the culture war is about culture, not economics. And immigration is the most important social issue in basically every rich country. But neither the narrative nor the teams has changed on immigration since it first became an issue, which was well before Trump came down the escalator to take advantage of it.

Conventional wisdom is that the reason why Trump got 49.8% of the vote in 2024 instead of the 46.7% he got in 2020 is something to do with economics, and if you ask the minority of voters who care about economics more than culture, they talked about prices and not jobs - unsurprisingly, given that the Biden economy was doing just fine on jobs and low-end wages.

It's tax dodging. You want to arrange your EU supply chain and associated transfer pricing so that most of the value added shows up in Ireland and is taxed at Irish rates. So imports of intermediate goods into Ireland are underdeclared and exports of finished goods are overdeclared.

Ireland has the highest ratio of GDP to Actual Individual Consumption of any medium or large country in the world - the Irish people are not seeing this money.

(Tangential hot take: give Italian Americans their own holiday worthy of their community's cultural spirit, and Columbus will disappear.)

You gave them the whole continent - it's named after Amerigo Vespucci. It isn't clear whether John Cabot, who was an Italian living in England, or Vespucci, who actually discovered America. But both reached the main continental landmass before Columbus did.

Detroit

The collapse of Detroit proper is a story of conventional urban decay and long precedes the decline of "Detroit" the auto-industry cluster. The factories were in the suburbs (Dearborn for Ford, much more widely distributed for GM because so much of the early growth was by acquisition). Some of the auto suburbs are post-industrial wasteland (e.g. Flint) but most of them aren't - notably including Dearborn.

I think Boeing have pretty conclusively demonstrated that compliance in safety-critical high-end manufacturing is not, in fact, uniformly negative sum.

He wrote a book on this.

No he didn't. The man who wrote the book has admitted his share of fault in building the myth that the man who bankrupted multiple casinos and has to give personal guarantees on commercial mortgages because his credit is shot is a successful businessman.

Here's a question: can you point out any actions he took in the foreign relations arena, from his first term, where he straight up 'lost?' i.e. where he capitulated with absolutely nothing to show for it or maybe even gave something up?

He surrendered to the Taliban. The surrender agreement was timed to go into effect after the election, meaning that he got to blame Biden, but it was Trump's deal.

Oh, and remember when he Went to North Korea, the FIRST President to do so, and got them to at least verbally agree to denuclearization talks?, and NK has been substantially less uppity since then?

Has North Korea actually taken any steps towards denuclearisation, or did they just offer Trump a photo op? Trump has a demonstrated pattern of kayfabe gunboat diplomacy where he threatens to harm another country and then doesn't do so because they announce something that doesn't cost them anything or deliver any actual benefit to the US - for example the first round of Canada tariffs which were dropped in exchange for Trudeau reannouncing a border security package he had already announced in November, or 1st term Trump relaxing tariffs on China in exchange for a non-binding promise to buy more American soybeans.

At the risk of speculating TOO much, its what you might expect from a "Door in the Face" negotiation tactic.

Did you read your helpfully provided Wiki link? DITF is about making a big ask which you know is going to be rejected in order to anchor the following smaller ask as reasonable. Trump hasn't made an ask - the tariffs are not, in fact, reciprocal, and the countries they are being imposed on know this even if the US public don't. If we are using feet and doors as our preferred metaphor, Trump's tactics here are banging the door down with a battering ram while shouting "Make me an offer, motherfuckers!" There isn't a name for that particular approach to negotiating, because it is retarded.

Blue collar labor has fared poorly since the 1990s when NAFTA really accelerated free trade in the United States. Trump is the first President in my lifetime who actually cares about unskilled American laborers. It’s why the head of the Teamsters spoke at the RNC last year.

NAFTA is a furphy - the big drop in US manufacturing employment happens after 2000 due to the China shock.

Also the Teamsters aren't a manufacturing union. They get paid to deliver the Chinese imports from the dock to the Walmart Supercentre. So if the Teamsters are supporting Trump it is unlikely to be about tariffs, or indeed economics at all.

