@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

This was obvious as soon as the story broke. Only an idiot would think her job at Skadden Arps could survive this, and Skadden Arps don’t hire idiots. My guesses as to motive were:

  1. She thinks that Perkins Coie or Williams & Connolly will hire her over this. Unlikely
  2. She is looking to jump to public interest work.
  3. She is trying to give her fiancé a social license to stay soulsold in their left-wing social circles.

He needs to boil the frog more slowly than that - particularly when going after the legal profession.

Once it is obvious that Trump wants to make the legal profession his bitches, the Supreme Court goes from a 6-3 Republican majority to a 7-2 not wanting to be Trump’s bitch majority. (Thomas and Alito dissenting). He either needs to have more hacks on the Court or be in a position to ignore it before this happens.

” Muh Jim Crow" also doesn't quite explain it either. Are you saying American anti-localists will change their mind if you constitutionally take that issue off the table?

No - what I am suggesting operates at a much more emotional level than that. The Civil Rights movement is the heroic epic of the American left, so in the stories American lefties tell themselves the heroes are centralisers and the villains cry “States’ Rights”. Whereas the heroic epic of the Spanish left is resistance to Franco, so in the stories Spanish lefties tell themselves the good guys are calling for autonomy for Catalunya and the Basque Country while the villains cry “Todos por la patria”.

The world consists of more than the UK and the US

I know. Having checked my research, there are more countries with centralised healthcare policy than I thought, but it is still generally devolved.

  • France is centralised
  • The German system is heavily decentralised, but the Krankenkasse are not organised on State lines, so technically counts as Federalised
  • In Italy healthcare is run by the regions
  • In Spain healthcare is run by the autonomous communities
  • In Denmark and Sweden the ground rules are set nationally but the healthcare system is actually run at County level
  • In Switzerland healthcare is run by the cantons
  • In Poland the national government and the regions share responsibility for healthcare in a way which appears to be incomprehensible to everyone except Polish bureaucrats
  • In Canada healthcare is run by the provinces
  • Australia is centralised
  • In India healthcare is run by the states.

It sure is if the Dems do an even worse job...

I wouldn't call self-sabotaging while hoping the other guy self-sabotages more a strategy. I agree it is what both American political parties have been doing for the last decade or so.

Bjelke-Petersen always seemed pretty Trumpy to my British sensibilities (his son is working with Clive Palmer, which confirms the theory). He was hugely successful inside Queensland and politically toxic in the rest of Australia.

I never understood the liberal and leftist antagonism to this.

It's pretty much entirely historical as a result of Jim Crow. Localism in the UK is weakly left-coded, although in practice it is generally supported by the party out of power in Westminster at the time. In Spain localism is strongly left-coded, but it is right-coded in Italy.

In the cases of the US, Spain, and Italy there are obvious stories about who the noisiest opponents of the centre are and how that determines the partisan valence.

That said, ID cards is a really stupid thing to push to the states (except in so far as they run the offices administering a federally determined policy, which is what happens in Germany) because it is so tied to immigration policy, which is a federal responsibility for good reasons.

Healthcare policy is run at a subnational level almost everywhere - even in the UK Scotland and Wales have their own NHSs.

How much of that is that is housing?

Saying people prefer to live in states with abundant housing is somewhat misleading - at the margin people have to live in states with abundant housing because of the pigeonhole principle. What we actually see is that people are willing to pay a premium to live in California and not Texas, but there isn't enough housing in California to accommodate them.

This is still a government failure, but it is a quite specific one rather than "people would rather live in more economically libertarian states".

(FWIW, I think Texas is sufficiently well-governed that quality of government is an important pull factor, but other fast-growing red states are not).

You need to tie the national ID number to a person, and before modern online biometric verification that meant a document (the "ID card") with a biometric (signature/photo/fingerprint) that could be checked against the person presenting it.

You can get large numbers of illegals to self-deport by cutting off services, but empirically there are plenty of illegal immigrants in the US who don't have legal employment or bank accounts. In any case, the right-populist voter base wants to see visible deportations as a show of good faith. I do not think the MAGA base would consider "Universal e-verify and deport foreign criminals when you catch them" to constitute effective enforcement without more.

Empirically, social media shitposts about assaulting someone are not true threats. Has anyone ever been attacked in meatspace by an internet rando (as opposed to an ex-boyfriend or suchlike) who trolled them on social media first? I think shitposting about violence is bad and the people who do it are bad people who should feel bad, but online culture (and especially the online culture of the anti-establishment right that emerged from places like 4chan and was a major influence on early MAGA culture) disagrees with me.

I think that Paul Chambers (of the UK Twitter Joke Trial fame) was an idiot, but nobody found it worth the effort to publicly point this out.

Musk is the last person who should be complaining about failure to peformatively condemn shitposters - if the law took Musk's shitposting seriously then he would be in jail for securities fraud and Vernon Unsworth would own Tesla. Musk doesn't even condemn actual political violence when carried out by his side (I am mostly thinking about the Paul Pelosi case here), let alone shitposting.

Then it's not so much "Nobody carries around..." as "There is nothing that could be carried for...". That seems like a bigger problem.