Why exactly are they non sensical? The first order effect is that tarriffs make it more profitable to produce things in America vs offshore, so there will be more jobs and industry created here. It’s only the secondary and tertiary effects where it starts to get ugly

You can get a car by making a car in Detroit, or by drilling for oil in North Dakota and trading the oil for a Japanese car. Tariffs is to favour the former process over the latter - to first order the increase in cars made in Detroit is exactly offset by the reduction in oil drilled in North Dakota (foreigners who can no longer sell cars to the US can't get the dollars to buy the oil, so they don't).

It is true that an autarchic America would do more manufacturing and less of other things (and would be poorer as a result, because Americans suck at manufacturing and excel at things like software engineering and oil drilling), so if by "produce things" you mean specifically manufacturing then tariffs will lead to America "producing" more "things". But Trump definitely doesn't want to kneecap American natural resource exports, and probably doesn't want to kneecap American tech exports.

There is also a second order effect, which is that chaotically imposed tariffs generate moron risk premium, which reduces foreigners' (and Americans') desire to invest in America, so foreigners with dollars are more likely to spend them on American goods and services than invest them. If this isn't neutralised by monetary or fiscal policy, it increases demand for American goods and services, which would lead to increased production in the short term in a Great Depression, or inflation under normal economic conditions. In either case, in the long term the decrease in investment will lead to a decrease in production. For these tariffs at this time, the fall in USD indicates that financial markets think the second order effect will be bigger than the first order effect.

This isn't pushing buttons or making adjustments - this is giving your toddler a pair of drumsticks and telling him that the control panel is his new xylophone.

But Norfolk Island (population 2188, also an Australian territory, zero direct trade with the US) gets a higher tariff than the Australian mainland - 29% vs 10%. Apparently it is because NH (for New Hampshire) was miskeyed as NI when processing a shipment of Timberland shoes, leading the computer to think the US had a trade deficit with them. I'm not sure how the computer knew that NI was supposed to be Norfolk Island and not Northern Ireland.

The relevant skill isn't economic theory - it is a deep understanding of supply chains and of potential sources of competitive advantage. Industrial policy is working on the flow of goods (and occasionally services), not the flow of money that pays for them.

But Trump isn't doing infant industry protection - the most important infant industry right now in the US is semiconductors, and they were excluded from the tariffs. There doesn't appear to be any microeconomic justification for the tariffs even from supporters. The main arguments being used to defend the tariffs are "we don't actually mean to do this - it's a negotiating tactic" and "this is a fiscal transfer from foreigners to Americans that will allow us to cut taxes". And if it is a negotiating position, the likely end goal is macroeconomic - the Mar-a-Lago accords will fundamentally be about exchange rate policy.

If countries are willing to play ball and lower all (their) paper barriers to trade

The tariffs aren't reciprocal - the "tariffs charged to the USA" column on the poster he held up is a measure of the bilateral trade deficit and has nothing to do with what tariffs are charged on US exports. Vietnam and Israel both cut tariffs on the US, and still got hit. Trump isn't asking Vietnam to cut tariffs, he is asking Vietnam to stop exporting manufactured goods.

Trump may reverse the tariffs in exchange for kayfabe concessions and falsely claim a yuge win (as he did with the first round of Mexico/Canada tariffs), but he hasn't articulated any demands for real concessions that other countries are in a position to make.

I consider politicians who successfully execute on agendas I oppose in the face of powerful opposition to be high quality, particularly if they remain popular while doing it and break fewer things that I expect (or would have expected ex ante in the case of Jackson). Effective/ineffective and good/evil are approximately orthogonal axes.

all of them were reactions to concrete fiscal crises/shocks

Canada/Sweden were. Sequestration was a response to an entirely artificial crisis (it was part of a deal to increase the debt ceiling), and Margaret Thatcher could have spent the North Sea oil money on spending increases instead of tax cuts.

DOGE is attempting the former.

Musk has always attempted to justify what he is doing at DOGE on the basis that the deficit and debt are a near-term crisis.

Who do you think is voting for all those far right parties in Europe?

20-25% of the population in most countries - which is not enough votes to include a supermajority of the proletariat for any standard meaning of the term "proletariat".

The right-populist parties that are doing significantly better than that - most obviously PiS in Poland and Fidesz in Hungary - aren't focussed on bringing back manufacturing jobs. PiS is talking about bringing back farm jobs in a country that was 20% agrarian within living memory. Fidesz is conventionally right-wing on economics (as is Reform in the UK and the AfD in Germany). And of course both parties, like other right-populist parties, focus on cultural issues over economic ones in their campaigning.

Why do you think Brexit happened?

Because retired people voted 2:1 in favour of it. Age was a stronger predictor of how people voted in the referendum than social class. If we define "proletariat" in the orthodox Marxist sense of people who have to work for other people in order to eat, the proletariat voted 55-45 for remain.

Given your response to @sohois, we don't disagree that the culture war is primarily about culture, not economics. And we don't disagree that you can carve out a demographic that does show supermajority support for right-populist parties that is in some sense more "proletariat"-like than the demographic of Motteposters. But if you are using the word "proletariat" to exclude working-age women, which you need to do if you want to make "The proletariat supports right-populist parties" a useful generalisation, you are using the word in a non-standard way. But that is an argument about the meaning of words. Where we have a substantive disagreement is about the economic views of right-populist voters.

If you look at:

  • What right-populist voters say in issue polls
  • What right-populist voters say in focus groups
  • What messages successful right-populist politicians run on
  • What right-populist poasters say on social media

then the conclusion you come to is "bring back assembly line jobs" is only a major right-populist cause in the US, and probably only because Trump made it one. The best economic right-populist message in essentially every European country is "we will protect the welfare-state-for-the-old by cutting white-collar government employees and welfare for immigrants" - i.e. it isn't about jobs or the private sector economy at all. The second-best message is "enviro-loonies are destroying your lifestyle", which could be about manufacturing jobs, but in practice turns out to be about domestic energy consumption (including private car use). The main time "enviro-loonies are destroying jobs" was a winning election message was around the Dutch nitrogen crisis, and the jobs were farm jobs.

There are right-populists with libertarianish economic policies. There are right-populists with agrarian economic policies. There are right-populists with what used to be mainstream centre-left economic policies. The common thread is that they promise to preserve the welfare-state-for-the-old and that they blame immigration for the inability of the centre-right to do so - not that they want to bring back manufacturing jobs.

You are in a bubble so your only experience of those people's discourse is the memes you and they exchange against each other about eggs and the price of gas.

I have actually done the work of politics - if you are running for office, or doing field work for someone who is, you can't avoid speaking to the sort of older socially conservative voters who are the traditional core vote of right populist parties. (I am aware that some countries have an new right-populist constituency among male Zoomers, but the UK isn't one of them and I got out of active politics before the Zoomers were old enough to vote). These people also exist in my extended family. And guess what - if you let them talk about policy, they mostly talk about crime and immigration. And when you do hear something about economics, 2/3 of the time it is a variant of "how can we afford X when we can't afford Y" where X is something that is perceived as benefitting foreigners, and most of the other 1/3 is about how much more expensive things are than they used to be. You don't have to take my anecdotes on authority - the point I am making is that I have lived experience of doing politics, and it is consistent with the data.

Donald Trump may be totally unable to implement his economic views correctly, but he's a friend, not an enemy.

"Friend" is what you call someone who is on your side based on shared values - i.e. it's about culture, not economics.

When military careers were attractive to able people, they acted as a gateway to government work in general and politics in particular. And of course in the Greatest Generation essentially every male citizen served in WW2. I think something similar happened in the 19th century - the quality of American politicians is higher when Revolutionary War veterans (and War of 1812 veteran Jackson) were in charge and then declines.

The execution? All kinds of programs that most people think are laudable are catching strays. The administration doesn't seem to be particularly on the ball when it comes to rolling back the most obviously negative changes. And the savings figures they tout are frankly speaking, worthless.

Everyone who is paying attention knows that the worst waste/fraud/inefficiency in the US government is in Medicare and defence. DOGE hasn't touched Medicare and has barely touched defence. Ergo they are not serious about reducing waste/fraud/inefficiency.