Yes. If you want effective in-country immigration enforcement, then you need a citizen register and either ID cards or a trustworthy biometric database so ID can be checked online. (Only Estonia has successfully implemented the latter to date, and it gets harder roughly quadratically as your population increases.)

Given the ubiquity of driving licenses as ID and that the SSA already has a de facto citizen register, this would be easy for the US to do - although a few long-standing illegal residents with fraudulently acquired SSNs (or genuine ones acquired on a now-expired working visa) will slip through the net. This is particularly true for the US because birthright citizenship makes the whole problem easier - the hardest part of verifying citizenship in non-birthright countries is verifying parent's status at the time of birth. But the people who are most committed to stronger immigration enforcement are by and large the same people who are deeply committed to the idea that the Anglosphere doesn't need no stinking citizen register and is not a papieren, bitte culture, nein und fock auf - so it doesn't happen.

Illegal aliens in particular are owed no due process and enjoy no protections from summary deportation.

The right to a fair trial exists for the benefit of the innocent, not the benefit of criminals. A US citizen who gets picked up by mistake gets the same due process an actual illegal gets - certainly in the UK this turned out to be the problem with a "deport them all" strategy - that a country with no citizen register and no papieren bitte culture doesn't know who is and isn't there legally accurately enough to do mass deportations without deporting an unacceptable number of citizens and legal immigrants by mistake. If you are deporting people who haven't done anything wrong except being illegal in the first place, the politically acceptable number of citizens deported by mistake is close to zero.

Realistically, the Anglosphere countries are going to have to become papieren bitte cultures if we want effective in-country immigration enforcement.

What is true is that (apart from the existence of a law passed by Congress, implementing the USA's obligations under a ratified treaty, protecting refugees, and people with a credible claim to be refugees until it is adjudicated) once you have established that someone is an illegal immigrant they have no right whatsoever to stay in the US - for example it is wicked but not illegal to prioritise immigration enforcement based on 1st amendment protected speech.

It isn't executing executive authority. The enabling legislation says it has the powers of a nonprofit organised under DC law (so no delegated sovereignty). The stated purposes are all scholarly, except that USIP can advise other government agencies that explicitly seek its advice.

See the caselaw re CFPB.

Seila Law relates to directly appointed agency heads. Humphrey's Executor relates to members of multi-member boards. The distinction is silly, but it is the current case law.

It's not as bad as it sounds as long as the Trump administration has the power to fire the board, install new leadership, and then do whatever they want to the organization. It sounds like they do.

As a matter of black-letter law, they don't. The law setting up the USIP says that the board members (apart from the three ex-officio ones) can only be fired for cause, with the consent of a majority of the board, or with the consent of the Congressional committees responsible.

Humphrey's Executor is the SCOTUS case saying that this type of law is constitutional. It is a unanimous decision from 1935 (before FDR threatened to pack the Court) holding that FDR couldn't sack Hoover's appointees on the FTC.

So the claim that the Trump administration has the power to fire the board is the claim that a SCOTUS precedent that has been widely followed for 90 years is incorrect.

Given that Trump's people have repeatedly said that they believe Humphrey's Executor was wrongly decided, I don't think a complex explanation is needed. The administration is unapologetically breaking the law because they believe the law they are violating is unconstitutional and that SCOUTUS will eventually rule in their favour.

Are you familiar with the 2001 AUMF? There are 24 years of precedence, including the use of this authorisation to justify the NSA's warrantless surveillance.

The AUMF was a declaration of war in all but name, and led to an actual shooting war in Afghanistan. I would prefer that the Congress use the words "Declaration of War" when it exercises its article I power to declare war, because I am a spergy believer in rectification of names, but all three branches of government treated the AUMF as a declaration of war.

This is fundamentally driven by the Trump administration's attempt to overturn Humphrey's Executor. The law setting up USIP says that the non-ex officio members of the Board can only be fired for cause. Trump attempted to fire them anyway. If Humphrey's Executor is good law, then Trump can't fire the board members, three random board members can't pass a resolution at a meeting from which the majority of the board is excluded, Moose was never fired, Jackson is some rando trying to break into an office building, and the DOGE employees and the police protecting them are common burglars. If Humphrey's Executor is wrong, then Trump fired most of the board, the remaining board members fired Moose, Jackson is the new president, the DOGE employees are his invited guests, and the police were quite properly escorting a fired employee off the premises.

This is an uncommonly silly way to set up a hard-to-punt test case, but if anyone involved sues then it will indeed do so. The litigation is a slam-dunk for Moose unless Humphrey's Executor is overruled. And the fate of Humphrey's Executor can only be decided by SCOTUS.

That depends on what happens with them after they get deported.

In the instant case, they are being shipped off to a foreign prison in a country with no effective habeas corpus and whose President (who describes himself as a "dictator") has boasted on social media about the inability of the US courts to protect the prisoners once they arrive in his jail. So no meaningful remedy.

I would not have said the things I said if this was a conventional deportation case. This is a detention without legal process case.

you cannot get court relief right there and then.

You are entitled to an arraignment within 48 hours, at which time the judge will normally set bail.

B) Likewise, they were all being held on at least probable cause for a crime.

The government is explicitly not claiming this - that is why they are using the Alien Enemies Act (which doesn't require probably cause of a crime). The affidavit linked by @Quantumfreakonomics says that the government has probably cause that the detainees are "members" of TdA, but that isn't in itself a crime. The affidavit conspicuously fails to allege that all the detainees provided material support to TdA (which would be a crime because TdA is a designated foreign terrorist organisation), only that some of them did.

C) The President is 100% allowed to enter deals with foreign states for, among other things, detention of criminals.

The powers of the federal government, including the Article II powers of the President, are limited by the Bill of Rights. What this means in practice is unclear, because no previous President has rented space in a foreign prison to house people detained under US law. If the President tried to do this type of deal to house US citizen criminals in a foreign prison without explicit permission from Congress, I would expect him to lose 9-0 at SCOTUS.

lol. If there were any truly innocent parties swept up in this particular action, the Admin can say "Whoops, here's a flight home, our treat" and its forgotten in a week.

I agree with you - but that is the problem. You set the face-eating leopards on an unpopular minority first in order to set a precedent. Trump is claiming the right to disappear (in the semi-technical sense that this term is used to describe administrative detention in authoritarian states) foreigners in the US. He is also claiming the right to do it in a way which would probably prevent a US citizen caught up accidentally getting relief through the courts. We all know what happens if nobody speaks out when they come for the Jews...

Detention without due process based on the use of emergency war powers during peacetime is a break glass moment if you care about the rule of law. The Hamdi case - both the plurality and the Thomas concurrence - take it for granted that the President is detaining Hamdi persuant to the post-9/11 AUMF - not under inherent Article II powers. It was a case about war powers in wartime based on a Congressional pseudo-declaration of war. This is a case about war powers based on an executive proclamation using a non-standard meaning of the term "invasion".

They couldn't have gone the way of Singapore without the permission of the occupying powers (arguably including the Soviet Union). The West Berlin senate was an institution of non-sovereign self-government with similar status to a Territorial legislature in the US. There was even a US Court for Berlin with a superordinate jurisdiction to the local courts established by the senate, although it only ever heard one case - as an amusing trivia point it is the only US Court for a place beginning with "B", as no state name does.

The Allies handed sovereignty over Berlin to the reunified Germany by treaty - the occupied Berliners didn't get a say in it.

This does not matter here. The courts can still review the deportations that have taken place; it is not as if there are no remedies available. A court could, for example, order the re-admission of illegally deported aliens. Thus there is no issue with litigating it by individual litigants with standing.

Can the US courts order detainees released from a Salvadorean prison? Bukele doesn't think so, given his "too late" tweet.

This isn't a deportation case - this is a detention without trial case.

They absolutely do. Even illegal immigrants get those rights -- you can't go around subjecting them to cruel punishments!

Given that Trump and Bukele are publicly boasting about the tough conditions in Salvadorean prisons (which would be dubiously legal in the US under current 8th amendment jurisprudence), Trump is unaplogetically doing just that by proxy.

I agree he shouldn't be. That is why I say this case is important - because Trump thinks that he has found a legal blackhole that nullifies the rights of foreigners living in the US, and there is a reasonable chance that he either wins on the merits when the case gets to SCOTUS or successfully ignores an adverse court ruling.

The numbers are actually pretty close. US aid to Israel is about 4 billion USD per year, so "in the last 30 years" is c. 120 billion (on an inflation-adjusted basis - the headline figure is lower). The total amount appropriated by Congress in Ukraine aid bills is 180-190 billion, but that includes the cost of new-for-old replacement of old weapons delivered to Ukraine - the highest estimate of the actualSo value of the aid (counting the weapons actually delivered, not the newer weapons the US is replacing them with) is 128 billion (not all of which has been spent) according to this CFR report

So given the difficulty of getting a straight answer to either question by googling, "about the same amount" seems accurate.

In addition, the government of El Salvador appears to be acting as an agent of the US here - if Bukele's public statements are correct then the US is paying an annual fee per prisoner in the same way that they would contract with a domestic private prison operator. That is a very different situation to Munaf v Geren which involved the US handing people over to an Iraqi court for trial under Iraqi law for crimes committed in Iraq. El Salvador isn't exercising its own jurisdiction here - its interest in the detainees is the cash they are getting from the US.

If the government can round you up in the middle of the night and ship you off to a foreign prison before a court has a chance to hear your case, you do not, in fact, have any of those rights. The arrangement between the US and El Salvador isn't functionally a deportation - it is a prisoner transfer. The 4th and 5th amendments are fairly obviously implicated. Conditions in Salvadorean jails are bad enough that the 8th amendment is being violated if prisoners are held there on behalf of the US (as Bukele has claimed). Bukele has also said that he wants to cover most of the costs of running the prisons with forced labour, which is a 13th amendment violation as applied to people who haven't been convicted of a crime.

It's an interesting question to me: where does violence in transition of power become a concern for individual subjects/citizens?

If the violence involves large-scale troop movements, it is generally bad for the civilian population of the areas fought over. The Year of Four Emperors involved two multi-legion battles.